Europe's PLAN to Challenge China and the US

Summary

Mario Draghi, former ECB president, has released a report addressing Europe's waning competitiveness, highlighting a 30% GDP gap with the US. He attributes this to productivity issues, especially in digital technology, and recommends significant investment in innovation, a joint decarbonization plan, and increased security to reduce dependencies. Draghi suggests a massive annual investment of 5% of EU GDP to revitalize the economy and prevent a slow decline.

Takeaways

• 😌 Mario Draghi, former ECB president, has released a new report focusing on Europe's future competitiveness amidst economic challenges.
• 📉 The EU's GDP gap with the US has increased from 15% in 2002 to 30% today, with 72% of this widening gap due to growth issues.
• 📚 Draghi's report includes 170 key recommendations across 400 pages, aiming to halt the EU's economic decline and prevent social unrest.
• 🌐 The EU has strengths such as a Single Market of 440 million consumers and 23 million companies, contributing to 17% of global GDP.
• 🏆 The EU leads in areas like governance, health, education, and environmental protection, with eight of the top ten countries for rule of law being EU members.
• 🔒 Europe faces challenges including reduced demand for exports, energy dependency, and a weakened defense sector.
• 📈 Europe's productivity has declined to around 80% of the US level, with digital technology being a key driver in the growing productivity gap.
• 💡 Draghi's first recommendation is to close the innovation gap with major competitors by investing in research and innovation and easing regulations for SMEs.
• 🌿 His second recommendation is a Joint decarbonization and Competitiveness Plan, viewing decarbonization as an opportunity for growth and energy security.
• 🛡️ The third recommendation focuses on increasing security and reducing dependencies by implementing strategies for critical raw materials and joint defense procurement.
• 💰 The estimated cost of Draghi's recommendations is EUR 750-800 billion annually, which is around 5% of EU GDP in 2023, requiring significant investment from both public and private sectors.

Q & A

What was Mario Draghi's famous declaration in 2012 that saved the Euro?

Mario Draghi's famous declaration in 2012 was 'Do whatever it takes', which was a commitment to do whatever was necessary to preserve the Euro.

What is the current state of the European economy according to the script?

The European economy is not thriving, with the GDP gap between the EU and the US having widened from 15% in 2002 to 30% today.

What percentage of the widening GDP gap between the EU and the US is attributed to growth issues?

72% of the widening GDP gap between the EU and the US can be attributed to growth issues.

How many key recommendations does Mario Draghi outline in his report on Europe's future competitiveness?

Mario Draghi outlined 170 key recommendations in his 400-page report.

What is the significance of the EU's Single Market in terms of consumers and companies?

The EU's Single Market is significant as it consists of 440 million consumers and 23 million companies, accounting for around 17% of global GDP.

What are some of the external factors holding Europe back according to Draghi?

External factors holding Europe back include slowing trade due to markets like China producing their own goods and focusing on internal consumption, reduced supply of cheap natural gas from Russia, and reliance on the US for defense.

What is the key driver behind the growing productivity gap between the EU and the US?

The key driver behind the growing productivity gap between the EU and the US is digital technology.

What is the market value milestone that no EU company founded in the last 50 years has reached?

No EU company founded in the last 50 years has reached a market value of EUR 100 billion.

What is Draghi's first recommendation to address the EU's competitiveness?

Draghi's first recommendation is to close the innovation gap between the EU and major competitors like the US and China by making massive investments in research and innovation.

What is the significance of the EU's decarbonization goals in terms of growth and competitiveness?

The EU's decarbonization goals are seen as both a challenge and an opportunity. If policies are in sync with climate goals, decarbonization can be a source of growth and enhance competitiveness.

How much additional funding does Draghi suggest is needed annually to implement his recommendations?

Draghi suggests that approximately EUR 750-800 billion annually, which is around 5% of EU GDP in 2023, is needed to implement his recommendations.

What is one of the ways Draghi suggests to reduce the EU's vulnerabilities in terms of critical raw materials and advanced tech?

To reduce vulnerabilities, Draghi suggests implementing the Critical Raw Materials Act (CRMA), establishing joint purchasing, and developing a supply chain strategy.

Outlines

00:00

📉 Europe's Economic Challenges and Draghi's Recommendations

Mario Draghi, former ECB president, has released a report addressing Europe's economic competitiveness. The European economy is facing a significant GDP gap with the US, which has widened from 15% in 2002 to 30% today. Draghi's report identifies the main issue as growth, particularly in productivity, and proposes 170 recommendations. Despite challenges, the EU has strengths in governance, health, education, and environmental protection. Draghi warns of a slow decline if issues are not addressed. He highlights external factors like trade slowdowns, energy dependency, and security weaknesses. His key recommendation is to close the innovation gap with the US and China, focusing on digital technology, and proposes significant investments in research and innovation, regulatory reviews, and support for SMEs.

05:04

🌿 Decarbonization and Competitiveness: A Dual Focus for Europe

Draghi's report emphasizes the need to synchronize decarbonization efforts with competitiveness to avoid adverse effects on growth. The EU's ambitious decarbonization goals come with short-term costs, but also present opportunities for growth in clean technologies and energy security. The report points out that while Europe leads in clean tech, it's losing its edge due to insufficient funding and competition from China and the US. Draghi suggests a comprehensive energy strategy, including a mix of renewables, nuclear, hydrogen, and carbon capture, along with measures to stabilize energy prices. He also calls for an industrial action plan for the automotive sector to maintain competitiveness in EVs and autonomous driving. The report underscores the importance of increasing security and reducing dependencies on critical raw materials and advanced tech.

10:06

🔄 Addressing Europe's Security and Dependency Issues

The report by Draghi addresses Europe's vulnerability due to reliance on critical raw materials and advanced tech, with a significant portion of imports coming from a few suppliers. It suggests implementing the Critical Raw Materials Act, joint purchasing, and supply chain strategies to reduce vulnerabilities. In terms of defense, the report calls for increased joint procurement among EU Member States and boosting defense R&D. The report also touches on the need for the EU to evolve, with suggestions to extend qualified majority voting in the Council and using Treaty mechanisms to allow like-minded Member States to move forward together. Draghi emphasizes the importance of cutting the regulatory burden for businesses, especially small ones, to foster innovation and growth.

Keywords

💡Euro

The Euro is the official currency of the European Union and the majority of its member countries, known as the Eurozone. In the video, Mario Draghi's 'Do whatever it takes' declaration in 2012 is highlighted as a pivotal moment in preserving the stability of the Euro during the European debt crisis.

💡GDP Gap

GDP Gap refers to the difference in economic output between two entities, in this case, the EU and the US. The video discusses how the GDP gap has widened from 15% in 2002 to 30% today, indicating a relative decline in the European economy's performance.

💡Productivity

Productivity measures the efficiency of production in an economy, often expressed as the ratio of output to input. The video points out that Europe's lack of productivity is a significant issue, with its labor productivity slipping back to around 80% of that of the US.

💡Digital Technology

Digital technology encompasses the hardware and software used in the creation, storage, and sharing of electronic information. The video emphasizes that the EU has not fully capitalized on the first digital revolution, leading to a growing productivity gap with the US.

💡Innovation Gap

The Innovation Gap refers to the difference in the ability to create new products, services, or processes between different economies or regions. The video notes that Europe has failed to keep pace with the US and China in terms of digital innovation.

💡Decarbonization

Decarbonization is the process of reducing carbon emissions to a net-zero level. The video discusses Draghi's view that decarbonization should be a source of growth and competitiveness for Europe, not just a cost.

💡Energy Security

Energy Security refers to the availability of consistent energy supplies at an affordable price. The video mentions Europe's reliance on Russian natural gas and the need to diversify energy sources to ensure security.

💡Critical Raw Materials

Critical Raw Materials are non-energy, non-agricultural materials that are essential for the economy and have supply issues or are at significant risk. The video highlights Europe's vulnerability due to its reliance on a few suppliers for these materials.

💡Venture Capital

Venture Capital refers to the financing given by investors to start-ups and early-stage growth companies in exchange for equity or debt. The video points out the significant gap in later-stage financing between the US and Europe.

💡Regulatory Burden

Regulatory Burden refers to the costs and obligations imposed on businesses by government regulations. The video suggests that Draghi recommends reviewing regulations to ensure they don't overly burden small businesses.

💡Joint Procurement

Joint Procurement is the process where two or more entities collaborate to purchase goods or services together. The video mentions that Draghi suggests the EU increase joint procurement among Member States to reduce vulnerabilities.

Highlights

Mario Draghi, former ECB president, has released a new report on Europe's future competitiveness.

The European economy is lagging, with the GDP gap between the EU and US widening from 15% in 2002 to 30% today.

72% of the GDP gap widening is attributed to growth issues.

Draghi's report includes 170 key recommendations to address economic decline and prevent social unrest.

The EU has strengths such as a Single Market of 440 million consumers and 23 million companies.

Europe leads in governance, health, education, and environmental protection, with 8 of the top 10 countries for rule of law.

Challenges include slowing trade, energy issues, and over-reliance on US for defense.

Europe's productivity has declined to around 80% of the US level.

The EU has not capitalized on digital technology, with no EU-founded company in the last 50 years reaching a EUR 100 billion market value.

Draghi calls for massive investment in research and innovation to close the innovation gap with the US and China.

Recommendations include targeted EU funding, a capital markets union, and increased budgets for tech projects.

Regulations should be reviewed to ensure they don't burden small businesses.

A Joint decarbonization and Competitiveness Plan is proposed to combine climate goals with economic growth.

Decarbonization is seen as an opportunity for growth, not just a cost, with potential for clean technology leadership.

The EU should diversify energy sources and develop an industrial action plan for the automotive sector.

Increasing security and reducing dependencies on critical raw materials and advanced tech are key.

The EU needs to implement the Critical Raw Materials Act and increase joint procurement for defense.

The total cost of Draghi's recommendations is estimated at EUR 750-800 billion annually, about 5% of EU GDP.

Draghi advocates for joint EU debt measures and more private sector investment.

The EU must evolve by refocusing, accelerating, and simplifying its policies and decision-making processes.

Transcripts

Mario Draghi, the former president of  the European Central Bank, famously  

saved the Euro with his “Do whatever  it takes” declaration in 2012. Now,  

he’s back with a new report on Europe’s  future competitiveness—and let's be honest,  

it couldn't come at a better time. The  European economy isn’t exactly thriving.

Take this for example: back in 2002, the GDP  gap between the EU and the US was just 15%. Fast  

forward to today, and that gap has widened to 30%.  Not great, right? So, what’s going wrong? Well,  

it turns out that 72% of this widening gap  can be attributed to one key issue: growth.

To address this, Draghi outlined 170 key  recommendations in a 400-page report,  

urging EU leaders to make some tough  decisions to stop the economic slide  

and prevent social unrest. And yes, we went  through all 400 pages so you don’t have to.

But it’s not all bad! The EU has created  a Single Market of 440 million consumers  

and 23 million companies, accounting  for around 17% of global GDP. The  

EU’s approach has also delivered impressive  outcomes in governance, health, education,  

and environmental protection. In fact, eight of  the world’s top ten countries for the rule of law  

are EU members. Europe even leads the US and China  in life expectancy and low infant mortality rates.

Still, there are significant challenges.  And Draghi warns that if these issues  

are not addressed, the EU will  die a slow and agonising death.

So, what’s holding Europe back?

Draghi points to several factors,  some of which are external.

Trade is slowing down because markets like  China are now producing their own goods  

and focusing on internal consumption,  reducing demand for European exports.

Energy is another big one—Europe used to  rely on cheap natural gas from Russia,  

but that pipeline has basically dried up.

And then there’s security—Europe has  leaned heavily on the US for defence,  

which weakened its own defence sector,  once a major source of innovation.

But, according to Draghi, the biggest issue  of all is Europe’s lack of productivity.

This graph shows EU vs. US labour  productivity from 1890 to 2022,  

and you can clearly see that Europe made  incredible progress from the end of World  

War II to the end of the century, almost  catching up with the US. However, since then,  

productivity has slipped back down to around  80%. This is likely not to improve anytime soon.

The key driver behind the growing productivity gap  between the EU and the US is digital technology. 

This brings us to Draghi’s first recommendation:  

closing the innovation gap between the EU  and major competitors like the US and China.

Europe has failed to fully capitalise on the  first digital revolution, led by the internet.  

For instance, no EU company founded in the  last 50 years has reached a market value of  

EUR 100 billion, while all six US companies worth  over EUR 1 trillion were created in that time.

“Since 2008 close to 30% of the so-called  unicorns, namely companies that would go  

to be valued more than one billion  euros, unicorns that had started in  

the European Union have left and the majority  of them went to the United States so 30% of  

our most successful innovators have moved  and this has to change Europe must become

a place ewhere innovation flourishes.  Especiallzy for digital tech.

Innovative digital companies in Europe are  struggling to scale and secure funding,  

especially compared to the US. The gap  in later-stage financing is huge, with US  

venture capital investment being five times higher  than in Europe across all development stages.

So what does Draghi suggest? In a  nutshell, he calls for a massive  

investment in research and innovation. He  proposes making EU funding more targeted,  

the creation of a capital markets  union, increasing budgets significantly,  

and channelling more resources into agencies  that back high-risk, high-reward tech projects.

He also recommends reviewing regulations,  especially in the digital sector, to ensure  

they don't burden small businesses.  The idea is to make sure SMEs aren't  

held back by rules that only big companies can  handle, freeing them up to grow and innovate.

This brings us to Draghi’s second recommendation:  A Joint decarbonization and Competitiveness Plan

“The second area is what the president  mentioned before, and it is combining  

decarbonization with competitiveness. Namely,  let me give you the bottom line of this,  

we want decarbonization to be a source  of growth. If all policies are in sync  

with our climate goals. And we will see  later in our conversation, it is a big if.

Decarbonization will be an opportunity for  growth. But if we fail to coordinate there  

is a risk that decarbonization could run  contrary to competitiveness and growth” 

The report indicates that the EU’s bold  decarbonization goals bring some short-term  

costs that others, like China and the US, simply  don’t face. For big industries like chemicals,  

metals, and paper, going green will cost about  EUR 500 billion over the next 15 years. And for  

the toughest transport sectors, like maritime  and aviation, investment needs are expected to  

hit EUR 100 billion annually from 2031 to 2050. But here’s Draghi’s big point: Decarbonization  

isn’t just a cost—it’s a massive opportunity  for Europe to slash energy prices,  

lead in clean technologies, and boost  energy security. Europe has some natural  

advantages—solar in the South, wind in the North  and Southeast— to give it a competitive edge.  

Renewable energy use is already climbing, making  up 22% of the EU’s energy consumption in 2023,  

far outpacing China (14%) and the US (9%). Plus,  while Europe may lag in digital innovation,  

it’s a leader in clean tech, with huge potential  to meet growing global demand for green solutions.

The sad truth is that, despite leading in clean  tech innovation, Europe is losing its edge due  

to a weak innovation system and lack of funding.  China and the US offer much stronger subsidies,  

leaving the EU at a cost disadvantage—solar panel  manufacturing in China is up to 65% cheaper.

Of course Draghi has plenty of suggestions,  but there were a couple that stood out:

First up, the EU needs to go all-in on a  mix of energy sources—renewables, nuclear,  

hydrogen, and carbon capture—while speeding up  approvals and boosting funding for new projects.  

And as natural gas isn’t going anywhere just yet,  the focus should be on stabilising prices, teaming  

up for LNG purchases, and securing long-term deals  with reliable suppliers to keep energy costs down.

Second, the EU should develop an industrial  action plan for the automotive sector to prevent  

production relocation and foreign takeovers.  This plan should focus on electrification,  

digitalization, and value chains like  raw materials and batteries to keep  

EU manufacturers competitive  in EVs and autonomous driving. 

This brings us to Draghi’s third recommendation:  Increasing Security and reducing dependencies 

Europe is vulnerable due to its reliance on  critical raw materials and advanced tech,  

with 40% of imports coming from a few suppliers,  half of which aren't aligned with the EU. 

Geopolitical tensions, like the Russia-Ukraine  war, are pushing Europe to spend more on defence  

due to rising conventional and hybrid warfare  threats. Even with increasing defence budgets,  

only nine EU countries meet NATO's  2% GDP target, and around EUR 500  

billion more is needed over the next decade  to restore and upgrade military capabilities.

To reduce vulnerabilities, Draghi suggests the  EU swiftly implement the Critical Raw Materials  

Act (CRMA), establish joint purchasing,  and develop a supply chain strategy,  

while also accelerating mining, recycling,  and innovation in alternative materials. 

In terms of defence, without  common European spending,  

the EU should increase joint  procurement among Member States.

Boosting EU defence R&D is key, with more funding  for innovations like drones and defence AI,  

and support for defence SMEs through better  lending policies and new EU-wide initiatives.

So, how often did you hear funding? What’s the  actual cost of Draghi’s recommendations? Well,  

he claims it's around EUR 750-800  billion. Annually. That is around 5%  

of EU GDP in 2023—much higher than  the 1-2% under the Marshall Plan.

With the EU’s budget just over 1% of GDP,  

Member States and the private  sector will need to step up.

Of course, many of these goals are not new.

Member States are actually doing this  on their own. But in doing so we really,  

in a sense, we are punching under our  power. We could do much more if all these  

things were done as if we acted as a community.  But we lack focus on key priorities. We don't  

combine our resources to generate scale. And  we do not coordinate the policies that matter.”

Draghi, who famously supported joint  EU debt with the NGEU recovery fund,  

also continues to advocate for joint debt  measures to unlock large-scale investments.  

But he is clear that most investment  needs to come from the private sector.

The report also acknowledges that the EU itself  needs to evolve: by refocusing, Accelerating,  

and Simplifying. One of the most interesting ideas  is to extend qualified majority voting (QMV) in  

the Council to reduce delays caused by unanimous  decisions. If things get stuck, Draghi suggests  

using Treaty mechanisms to allow like-minded  Member States to move forward together. And,  

of course, he emphasises cutting the regulatory  burden for businesses, especially small ones.

What do you think of the report? Do Draghi's  suggestions hit the mark? We’d love to hear  

your thoughts! If you're curious about  why we think the EU struggles with tech,  

check out our video on that topic.  Or, dive into our video on which  

country leads Europe for a closer look  at the most powerful EU member states.

Thanks for watching! Don’t  forget to like, subscribe,  

and if you want to support us even  more, consider joining us on Patreon.

Until next time!