Is it true? women have menstrual pain because of Eve's sin?! An answer leading to be Muslim

Summary

The transcript discusses the Biblical story of Adam and Eve, focusing on their punishment after disobeying God and being expelled from the Garden of Eden. It highlights how Christianity interprets the punishment, particularly for women, regarding childbirth and labor. The speaker contrasts this with Islamic teachings, where both Adam and Eve share the blame, and pregnancy is seen as a blessing rather than a curse. The speaker then engages in a discussion with a woman about converting to Islam, which she accepts after confirming her belief in one God and Prophet Muhammad.

Takeaways

• 🌍 The story of Adam and Eve in the Bible mentions that they were banished from the Garden of Eden for disobeying God's command.
• 🍎 Adam and Eve's sin of eating the forbidden fruit led to punishments, including the need to work for daily sustenance and increased pain in childbirth for women.
• 📖 In the Bible, the blame for the disobedience is primarily placed on Eve, and pregnancy is described as a curse.
• 🤔 The speaker questions how forgiveness can be emphasized when God appears not to have forgiven Adam and Eve for their disobedience.
• 📜 The Quran differs from the Bible by attributing blame to both Adam and Eve equally, and it highlights that both repented and were forgiven by God.
• ⚖️ In the Quran, pregnancy is not seen as a curse but as a revered state, and women are uplifted for their role in childbirth.
• 🤱 The Quran encourages respect for mothers, as they endure pain and hardship during pregnancy and childbirth, mentioned in several verses.
• 👩‍👧‍👦 The Prophet Muhammad emphasized the importance of respecting and honoring mothers, stating that they deserve three times the love and companionship compared to fathers.
• 🕌 Islam teaches that once God has forgiven, He does not continue to punish, making it distinct from the Christian interpretation of original sin.
• 💡 A woman in the dialogue accepts Islam, declaring her belief in one God and that Prophet Muhammad is the final messenger, signifying her conversion.

Q & A

What does the Bible say about the punishment of Adam and Eve for eating the forbidden fruit?

According to the Bible, Adam and Eve were banished from the Garden of Eden because they disobeyed God's command. The Bible says that women will suffer pain during childbirth and will have a desire for their husband as part of the punishment. This is mentioned in Genesis chapter 3, verses 16 and 23.

How does the Bible specifically place blame for the original sin?

In the Bible, the blame for the original sin is predominantly placed on Eve, which has led to the interpretation that women are cursed with the pain of childbirth because of her actions.

What does the Quran say about the sin of Adam and Eve?

In the Quran, both Adam and Eve are equally blamed for the original sin. Both disobeyed God and were forgiven after repenting. The Quran does not place the blame solely on Eve, unlike the Bible.

Is pregnancy seen as a curse in the Quran?

No, the Quran does not consider pregnancy a curse. Instead, it honors women for the pain and effort they endure during childbirth. Verses in Surah Luqman (31:14) and Surah Al-Ahqaf (46:15) emphasize kindness and respect for mothers due to their sacrifices.

How does the Prophet Muhammad (PBUH) emphasize the importance of mothers in Islam?

The Prophet Muhammad (PBUH) highlighted the importance of mothers by stating that 75% of one's love and companionship should go to the mother, and only 25% to the father. This is evident from a hadith where the Prophet told a man that his mother deserves his love and respect three times more than his father.

Why is the story of Adam and Eve interpreted differently in Christianity and Islam?

In Christianity, the blame for the original sin is primarily placed on Eve, leading to the idea of childbirth being a curse for women. In Islam, both Adam and Eve are held equally responsible, and there is no concept of pregnancy being a curse. Instead, pregnancy and motherhood are seen as a source of respect and honor.

How does the Quran view the relationship between parents and children?

The Quran emphasizes the importance of respecting parents, particularly mothers, because of the difficulties they endure during pregnancy and childbirth. This respect is a core value in Islam, as mentioned in Surah Al-Nisa (4:1) and Surah Luqman (31:14).

What is the significance of the phrase 'respect the womb that bore you' in the Quran?

The phrase highlights the importance of acknowledging and respecting the sacrifices mothers make in bringing children into the world. It signifies that Islam honors and uplifts women for their role in childbirth, contrary to the view that childbirth is a curse.

What is the process of accepting Islam, as shown in the transcript?

In the transcript, a woman accepts Islam by declaring the Shahada, the Islamic testimony of faith. She states that there is no god but Allah and that Prophet Muhammad (PBUH) is His messenger. This is done out of her own free will, without coercion or bribery.

What does the transcript say about forgiveness in Islam versus Christianity?

The transcript suggests that while Christianity portrays the punishment of women through childbirth as ongoing due to Eve's original sin, Islam teaches that Adam and Eve were forgiven after repenting. Islam emphasizes God's mercy and forgiveness, contrasting with the perpetual punishment described in the Bible.

Outlines

00:00

🌿 The Biblical Story of Adam and Eve's Punishment

The speaker recounts the story of Adam and Eve from the Bible, explaining how after they ate the forbidden fruit, they were banished from the Garden of Eden. As a result, humans were condemned to work for their sustenance, and women were cursed with increased pain during childbirth. The speaker questions why Allah would continue to punish humanity for this sin, if He has forgiven them. This is contrasted with the Quran’s account, where both Adam and Eve are equally blamed, and forgiveness is emphasized.

05:02

🌙 Comparison Between Islamic and Christian Teachings

The speaker contrasts the Bible and the Quran's treatment of Adam and Eve's disobedience. In the Bible, Eve is primarily blamed, and pregnancy is depicted as a curse on women. However, in the Quran, both Adam and Eve are equally at fault and are forgiven. Pregnancy is seen as an honor that elevates women, rather than a curse. The speaker also highlights Islamic teachings on the respect due to mothers, citing hadiths where the Prophet Muhammad emphasized the importance of honoring one's mother above all else.

🌟 A Woman Embraces Islam

In this segment, the speaker engages in a dialogue with a woman who expresses her desire to convert to Islam. The speaker confirms her belief in Allah and the Prophet Muhammad as the final messenger. After ensuring that she is converting of her own free will, the woman recites the Shahada (Islamic declaration of faith) in Arabic and English, officially becoming a Muslim. The speaker prays for her guidance and for her family's acceptance of Islam, offering her blessings for both this life and the hereafter.

Keywords

💡Garden of Eden

The Garden of Eden refers to the paradise where, according to the Bible, Adam and Eve were placed by God after creation. It symbolizes innocence and purity before they disobeyed God by eating the forbidden fruit. In the script, it is discussed in the context of their disobedience and subsequent punishment by God.

💡Adam and Eve

Adam and Eve are considered the first humans created by God in both the Bible and the Quran. They are central figures in the story of the original sin, where they disobeyed God by eating the forbidden fruit. The video contrasts how the Bible and Quran attribute blame for this act, with the Bible blaming Eve more heavily and the Quran sharing the blame equally between both.

💡Forbidden fruit

The forbidden fruit represents the object that Adam and Eve were instructed not to eat in the Garden of Eden. Eating this fruit led to their expulsion from the Garden. In the script, it symbolizes disobedience to God's command and the subsequent consequences that followed.

💡Punishment

Punishment refers to the consequences Adam and Eve faced after disobeying God. In the Bible, this includes hard labor for men and painful childbirth for women. The script discusses how these punishments have persisted and questions why, if God forgave them, the punishments continue to affect humanity today.

💡Christianity

Christianity is the religion based on the teachings of Jesus Christ. In the video, the speaker contrasts Christian beliefs, particularly the biblical account of Adam and Eve, with Islamic beliefs. The speaker critiques how the Bible places blame primarily on Eve and views pregnancy as a curse.

💡Islam

Islam is the religion based on the teachings of the Prophet Muhammad and the Quran. The video highlights how Islam treats the story of Adam and Eve differently from Christianity, emphasizing that both are equally responsible for disobedience and that pregnancy is viewed as a blessing, not a curse.

💡Repentance and Forgiveness

Repentance refers to the act of seeking forgiveness for wrongdoing, and forgiveness is when one is absolved of their sin. In the script, the speaker discusses how in the Quran, both Adam and Eve repented for their disobedience and were forgiven by God, unlike the Bible, which does not emphasize their forgiveness.

💡Pregnancy

Pregnancy in this script is discussed in the context of religious interpretations. In the Bible, it is described as a curse and punishment for Eve’s disobedience. In contrast, the Quran views pregnancy as something that uplifts women, emphasizing respect and honor for mothers.

💡Quran

The Quran is the holy book of Islam, believed to be the word of God as revealed to the Prophet Muhammad. In the script, the speaker references verses from the Quran to explain the Islamic perspective on the story of Adam and Eve, emphasizing shared blame, forgiveness, and respect for women.

💡Prophet Muhammad

Prophet Muhammad is considered the last and final messenger in Islam. In the script, his teachings are referenced, particularly his emphasis on the importance of honoring one's mother, which aligns with the Quran's teachings about the high status of women, especially in relation to pregnancy and motherhood.

Highlights

The question addresses why punishment continues for humanity if Allah has forgiven Adam and Eve after their disobedience.

The speaker explains that the idea of women being cursed with childbirth pain is from the Bible, specifically in Genesis, and not from the Quran.

According to the Bible, Eve is blamed for the fall of humanity, and women are punished with childbirth pain and subordination to men.

In contrast, the Quran places equal blame on both Adam and Eve for disobeying Allah.

The Quran does not portray pregnancy as a curse but rather as a means of elevating and honoring women.

The Quran emphasizes kindness and respect towards parents, especially mothers, highlighting the struggles they endure in childbirth.

In Islam, the Prophet Muhammad (PBUH) teaches that mothers deserve three-quarters of their children's love and respect, with the father receiving the remaining quarter.

The speaker draws a distinction between Islamic teachings and the Christian concept of original sin, suggesting that God’s forgiveness in Islam means that punishment is not eternal.

The speaker emphasizes that in Islam, pregnancy is seen as an uplifting process for women, not a punishment.

The questioner then expresses a desire to accept Islam, stating her belief in one God and Prophet Muhammad (PBUH) as the final messenger.

The speaker asks if anyone is forcing her to accept Islam, and she confirms that she is doing so of her own free will.

The speaker leads her through the Shahada, the Islamic declaration of faith, affirming her acceptance of Islam.

After reciting the Shahada, the speaker congratulates her and prays for her guidance, her family's guidance, and success in both this life and the next.

The speaker reiterates the differences between Islamic teachings and Christianity regarding the concepts of sin, forgiveness, and the role of women.

The speaker highlights the respect given to mothers in Islam, with the Prophet Muhammad (PBUH) stating that mothers deserve more love and companionship than fathers.

Transcripts

which said that like when Allah had

created the Garden of Eden he put an

Adam and Eve there and but because they

broke the rule eyes and they had the

fruit of I don't know what it is he had

the fruit which was forbidden they were

banished from the garden they were

thrown out and because of which it was

told that let you have to work for your

daily bread you need to work and only

then will you earn to have your daily

bread likewise it was also told that

women they would their pain and

pregnancy will increase it's like till

now the same thing is happening we have

to work hard you have to struggle we

have to do everything necessary to earn

a belly bread and the same thing with

the women like they are dying in

pregnancy their pain is increased

why is it that if Allah Himself had

punished them so badly till date

they are like with the same punishment

how is it as it is an example for just

to forgive other people when Allah

Himself has not forgiven Oh

guide me right sisters also very good

question she rightly said that what a

quoting sister is about the Bible what

is saying is mention in the Bible there

are Adam and Eve may Allah be pleased

with them when they were in the Garden

of Eden they disobeyed the commandment

of Almighty God it's mentioned in the

Bible and it's mentioned in Genesis

chapter number 3 what's the matter 23

that Almighty God punished them and feed

threw them out of the garden and

Almighty God says in Genesis chapter 3

verse number 16 that you women because

they disobeyed God you shall give birth

to children in pain and your desire

shall be that of the husband so

according to the Bible pregnancy is the

curse on the woman this is what

according is the Bible and I agree with

you that how can God not forgive any

Christianity

the full blame in the Bible is put on

the woman Eve Eve Eve man lobby visitor

in Quran if you read there is not a

single place in the Quran where the

blame is put only on Eve the blame is

equally put on Adam and Eve both MyLab

repeat with them if you read in the

Quran it's mentioned in far-off chapter

number 7 verse number 19 to 27 that Adam

and Eve may allah be pleased with them

both of them they disobeyed god both of

them they repented and both were

forgiven the blame is put equally on

them there is not a single verse in the

quran where the blame is only put on Eve

melih between itself but there is a

version of quran in surah taha chapter

number 20 was number 121 which says that

Adam peace be upon him he disobeyed God

so there is one verse which speaks only

about Adam peace be upon him but as a

whole if you analyze the Quran puts the

blame on both of them Adam and Eve both

of them may Allah be pleased with them

in the Bible the blame is only put on

women and because of that Almighty God

says you shall bear children in pain and

your desires will be that of the husband

so pregnancy account the Bible is a

curse but if you read the Quran

pregnancy is not a curse pregnancy

uplift the woman allah says in the quran

in surah nisa chapter 4 verse number 1

respect the womb that bore you

furthermore quran says in surah Luqman

chapter 31 verse number 14 and surah

kahf chapter number 46 verse number 15

that we've enjoyed on the human beings

to be kind to the parents in travail

upon travel to the mother for you and in

pain did she give you birth so here we

realize that the quran says that we have

to respect your parents especially a

mother and a beloved prophet musa

alehsalaam said it's been since i Buhari

volume number 8 in the book of allah

chapter number 2

hadith number 2 a man approaches prefer

misil solemn and asked him that who

deserve the maximum love and

companionship in this world so the

prophet replies your

the man asked after the to the Prophet

against is her mother the man asked

after the two again the Prophet save

your mother

the man asked after the two then for the

fourth time the Prophet says their

father

that means 75% 3/4 of the love and

companionship goes to your mother

25% one foot goes to the father in short

month against the gold medal she gets

the silver medal as well as the bronze

medal the father has to be satisfied

with a mere consolation prize so these

are the teachings of Islam in Islam

pregnancy uplift the woman and I agree

with you once Almighty God has forgiven

the human beings how can you keep on

punishing them so this is the difference

between Islam and Christianity sister

you can reason the answer yes definitely

do you want to accept Islam now yes do

you believe that there is one God yes I

do

do you believe Jesus is God

do you believe Prophet Muhammad peace be

upon him is the last and final messenger

yes I do

if anyone forcing you to accept Islam no

are you doing a lot of your own free

will

yes I would do you out of your own

conviction please is there anyone giving

you a bribe no insha Allah says in

Arabic and you can repeat it like I

should do I said oh Allah Allah Allah ha

ha ha Allah Allah

what I should do I should do ana Ana

Muhammadan muhammadan abduhu wa rasuluhu

personal I bear witness I bear witness I

bear witness that that there is no God

there is no god but Allah but Allah and

I bear witness that that Prophet

Muhammad Prophet Muhammad is is the

messenger the messenger and servant of

Allah and servant of Allah Masha Allah

you're a buffoon and I paid you a lot of

I know that I let you guide you and help

you guide your family members also and

to give you the best in this world as

well as in the next life and inshallah

grandpa Jenna