Fundamentals of Liquid-Liquid Extractions
Summary
TLDRDr. Frank's video delves into liquid-liquid extraction, a purification technique pivotal in organic synthesis. It hinges on solubility differences and immiscibility of solvents, typically employing water and an organic solvent. The video elucidates the 'like dissolves like' principle, emphasizing polar and non-polar solubility preferences. It also introduces reactive extractions, leveraging acid-base chemistry and pKa values to selectively extract organic compounds into aqueous phases. Practical tips on using separatory funnels and the impact of pH on extraction efficiency are provided, concluding with a strategy for separating a mixture of benzoic acid, naphthalene, and aniline.
Takeaways
- 🌟 Liquid-liquid extraction is a purification technique used in organic synthesis, relying on the differing solubilities of compounds in immiscible solvents.
- 💧 The principle of 'like dissolves like' is crucial; polar solvents dissolve polar molecules better, and non-polar solvents dissolve non-polar molecules better.
- 🔬 Water is often used in liquid-liquid extraction due to its immiscibility with many organic solvents and its high polarity.
- 🧪 A separatory funnel is a common piece of lab equipment used to perform liquid-liquid extractions by physically separating immiscible solvent layers.
- ⏏️ The order of solvent layers (organic on top or bottom) depends on their densities, with water typically being the denser layer.
- 📚 Reactive extractions involve using acid-base chemistry to ionize organic molecules, making them soluble in the aqueous phase for separation.
- 🔄 The acid dissociation constant (pKa) is essential for planning reactive extractions, as it indicates the strength of an acid and its tendency to ionize.
- 🔄 The Henderson-Hasselbalch equation relates the pH of a solution to the pKa of an acid, helping predict the partitioning of acid and its conjugate base.
- ⚖️ Performing multiple extractions with small volumes of solvent is more efficient than a single extraction with a large volume for accumulating the product in its preferred phase.
- 🧪 In a mixture of benzoic acid, naphthalene, and aniline, each compound can be selectively separated based on its pKa and the pH of the extraction solution.
Q & A
What is liquid-liquid extraction?
-Liquid-liquid extraction is a purification technique used in organic synthesis, based on the differing solubilities of compounds in immiscible solvents, allowing for the separation of a mixture into distinct layers that can be physically separated.
Why are most organic solvents not suitable for liquid-liquid extraction?
-Most organic solvents are miscible with each other, meaning they mix together and do not form separate layers, which is necessary for effective liquid-liquid extraction.
What is the role of water in liquid-liquid extraction?
-Water is often used in liquid-liquid extraction because it is immiscible with many organic solvents and has a high polarity, allowing it to dissolve polar impurities and ionic compounds effectively.
How does the separatory funnel facilitate liquid-liquid extraction?
-The separatory funnel is a piece of glassware used to mix immiscible solvents, allowing them to separate into distinct layers. It has a valve at the bottom that enables the separate collection of each layer.
What determines whether the organic layer is on top or bottom in a liquid-liquid extraction?
-The density of the solvents determines the layering in liquid-liquid extraction. Water, with a density of one gram per milliliter, is typically on the bottom, while less dense organic solvents float on top.
How does the 'like dissolves like' rule apply to solubility in liquid-liquid extraction?
-The 'like dissolves like' rule suggests that polar solvents dissolve polar molecules better, and non-polar solvents dissolve non-polar molecules better. This principle is used to predict which solvent will preferentially dissolve a given compound.
Why is it more effective to perform multiple extractions with small volumes rather than a single extraction with a large volume?
-Multiple extractions with small volumes allow for the product to accumulate in its preferred phase over time, leading to a higher concentration and more efficient purification compared to a single large volume extraction.
What is reactive extraction and how does it differ from standard liquid-liquid extraction?
-Reactive extraction is a process where an organic compound is selectively ionized to become water-soluble, allowing it to be separated from other compounds in the organic phase. This differs from standard extraction, which relies solely on the physical properties of the compounds.
How is the acid dissociation constant (pKa) used in planning reactive extractions?
-The pKa value is used to predict the partitioning of a weak acid between its neutral and anionic forms based on the pH of the solution. This information is crucial for determining the conditions under which a compound will be soluble in either the organic or aqueous phase.
What is the Henderson-Hasselbalch equation and how does it relate to liquid-liquid extraction?
-The Henderson-Hasselbalch equation is used to predict the ratio of a compound in its ionized form to its neutral form based on the pH of the solution and the compound's pKa. It is used in liquid-liquid extraction to determine the optimal pH for selectively extracting a compound into one phase.
How can the compounds separated by liquid-liquid extraction be recovered in their original form?
-After extraction, compounds like anilinium chloride or sodium benzoate can be converted back to their neutral forms by adding an excess of acid or base, respectively. The neutral compounds can then be extracted into an organic solvent or precipitated out of the aqueous solution.
Outlines
🧪 Fundamentals of Liquid-Liquid Extraction
Dr. Frank introduces liquid-liquid extraction, a purification technique in organic synthesis. The process relies on the differing solubilities of compounds in immiscible solvents, allowing for the separation of a pure product from impurities. Organic solvents are often miscible with each other, but water is immiscible with many organic solvents, making it a common choice for extraction. A separatory funnel is used to physically separate the immiscible solvents into layers, with compounds dissolving preferentially in one layer based on their solubility. The density of the solvents determines the layering, with water typically forming the bottom layer unless the organic solvent is halogenated. The 'like dissolves like' rule is used to predict solubility, with polar solvents dissolving polar molecules better. The video also explains that multiple extractions with smaller volumes are more effective than a single extraction with a large volume.
💧 The Role of Water in Liquid-Liquid Extraction
Water, being a highly polar solvent, is used in liquid-liquid extraction to remove polar impurities like ionic compounds or salts. These compounds, consisting of cations and anions, are among the most polar and thus dissolve preferentially in water. The video discusses how simple inorganic compounds, such as excess base or acid, or ionic byproducts, can be removed through extraction. However, neutral organic compounds cannot be separated by extraction alone, leading to the concept of reactive extractions. This involves using acid-base chemistry to ionize organic molecules, making them water-soluble and allowing for their separation. The video emphasizes the importance of understanding the acid dissociation constant (pKa) for planning reactive extractions, as it quantifies an acid's strength and helps predict the partitioning of a weak acid between its neutral and anionic forms.
🔍 Reactive Extractions and the Henderson-Hasselbalch Equation
The video delves into reactive extractions, explaining how organic molecules can be selectively transferred into the aqueous phase by ionizing them. Acid-base chemistry is used to form water-soluble conjugate bases or acids from weak acids or bases, respectively. The Henderson-Hasselbalch equation is introduced to predict the partitioning of a weak acid between its neutral and anionic forms based on the solution's pH and the acid's pKa. The video graphically illustrates how the partitioning changes with pH, showing that at acidic pHs, the neutral form dominates, while at basic pHs, the conjugate base form is prevalent. It is emphasized that to achieve efficient purification, the pH should be adjusted away from the pKa value to ensure that the target molecules remain in a single phase. The video concludes with a practical scenario involving the separation of benzoic acid, naphthalene, and aniline, demonstrating how their differing acidities and basicities can be exploited for selective extraction.
🌡️ Adjusting pH for Efficient Reactive Extraction
This section focuses on the practical application of pH adjustment for reactive extractions. It explains that to achieve efficient separation, the pH should be set well below the pKa for acids or well above for bases to ensure that the target molecules are almost entirely in one phase. The video uses benzoic acid, naphthalene, and aniline as examples to illustrate how their extraction can be selectively controlled by adjusting the pH. It outlines a step-by-step process for separating these compounds using liquid extraction, starting with the crude mixture in an organic solvent. Aniline is first extracted into the aqueous phase using an acidic solution, followed by the extraction of benzoic acid into the aqueous phase using a basic solution. Naphthalene, remaining neutral and organic-soluble, can be isolated by evaporating the solvent. The video concludes by discussing the regeneration of the neutral forms of aniline and benzoic acid from their respective salts, either by adding excess base or acid, and the subsequent extraction into an organic solvent or precipitation from the aqueous solution.
Mindmap
Keywords
💡Liquid-liquid extraction
💡Solubility
💡Miscibility
💡Separatory funnel
💡Organic solvent
💡Polar solvents
💡Non-polar solvents
💡Acid-base chemistry
💡pKa
💡Henderson-Hasselbalch equation
💡Reactive extractions
Highlights
Liquid-liquid extraction is a purification technique based on the differing solubilities of compounds in immiscible solvents.
The technique exploits the principle that immiscible solvents will separate into layers when mixed.
Organic solvents are often miscible with each other, making them unsuitable for liquid-liquid extraction.
Water is immiscible with many organic solvents, making it a common choice for liquid-liquid extraction.
A separatory funnel is a glassware used for separating immiscible solvents in liquid-liquid extraction.
The density of solvents determines whether the organic layer is on top or bottom in extraction.
Halogenated solvents, like chloroform, have densities higher than water and will be found underneath the aqueous layer.
The 'like dissolves like' rule helps predict solubility, with polar solvents dissolving polar molecules better.
Most neutral organic molecules preferentially dissolve in organic solvents over water.
Multiple extractions with small volumes of solvent are more efficient than a single extraction with a large volume.
Water can remove polar impurities, including ionic compounds or salts, from organic mixtures.
Reactive extractions involve selectively transferring molecules into the aqueous phase by ionizing them.
Acid-base chemistry can be used to ionize organic molecules, making them soluble in the aqueous phase.
The acid dissociation constant (pKa) is a quantitative measure of an acid's strength and is crucial for planning reactive extractions.
The Henderson-Hasselbalch equation relates the pH of a solution to the pKa of an acid, predicting the partitioning of acid and conjugate base.
Molecules are mostly in the neutral form at pH values below their pKa, and in the conjugate base form at pH values above their pKa.
To ensure efficient purification, avoid intermediate pHs around the pKa value of the target molecule.
Reactive extraction can be used to selectively separate compounds like benzoic acid, naphthalene, and aniline based on their pKa values.
A flow chart summarizes the steps for separating a mixture of benzoic acid, naphthalene, and aniline using liquid-liquid extraction.
Aniline can be selectively extracted into the aqueous phase using an acidic solution, while benzoic acid and naphthalene remain in the organic phase.
Benzoic acid can be converted to its water-soluble form by treating the organic solution with a base, leaving naphthalene in the organic phase.
The salts formed during extraction can be converted back to their neutral forms for purification, using either excess acid or base.
Transcripts
Hi everybody, Dr. Frank here to give you a rundown on the fundamental theory behind liquid-liquid
extraction, a useful purification technique in organic synthesis. Liquid-liquid extraction is a
purification technique based on two key concepts: 1) The solubility of various compounds differs
from solvent to solvent. 2) Not all solvents will mix together; this is what we refer to
as miscibility. Two solvents that are immiscible will spontaneously separate themselves if mixed.
So two immiscible solvents with wildly different solvating powers can be used to dissolve an impure
product: in the ideal scenario, all the impurities will preferentially dissolve in one solvent,
while the product alone will remain in the second solvent. Since the solvents won't mix,
they can be physically separated to isolate the solution of the pure product.
While organic solvents can display a wide range of dissolving power, most of them tend to be miscible
with each other so most organic solvent pairs are inadequate for liquid-liquid extraction. Water on
the other hand is immiscible with many organic solvents, save for a few very polar solvents.
As an extremely polar and protic solvent itself, its dissolving power is also fairly distinct
than most of the organic solvents. For this reason, in the overwhelming majority of cases,
liquid-liquid extraction is performed using water and an organic solvent.
Practically speaking, this is easily achieved with minimal effort in an organic synthesis lab
using a specialized piece of glassware known as a separatory funnel,
or a step funnel. When two immiscible solvents are mixed therein, they separate into distinct layers;
compounds found in our mixture will preferentially dissolve in either phases
depending on their respective solubilities. Thanks to the valve at the bottom,
both layers can then be physically separated by draining separately into two different containers.
Distinguishing whether the organic layer is on top or at the bottom
is fairly easily achieved, as the relative ordering depends on the density of each solvent.
Water has a density of one gram per milliliter: most organic solvents have densities that are
inferior to one gram per ml and as such will be found as the top layer. A very notable
exception however are halogenated solvents, such as chloroform and dichloromethane. These solvents
have densities higher than one gram per ml and as such will be found underneath the aqueous layer.
Now that we can distinguish our layers, we need to determine what will be found
in each of those layers. The general rule of thumb when it comes to determining solubility
is "like dissolves like": polar solvents tend to dissolve polar molecules better than non-polar
molecules, and vice-versa. Water is by far the most polar of solvents commonly encountered
in the lab and will thus preferentially dissolve polar compounds, while the organic solvent will
preferentially dissolve non-polar compounds. However, most neutral organic molecules can be
considered as relatively non-polar: sure, some molecules are definitely more polar than others.
Take caffeine, for example: with its various nitrogen atoms and carbonyl moieties, it is
without a doubt more polar than, say, benzene, and as a result has better water solubility.
Yet, caffeine remains better dissolved by many organic solvents: as a rule of thumb for CHM2123,
you can consider that all neutral organic molecules, if given a choice, will preferentially
dissolve in an organic solvent over water. A quick comment regarding this rule of thumb:
you will notice that the word "preferentially" has been repeatedly used throughout this video,
instead of the word "exclusively". The reason for this is fairly simple: let's consider caffeine
again and its respective solubilities in water and chloroform. You'll notice that caffeine is
indeed approximately eight times more soluble than chloroform than it is in water: if we were
to add caffeine to a sep funnel containing equal volumes of chloroform and water, the majority of
the caffeine would be found in the organic phase. We wouldn't find, however, ALL of the caffeine,
since it does have a noticeable solubility in water. This leads us to rule of thumb number two:
when performing liquid-liquid extraction, it is both more efficient and more effective to
perform several extractions with small volumes of organic solvent rather than a single extraction
with a large volume. Over those multiple extractions, the product will accumulate
in its preferred phase. With this said, what is the role of water in a liquid-liquid extraction?
Being an extremely polar solvent, water can be used to remove particularly polar impurities,
notably ionic compounds, or salts. Salts are compounds consisting of cations and anions;
because each ion bears an electrical charge due to the complete transfer of an electron, salts are
among the most polar compounds typically seen in chemistry. As a third rule of thumb for CHM2123,
you can consider that all ionic compounds will preferentially dissolve in water. In many cases,
the impurities removed by a liquid extraction will be relatively simple inorganic compounds;
for instance, excess base or acid used in the reaction, or ionic byproducts that
can result from the reaction, such as the case in a substitution reaction shown here.
However, if a crude reaction mixture is comprised of various neutral organic compounds,
liquid extraction will typically be powerless to further separate them. Typically, but not always:
in some cases, liquid extraction can be used to further separate organic compounds using a process
dubbed reactive extractions. Since most organic molecules tend to be soluble in the organic phase,
further separation will only occur by selectively transferring one of our molecules into the aqueous
phase. How would this be achieved? As mentioned previously, ionic compounds will preferentially
dissolve in water, so to push one molecule into the aqueous phase, it has to be ionized. This
can be done with organic molecules using acid-base chemistry: if an organic molecule is a weak acid,
reacting it with a sufficiently strong base will form the molecule's conjugate base, which will be
water soluble. On the other hand, if an organic molecule is a weak base, reacting it with a
sufficiently strong acid will form the molecule's conjugate acid, which will also be water soluble.
In either cases, the aqueous phase containing the conjugate derivative can be physically separated.
Because acid-base chemistry is reversible, we can isolate the neutral form of whatever we extracted
into the water by adding an excess of acid or base to regenerate the original compound.
To better understand and plan reactive extractions, it is imperative to have a good
understanding of the acid dissociation constant, or pKa, which is a quantitative measure of an
acid's strength in solution. An acid reaction can be described as an equilibrium between the
neutral acid and both its conjugate base and a proton. Being an equilibrium, this process can
be quantified using an equilibrium constant Ka, which is the product of the concentration of the
products over the concentration of the acid. For simplicity, we typically use the inverse
log of this constant (the pKa) which will in most cases be a number ranging from -10
to 55. We can define a pKa value for any hydrogen in a given molecule: this pKa tells us how acidic
this hydrogen is. The lower the pKa, the more acid the hydrogen. Typically, for a molecule,
we will consider the pKa of the most acidic hydrogen, since it will be the first hydrogen to
leave in case of an acid-base reaction. Shown here are the approximate pKas of various functional
groups and simple molecules: strong acids such as hydrochloric acid have very low pKas.
Alkanes have the highest pKas and as a result are the least acidic compounds you will see in
organic chemistry. What we are interested in knowing when doing reactive extractions is the
partitioning of our weak acid: is it mainly in the neutral acid form, which would be organic soluble,
or in the anionic conjugate base form, which would be water soluble?
We can easily predict this partitioning by making use of the pKa value: the key aspect to consider
here is the relationship between the weak acid's pKa and the solution's pH. To do so, we start from
the definition of Ka. By applying a log on each side of the equation and rearranging the terms,
we get the Henderson-Hasselbalch equation, shown here with the pKa and pH highlighted.
We can graphically plot the partitioning of both species as a function of the solution's pH:
unsurprisingly, at acidic pH, almost 100% of the molecules are in the neutral acid form. Inversely,
the conjugate base form dominates at basic pHs. Now, what about this point here,
where the two lines meet? In this case, exactly half of the molecules are in a neutral acid form
and the other half is in the conjugate base form. What is so special about the pH at this point?
Let's analyze this using the Henderson-Hasselbalch equation. Regardless of the actual concentrations
involved, if both species are found in equal amounts, then the ratio A-/HA is equal to one.
The log of one is zero: this tells us that for both species to be found in equal amounts
in the solution, the pH of the solution has to be exactly equal to the pKa of our acid molecule.
Practically speaking this means that half of the molecules will tend to dissolve in the organic
phase, while half of our molecules will dissolve in the aqueous phase.
As you might imagine this scenario is not particularly enviable for purification purposes;
however, if we decrease the pH by acidifying our mixture, we find that the equilibrium is shifted
toward the acid form. This could be demonstrated with the Henderson-Hasselbalch equation;
if the pH is inferior to the pKa, log of A-/HA is negative, which would mean that the concentration
of A- would be inferior to that of HA. A similar argument could be made to show that instead,
by increasing the pH to basic conditions, we promote the formation of the conjugate base.
So, for reactive extraction purposes, we want an almost quantitative partitioning of our acid
into either organic or aqueous soluble species to ensure an efficient purification. For this reason,
we want to avoid intermediate pHs, which typically correspond to the acid's pKa value,
plus or minus one unit, to ensure that all of our target molecules remain in a single phase. Let's
apply this to a concrete scenario, taking as an example three different compounds: benzoic acid,
naphthalene and aniline. The most acidic proton on benzoic acid is a carboxylic acid,
with a pKa value of approximately four. What this tells us is that in the presence of an aqueous
solution whose pH is inferior to 3, benzoic acid will be over 99% in the neutral form
and will dissolve preferentially in the organic solvent. At pHs superior to 5, over 99% of the
molecule will be found instead as a benzoate anion, which is water soluble. Naphthalene bears
no particularly acidic hydrogens: all of its hydrogens have pKas of approximately 40 to 45.
This means that, to be deprotonated, the pH of water would have to be superior to 45,
which is impossible. For this reason, naphthalene will never be deprotonated
in the presence of water and will always remain neutral, and thus organic soluble. Finally,
aniline, which is a bit of a special case. It bears somewhat acidic hydrogens: the one bound to
the nitrogen. However, the pKa for such hydrogens is approximately 30. For similar reasons to what
was just described for naphthalene, aniline will never be deprotonated in the presence of water.
However, aniline is also a base: the nitrogen atom bears a lone pair that can be used to capture an
acidic proton and form a conjugate acid. This acid is indeed stable in the presence of water
and has a pKa of approximately four. So, in acidic solutions with a pH inferior to 3,
the aniline is mostly protonated as the anilinium and is therefore water soluble. On the other hand,
in basic solutions, the anilinium is rapidly deprotonated to form the neutral aniline,
which is organic soluble. So, considering what we just discussed, if given a mixture of the
three compounds, we should easily be able to separate them using only liquid extraction.
We will summarize our steps in a table called a flow chart. Firstly we have a crude mixture
of the three compounds co-dissolved in an appropriate organic solvent, such as ethyl
acetate or dichloromethane. No matter what we do, naphthalene will always remain in the
organic phase, while the acid and the aniline can be selectively pushed into the aqueous phase
one at a time. It does not really matter which compound we start with, so we will start by
removing the aniline. If you remember, aniline can be made water-soluble in fairly acidic conditions,
so we will use a 1M hydrochloric acid solution. At this pH, the aniline is readily extracted
into the aqueous solution as anilinium chloride, while the benzoic acid and the naphthalene remain
neutral and thus organic soluble. Using our sep funnel, we can physically separate each solution.
We can then further purify the remaining organic solution by treating it with base;
1M sodium hydroxide. In these fairly basic conditions, the benzoic acid reacts to form
sodium benzoate, which is water-soluble, and leaves the naphthalene intact in the organic
phase. At this point, we have three relatively pure solutions: two aqueous solutions of anilinium
chloride and sodium benzoate, respectively, and an organic solution of naphthalene. If
naphthalene is the target product, the solvent can be easily evaporated to yield a pure product.
However if aniline and/or benzoic acid are the targets, we have a bit of a problem.
First off, we currently do not have either compounds, but instead their respective
conjugate acid and base. Furthermore, water is impractical to completely evaporate,
so you want to finish with your product in a volatile organic solvent. For both reasons,
we need to convert our salts back to their respective neutral form. The anilinium chloride
can be converted back to aniline by using an excess of base, to ensure complete regeneration
of the neutral form, which can then be extracted into an organic solvent and isolated. Similarly,
the benzoic acid can be regenerated by adding an excess of acid: the resulting benzoic acid
could be extracted using an organic solvent. However, since the acid itself is a solid, it will
precipitate from the water upon acidification and could alternatively be filtered from the solution.
This wraps it up for this video, which focused on the fundamental theory
of liquid-liquid extraction, along with its potential uses.
Coming up next is a technical video that will demonstrate how to effectively assemble
and perform liquid extraction when in a chemistry undergrad lab here, at the University of Ottawa
5.0 / 5 (0 votes)