Kohlberg’s 6 Stages of Moral Development

Summary

This script explores Lawrence Kohlberg's six stages of moral development through three levels: pre-conventional, conventional, and post-conventional. It uses a schoolyard fight scenario to illustrate how individuals at different stages might react and justify their actions. The Heinz dilemma is presented to challenge viewers' moral reasoning, inviting them to consider the complexities of justice, compassion, and social norms in ethical decision-making.

Takeaways

• 📚 Lawrence Kohlberg's theory outlines six stages of moral development across three levels: pre-conventional, conventional, and post-conventional.
• 👦 At stage one, moral reasoning is based on obedience and the fear of punishment, exemplified by Finn's hesitation to intervene in a fight due to potential punishment.
• 🤔 Stage two is characterized by self-interest, as seen with Mary who helps Tom with the expectation of reciprocation, weighing the risks and benefits.
• 👥 At stage three, conformity and interpersonal accord influence moral judgments, like Betty's decision to not intervene in the fight to fit in with the crowd.
• 👮‍♂️ Stage four values authority and social order, demonstrated by the teacher's immediate action to stop the fight, prioritizing rules and order.
• 📜 In stage five, individuals like Jessie understand rules as a social contract, questioning the purpose and fairness of rules, and considering the broader implications.
• 🌟 Stage six is guided by universal ethical principles, with the headmaster emphasizing justice and compassion as the highest moral principles, even when it means breaking rules.
• 🧒 The pre-conventional level (stages one and two) is common among children, focusing on direct consequences rather than social norms.
• 👩‍🎓 The conventional level (stages three and four) is prevalent during adolescence and adulthood, where morality is centered around societal norms and rules.
• 🤓 The post-conventional level (stages five and six) is less common, where individuals may act against societal norms or rules if they conflict with personal morality.
• 🔍 Kohlberg's theory was developed based on Piaget's cognitive development theory and was tested through interviews with boys aged 10 to 16 about hypothetical moral dilemmas.
• 💊 The Heinz dilemma is a famous moral scenario used by Kohlberg to explore moral reasoning, asking whether stealing a drug to save a life is justified and how love or stranger status might affect the decision.

Q & A

What are the three levels of moral development according to Lawrence Kohlberg's theory?

The three levels of moral development according to Kohlberg's theory are pre-conventional, conventional, and post-conventional.

What is the primary concern of individuals at stage one of Kohlberg's theory?

At stage one, individuals are primarily concerned with obedience and punishment, making moral judgments based on the direct consequences they expect for themselves.

How does Mary's decision to intervene in the fight reflect stage two of Kohlberg's theory?

Mary's decision to intervene reflects stage two, where she is motivated by self-interest, considering the potential for reciprocity and the personal benefits of helping Tom.

Why does Betty decide not to intervene in the fight according to stage three?

Betty decides not to intervene because at stage three, she is guided by interpersonal accord and conformity, valuing the opinions of others and the desire to fit in with the community's ethics.

What does the teacher's reaction to the fight indicate about his moral development stage?

The teacher's reaction indicates that he is at stage four, where he values authority and the maintenance of social order, emphasizing the importance of following rules to prevent chaos.

How does Jessie's perspective on the school rules differ from the others?

Jessie's perspective differs as she is at stage five, understanding rules as a social contract and questioning whether they serve the right purpose, rather than accepting them as strict orders.

What is the headmaster's approach to moral reasoning at the post-conventional level?

The headmaster's approach at the post-conventional level is guided by universal ethical principles, particularly justice and compassion, which he believes should underpin all rules and actions.

Why did Kohlberg base his work on Piaget's theory of cognitive development?

Kohlberg based his work on Piaget's theory because it provided a foundation for understanding how individuals develop cognitively, which he then applied to the development of moral reasoning.

What is the Heinz dilemma and why is it significant in Kohlberg's research?

The Heinz dilemma is a moral dilemma used by Kohlberg to test his theory, presenting a situation where Heinz must decide whether to steal a life-saving drug. It is significant because it allows Kohlberg to analyze how individuals justify their decisions based on their stage of moral development.

How can the Heinz dilemma be used to understand different stages of moral development?

The Heinz dilemma can be used to understand different stages of moral development by examining how individuals justify their decisions. For example, those at the pre-conventional level might focus on the direct consequences, while those at the post-conventional level might consider universal ethical principles.

Outlines

00:00

📚 Stages of Moral Development

This paragraph introduces Lawrence Kohlberg's theory of moral development, outlining six stages grouped into three levels: pre-conventional, conventional, and post-conventional. It uses a schoolyard fight scenario to illustrate how individuals at different stages might react and justify their actions. Stage one is driven by obedience and punishment, stage two by self-interest, stage three by conformity and social norms, stage four by authority and social order, stage five by social contract and the purpose of rules, and stage six by universal ethical principles. The paragraph also explains the reasoning behind each stage, indicating that moral development is a progression from self-centered to societal and finally to principled thinking.

05:00

💊 The Heinz Dilemma

The second paragraph presents the Heinz dilemma, a moral scenario used by Kohlberg to explore moral reasoning. It describes a situation where a man named Heinz must decide whether to steal a life-saving drug that is priced exorbitantly by the pharmacist. The paragraph poses several questions to the audience regarding the morality of Heinz's actions and variations of the scenario, such as the relationship to the sick person and the pharmacist's responsibility. It concludes with an invitation for viewers to engage by sharing their thoughts in the comments and supporting the channel through Patreon, emphasizing the educational mission of making complex subjects accessible.

Keywords

💡Moral Reasoning

Moral reasoning refers to the cognitive process of forming judgments about moral issues. In the video, it is the central theme, illustrating how individuals at different stages of moral development reason about right and wrong. For instance, Finn at stage one bases his moral judgment on the fear of punishment, while the headmaster at stage six considers universal ethical principles.

💡Stages of Moral Development

This concept outlines the progression of moral understanding from childhood to adulthood. The video script describes six stages categorized into three levels: pre-conventional, conventional, and post-conventional. Each stage represents a different way of justifying moral decisions, such as self-interest at stage two or social contract at stage five.

💡Pre-conventional Level

The pre-conventional level represents the earliest stage of moral development, where individuals are driven by external consequences and self-interest. The script uses Finn and Mary as examples, with Finn avoiding punishment and Mary considering potential future reciprocation as her moral compass.

💡Conventional Level

At the conventional level, moral judgments are influenced by social expectations and norms. The script illustrates this with Betty conforming to the community's ethics and the teacher upholding social order through adherence to rules, showing how their morality is centered around societal views of right and wrong.

💡Post-conventional Level

The post-conventional level is the most advanced stage of moral development, characterized by an understanding of universal ethical principles that may transcend societal rules. The headmaster represents this level, as he believes in justice and compassion as the highest moral principles, independent of societal norms.

💡Obedience and Punishment

This concept is tied to the first stage of moral development, where moral judgments are based on the fear of punishment. Finn exemplifies this by not intervening in the fight due to his fear of being punished by the teacher, demonstrating a direct link between obedience and moral reasoning.

💡Self-Interest

Self-interest is a motivational factor at the second stage of moral development, where individuals act based on personal gain or loss. Mary's decision to help Tom, despite the risk of punishment, is driven by the potential for future help in return, showcasing self-interest as a moral reasoning factor.

💡Interpersonal Accord and Conformity

This concept relates to the third stage of moral development, where individuals conform to the expectations of others to maintain social harmony. Betty's decision not to intervene in the fight is influenced by the behavior of her peers, highlighting the importance of social acceptance in her moral judgment.

💡Authority and Social Order

The script illustrates the fourth stage of moral development, where authority and social order are paramount. The teacher's intervention in the fight is driven by a duty to maintain rules and order, reflecting a belief in the necessity of societal structures for a functioning community.

💡Social Contract

At the fifth stage, moral reasoning is based on the idea of rules as a social contract, which can be questioned and altered if they do not serve the community's interests. Jessie's uncertainty about the school's anti-fighting rule in light of Tom's previous aggression reflects a nuanced understanding of the purpose of rules.

💡Universal Ethical Principles

This concept is central to the sixth stage of moral development, where moral decisions are guided by principles such as justice and compassion. The headmaster's approach to the fight, emphasizing the importance of understanding and compassion, illustrates the application of universal ethical principles in moral reasoning.

💡Heinz Dilemma

The Heinz dilemma is a famous moral dilemma used by Kohlberg to study moral reasoning. It presents a complex situation where Heinz must decide whether to steal a life-saving drug. The script uses this dilemma to engage viewers in moral reasoning, asking them to consider the justifications for Heinz's actions and the implications of varying circumstances.

Highlights

Lawrence Kohlberg's theory outlines six stages of moral reasoning development.

Moral development stages are categorized into three levels: pre-conventional, conventional, and post-conventional.

A schoolyard fight scenario illustrates different moral reasoning stages among students.

At stage one, moral judgments are based on obedience and punishment, as exemplified by Finn.

Stage two is characterized by self-interest motivation, as shown by Mary's decision to help Tom.

Stage three involves moral judgment guided by interpersonal accord and conformity, like Betty's actions.

At stage four, authority and social order are paramount, as the teacher's intervention demonstrates.

Stage five recognizes rules as a social contract, with Jessie questioning the purpose of school rules.

Stage six is guided by universal ethical principles, as the headmaster's approach to justice and compassion indicates.

Pre-conventional level reasoning is driven by fear and self-interest, common in children.

Conventional level morality is centered around societal norms and is typical in adolescence and adulthood.

Post-conventional reasoning involves a complex understanding of morality, beyond societal rules.

Kohlberg's work is based on Piaget's theory of cognitive development.

Kohlberg confirmed his theory by interviewing boys aged 10 to 16 about moral dilemmas.

The Heinz dilemma is a famous moral test presented by Kohlberg to assess moral reasoning.

The dilemma raises questions about stealing a drug to save a life and the implications of different relationships.

The video encourages viewers to consider their own moral reasoning through the Heinz dilemma.

The video aims to explain complex subjects simply, using language and cartoons to aid student learning.

Support for the channel is offered through Patreon, where donations help in creating educational content.

Transcripts

Lawrence Kohlberg's theory claims that our development of moral reasoning happens in six stages.

The stages themselves are structured in three levels:

pre-conventional, conventional, and post-conventional

To understand this better, imagine a conflict at school

There is a fight in the schoolyard, two ninth-graders are beating up Tom

Those who watch the fight are at different stages of moral development

Let's see what they do and how they justify their behavior

At stage one, we make moral judgments based on obedience and punishment

Finn's sense of good or bad is directly linked to whether he gets punished or not

Finn sees what is happening to his friend and wants to help, but

he doesn't because he is afraid the teacher may punish him if he gets caught fighting

He asks himself, how can I avoid punishment?

At stage two, we are motivated by self-interest

Mary decides to intervene and help Tom

She knows that she might get punished,

but she also knows that she could become a victim herself someday

If she helps Tom now, he might help her in the future

She is asking herself: What's in it for me?

At stage three, interpersonal accord and conformity guide our moral judgment

Betty sees the fight and wants to intervene

But when she realizes that all the others are just watching, she decides not to get involved

She wants others to see that she is a good girl who is conforming with the ethics of the community

She asks herself: What do others think of me?

At stage four, we value authority and want to maintain social order

When the teacher sees the group fighting he immediately steps in and shouts: Stop! Fighting at school is forbidden!

He feels that, above all, it is important to follow the rules, otherwise chaos breaks out

He feels it is his duty to uphold the rules that sustain a functioning society

He asks himself: How can I maintain law and order?

At stage five, we understand rules as a social contract as opposed to a strict order

Jessie who watches from afar is not sure how she feels about this

To her, rules make sense only if they serve the right purpose

Obviously, the school rules prohibit fighting. But maybe Tom deserves to finally learn his lesson

Just yesterday he punched a young girl from grade one

She asks herself: Does a rule truly serve all members of the community?

At stage six, we are guided by universal ethical principles

All those involved now have to face the headmaster

He first explains the school rules and why they exist

He then clarifies that rules are valid only if they are grounded in justice

The commitment to justice carries with it an obligation to disobey unjust rules

The headmaster's highest moral principle is compassion

He believes that all people should learn to understand each other's viewpoints and that they don't feel alone with their feelings

He asks: What are the abstract ethical principles that serve my understandings of justice?

At the pre-conventional level, Finn is driven by fear and Mary by self-interest

Both judge what is right or wrong by the direct consequences they expect for themselves, and not by social norms

This form of reasoning is common among children

At the conventional level,

Betty responds to peer pressure and the teacher follows the rules

Their morality is centered around what society regards as right

At this level, the fairness of rules is seldom questioned

It is common to think like this during adolescence and adulthood

At the post-conventional level, Jesse knows that things are complicated because individuals may disobey rules inconsistent with their own morality

The headmaster follows a universal ethical idea at complete disconnect with what society thinks or the rules say

To him, everything is solved through compassion

The right behavior in his opinion is therefore never a means to an end, but always an end in itself

Not every person reaches this level

The American psychologist Lawrence Kohlberg based his work on Piaget's theory of cognitive development

In order to confirm his theory of stages of moral development

Kohlberg interviewed boys between the ages of 10 and 16

He analyzed how they would justify their decision when confronted with different hypothetical moral dilemmas

We will now present to you the most famous moral dilemma Kohlberg presented to his students

Let's see what you would do

The Heinz dilemma: A woman was on her deathbed

There was only one drug that the doctors thought might save her

The druggist that made that particular medicine sold it for ten times the price of the production costs

The sick woman's husband, Heinz, was poor and could not afford to buy the drug

not even with the financial help of his friends

Heinz then asked the pharmacist to sell it to him for half the price

But he refused

To save the life of his wife, Heinz broke into the man's laboratory and stole the medicine

Now tell us:

Should Heinz have stolen the drug?

Would it change anything if Heinz didn't love his wife?

What if the person dying was not his wife but a stranger?

Should the police arrest the druggist for murder if the wife had died?

Please write your answers and their justifications in the comments below

If you like this video and the way we explain the subject subscribe to our channel

We try to explain complex subjects in simple language and cartoons to support students all around the world in their learning

If you want to support us, you can go to www.patreon.com/sprouts and donate

Just $1 from many fans makes a big difference