What is False Consciousness?

Summary

This video explores the concept of false consciousness, a term popularized by Marxist theorist Friedrich Engels. False consciousness refers to the ways people misunderstand their own social and economic realities, shaped by ideological forces. The video discusses examples such as patriarchal and capitalist false consciousness, illustrating how both oppressors and the oppressed are affected. It also touches on how beliefs about societal roles, like women's association with childcare, perpetuate systems of domination. The video emphasizes that false consciousness is political and highlights its impact on social hierarchies.

Takeaways

• 📚 False consciousness was introduced by Friedrich Engels in a letter to Franz Mering in 1893.
• 🧠 Engels defined false consciousness as when thinkers are unaware of their real motives and instead imagine false or apparent reasons.
• 🏛️ False consciousness manifests when people view history as a succession of independent thinkers, rather than seeing ideas shaped by society.
• ⚖️ Lorna Finlayson identifies five kinds of false consciousness, including false beliefs about the world, inaccurate self-perception, and inappropriate emotional responses.
• 👁️‍🗨️ False consciousness can lead individuals to ignore relevant social truths, such as not recognizing racism or gendered labor in society.
• 🔄 Ideological false consciousness is inherently political and serves to maintain power structures, promoting the interests of one group over another.
• 👨‍👩‍👧 Patriarchal false consciousness justifies gender roles by promoting the idea that women are naturally suited for childcare, helping to sustain patriarchal norms.
• 💼 Both oppressors and the oppressed can experience false consciousness, such as workers under capitalism or people of all genders under patriarchy.
• 🗣️ Women can also adopt and propagate patriarchal false consciousness, as seen with female content creators who attack feminism to appeal to male audiences.
• 🏦 Marx criticized figures like Jeremy Bentham for embodying capitalist false consciousness, particularly the belief that personal wealth is solely earned through hard work without recognizing exploitation.

Q & A

What is false consciousness according to Friedrich Engels?

False consciousness, as explained by Friedrich Engels, refers to the phenomenon where a person believes they are acting with full awareness, but their real motivations remain unknown to them. Engels noted that people often imagine false motives behind their thoughts and actions, leading them to misunderstand the true reasons driving societal and historical developments.

What is Engels’ example of false consciousness in history?

Engels gave the example of people thinking about the history of ideas as a progression of abstract thinkers producing thoughts independent of their societal context. This view ignores how ideas are shaped by the societies in which the thinkers live, making it a form of false consciousness.

How does false consciousness affect views on the history of ideas?

False consciousness can lead to a misunderstanding of the history of ideas by treating it as a series of great individuals thinking in isolation. In reality, thoughts and ideas are influenced by the society and historical context in which they arise.

What are the five types of false consciousness according to Lorna Finlayson?

Lorna Finlayson identifies five types of false consciousness: 1) false beliefs about the world, 2) inaccurate representation of the world, 3) inappropriate emotional responses to situations, 4) failure to notice relevant truths, and 5) failure to experience appropriate emotional states.

How is ideological false consciousness different from mere false consciousness?

While false consciousness refers to any mistaken belief, ideological false consciousness specifically refers to false beliefs produced by power relations in society. It serves the interests of one social group over another, such as patriarchal or capitalist ideologies.

Can false consciousness affect both the oppressed and the oppressor?

Yes, false consciousness affects both the oppressed and the oppressor. In a patriarchal system, for example, both men and women can have distorted views about gender roles, although the forms of false consciousness may differ depending on their social position.

What is an example of ideological false consciousness in patriarchy?

An example of ideological false consciousness in patriarchy is the belief that women are naturally better suited for childcare. This belief perpetuates gender roles and contributes to the unequal division of labor, reinforcing patriarchal structures.

How does capitalist false consciousness manifest in workers and capitalists?

In capitalist false consciousness, workers may falsely believe that there is no alternative to capitalism, while capitalists may believe they earned their wealth purely through hard work, ignoring the exploitation of labor that contributed to their success.

What criticism does Marx offer about Jeremy Bentham's views?

Marx criticized Jeremy Bentham for embodying capitalist false consciousness. He described Bentham as an 'insipid, pedantic leather-tongued oracle' who viewed the English shopkeeper as the 'normal man,' applying this limited perspective to past, present, and future social realities.

How does false consciousness help maintain power structures in society?

False consciousness helps maintain power structures by promoting beliefs that justify and reinforce existing social hierarchies. For example, patriarchal and capitalist ideologies perpetuate gender and class inequalities by making these systems appear natural or inevitable.

Outlines

00:00

🤔 Understanding False Consciousness and Its Origins

This paragraph introduces the concept of false consciousness, as used by Frederick Engels, who describes it as a state where thinkers are unaware of the real forces driving their thoughts. Engels highlights that this false consciousness leads people to misinterpret the history of ideas as a sequence of isolated thinkers, rather than seeing it as intertwined with societal changes. The paragraph explains that false consciousness manifests in two ways: having incorrect views on the history of ideas and not realizing how societal structures shape one’s thinking. The reference to Engels' letter emphasizes how ideological processes mask true motives, and the paragraph sets the stage for a broader understanding of false consciousness.

05:02

📚 Lorna Finlayson’s Five Forms of False Consciousness

This section explores five distinct types of false consciousness identified by Lorna Finlayson in her book *An Introduction to Feminism*. The types include: 1) false beliefs about the world, such as workers believing capitalism doesn't oppress them, 2) inaccurate self-representations, like a woman seeing herself as uglier than she is, 3) inappropriate emotional responses to situations, 4) a failure to notice relevant truths, such as ignoring systemic racism, and 5) the failure to experience certain emotional states, like a capitalist lacking empathy. The paragraph also introduces the idea of 'ideological false consciousness'—a politically driven type of false consciousness that arises from power relations and serves to uphold the interests of dominant social groups.

Keywords

💡False Consciousness

False consciousness refers to a misrepresentation or misunderstanding of the world and one’s place within it. In the video, it is discussed in the context of people holding beliefs that do not align with reality, particularly under the influence of ideology. For example, workers may believe capitalism does not oppress them, or a misogynist may believe women are inherently bad at math. False consciousness prevents people from recognizing the true nature of societal power relations.

💡Ideology

Ideology is a set of beliefs or ideas that shape how individuals view the world, often unconsciously. Engels explains that ideology is produced by thinkers with false consciousness. The video describes ideological false consciousness as being political in nature, helping to maintain social structures like capitalism or patriarchy by distorting reality in ways that serve the interests of dominant groups.

💡Patriarchy

Patriarchy refers to a social system in which men hold primary power and dominate roles in leadership, moral authority, and control of property. The video gives an example of patriarchal false consciousness, where the idea that women are naturally suited for childcare contributes to the reproduction of gender roles, making people believe this arrangement is natural, thus perpetuating the gendered division of labor.

💡Capitalism

Capitalism is an economic system in which private individuals or corporations own the means of production and operate for profit. The video mentions capitalist false consciousness, where workers may believe there is no alternative to capitalism, and capitalists may believe their success is due solely to their hard work, ignoring the exploitation of labor.

💡Oppressor and Oppressed

In the video, the terms oppressor and oppressed describe the power dynamics within systems like patriarchy and capitalism. Both groups are affected by false consciousness, although in different ways. The oppressor benefits from the social structure, while the oppressed are made to accept or internalize their subordinate status. For example, both men and women can possess patriarchal false consciousness, but it manifests differently based on their position in the power hierarchy.

💡Misogyny

Misogyny is the dislike of, contempt for, or ingrained prejudice against women. The video discusses how misogynistic beliefs, such as the notion that women are bad at math, are examples of false consciousness. These beliefs serve to reinforce patriarchal power structures and contribute to women’s continued subordination in society.

💡Reproductive Labor

Reproductive labor refers to the unpaid work, often performed by women, such as childcare, housework, and caring for the elderly. The video explains that many people do not recognize reproductive labor as valuable work due to patriarchal false consciousness. This failure to acknowledge the importance of such labor contributes to the perpetuation of gender inequality.

💡Jeremy Bentham

Jeremy Bentham was an English philosopher and utilitarian. In the video, Marx critiques Bentham as an example of capitalist false consciousness, describing him as representing the 'ordinary bourgeois intelligence.' Bentham’s ideas are used to illustrate how even philosophers can be subject to the false consciousness of their time, promoting capitalist interests without realizing it.

💡Emotional Responses

The video discusses how false consciousness can affect emotional responses, making them inappropriate for the situation. For example, a victim of abuse may blame themselves or venerate their abuser. This is a form of false consciousness where the emotional reaction is shaped by distorted views of reality, often influenced by power structures like patriarchy.

💡Ideological False Consciousness

Ideological false consciousness is a specific form of false consciousness tied to political power structures. It serves the interests of a dominant group, such as capitalists or men in a patriarchal society. In the video, it’s explained that patriarchal ideology distorts the way both men and women see the world, ensuring the reproduction of patriarchal gender roles and maintaining the division of labor.

Highlights

Frederick Engels first introduced the concept of false consciousness in an 1893 letter to Franz Mehring.

Engels describes ideology as a process completed consciously, but with a false consciousness where the real motives remain unknown to the thinker.

False consciousness is illustrated by thinkers attributing the history of ideas to abstract thinkers rather than the social contexts in which they lived.

Lorna Finlayson identifies five types of false consciousness in her book 'Introduction to Feminism,' including false beliefs and emotional responses.

Examples of false consciousness include workers believing capitalism doesn’t oppress them or misogynists thinking women are naturally bad at math.

An inaccurate representation of the world is another form of false consciousness, such as a woman seeing herself as uglier or larger than she is.

False consciousness can manifest in emotional responses, like victims of abuse blaming themselves and venerating their abusers.

It also includes a failure to notice relevant truths, like white people who think racism no longer exists in a 'post-racial' society.

A significant form is the failure to experience an emotional state, such as capitalists who lack empathy for their workers.

Ideological false consciousness arises from power relations, where ideas serve to promote the interests of one social group over another.

Patriarchal ideology distorts reality to justify gendered divisions of labor, such as the idea that women are naturally suited for childcare.

This patriarchal ideology leads women to internalize the idea that their worth is tied to their success as mothers and caregivers.

Both oppressors and the oppressed can experience false consciousness, such as women on YouTube promoting misogynistic ideas.

Workers and capitalists both experience capitalist false consciousness, with workers accepting capitalism and capitalists believing their success is solely due to their hard work.

Karl Marx critiqued utilitarian Jeremy Bentham for embodying capitalist false consciousness, believing the English shopkeeper represented a universal 'normal man.'

Transcripts

Marxists like to talk about false

consciousness but what exactly is it the

term false consciousness was used by

Frederick Engels in his 1893 letter to

Franz meringue Angles writes quote

ideology is a process accomplished by

the so called thinker consciously indeed

but with a false consciousness the real

motives impelling him remain unknown to

him otherwise it would not be an

ideological process at all hence he

imagines false or apparent motives his

example of false consciousness is people

thinking of the history of ideas as a

succession of abstract thinkers

producing thoughts independently of the

society in which they lived and

overcoming previous generations of

thinkers with better thoughts such a

view is a form of false consciousness

since it ignores that the history of

ideas is bound up with the history of

society thinkers live in societies and

so their thoughts change and society

changes indeed the very idea that the

history of ideas is a history of great

men with great thoughts who live outside

of history is itself a product of a

particular kind of society someone who

ascribed to this view of history would

therefore have false consciousness in

two senses firstly they would have a

false view of the history of ideas

second they would have a false view

about how they came to hold the views

they do building on angles we can hold

that false consciousness refers to

consciousness which is false or

inappropriate in a general sense lorna

Finlayson distinguishes between five

different kinds of false consciousness

in her book and introduction to feminism

these are one a false belief about the

world for example a worker who thinks

capitalism doesn't oppress them or a

misogynist who thinks women are innately

bad at maths - an inaccurate

representation of the world for example

a woman who looks in the mirror and sees

herself as ugly and larger than she

actually is 3 an emotional response that

is inappropriate to the

situation for example a victim of abuse

who blames themselves their abuse and

venerates their abuser for the failure

to notice a relevant truth for example a

white person who doesn't notice racism

and thinks they live in a post-racial

Society or a man who doesn't notice the

reproductive labor that women perform 5

the failure to experience a certain

emotional state

for example a capitalist who doesn't

feel empathy for their employees or a

trans person who doesn't love themselves

because of internalized transphobia a

further distinction can be drawn between

mere false consciousness and ideological

false consciousness false consciousness

is not necessarily political since I am

technically experiencing false

consciousness when I think it is

Wednesday but it is in fact Thursday as

I have a false belief about the world

but the kind of false consciousness

which Marxists are interested in is

false consciousness which is produced by

particular power relations and is

therefore inherently political this is

ideological false consciousness which

refers to false consciousness whose

existence and character is explained by

its tendency to promote the interests of

one social group over another an example

of ideological false consciousness is

patriarchal ideology which consists of

the distorted ways of seeing feeling and

relating to the world which exist and

have the character they do because of

their tendency to further the interests

of men who are dominant over women you

are subordinate for example the idea

that women are naturally best suited to

childcare contributes to a situation in

which women do the majority of childcare

and are expected to by people of all

genders this idea helps reproduce

patriarchal gender roles and

patriarchy's gendered division of labor

by ensuring that people think this

arrangement is natural and should exist

and by producing people who judge the

worth of women relative to their success

at being mothers this in turn leads

women to feel

compelled to do the majority of

childcare so that both others and

themselves do not judge them as failing

to be good women the fact that this idea

reproduces patriarchy in turn explains

why the idea exists and permeates

patriarchal culture after all young

girls are taught these ideas as children

in order to prepare them for an

adulthood in which it is assumed that

they will be mothers and wives one

important feature of false consciousness

so understood is that it affects both

the oppressor and the oppressed in the

case of patriarchy for example people of

all genders possess patriarchal false

consciousness although it takes

different forms depending on sex gender

race class the country live in the

culture you grew up in and so on one of

the most startling examples of this in

the modern world is women who make their

living on YouTube by attacking feminists

and validating the misogyny of their

majority male audience since women are

just as much subject to patriarchal

ideology as men we should keep in mind

that just because a woman does or think

something doesn't automatically mean

that it is furthering the emancipation

of women or that it reflects an accurate

understanding of gender relations in our

society in a similar fashion both

workers and capitalists experience

capitalist false consciousness a worker

may falsely believe that there is no

alternative to capitalism while a

capitalist may falsely believe that they

have earned their wealth through their

own hard work when in reality they have

exploited the labor of others Marx

himself thought that the English

philosopher and utilitarian Jeremy

Bentham suffered from capitalist false

consciousness in Das Kapital Marx

describes Bentham as quote that insipid

pedantic leather tongued Oracle of the

ordinary bourgeois intelligence of the

19th century he continues in a footnote

quote with the driest naivete he takes

the modern shopkeeper essentially the

English shopkeeper as the normal man

whatever is useful to this queer normal

man and to his world is absolutely

useful this yard measured then he

applies to past present and future mr.

jeremy is a genius in the way of

bourgeois stupidity false consciousness

is thus not a patronizing idea about the

B'nai today sirs suffering under

delusions consciously created by

conspiracy of capitalists in reality the

capitalists and the ideologues are

subject to a vast amount of false

consciousness themselves as can be seen

when one reads fortune magazine or

neoclassical economics or when one

watches interviews with Silicon Valley

entrepreneurs talking about why they are

successful if you liked this video

please support me on patreon and follow

me on Twitter have a nice day