【冒頭無料】三牧聖子×青山直篤×東浩紀「アメリカはなぜトランプを欲望するのか？──米大統領選に見る民主主義の盲点と可能性」@SeikoMimaki @hazuma #ゲンロン240321

Summary

The transcript captures a discussion event focusing on the question of why America desires Trump, exploring the blind spots and possibilities of democracy through the lens of the American presidential election. The event features international political scholar Ms. Misaki and Asahi Shimbun International Reporting's Mr. Aoyama. They delve into the intricacies of the U.S. election process, including the unique aspects of the primary elections and the role of party members and states. The conversation also touches on the perception of Trump's strength in Japan and the U.S., the challenges faced by the Republican party, and the potential impact of Trump's legal issues on the upcoming elections.

Takeaways

• 🎙️ The event is a discussion featuring international political scholar Misaki and Asahi Shimbun International News Department's Aoyama, focusing on the topic 'Why does America desire Trump?' exploring the blind spots and possibilities of democracy through the lens of the American presidency.
• 👥 Misaki and Aoyama are both from the same university year and have a friendly rapport, which sets a casual tone for the discussion.
• 🗳️ The conversation touches on the unique aspects of the American presidential election process, including the caucus system and the primary elections, which can be confusing even for American citizens.
• 🇺🇸 There's a mention of the 'Super Tuesday' concept, which refers to a day with a high concentration of state primaries, significant in determining the direction of the presidential nominations.
• 📊 The script discusses the media's role and its portrayal of Trump's candidacy, highlighting a gap between the excitement within the media and the public's engagement.
• 📰 Japanese media is contrasted with American media, suggesting that the latter is more objective and acknowledges Trump's weaknesses, whereas the former may have a more sensationalist approach.
• 🤔 The speakers ponder why Trump remains strong despite controversies and criminal allegations, suggesting it reflects deeper issues within American society.
• 📈 There's an acknowledgment of the high level of interest and investment in Trump's campaign, indicating a significant support base.
• 🗣️ The discussion includes the idea that the American public may be too accustomed to Trump's strong presence, and that there is a need to reassess and not take his strength for granted.
• 📆 The script references specific dates and the timeline of the election process, indicating the lengthy and complex nature of American presidential elections.
• 🏛️ The conversation suggests that the current system may not be perfectly selecting the most suitable candidates, hinting at potential flaws and room for improvement in the democratic process.

Q & A

What is the main topic of the discussion event in the transcript?

The main topic of the discussion event is 'Why does America desire Trump?' focusing on the blind spots and possibilities of democracy as seen through the lens of the American presidential election.

Who are the guests invited to the discussion event?

The guests invited to the discussion event are Ms. Misaki, an international political scholar, and Mr. Aoyama Nao, from the Asahi Shimbun International News Department.

What is the significance of the 'Super Tuesday' mentioned in the script?

Super Tuesday is a day when a concentration of state primaries and caucuses are held, which can significantly influence the outcome of the presidential nominations in the United States.

How does the script describe the Japanese media's portrayal of Trump's victory?

The script suggests that the Japanese media portrayed Trump's victory as a foregone conclusion, despite the fact that there were signs of his potential weaknesses in the actual election.

What is the role of Mr. Aoyama Nao in the Asahi Shimbun International News Department?

Mr. Aoyama Nao serves as the deputy chief of the International News Department at Asahi Shimbun, overseeing news related to the United States, including South America.

What does the script imply about the general public's understanding of the American presidential election process?

The script implies that the general public, including Japanese citizens, may find the American presidential election process difficult to understand due to its complexity and indirect nature.

What is the unique feature of the American election process mentioned in the script?

The unique feature mentioned is the indirect election process, where the election is not directly by the people but through an electoral college, which is a reflection of the long and complex process in the American election system.

How does the script discuss the role of third-party candidates in the American election?

The script suggests that third-party candidates, such as Robert Kennedy Jr. and Cornel West, have a challenging time gaining visibility and influence in the election process, which is largely dominated by the two major parties.

What is the significance of the 'open primary' mentioned in the script?

An open primary is significant because it allows voters who are not registered with a particular party to participate in the primary election, potentially influencing the outcome.

What is the role of state governments in the American presidential election process as described in the script?

State governments play a crucial role in the American presidential election process by organizing and funding the primary elections and caucuses, which are part of the selection process for the party nominees.

How does the script address the issue of public participation in the election process?

The script addresses the issue by noting that only a small percentage of the electorate actively participates in the primary voting process, and the general public's participation is limited to the general election.