Livewire or Vue.js: Which to Use When?

Summary

This video discusses the results of a poll comparing Livewire and Vue.js popularity across Twitter, LinkedIn, and YouTube, garnering over 6,000 votes. It reveals that audience bubbles can skew results, as Livewire leads on Twitter while Vue.js dominates on YouTube and LinkedIn. The video explores community feedback, highlighting that Livewire is favored for quick Laravel integration by PHP developers, whereas Vue.js is preferred for larger projects requiring front-end and back-end separation and better performance. It also touches on the broader community support for Vue.js and mentions other alternatives like Alpine JS, Inertia, and jQuery, concluding that both Livewire and Vue.js have their merits and job opportunities.

Takeaways

• 📊 The poll conducted across Twitter, LinkedIn, and YouTube revealed significant differences in the popularity of Livewire and Vue.js, with Livewire leading on Twitter and Vue.js on YouTube and LinkedIn.
• 🔍 The results highlight the existence of 'bubbles' in online communities, where audience composition can skew perceptions of tool popularity.
• 🌐 Livewire's adoption into the official Laravel ecosystem and its domain change to livewire.laravel.com suggest a growing presence, despite not matching the expected poll results.
• 🏆 Vue.js showed a strong lead on LinkedIn, indicating broader acceptance outside the Laravel community, while Livewire remains more niche.
• 🤔 The poll numbers were close, suggesting no clear winner, and implying that both Livewire and Vue.js have their merits and are viable choices.
• 🛠️ Comments from the community suggest that Livewire is favored for quick, easy integration within the Laravel ecosystem, especially by backend developers.
• 🔧 Vue.js is seen as a better choice for larger projects, with a clear separation of frontend and backend roles, and for teams with dedicated front-end developers.
• 👥 The size of the community can impact support and resources available for developers, with Vue.js having a broader community than Livewire.
• 🚀 Livewire is considered more suitable for PHP developers who prefer not to delve deeply into JavaScript, offering a more backend-oriented approach.
• 🛑 Some concerns were raised about Livewire's performance, particularly with slow networks, and the potential for unnecessary server requests.
• 🌟 Job opportunities were noted as a factor, with Vue.js and React having a broader job market compared to Livewire, at least in some regions.

Q & A

What was the purpose of the poll conducted by the video creator?

The purpose of the poll was to compare the popularity of Livewire and Vue.js among the creator's audience across three different platforms: Twitter, LinkedIn, and YouTube.

How many votes did the poll receive in total?

The poll received more than 6,000 votes in total.

What were the main platforms where the poll was published?

The poll was published on Twitter, LinkedIn, and YouTube.

What was the general outcome of the poll on Twitter?

On Twitter, Livewire was more popular, with 50% of the votes.

How did the results differ on YouTube and LinkedIn compared to Twitter?

On YouTube and LinkedIn, Vue.js won by a significant margin, indicating that the audience on these platforms preferred Vue.js over Livewire.

What does the video creator suggest about the audience's perspective on technology tools?

The creator suggests that everyone lives in a bubble, meaning that the audience's preferences are influenced by the platform they are on and their own experiences.

What is the significance of Livewire's domain name change to livewire.lal.com?

The domain name change signifies that Livewire has been officially adopted into the Laravel ecosystem, indicating its growing popularity and integration within the Laravel community.

What are the main concerns raised by the community regarding Livewire and Vue.js?

The main concerns include the suitability of each framework for different types of projects, the separation of concerns, the size and helpfulness of the community, and the performance implications of each framework.

Why might a backend developer or a PHP developer prefer Livewire?

Backend developers or PHP developers might prefer Livewire because it allows them to work within the Laravel ecosystem without needing to focus much on JavaScript, and it offers quick and easy integration for small projects.

What are some alternative technologies mentioned by the community for reactivity besides Livewire and Vue.js?

Some alternatives mentioned include Alpine JS, Inertia, React, jQuery, and Angular.

What advice does the video creator give regarding the choice between Livewire and Vue.js?

The creator advises that if speed and small project scope are priorities, Livewire might be the better choice. However, for long-term projects with a focus on frontend performance and potential separation of frontend and backend, Vue.js or React could be stronger alternatives.

What does the video suggest about the importance of considering the project's business goals and strategy?

The video suggests that the choice between Livewire and Vue.js can depend on whether the project prioritizes backend optimization or frontend reactivity and user experience, aligning with the business goals and strategy of the project.

Outlines

00:00

📊 Poll Results on Livewire vs Vue.js Popularity

The video script discusses the results of a poll comparing the popularity of Livewire and Vue.js across three platforms: Twitter, LinkedIn, and YouTube. The poll gathered over 6,000 votes, indicating a significant level of objectivity. The results varied by platform, with Livewire leading on Twitter but Vue.js taking a significant lead on YouTube and LinkedIn. The script highlights the importance of considering the audience's bubble when interpreting these results. It also points out that despite expectations of higher numbers for Livewire, Vue.js showed a strong presence, especially on LinkedIn where the audience is broader and includes general IT professionals.

05:00

🔍 Analyzing Community Feedback on Livewire and Vue.js

This section delves into the community's comments and reasons for preferring Livewire or Vue.js. It mentions that Livewire is favored for its simplicity and integration within the Laravel ecosystem, making it ideal for backend developers and quick projects. Conversely, Vue.js is seen as a better choice for larger projects requiring a separation of frontend and backend, as well as for those who value frontend performance and have a team with specialized front-end developers. The script also references other polls and surveys that echo similar sentiments, indicating a small but growing trend towards Livewire, despite Vue.js maintaining a strong position.

10:02

🛠️ Comparing Livewire and Vue.js: Community Insights and Alternatives

The final paragraph summarizes the community's insights on the advantages and disadvantages of using Livewire versus Vue.js. It emphasizes that Livewire is well-suited for PHP developers who prefer to avoid deep JavaScript customization, while Vue.js offers more control and a broader community support base. The script also touches on job opportunities, suggesting that Vue.js might have a slight edge in the job market. Additionally, it mentions other alternatives to Livewire and Vue.js, such as Alpine JS, Inertia, React, jQuery, and Angular, acknowledging the diversity of choices available to developers. The video concludes by encouraging further discussion in the comments and promoting subscription for more in-depth content.

Keywords

💡Livewire

Livewire is a full-stack framework for Laravel that allows developers to build dynamic interfaces with minimal JavaScript. It's designed to be easy to use for backend developers who might not be as comfortable with front-end technologies. In the video, the presenter discusses the results of a poll comparing Livewire's popularity to Vue.js, highlighting that Livewire is often chosen for its simplicity and seamless integration within the Laravel ecosystem, as mentioned in the context of 'Livewire is within the Laravel ecosystem'.

💡Vue.js

Vue.js is a progressive JavaScript framework for building user interfaces. It's known for its reactivity, component-based architecture, and the ability to be incrementally adopted. The video script mentions Vue.js as a popular choice, especially when there's a need for a clear separation of concerns between front-end and back-end, or when developers require more control over the behavior and debugging, as indicated by comments praising Vue.js for its 'front-end performance' and 'control over the behavior'.

💡Poll

A poll, as discussed in the video, is a survey used to gather opinions or make decisions. The presenter conducted a poll on platforms like Twitter, LinkedIn, and YouTube to gauge the community's preference between Livewire and Vue.js. The poll results are central to the video's theme, as they provide data that drives the discussion on the relative merits and popularity of Livewire versus Vue.js.

💡Community

The term 'community' in the video refers to the collective group of developers and professionals who use and contribute to the Laravel ecosystem. The script mentions that the community's size can impact support and resources, such as when solving bugs or problems. For instance, the presenter notes that Vue.js has a broader community that could provide more extensive help, which is an advantage over Livewire's more niche community.

💡Ecosystem

An ecosystem, in the context of the video, refers to the interconnected network of tools, frameworks, and practices that support a particular technology or platform, such as Laravel. The presenter mentions that Livewire is well-suited for those who prefer to stay within the Laravel ecosystem, leveraging its integration and familiarity, as opposed to using Vue.js, which can be used outside of Laravel.

💡Reactivity

Reactivity in web development refers to the ability of a user interface to respond instantly to state changes. The video discusses reactivity in the context of choosing between Livewire and Vue.js, with the latter being known for its reactive data binding and component system. The script highlights that for those who value a reactive front-end, Vue.js might be a preferred choice.

💡Performance

Performance in the video refers to the efficiency and speed of web applications. The script includes comments from developers who have concerns about Livewire's performance, particularly in scenarios with slow networks or when there's a need for optimization. The video suggests that Vue.js might be a better option for those who prioritize performance and optimization.

💡Job Opportunities

The video touches on the practical aspect of job opportunities when choosing between Livewire and Vue.js. It mentions that there might be more job openings for developers skilled in Vue.js or React, indicating that the choice of technology could be influenced by market demand and professional prospects.

💡Back-end vs. Front-end

The video script contrasts back-end and front-end development, highlighting that Livewire is often chosen by back-end developers who prefer not to delve deeply into JavaScript, while Vue.js is favored by those who want to separate front-end concerns and have more control over the user interface. This distinction is evident in comments where developers discuss their preference based on their role and expertise.

💡Debugging

Debugging is the process of identifying and correcting errors or issues in code. The video mentions that some developers find it easier to debug with Vue.js due to its more transparent nature compared to Livewire, which is said to have 'a lot of magic under the hood.' This highlights the importance of developer comfort and familiarity with the debugging process when choosing a technology.

Highlights

Poll results show varying preferences for Livewire and Vue.js across Twitter, LinkedIn, and YouTube, with over 6,000 votes.

Audience bubble effect is evident, as different platforms have distinct user bases leading to different poll outcomes.

Expectations for Livewire's popularity were higher due to its adoption into the official Laravel ecosystem.

Vue.js shows a significant lead on YouTube and LinkedIn, indicating broader appeal outside the Laravel community.

The poll results suggest that neither Livewire nor Vue.js has an overwhelming advantage, with a near 50/50 split in some cases.

Livewire's domain name change to livewire.laravel.com signifies its official integration with Laravel.

Comments from the community highlight the suitability of Livewire for backend developers and smaller projects.

Vue.js is favored for larger projects requiring a separation of frontend and backend concerns.

The Laravel community seems to be gravitating towards a full-stack approach with Livewire.

Livewire's smaller community size could pose challenges in troubleshooting and problem-solving.

Vue.js benefits from a larger community, providing more resources and support.

Livewire is praised for its ease of integration within the Laravel ecosystem for quick projects.

Vue.js is considered more suitable for projects requiring advanced front-end functionalities.

Personal preferences and initial exposure to either Livewire or Vue.js influence developers' choices.

Performance concerns are raised regarding Livewire's tendency for excessive server requests.

Alternatives to Livewire and Vue.js, such as Alpine JS, Inertia, and jQuery, are mentioned by the community.

Job opportunities and market demand are considered when choosing between Livewire and Vue.js.

The video concludes that both Livewire and Vue.js have their merits, and the choice depends on project needs and personal preferences.

Transcripts

hello guys recently I asked my audience

Livewire or vue.js without any context

and I published that poll on three

platforms Twitter LinkedIn and YouTube

and in total there were more than 6,000

votes so it's pretty objective I would

say and in this video I will discuss the

results so the numbers on different

platforms and they differ quite a lot

but also I want to share the comments

and the reasons why Live Wire then why

.js and then there was a third option

other so what other alternatives to

those two people actually use in Lille

community so first let's dive into the

results here are the results of the poll

on those different platforms so on

Twitter Livewire is at 50% and more

popular than vuejs but on YouTube and on

LinkedIn VJs wins by quite a big margin

and it's not just from five or 10 votes

it's from thousands of votes so what do

these numbers actually mean two things

first that everyone lives in a bubble so

even with my big audience of thousands

of people on Twitter there's different

audience than on YouTube or LinkedIn so

if you ask about popularity of any tools

doesn't matter Live Wire view JS or

others the answers will be limited by

your audience your kind of a bubble so

you shouldn't blindly trust those

numbers but the second thing about those

numbers I was expecting bigger numbers

from Live Wire because it feels like

laral Community is going towards tall

stack towards filament for example even

Livewire was adopted into official laral

so the domain name of Livewire is now

live wire. lal.com and a lot of

tutorials and videos and it feels

growing but I didn't see the result that

I was expected Vue is quite a big leader

on YouTube and Linkedin and especially

on LinkedIn where people follow me not

just for larl Content historically so

Twitter and YouTube is mostly about

laravel but LinkedIn is a general IT

professional group so people follow me

also about professional advice and

career thing so the broader you get

outside of LL world the bigger vuejs

becomes because vuejs it's not only

about laravel it's broader Livewire is

within the laral ecosystem view can be

used outside of Laro but at the same

time if you're choosing live wire or

view the difference in those numbers is

not big enough so that you would choose

just because from those numbers the

split is not like 80/20 or 90 versus 10

it's more about 4060 or sometimes even

50/50 something like that so it's not

enough it's not an overwhelming win to

each side so if you're asking the same

question what should you learn or adopt

Livewire or vs both are are okay both

are popular and both have their own

advantages and disadvantages and next we

will talk about exactly that advantages

and disadvantages in your comments but

before going there I wanted to also show

you two more numbers so Tobias Petri

replied with his own state of Lille

survey from 2023 and similar question

there showed these numbers which is

actually pretty similar so VJs is 60%

Live Wire is at 40% and there is a small

trend of growth over the year with

Livewire and slow decline in vue.js but

it's really insignificant so these

numbers kind of correspond to the ones

on my poll and then another one another

poll from Twitter by Jack Alice this

time founder of use fathom fathom

analytics and this was a different angle

on a similar question Live Wire versus

inertia and inertia May mean view or

react or the third option was blade so

see how many people don't even go into

spa or JavaScript or dynamic Pages they

use just good old blade 28% and from

those who do use Dynamic Pages Live Wire

is in the lead here as well so yeah

these are the numbers now let's get into

the comments in the description below I

will link to the original tweet which

contains all three links so you can read

all the comments yourselves but I will

focus on those that represent the main

Trends the main reasons why live wire or

why ugs first from Twitter I like the

thought by Mark relaxed criteria for one

Dev it's Livewire for two or more devs

if one of those is front Ender then

front Enders should do their job with

View and react so basically if you have

a team with potential separation of

front Enders and back Enders then it's

kind of a no-brainer each part is

responsible for their part the next

comment comes from LinkedIn from Seri

here Livewire is a mix of concerns

between back end and front and should

never be used on a project larger than a

hobby and he's talking about bigger

projects and scaling separately front

end or backend whether it's about

technical scaling or scaling the team

and if you have Livewire it's kind of

doing both so again similar thought if

you have a team with front Enders and

back Enders view or react as an

alternative is a better choice than Live

Wire another comment from Luke wats on

LinkedIn react plus inertia and this

comes from developer who is more

experienc with react or view so front

end first and has limited Livewire

experience but from that limited

Livewire experience Luke understands why

but still prefers to optimize the front

end components himself but he also

raises a great point if he was just a

PHP Dev without react experience he

would probably want Live Wire so here's

where we get to the essence Live Wire is

more suitable for historically PHP

developers backend developers who don't

really want to touch JavaScript too much

and don't need that much customization

on the front end but let's read more

comments to get even more full picture

this long reply from Twitter comes from

cam cam who use Livewire reasonably

extensively in the past couple of months

however he states that view provides

tool that don't exist with Live Wire

more functionality for example unbe

unmount and higher granularity of the

life cycle hooks in view that said he

loves the work by Caleb on Livewire and

this is actually what I like about most

replies to this poll people do respect

alternative options so if you vote for

Live Wire you understand the view part

and vice versa so I really like that

respectful Community from this comment

by Carlos I want to emphasize one

sentence that liveo has a much smaller

Community around and this may be a

problem if you're trying to solve some

bug or a problem and in vuejs many

people could help potentially not

necessarily laravel developers again

we're getting back to live are being

limited to larel community and view

isn't so that includes the community

that could help you with Forum answers

YouTube comments or stuff like that on

the other hand this comment for Livewire

I love Livewire because you don't leave

the laral ecosystem and if you need

something quick easy to integrate just a

few tweaks

and you're good to go so this kind of

describes Livewire this comment by Ian

also represents it quite well for

personal projects live wire for

professional view another factor to

consider the amount of job opportunities

so Yun IM on LinkedIn says that there

aren't many toll stack jobs compared to

react or view at least in Australia and

I think this trend is similar not only

in Australia but worldwide now on

YouTube Here's a comment by 891 for a

bit of interactivity live wire is

totally fine so to get stuff done fast

Live Wire but I wouldn't want to

maintain a live wire based app which

means long-term bigger project and

separation of concerns this is actually

a concern for many people who replied to

this poll another typical Reason by

Thomas here is actually pretty natural

so whatever people started with they

just continue that route so if they

learned view first they are fans of view

and vice versa if they started with

Livewire they will praise Livewire so no

reason to learn anything else at the

moment logical nothing to add here

another angle of the same question by

diit here who hates Livewire for bad

performance with slow networks and yes

Livewire has a reputation of doing too

many server requests which you can of

course optimize and minimize but in

general there are more server requests

sometimes unnecessary than view ja and

in the replies to that comment a few

people agreed and actually we're

planning a separate video with the team

I'll try to make kind of a showdown

between Livewire and view specifically

on slower networks and compare the

results and see how much we can optimize

from Live Wire so that wouldn't be the

case because in some cases it's actually

kind of a myth almost like a meme that

Livewire is slower and in many cases it

can be optimized quite well similar

comment by Ryan here he's more

productive with tol stack with live but

it puts too much unnecessary load on the

server so again if you want to go fast

go with tall but if you want to go more

stable and you care about performance a

lot view react may be your choice next

this Comon Livewire is for those with

backend mindset so again historically

backend developers PHP developers but

it's harder to debug if something goes

wrong so if you are familiar and good

with VJs it's easier to debug strange

situations because it gives you more

control over the behavior and Livewire

is kind of a lot of magic under the hood

another comment emphasizes that Livewire

is better because thinking about

JavaScript is less productive and that

person would rather optimize server

stuff optimize PHP code in general then

think about how JavaScript works so this

is the comment about happiness but in

fact it depends also on the project

whether you can afford to be backand

first and don't care that much about

frontend reactivity so it also can

depend on the business goals of the the

project or the strategy of the project

owners whether they care about ux more

or about optimization on the back end so

yeah these are the comments about

Livewire versus vue.js I actually didn't

plan it to be such a long video but I

wanted to read more comments to have

bigger picture for you of pros and cons

and various logic points and finally

let's take a look of what else was

mentioned as those 10% Alternatives or

7% Alternatives what else people use for

reactivity so Alpine JS inertia plus

react of course comes quite often jQuery

still alive and that comment proves the

point jQuery wasn't mentioned just by

one person also we have swelt here next

jQuery again with two likes by the way

angular is also still alive next with

these cases listed so yeah as you can

see there are more Alternatives even to

those two popular choices of Livewire

versus vue.js so yeah these are the

thoughts from the community and from

myself on top how I comment those what

do you think would you add something to

that my overall conclusion would be this

if you want to go fast and you have

small project Livewire is great but if

you want to go longterm with potential

separation of frontend and backend and

you care about front end performance

then vuejs or react as a strong

alternative could be your choice but

again both are good both are popular and

both can land you job opportunities

let's continue discussions in the

comments and subscribe to the channel to

get more videos not just about how

things work but also about why with such

polls and discussions that's it for this

time and see you guys in other videos