Two Major Provinces of Canada say No to Asylum Seekers #canada #canadavisa #canadaimmigration #trv

Summary

In this video, Ajmal from Canada discusses the challenges asylum seekers are facing as major provinces like Quebec and Ontario request the federal government to redistribute asylum seekers due to resource constraints. Smaller provinces, however, are refusing to accept them, raising concerns about the future of these individuals. Ajmal highlights that while larger provinces struggle with capacity, asylum seekers can still seek refuge in smaller provinces, where processes may be smoother. He advises those in need of asylum to consider these regions to avoid delays and complications.

Takeaways

• 🌍 Two major Canadian provinces (Quebec and Ontario) are facing a heavy burden from asylum seekers and have requested the federal government to redistribute them.
• 🚫 Smaller provinces have refused to take any additional asylum seekers from the larger provinces, leading to uncertainty about the future of these asylum seekers.
• 💼 Quebec and Ontario claim their resources and infrastructure are overwhelmed and unable to support the growing number of asylum seekers.
• 📊 The federal government is considering a plan to redistribute asylum seekers across provinces based on population size, but this is still under discussion.
• 🛑 New Brunswick, Nova Scotia, and other smaller provinces have outright declined to accept asylum seekers, particularly if they come through federal channels.
• ⚖️ Canada is obligated to hear asylum cases on merit, regardless of the challenges posed by resource constraints in larger provinces.
• 📍 Asylum seekers typically prefer Quebec (Montreal) or Ontario (Toronto) as their initial destination, leading to overcrowding in these provinces.
• ⏳ Smaller provinces argue that asylum seekers who initially settle in major provinces often return to these provinces after spending some time in smaller regions, reducing the incentive for smaller provinces to invest resources.
• 💰 Smaller provinces demand that if they are to accept asylum seekers, they need financial support and additional resources from the federal government.
• ✅ Despite the challenges, smaller provinces still present opportunities for asylum seekers, especially for those seeking faster processing times and fewer delays compared to larger provinces.

Q & A

What is the main topic of the video?

The video discusses the current situation of asylum seekers in Canada, focusing on how two major provinces, Quebec and Ontario, have requested the federal government to relieve the burden of asylum seekers due to limited resources and infrastructure.

Why are Quebec and Ontario asking the federal government to take action regarding asylum seekers?

Quebec and Ontario are asking the federal government to take action because their resources and infrastructure are overwhelmed by the high influx of asylum seekers. They have requested either the redistribution of asylum seekers to other provinces or an alternative arrangement to ease their burden.

How have the smaller provinces responded to the request to take in asylum seekers?

Smaller provinces, such as New Brunswick and Nova Scotia, have refused to accept asylum seekers that would be transferred from other provinces. They are concerned about the resource demands that come with supporting asylum seekers, including providing healthcare, education, and other services.

What concerns do smaller provinces have about taking in asylum seekers?

Smaller provinces are concerned that asylum seekers may not stay in their province long-term. They worry that after investing resources in supporting them, the asylum seekers will eventually move back to the larger provinces, such as Ontario and Quebec, where they initially settled.

What is the federal government's proposed solution for the asylum seekers issue?

The federal government is considering distributing asylum seekers among provinces based on population size. For example, if a province has 7% of the national population, it would receive 7% of the asylum seekers from Quebec and Ontario.

Will asylum seekers still be able to find refuge in Canada despite the challenges discussed?

Yes, Canada is bound by treaty obligations to hear asylum seekers' cases on merit. Despite the current challenges, asylum seekers will still be able to find refuge in Canada.

Why do asylum seekers prefer to settle in Quebec and Ontario initially?

Asylum seekers prefer to settle in Quebec and Ontario initially because these provinces, particularly cities like Toronto and Montreal, are well-known as popular destinations for newcomers. They offer more established immigrant communities, resources, and support networks.

What advice is given to asylum seekers in light of the current situation?

Asylum seekers are advised to consider settling in smaller provinces rather than larger ones like Quebec and Ontario. Smaller provinces have a shorter processing time for asylum applications and may offer a quicker path to establishing their lives in Canada.

What is the main challenge for smaller provinces in supporting asylum seekers?

The main challenge for smaller provinces is the allocation of resources. They do not want to invest in asylum seekers' healthcare, education, and other services, only for the asylum seekers to move back to the larger provinces after they become self-sufficient.

What is the current status of the asylum process in Canada according to the video?

The asylum process in Canada is still ongoing. However, there is pressure on the federal government to provide resources and financial support to provinces that accept asylum seekers to ensure they can adequately handle the influx.

Outlines

00:00

🌍 Concerns Over Asylum Seekers' Impact on Larger Provinces

The speaker discusses the growing concern that larger provinces like Quebec and Ontario are burdened by an influx of asylum seekers. These provinces have requested federal support to redistribute some of these individuals to smaller provinces, or to find alternative solutions to reduce the pressure on their infrastructure and resources. Despite these requests, many smaller provinces have refused to take in more asylum seekers. The video aims to explore the potential future for asylum seekers in Canada amidst these developments.

05:02

📊 Redistribution Proposal Based on Population

The federal government is considering redistributing asylum seekers based on the population size of each province. For instance, provinces with a smaller population would receive fewer asylum seekers compared to those with larger populations. However, some smaller provinces like New Brunswick and Nova Scotia have outright rejected taking in more asylum seekers, creating a complicated situation where asylum seekers might face uncertainty about where they will be settled.

🏠 Preference for Larger Provinces Among Asylum Seekers

Asylum seekers tend to settle in larger provinces such as Ontario and Quebec due to their infrastructure and resources. The video explains that after spending time in these provinces, many asylum seekers are hesitant to move elsewhere, even if their cases are transferred to smaller provinces. This creates an additional challenge, as smaller provinces are unwilling to bear the costs associated with supporting these individuals if they eventually return to larger provinces where they initially settled.

🚪 Smaller Provinces' Reluctance to Accept Transferred Asylum Seekers

Smaller provinces are concerned about the financial burden of supporting asylum seekers. They argue that after spending resources on healthcare, education, and other services, many asylum seekers will return to the larger provinces once they are financially stable, making the initial investment unsustainable. Therefore, smaller provinces are more open to directly receiving new asylum seekers rather than taking those transferred from larger provinces.

🌍 Canada’s Commitment to Asylum Seekers Despite Provincial Challenges

Despite the reluctance from both larger and smaller provinces, Canada remains committed to hearing asylum cases based on merit, as the country is bound by international treaties. The speaker emphasizes that while the larger provinces are overwhelmed, smaller provinces could offer asylum seekers faster processing times, though they are also pushing back unless additional resources are provided by the federal government.

🎯 Recommendation for Asylum Seekers to Consider Smaller Provinces

The speaker encourages asylum seekers to consider heading directly to smaller provinces, where processing might be quicker and where there is still room for them. The video concludes by reiterating that smaller provinces are willing to take on asylum seekers if the federal government allocates adequate resources to support them, making them a viable option for those seeking refuge.

Keywords

💡Asylum seekers

Asylum seekers are individuals who have fled their home countries due to persecution, war, or violence and are seeking refuge in another country. In the video, the asylum seekers are described as being a burden on the larger Canadian provinces, such as Quebec and Ontario, due to the influx of people, which is overwhelming the available resources and infrastructure.

💡Burden on provinces

The term 'burden' refers to the strain placed on Quebec and Ontario, where large numbers of asylum seekers have settled. The provinces are requesting the federal government to distribute asylum seekers more evenly across the country, as they feel unable to support the increasing population with their current resources.

💡Federal government

The federal government is responsible for overseeing the country's immigration policies, including managing asylum seekers. In the video, Quebec and Ontario are asking the federal government to help redistribute asylum seekers to other provinces and provide additional resources to ease the burden on larger provinces.

💡Resource allocation

This refers to the distribution of financial, healthcare, and other support services needed to care for asylum seekers. The video emphasizes that larger provinces are struggling with resource shortages due to the overwhelming number of asylum seekers and are asking for federal assistance in reallocating these resources.

💡Quebec and Ontario

These are two of the largest provinces in Canada, and they have received a disproportionately high number of asylum seekers. In the video, both provinces are described as having reached their capacity, leading to requests for redistribution of asylum seekers to other, smaller provinces.

💡Smaller provinces

Smaller provinces like New Brunswick and Nova Scotia are discussed in the video as refusing to take in more asylum seekers. They argue that they don't have the resources or capacity to support them and are concerned that people may eventually leave for larger provinces after receiving initial support.

💡Redistribution of asylum seekers

This concept involves transferring asylum seekers from overcrowded provinces like Quebec and Ontario to other provinces across Canada. The video highlights that this is being considered by the federal government as a potential solution to alleviate pressure on larger provinces.

💡Population-based asylum allocation

This refers to the idea of distributing asylum seekers based on the population size of different provinces. The video mentions this as one of the potential approaches under consideration by the federal government to ensure a more balanced distribution of asylum seekers across Canada.

💡Provincial rejection

Several smaller provinces, such as New Brunswick, are rejecting the idea of taking in more asylum seekers, especially those sent by the federal government. They argue that while they may accept asylum seekers who arrive directly, they will not accept those relocated from other provinces.

💡Pressure on infrastructure

The term 'pressure on infrastructure' refers to the strain on housing, healthcare, education, and social services caused by the large influx of asylum seekers in Quebec and Ontario. The video underscores that these provinces are finding it difficult to maintain adequate services for both asylum seekers and their existing populations.

Highlights

Two major provinces in Canada, Quebec and Ontario, have declared that asylum seekers are becoming a burden due to limited resources.

These provinces have requested the federal government to relocate some asylum seekers to other provinces or find alternative arrangements.

Smaller provinces like New Brunswick and Nova Scotia have refused to accept asylum seekers, stating they cannot support them.

The federal government is considering distributing asylum seekers based on population size across provinces.

If provinces like Ontario and Quebec face overwhelming numbers of asylum seekers, smaller provinces may have to step in, but many are reluctant.

Canada is legally obligated to process asylum cases due to international treaties, even if some provinces are unwilling to accept asylum seekers.

Ontario and Quebec have been the top destinations for asylum seekers due to their large populations and resources, but this has caused strain on their infrastructure.

Smaller provinces argue that asylum seekers who spend significant time in larger provinces eventually return there after their cases are processed.

A study shows that most immigrants tend to settle within a 30-kilometer radius of their initial landing spot, making them less likely to remain in smaller provinces.

Smaller provinces worry that providing healthcare and education to asylum seekers only for them to later move back to larger provinces would strain their limited resources.

These provinces want the federal government to provide additional resources or funding if they are to accept more asylum seekers.

Despite the challenges, asylum seekers will not be turned away entirely. Canada is committed to processing their cases.

Asylum seekers are encouraged to consider smaller provinces for faster processing times and fewer delays.

Larger provinces have a high influx of asylum seekers, leading to long wait times due to resource shortages.

Smaller provinces propose that if the federal government wants them to accept more asylum seekers, financial incentives should be included.

Transcripts

अस्सलाम वालेकुम फ्रेंड्स अजमल कनाडा से

मेरी आज की वीडियो का टॉपिक है कि अससाइलम

सीकर्स के हवाले से दो बड़े सूबों ने यह

कहा है कि असलम सीकर्स हम पर बर्डन बन रहे

हैं और वफा से उन्होंने कहा है कि यह हमसे

ले लिए जाएं और छोटे सूबों ने इंकार कर

दिया है उन असाम सीकर्स को लेने से तो आगे

असाम सीकर्स का मुस्तकबिल क्या होगा

वीडियो शुरू करने से पहले मैं हूं अजमल आप

देख रहे हैं मेरा

और जिन लोगों ने जूम सेशन कर रहे हैं वो +

1 825 747 7551 पर मेरी टीम से राबता कर

सकते हैं पिछले दिनों से एक बड़ी खबर

मुसलसल वायरल हो रही है और यह ऑफिशियल

न्यूज़ भी है कि बड़े सूबे जिनमें क्यूबेक

और ओंटेरिगा उन्होंने कहा है जी कि हमारे

पास जो अाइलमेर जमा हो गई है हमारे जो

रिसोर्सेस हैं य हमारा जो इंफ्रास्ट्रक्चर

है वो इनको सपोर्ट नहीं कर सकता तो

उन्होंने फेडरल से यह रिक्वेस्ट की है कि

कुछ लोगों को यहां से लेके तो कुछ और

सूबों में दिया जाए या इनका कोई और मुत

बादल अरेंजमेंट किया जाए ताकि हमारे ऊपर

से प्रेशर थोड़ा कम हो अब इस खबर को लेके

दूसरी खबर इसके साथ कनेक्टेड यह थी कि

फेडरल इस बारे में सोच रहा है कि पॉपुलेशन

के हिसाब से कनाडा में साइलम सीकर्स को

तकसीम किया जाए मिसाल के तौर पर अगर किसी

प्रोविंस की जो आबादी है वह 7 पर है तो 7

पर उन दो सूबों से लेके तो उन उस सूबे को

दे दिया जाए किसी को 5 पर है किसी की 3 पर

है तो इस तरह मुख्तलिफ अभी यह तजवीज पर

काम चल ही रहा था कि न्यू ब्रंस विक ने कह

दिया कि हम कोई भी अससाइलम सीकर नहीं

लेंगे उसके बाद नोवा स्को शिया ने कहा और

काफी सारे और छोटे सूबों ने भी यह अलल

ऐलान कहा कि हम असाल सीकर्स को नहीं लेंगे

खासकर जो व फाक दे रहा है तो बात यह है और

इसके हवाले से फिर लोगों में बड़ी तश्वी

पाई गई कि यार अगर अाइलमेर बड़े सूबे भी

नहीं ले रहे छोटे सूबे भी नहीं लेंगे तो

अाइलमेर कोई असाल सीकर्स नहीं रहेगा या

एक्सेप्ट नहीं किया जाएगा ऐसी बात नहीं है

बात यह है कि कनाडा मैं अपनी पिछली भी

वीडियो में कह चुका हूं कि असाल सीकर्स

अगर खुदान खस्ता किसी बंदे को प्रोक्यू का

सामना है तो कनाडा बाउंड है क्योंकि कनाडा

ने ट्रीटी साइन की हुई है उन लोगों को

उनका केस मेरिट पर सुनने के लिए अब बात यह

है कि बड़े सूबों में तादाद बहुत ज्यादा

है वो मैं पिछली वीडियो में भी बता चुका

हूं कि हां पर इसी वजह से इफ्लक्स ज्यादा

होने की वजह से साइलम सीकर्स का पूरी

दुनिया से लोग जब आते हैं तो उनका पहला जो

मसकन होता है वो टेरियो टोरंटो होता है या

मटियाल होता है क्यूबेक के अंदर यह दो

उनकी असलम सीकर्स की पूरी दुनिया से आने

के बाद फेवरेट डेस्टिनेशन होते हैं अब

वहां पर चका तादाद बहुत ज्यादा हो चुकी है

और वो जो वो सुबे जो है उन्होंने हाथ खड़े

कर दिए हैं तो छोटे सूबे छोटे सूबों में

वैसे भी मैंने आपको पहले भी बताया था कि

टाइमिंग थोड़ी कम होती है वहां पर टाइमिंग

ज्यादा इसी वजह से है क्योंकि वहां पर रश

बहुत ज्यादा है तो छोटे सूबों ने यह कहा

है कि हम भी असलम सीकर्स को जो वफा देगा

हम उनको नहीं लेंगे लेकिन क्या छोटे सूबे

जो खुद से अगर कोई बंदा आके साइलम करता है

तो उसको भी नहीं लेगा ऐसी बात नहीं है जो

छोटे सूबे हैं वह उनका यह मानना है और यह

स्टडी भी है कि इमीग्रेंट कोई भी कोई भी

इमीग्रेंट आता है तो यह स्टडी पब्लिश

स्टडी है कि जब वह जिस जगह पर लैंड करता

है उसी एरिया में 30 किलोमीटर के रेडियस

में वह वहीं पर अपनी जिंदगी गुजार देता है

तो दूसरे लफ्जों में अगर एक बंदा ओंटेरिगा

है

ओंटेरिगा और छ आठ महीने साल वहां पर

गुजारता है तो उसके बाद वह कहीं भी अगर

उसका केस ट्रांसफर हो तो इवेंचर वापस अपने

उस सूबे में आ जाना है क्योंकि उसने

इनिशियल टाइम वहां पर गुजारा है वो कहीं

और सेट नहीं हो पाता मन देखने में ये आया

अब छोटे सूबों का कहना यह है कि जो बंदा

पहले साल डेढ़ साल दो साल या छ महीने

गुजार चुका है किसी और सूबे में वो हमारे

पास आएगा हम उस परे अपने रिसोर्सेस

लगाएंगे छोटे सूबों का मसला है कि उनके

पास पॉपुलेशन नहीं है लेकिन वो यह भी नहीं

चाहते कि वो हेल्थ भी प्रोवाइड करें एक

बंदे को उसको एजुकेशन भी दें उसके बाद

उसको और भी उस परे खराज जात करें और जब वो

जरा सेट हो कमाने लायक हो तो वो वापस बड़े

सूबे में चला जाए यही वजह है कि छोटे सूबे

कहते हैं कि कोई बंदा डायरेक्ट आ जाए तो

फिर तो कोई मसला नहीं है लेकिन इनडायरेक्ट

आएगा तो हम और वफा के जरिए आएगा तो हम

उसको एक्सेप्ट नहीं करेंगे दूसरे लफ्जों

में मैं फिर यही कहूंगा कि अगर पूरी

दुनिया में किसी को भी अगर प्रोक्यू या

जुल्म और सितम का सामना है और वह कनाडा

में आकर उसने साइलम ही करना है तो उसको

चाहिए कि बड़े सूबों की बजाय छोटे सूबों

में अपना रुख करें और छोटे सूबों में उनका

जो प्रोसेस है वह हो भी जाएगा और व कहने

का मकसद यह है कि अपना टाइम अपना जो

रिसोर्स है या अपना जो अ मेन अपना फोकस है

आपको चाहिए कि वह जो भी प्रोक्यू का शिकार

है वह छोटे सूबों का रुख करें बड़े सूबों

की तरफ ना जाए क्योंकि बड़े सूबों में एक

तो टाइम बहुत ज्यादा लग रहा है दूसरा

रिसोर्सेस की कमी होने की वजह से वह उसमें

काफी सारे मुश्किलात पेश आ रही हैं तो

छोटे सूबे और यह अससाइलम जो है मैंने पहले

भी बताया था मैं फिर बता रहा हूं ये बंद

नहीं होगा सिर्फ वफा पे प्रेशर दिया जा

रहा है कि वफा अगर बंदे देता है तो साथ

कुछ रिसोर्स एलोकेशन भी करें या साथ कुछ

पैसे भी दे या साथ कुछ इस तरह का कोई ना

कोई इंसेंटिव दे जो कि उनको कॉमेट करने के

लिए काफी हो या उनको कमेट करने के लिए

उनको फैसिलिटेट करें तो इस वजह से छोटे

सूबे बेसिकली तेजाज ये कर रहे हैं कि हमें

अगर आपने देने ही है तो आप साथ हमें

रिसोर्सेस भी दें आप हमें साथ में

डॉलर्स भी दे दूसरे लफ्जों में तो आज की

वीडियो में मैंने आपको बताया कि असलम

सीकर्स के हवाले से छोटे सूबों में स्टिल

गुंजाइश

रहेगी वीडियो अच्छी लगे लाइक करें शेयर

करें सब्सक्राइब करें थैंक यू