What is Pragmatism?

Summary

Pragmatism is a philosophical approach emphasizing practical consequences as key to meaning and truth. It posits that truth is relative to what works effectively. Founded by Charles Sanders Peirce, pragmatism evolved through William James and John Dewey, suggesting that theories closer to truth are those that better predict and control our world. It values the scientific method for inquiry but also acknowledges other means of resolving doubt.

Takeaways

• 🔧 **Practical Consequences**: Pragmatism emphasizes that the truth and meaning of ideas are determined by their practical consequences or real effects.
• 🛠️ **Working Theory**: A central claim of pragmatism is that something is true only to the extent that it works in practice.
• 🌐 **Not a Single Philosophy**: Pragmatism is not uniform; it is a diverse style or approach to philosophy, with various interpretations and applications.
• 🔮 **Predictive and Control Success**: Pragmatism asserts that theories that are more successful in predicting and controlling the world are closer to the truth.
• 📚 **Meaning through Consequences**: The meaning of a concept is equated with its operational or practical consequences.
• 🔬 **Scientific Method**: Pragmatism aligns with positivism in asserting that the scientific method is the best approach for theoretical inquiry.
• 🏋️‍♂️ **Doubt Settlement**: Pragmatism acknowledges that settling doubt can be achieved through persistence and other methods beyond the scientific method.
• 🏛️ **American Philosophy**: Pragmatism was founded by American philosopher Charles Sanders Peirce as a reaction to metaphysical theories.
• 📖 **Pragmatic Maxim**: The pragmatic maxim is a set of principles that guide logical thinking and has many variations with broad philosophical implications.
• 📈 **Peak in Early 20th Century**: Pragmatism reached its peak in the early 20th century through the works of William James and John Dewey.

Q & A

What is Pragmatism?

Pragmatism is a philosophical doctrine that emphasizes practical consequences and real effects as essential components of meaning and truth. It suggests that something is true only to the extent that it works.

How does Pragmatism define truth?

Pragmatism defines truth as that which is successful in predicting and controlling our world, asserting that a theory is closer to the truth if it is more effective than its rivals.

What is the relationship between meaning and practical consequences in Pragmatism?

In Pragmatism, the meaning of any concept is equated with the conceivable operational or practical consequences of whatever the concept portrays.

Is Pragmatism a single philosophy?

No, Pragmatism is not a single philosophy; it is more of a style or approach to doing philosophy that focuses on practical outcomes and consequences.

How does Pragmatism view the scientific method?

Pragmatism regards the scientific method as generally best suited for theoretical inquiry, although it also recognizes other methods such as tenacity and persistence in settling doubt.

Who is credited with founding Pragmatism?

Charles Sanders Peirce is credited with founding Pragmatism, having first stated the pragmatic maxim in the late 19th century.

What was the pragmatic maxim originally intended for?

The pragmatic maxim was originally intended as a maxim of logic and a reaction to metaphysical theories.

How did the term 'Pragmatism' come into use?

The term 'Pragmatism' was first used in print by William James, who credited Charles Sanders Peirce with coining the term during the early 1870s.

Who were the prominent figures in the Pragmatism movement during the early 20th century?

William James and John Dewey were the prominent figures in the Pragmatism movement during the early 20th century.

What are some variations within Pragmatism?

The pragmatic maxim is a family of principles with numerous subtle variations, indicating that there are different interpretations and applications of Pragmatism within philosophical thought.

Outlines

00:00

🔍 Pragmatism: Philosophy of Practical Consequences

Pragmatism is a philosophical doctrine that emphasizes the importance of practical consequences and real effects in determining meaning and truth. It suggests that the truth of a statement is tied to its practical utility. This philosophy is not a single, unified theory but rather a flexible approach to philosophy that values theories based on their success in predicting and controlling the world. Pragmatism equates the meaning of a concept with its potential practical consequences. It supports the scientific method as the best approach for inquiry but also acknowledges other methods for resolving doubt. Founded by Charles Sanders Peirce in the late 19th century, pragmatism gained prominence through the early 20th-century works of William James and John Dewey, with the term itself first used by James.

Keywords

💡Pragmatism

Pragmatism is a philosophical doctrine that emphasizes the practical consequences or real effects as crucial components of meaning and truth. It suggests that the truth of a proposition is tied to its utility or 'workability' in practical terms. In the video, pragmatism is discussed as a way of doing philosophy that focuses on the success of theories in predicting and controlling our world, thereby being closer to the truth.

💡Philosophical Doctrine

A philosophical doctrine refers to a set of principles or a system of beliefs that guide philosophical inquiry. In the context of the video, pragmatism is presented as such a doctrine, offering a framework for understanding the nature of truth and meaning through the lens of practical application.

💡Practical Consequences

Practical consequences are the real-world effects or outcomes that result from applying a theory or concept. The video underscores the importance of these consequences in pragmatism, where the truth of an idea is determined by its effectiveness in practice, rather than abstract or theoretical considerations.

💡Truth

In pragmatism, truth is not an absolute or fixed property but is relative to its practical success. The video explains that something is considered true in pragmatism to the extent that it 'works' or has practical utility, aligning with the philosophy's focus on the applicability of ideas.

💡Predicting and Controlling

The video mentions that pragmatism asserts theories that are more successful in predicting and controlling our world can be considered nearer to the truth. This highlights the empirical and action-oriented nature of pragmatism, where theories are valued for their predictive and manipulative power over reality.

💡Conceptual Meaning

Conceptual meaning, as discussed in the video, is equated with the practical consequences of a concept in pragmatism. This means that the meaning of an idea is derived from its operational or practical implications, rather than from abstract definitions.

💡Operational Consequences

Operational consequences refer to the practical applications or uses of a concept. The video explains that pragmatism equates the meaning of a concept with its conceivable operational consequences, emphasizing the importance of action and practice in defining meaning.

💡Scientific Method

The scientific method is presented in the video as the preferred approach to theoretical inquiry in pragmatism. It is valued for its empirical and testable nature, which aligns with pragmatism's focus on practical consequences and real-world effects.

💡Charles Sanders Peirce

Charles Sanders Peirce is identified in the video as the founder of pragmatism. He introduced the pragmatic maxim as a reaction to metaphysical theories, marking a significant shift in philosophical thought towards a more practical and empirical approach.

💡Pragmatic Maxim

The pragmatic maxim, as mentioned in the video, is a central principle of pragmatism introduced by Peirce. It serves as a maxim of logic that emphasizes the practical implications of ideas, suggesting that the meaning of a concept is tied to its practical effects.

💡William James and John Dewey

William James and John Dewey are highlighted in the video as key figures in the development of pragmatism. Their philosophies in the early 20th century brought pragmatism to its peak, influencing a wide range of philosophical thought and emphasizing the practical aspects of truth and meaning.

Highlights

Pragmatism is a philosophical doctrine focusing on practical consequences and real effects as vital components of meaning and truth.

Central claim of pragmatism is that something is true only insofar as it works.

Pragmatism is not a single philosophy but a style or way of doing philosophy.

Pragmatism asserts that a theory is nearer to the truth if it is more successful in predicting and controlling our world.

The meaning of a concept can be equated with its conceivable operational or practical consequences.

Pragmatism aligns with positivism in asserting that the scientific method is best suited for theoretical inquiry.

It accepts that doubt can be settled by tenacity, persistence, and other methods beyond the scientific method.

Pragmatism was founded by American philosopher Charles Sanders Peirce in the late 19th century.

Peirce introduced the pragmatic maxim as a maxim of logic and a reaction to metaphysical theories.

The pragmatic maxim is a family of principles with numerous subtle variations.

Pragmatism's implications reach into almost every corner of philosophical thought.

The term 'pragmatism' was first used in print by William James, who credited Peirce with coining the term.

Pragmatism reached its peak in the early 20th century philosophies of William James and John Dewey.

James credited Peirce with the term 'pragmatism' during the early 1870s.

Pragmatism emphasizes the importance of practical application and consequences in determining truth and meaning.

The philosophy suggests that the success of a theory in predicting and controlling the world is a measure of its truth.

The school of pragmatism has had a significant impact on various areas of philosophy.

Transcripts

what is pragmatism

broadly construed pragmatism is a

philosophical doctrine which considers

practical consequences

or real effects to be vital components

of both meaning and truth

its central claim is the idea that

something is true only insofar as it

works

but it must be noted that pragmatism is

not a single philosophy in fact it is

more of a style or way of doing

philosophy

in particular pragmatism asserts that

any theory that proves itself more

successful in predicting and controlling

our world than its rivals can be

considered to be nearer the truth

it argues that the meaning of any

concept can be equated with the

conceivable operational or practical

consequences of whatever the concept

portrays

like positivism it asserts that the

scientific method is generally best

suited to theoretical inquiry

although pragmatism also accepts that

the settlement of doubt can also be

achieved by tenacity and persistence the

authority of a source of reader-made

beliefs or other methods

pragmatism is founded by the american

philosopher charles sanders purse who

first stated the pragmatic maxim in the

late 19th century as a maxim of logic

and as a reaction to metaphysical

theories

the pragmatic maxim is actually a family

of principles not all equivalent and

there are numerous subtle variations

with implications which reach into

almost every corner of philosophical

thought

it is interesting to note that the

school of pragmatism reached its peak in

the early 20th century philosophies of

william james and john dewey

in fact the term pragmatism was first

used in print by james who credited

purse with coining the term during the

early 1870s