How Can Fashion Become Truly Circular? | BoF VOICES 2021
Summary
TLDRThe Allen Cath Foundation's book on circular design highlights the importance of transitioning from a linear to a circular economy in fashion. The three core principles of circular design include eliminating waste, extending product and material life cycles, and regenerating natural systems, all powered by renewable energy. This shift is crucial for sustainability, as the current economy results in significant GHG emissions and biodiversity loss. The potential economic opportunity in circular fashion is vast, estimated at $700 billion by 2030. Challenges remain, including systemic change, design innovation, and infrastructure for recycling, but the transition is necessary for a sustainable future.
Takeaways
- 🔄 **Circular Design Principles**: The concept of circular design in fashion revolves around three main principles - eliminating waste and pollution through design, circulating products and materials for as long as possible, and regenerating natural systems.
- 🌱 **Renewable Energy Integration**: For a circular economy to be sustainable in the long term, it must run on renewable energy, affecting not just the fashion industry but also the technology and automotive sectors.
- 🚫 **Waste Reduction**: The fashion industry, known for its creativity, has a significant opportunity to reduce waste by rethinking its business models and product lifecycles.
- 🌐 **Economic Impact**: Shifting to circular business models could create a $700 billion economic opportunity by 2030, highlighting the potential for systemic change in the fashion industry.
- 🔄 **Product Lifecycle**: The importance of designing products that can be easily reintegrated into the system at the end of their useful life is emphasized, to prevent them from ending up in landfills or being incinerated.
- 💡 **Innovation and Collaboration**: The transition to a circular economy requires innovation, collaboration across the entire value chain, and a mindset shift from traditional linear models.
- 🛍️ **Consumer Behavior**: The way the economy functions can influence consumer behavior, making them part of the solution rather than the problem in terms of waste and pollution.
- 🌿 **Regenerative Agriculture**: The fashion industry can contribute to regenerative agriculture by using cotton grown in ways that enhance biodiversity and enrich the soil.
- 🔧 **Challenges in Implementation**: The complexity of designing for a circular economy is acknowledged, with the need for a holistic approach that considers cultural and territorial differences.
- 🎯 **Education and Material Science**: The role of education and material science in developing innovative materials that fit within a circular system is crucial for the success of the circular economy.
- 💼 **Investment and Policy**: The availability of funds for circular economy initiatives is mentioned, with the need for these investments to be directed towards the right projects and for policy changes to support the transition.
Q & A
What are the three principles of circular design mentioned in the transcript?
-The three principles of circular design are: 1) Eliminate waste and pollution through design, 2) Circulate products and materials for as long as possible, and 3) Regeneratively restore natural systems, all while running on renewable energy.
How does the circular economy approach differ from the traditional linear economy?
-The circular economy approach focuses on designing out waste and pollution, keeping products and materials in use, and regenerating natural systems through renewable energy. This is in contrast to the traditional linear economy, which is based on a 'take-make-dispose' model that often leads to resource depletion and environmental degradation.
What is the significance of renewable energy in the context of circular design?
-Renewable energy is crucial in the context of circular design because it ensures that the entire system, including the fashion, technology, and automotive economies, can operate sustainably in the long term without depleting finite resources or causing environmental harm.
How does the circular economy relate to tackling the climate crisis?
-The circular economy addresses the climate crisis by reducing greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions from the way products are made and used, which accounts for approximately 45% of all GHG emissions. By transforming the economy to be circular, it can contribute to mitigating climate change and preserving biodiversity.
What is the potential economic opportunity in the global fashion market through circular business models?
-The potential economic opportunity through circular business models in the global fashion market is estimated to be between $700 billion to $3,700 billion by 2030, representing 23% of the global fashion market.
Why is it important for products to be designed for circularity?
-Designing products for circularity is important because it ensures that products can be reused, repaired, and recycled, thus keeping materials in use and reducing waste. This aligns with the principles of circular design and contributes to a sustainable and regenerative economy.
What challenges does the fashion industry face in implementing circular business models?
-The fashion industry faces challenges such as skepticism from traditional luxury brands, the complexity of designing for circularity across different products and territories, and the need for systemic change that involves coordination across the entire value chain and policy landscape.
How can the fashion industry's interaction with its customers or users change under circular economy principles?
-Under circular economy principles, the fashion industry's interaction with its customers can shift from a transactional model to a relational one, where customers engage in rental, resale, or subscription services, and become part of a system that values product lifecycle and sustainability.
What is the role of digital transformation in enabling the circular economy?
-Digital transformation plays a vital role in enabling the circular economy by facilitating the tracking, sharing, and management of product lifecycles, as well as enabling new business models like online platforms for rental, resale, and other circular services.
How does the concept of 'access over ownership' fit into the circular economy?
-The concept of 'access over ownership' is central to the circular economy as it encourages business models that provide access to products and services without the need for consumers to own them. This reduces the overall demand for new resources and extends the life of products, aligning with the circular design principles.
What are some of the barriers to implementing circular design in the fashion industry?
-Barriers to implementing circular design in the fashion industry include the need for new material science innovations, challenges in designing products that can be easily recycled or repaired, the cultural and logistical complexities of product recovery systems, and the need for systemic change in business models and policy frameworks.
Outlines
🌿 Introduction to Circular Design
The Allen Cath Foundation is launching a book on circular design, which aims to clarify the concept of circularity in the fashion industry. The speaker discusses the importance of understanding the industry's jargon and the three principles of circular design: eliminating waste and pollution through design, circulating products and materials for as long as possible, and regenerating natural systems. These principles, when combined with renewable energy, can create a sustainable economy in various sectors, including fashion. The speaker emphasizes the role of design in achieving circularity, from business models to product lifecycles, and the potential impact on the climate crisis.
🔄 The Shift from Linear to Circular Economy
The speaker highlights the need to transition from a linear economy to a circular one, where economic growth is decoupled from finite resources. The automotive and fashion industries are undergoing this transformation, recognizing the importance of recycling materials and adopting new business models like access over ownership. Digital technology plays a crucial role in facilitating this shift. The speaker also discusses the economic opportunity in circular business models, citing a study that estimates a potential value of $20-30 billion and the potential to capture 23% of the global fashion market. The rise of rental and resale platforms is noted as a significant development in this direction.
🌐 Addressing Industry Skepticism and Barriers
The speaker addresses skepticism within the fashion industry towards circular business models, particularly at the luxury end of the spectrum. The conversation delves into the systemic change required within industries and the need for a collective effort to redefine success. The importance of correctly designing products for a circular economy is emphasized, along with the challenges of ensuring that products fit back into the system at the end of their life cycle. The complexity of creating a circular garment is discussed, highlighting the need for collaboration across the entire value chain.
💡 Overcoming Barriers and Envisioning a Sustainable Future
The speaker discusses the barriers to implementing circular design, including material science challenges and the need for financial innovation. The potential of education and material science to develop materials that fit within a circular system is highlighted. The conversation touches on the role of the finance industry in supporting this shift and the importance of communication in driving the circular economy. The speaker concludes with a call to action for the industry to unite and advocate for a circular economy based on the three principles of regenerating natural systems, eliminating waste, and keeping products and materials in use, all powered by renewable energy.
Mindmap
Keywords
💡Circular Design
💡Sustainability
💡Renewable Energy
💡Economy
💡Biodiversity Loss
💡Fashion Industry
💡Circular Economy
💡Climate Crisis
💡Waste Reduction
💡Business Models
💡Material Science
Highlights
The Allen Cath Foundation is launching a book on circular design.
Circular design is based on three principles: eliminating waste and pollution, circulating products and materials, and regenerating natural systems.
A circular economy, powered by renewable energy, can lead to a sustainable long-term economy in various industries including fashion and technology.
The current economy is responsible for 45% of all GHG emissions and over 90% of biodiversity loss due to the linear model of making and using things.
Circular design is not just about the product but also how it fits within the system and relates to the user.
A shift to circular business models could create a $700 billion economic opportunity and capture 23% of the global fashion market by 2030.
Business models like rental and resale are becoming more popular, especially during the pandemic, showing a potential shift in consumer behavior.
There was initial skepticism in the luxury fashion industry towards circular business models like rental and resale.
The transition from a linear to a circular economy is vital for addressing the climate crisis and biodiversity loss.
Circular design involves designing products to be repaired, reused, and recycled, ensuring they fit back into the system at the end of their life.
A study on circular business models shows the significant economic opportunity in transforming the fashion industry.
The fashion industry has an opportunity to reinvent itself and change the system from linear to circular.
Circularity in fashion is not just about business models but also about the design of the products and how they are communicated to the consumer.
Designers are excited about being part of the solution and the creativity involved in circular design.
Barriers to circular design include challenges in material science, financing, and the need for systemic change across the entire industry.
The fashion industry needs to coordinate with policymakers and other sectors to establish a circular system.
The potential for a circular fashion economy is vast, with the right combination of design, business models, and systemic change.
Transcripts
the allen cath foundation is launching
its book on circular design and you gave
a little teaser in that video of of what
circularity really means but i've been
covering sustainability in this industry
for some time now and i know we throw
around these very big words that mean
very big things and we don't drill into
what it really means and that's
important that we understand what we're
talking about so i wondered if you could
just lay down
what fashion is really aiming for here
circular design is about three
principles the first principle is to
eliminate waste and pollution through
design
the second is to circulate products and
materials for as long as possible and
then the third is to regenerate natural
systems if you do that all running on
renewable energy you effectively build a
fashion economy a technology economy an
automotive economy which can really run
in the long term it's a completely
different approach and it all begins
with design design of the business
models design as a product design of the
the way the product flows through the
system it's all really about design
right from the outset and just to
contextualize what what this could mean
when you talk about you know how we
could run this on green energy
what is the impact in in terms of
tackling
the crisis that i think imran laid out
the start of today as being the biggest
one facing us the climate crisis how
important is this well when you look at
some of the statistics it's quite
surprising you know we when we talk
about climate we hear a lot of
conversation around energy the switch to
renewable energy is vital but actually
the way the economy functions you know
the way we we make and use things
including food that's responsible for 45
of all ghg emissions and over 90 of
biodiversity loss just because of the
way we do things so if you change the
way we do things you change the way the
economy functions to enable all the the
users i love the word user we use that
as well you know the users the actors
within the economy to make the economy
work for you so that you have designed
out waste there is no waste there's no
pollution products cycle for as long as
they need to and then they they feed
back into the system and then you
regenerate natural systems then actually
through the way the economy functions
you're making the world a better place
and it's not just the energy question
it's actually how the economy functions
and that's really fascinating today our
economy is so wasteful and yet we're
innovative and creative and you see the
presentations here and you think you
know we can do anything this is you know
we have this world of opportunity we
have digital we can share in seconds why
are we making stuff that becomes waste
when we have finite materials and then
you put that in line with the statistics
around ghd emissions from the way we
make and use things it's crazy we can do
so much better with this if we have that
goal yeah and i think it's one of the
great ironies of the fashion industry in
particular as you say it's such a
creative industry absolutely has an
opportunity to take such a creative
stance to find solutions and yet the
waste in this industry
as dave vivian han outlined yesterday i
think she if i'm remembering the
statistics she used correctly 12 of all
fibers just never used completely
wasteful so the scale of opportunity
here in terms of transforming the
industry
how much of a difference to fashion
could we make oh we've just done a study
on circular business models which is how
the products fit within the economy how
they can cycle within the economy notice
the design of the materials but this is
actually the business model and we
reckon up by 20 30 700 billion us
dollars worth of economic opportunity
and 23 percent of the global fashion
market when you see companies like you
know the real real and rent the runway
coming from nowhere and grasping a
sector of the market that really wasn't
there and it you know billion dollar
businesses you know in a heartbeat
really when you look at the timeline
it's really interesting to see and i
think this this
this conversation around the users and
the way that the fashion industry
interacts with their customers or their
users or the participants within it i
think there's some really big
opportunities here because when you look
at that circular economy and you look at
cycling those products and how those
products fit this can become a
relationship with an organization or a
company that makes the products this
isn't just about the design of the
product but it's also so important how
that product relates to the user how
that product fits back within the system
there's no point in building the perfect
circular item of clothing if once it
gets to the end of its useful life you
can't do anything with it or the person
who ends up with it doesn't know the
materials and it's been really really
interesting to see particularly during
the pandemic how those business models
like rental and resale have begun to
take off more but
there was a lot of hesitancy within the
industry towards these business models
when they first came onto the scene
particularly particularly at the luxury
end of the spectrum there was a lot of
skepticism a lot of concern
why do you think that was and do you
do you think we've got past that barrier
i think you know in some
if you're in a traditional linear system
which really we've inherited since the
industrial revolution where the way you
make your profits is to take a material
turn it into something and sell it i
mean one of my earliest conversations
was in the automotive sector this was
nearly 10 years ago
where raw material prices had gone up by
500 million euros in 12 months half the
operating profits wiped away like that
and that that business had no control
over it that's because they're tied to
that linear system and you only make
money when you sell stuff that's now
transforming in automotive as it's
transforming in fashion as we realize
actually we need to decouple our
economic growth from the use of finite
resources we need to feed those
resources into a system so they become
not virgin resources but they're
recycled materials how do you do that
well you can do that through design
through the cycling of materials but
through just different business models
you know access over ownership this is
all changing and digital makes this
happen that's why this the digital
transformation is so vital to to
bringing this all to life so get on
board or miss out
yes
but it's really interesting because you
know i was at cop last month and i sat
on a panel with philip hildebrand who's
the number two in blackrock you know
if anybody knows about global investment
it's him and he was challenged by the
moderators saying but this is about
sacrifice you know this transition is
going to cost this is down to us as the
users the consumers whatever you want to
call them we're going to pay for this
and he just said do you know what he
said if we continue with business as
usual gdp goes down by 25 in the next
two decades business as usual doesn't
work it's not the solution and i think
that's where we need to begin
the process from is realizing that
actually carrying on as we are is not a
solution it it's never going to work we
have a growing world population we have
finite resources we have the climate
crisis we have we have to change the
system can't we change the system from
linear to circular so it works for us so
consumers make the world a better place
through their choices through the fact
that the cotton that they're buying is
grown in a regenerative way and it's
enhancing biodiversity and it's making
the topsoil richer not poorer because
we're at the moment we're locked in a
race to the bottom and that's about
making a product with a little bit less
for a little bit cheaper so people can
buy it a little bit cheaper and it's and
you're kind of racing down how can we
make a bit more profit from this this
turns all of that on its head this is a
race to the top this is to build better
to design better to change the system to
enable access over ownership to let
people have these products and
participate in the solution not feel
like every time they're making a choice
they're actually part of the problem and
that's why the sys the sys the system
has to change and systemic change within
the fashion industry in the automotive
industry and the plastic packaging
industry it has to be
the entire system shifting towards that
regenerative model let's talk a little
bit about our basic instincts as human
beings here though as well
because what we're seeing interestingly
in fashion is
business as companies test out things
like rental and resale which is very
exciting and potentially transformative
is you're also seeing companies spot an
opportunity to
drive more consumption so you know come
to my resale site get a voucher to buy
new things yeah other side so
do do we get to a do we run the risk of
being in a position where we have this
opportunity transform but because
the there is a higher value near term by
doing it in a way that doesn't
absolutely shift the system we don't
take advantage exactly yeah
there's always a risk but what we're
beginning to see and this you know
we see this in the fashion sector
beginning but there are some fascinating
things going on in other sectors like in
faster moving consumer goods food
production we're beginning to see some
of the biggest
food retailers in the world you know
producers of product compete over nature
positive food
now imagine that when you walk into a
supermarket at the moment we're thinking
you know if you're a conscious
individual and you can afford
the choice because not everyone can
you're trying to make an informed
decision with not a lot of data what do
you buy you know what do you choose
what's
if the companies involved in that sector
are then competing over nature positive
food you know that what you're buying is
making the world a better place
and you don't have to understand
circularity or the circular economy to
do that this is nature positive this is
hunter's biodiversity this builds up the
natural capital in farmland this is a
good thing i think in the fashion
industry we're going to see something
similar we know business as usual
doesn't work we know we need to reinvent
the system it's not just about different
business models and access over
ownership it's the design of the
products that are sold no we're not
going to have access over ownership for
underwear you know there are products
that that won't work for we have a whole
range of things there are some really
high value items like things that i've
been given by my parents i'm going to
keep those forever they're incredibly
valuable to me
but then you also have the things that
just quite frankly aren't or technology
that has to cycle because technology
moves on
all of these opportunities need to fit
within a system and need to be correctly
designed so when that thing that you
won't rent and you actually have to buy
or access in a different way when that
goes back into the system it's designed
for that system and what does that mean
correctly designed what is a product
that is designed for a circular model
well it's interesting we ran a big
project on the jeans redesign right
getting together the biggest genes
manufacturers in the world and saying
what do circular genes look like and how
do you make this happen you know what do
you put in them
what level of um
what level of uh
quality do you have to look at when you
grow the cotton in the first place um
how do you extract the material and make
sure that when those genes if they're
not resold or repaired reach the end of
their life that they can be fed back
into the system and that's really hard
and it's actually very rare to get the
biggest competitors and this has been
mentioned at this conference we need to
work together to make this happen this
is not a question of competing you know
100 innovations in 100 directions
doesn't add up to a solution you need to
work out what success looks like for
that for the you know the jeans industry
or for the fashion industry and then
orientate everybody towards it so that
every step takes you one close one step
closer to that goal and we know we can
identify what that goal looks like and
that's where the circular design comes
in looking at what is circular design
well it's making sure you can take the
materials out of those products you can
repair the garments you can keep them in
the system but if it's something that
can't stay in the system and make sure
it fits within the system when it gets
to the end of its life make sure there's
there's a system there that enables that
product to be fed back into the system
because there's no point in designing a
circular t-shirt if it just ends up in
landfill 87 of textiles ends up you know
incinerated or landfill and only one
percent currently globally gets recycled
into the same quality material i mean
the statistics are
really shocking so we can do better than
that we can build products that can fit
within a cycle and we won't always get
it right but that goal gives the
direction of travel which is so
important were you surprised when you
started digging into this about the
complexity
involved in figuring out how to make a
circular garden garment
um it it is incredibly complex
and there are and it's interesting you
need the entire
value chain in the room this is not just
a design question
it's obviously a design question but
it's everything that sits around that
and everyone needs to get their heads in
the room to get their heads around it
and then you actually need to do it to
learn more about it as you put
everything in process and in a way
it sounds crazy to say but to design a
circular pair of jeans is fairly
straightforward because the criteria is
clear but then when you look at the
fashion industry this is not about one
product in one territory it's about
multiple products in multiple
territories and different countries have
different recovery systems for garments
so if you design that perfect circular
garment how do you guarantee it fits
back into that system so the cotton is
you know ultimately the very end of its
life you know by degraded and put back
on agricultural farmland how do you
build that and that's different
everywhere so it's a very culturally
specific as well as design orientated
and value chain conversation and so it's
about taking a really holistic point of
view at the point of design and i know
that you and the macarthur foundation
consulted when you were putting together
the circular design but did you get
pushback from designers
in saying you know this isn't realistic
this is too restrictive
you're telling us how we should design
it's it's not creative i would say
that's not the vibe at all i think there
was and it's really interesting
genuine excitement
to be part of
the solution but from a real it's a book
for creatives from a real creativity
perspective and there's some really
interesting points of view in the book
about values
you know
do you have pride in a designer at
making multiple garments that are sold
multiple times that you know 87 of which
you know are going to be on landfill or
incinerated or is there pride in
building something that people value
that is valuable and even if it's you
know underwear that underwear at the end
of its life still has a value because
today it doesn't
you know
things are made to be worn and then
they're not really valuable at all so
they they end up being incinerated or
landfilled i mean that's what happens to
things that don't have value so i think
there's a real
excitement around being part of the
opportunity and i think also the opening
of the conversation from the creatives
in the design space to the creatives in
the marketing space in the online space
in the in the in the communication space
you know how we're going to communicate
circular business models what what's the
message and that's a fascinating
challenge to have and an opportunity to
seize
to to to be ahead of the game and to
think of the future because as we know
business as usual can't run so we need
to be creative as to how we build that
that future economy and so and what are
the barriers
that we're facing here you know 700
billion opportunity 23 of the market
potentially by 2030
what is it going to take to get there
well mindset change
you know you said yourself sarah some
people resist this some people are more
up for this some people realize they
might actually do this themselves you
may have a service with a luxury goods
provider whereby you don't actually own
what you're wearing at all and you're
just clothed by them like the stars are
why not you know why not everybody do
that there's no
there are certain items you wouldn't do
that with
for but actually the majority absolutely
you can and we've you know seen
companies appear and provide this so i
think there is there's a massive
opportunity there and there's there's an
opportunity to communicate in a
different way i'd say some of the
barriers around design you know we don't
have all the answers around design it's
the same with plastic packaging it's the
same with automotive you know how do you
design this in a different way
some of the challenges sit with material
science but then the opportunities sit
there too and you know we work a huge
amount in education globally with
universities around the world and it's
fascinating looking at new materials the
material science innovation making
materials that fit within a system it's
it's you're being part of the solution
and it's all about innovation and
creativity so for me there are barriers
and they sit in different areas you know
the financing if you're if you're
renting your clothing or providing it as
a service how does that sit on the books
how are you invested but then
the the other side of that is that there
is you know as again to go back to the
conversation with blackrock and
about the finance industry the money's
there
the money's there to be invested but it
needs to be connected to the right
investments
and this isn't a conversation about um
the csr part of the business this isn't
a conversation about um you know
environmental and social governance this
is a conversation about how the they're
vital but this is a conversation about
the industry and how the industry
functions and how that industry plays a
role in the switch from linear to
circular and that's not clear and that's
not measured very clearly yet but the
money's there waiting to back it up so
the communication of how this will
unfold
is really really interesting
it's and i think that is a really
interesting barrier to talk about
because
when i talk to people in the industry
about this there's a lot of
excitement about it there's a lot of
experimentation there are a lot of pilot
projects
there's not much scaling and there's a
lot of challenges still in play around
how you figure out getting products back
to recycle them what the infrastructure
is who is meant to put that in place as
you said changes from country to country
yeah
the industry
can't do this alone
who does it need to be coordinating with
and
how quickly does do we all need to get
our acts together i think that's a
really good question and
i think what's interesting is
the industry
from our perspective and the work we've
done with you know the players and
organizations we work with there's a
there's a real feeling that the system
has to change that the fashion industry
has to change not just a feeling you
know the pilot project in place
um such as we're next in new york where
there's a we you know worked with new
york state to put a system together so
the clothing could feed back in as a as
a pilot as a trial to see how do we get
this clothing back how do we build this
system that can cycle but because
because it is so different in all the
different territories and and that
really is a channel but the most
important point comes back to the fact
that
if some of the biggest players in the
world and we've we've seen this and done
this with plastic packaging globally
we've got 20 of the global plastic
packaging industry signed up to a global
commitment with unep which is now
changing policy if the biggest players
in the world say do you know what this
is what success looks for our industry
you know with the jeans or with the
fashion industry as a whole which is a
really big goal but if that that
direction of travel is fixed that makes
it so much easier for policymakers to
change so what what should everyone in
this room be getting together to ask for
abs well absolutely a circular economy
for fashion based on three principles
that regenerates natural systems that
designs that waste and pollution and
keeps products and materials in use you
run that on renewable energy we have a
fashion industry that can run forever
and build the most beautiful things
because they sit within a system that
ultimately make the world a better place
what an amazing place to get to
i feel like there is no more to say on
this
thank you so much
[Music]
Browse More Related Video
![](https://i.ytimg.com/vi/y78UVWd5PHE/hq720.jpg)
Creating a circular economy for fashion | Rethink Sustainability
![](https://i.ytimg.com/vi/NAnYJOu_H24/hqdefault.jpg?sqp=-oaymwEXCJADEOABSFryq4qpAwkIARUAAIhCGAE=&rs=AOn4CLDwsUB_UgNGNitnrzFtqyWTgOLOHQ)
Sustainability Hub: SDG12 – Responsible Consumption and Production
![](https://i.ytimg.com/vi/wXASRXbjR08/hq720.jpg)
Red Alert - How to meet the Sustainable Development Goals together | SDG Moment | United Nations
![](https://i.ytimg.com/vi/Czu3BC7SrFQ/hq720.jpg)
E-waste: Cleaning Up The World's Fastest-Growing Trash Problem
![](https://i.ytimg.com/vi/NBEvJwTxs4w/hq720.jpg)
Ellen MacArthur on the basics of the circular economy
![](https://i.ytimg.com/vi/xC_h8QLo1Iw/hq720.jpg)
Automotive Industry & Circular Economy
5.0 / 5 (0 votes)