No SIM? No Problem!
Summary
TLDRThe video discusses the privacy implications of SIM cards, explaining how they can track location, enable hidden messaging between cell networks, and lead to VPN leaks. It advocates removing the SIM card from phones and instead using a mobile hotspot, which can provide connectivity while better protecting privacy. However, hotspots come with downsides like carrying multiple devices. Overall, the video aims to educate on SIM card risks and present alternatives, so viewers can make informed choices about optimizing phone privacy.
Takeaways
- 😲 SIM cards track your location and enable monitoring of your phone activity
- 😯 Secret communication occurs between the SIM and baseband processor
- 🤔 Centralizing phone functions creates privacy risks like VPN leaks
- 🌇 Using WiFi instead of cellular can improve privacy
- 👍 Hotspots allow connectivity while isolating the SIM
- 🔒 Hotspots can reduce location tracking and data collection
- ❌ No SIM means no phone number or seamless connectivity
- 📶 Calyx hotspots offer anonymous purchase and unlimited data
- 🌟 Supporting Calyx supports online privacy efforts
- ✈️ Hotspots provide reliable connectivity for travelers
Q & A
What are some of the ways a SIM card can track your location?
-A SIM card tracks your location through constant communication with cell towers to maintain network connectivity. As your phone connects to different towers, the time and signal strength is recorded, creating a map of your movements.
How does a SIM card enable targeted advertising?
-Your location data from the SIM card provides info about your daily habits and movements. Cell providers can use this to infer your activities and interests, allowing more targeted ads.
What are the hidden messages a SIM card sends to the network?
-The baseband processor and SIM card can communicate autonomously to send encrypted messages to the cell network unbeknownst to the user. The contents are proprietary and not publicly documented.
What are some alternatives for connectivity without a SIM card?
-You can use WiFi networks, both public and private, to connect your phone. You can also use a mobile hotspot device that has a SIM card in it to provide internet access.
What are the benefits of using a mobile hotspot over a phone SIM?
-Hotspots allow you to separate functions across devices, encrypt traffic at the hotspot level, reduce insights into personal usage patterns, and lower location tracking associated directly with you.
What are some downsides of using a hotspot instead of a phone SIM?
-You have to carry multiple devices, you may experience connectivity delays as devices reconnect, and you don't have a standard cell phone number that people can call.
How does the Calyx Institute provide anonymous hotspots?
-Calyx uses a non-commercial frequency band allocated for education. This allows them to offer anonymous accounts without collecting personal info, paid by cash or cryptocurrency.
What privacy risks remain with using a SIM in a hotspot?
-The hotspot SIM still communicates with cell towers, so some location data is still generated. However, it's dissociated from your personal devices and usage patterns.
What was Nick Merrill's experience that led to starting Calyx?
-Nick was the first person to challenge an NSA National Security Letter in court. This 12 year legal fight exposed mass surveillance and led Nick to start Calyx.
How can I support the creation of more digital privacy tools?
-You can donate to non-profits like Calyx Institute that develop privacy-focused technologies and fight for digital rights.
Outlines
📱 How SIM cards allow your phone to track you and connect to networks
SIM cards link your device identity to your account, enable connectivity through communication with cell towers which tracks your location, and proactively initiate hidden communication with networks. Reasons to be cautious of privacy implications.
😶 SIMs can send hidden commands without you knowing
SIM cards can autonomously send commands to the baseband processor to perform tasks without intervention from the main phone processor. The contents of this communication is unknown and not documented by carriers.
🌐 Centralizing control on one device risks bypassing VPN
Having phone act as internet gateway and VPN client means OS can intentionally bypass VPN for some services, risking split tunneling. Separating SIM into hotspot gives more control over VPN.
🚫 Downsides of no SIM: Connectivity, phone number, multiple devices
Without a SIM, need WiFi for connectivity instead which has availability and security downsides. Also lose phone number tied to SIM, requiring alternative like VOIP. Must carry separate hotspot device.
👍 Hotspots from nonprofit Calyx provide anonymity and unlimited data
Calyx hotspots in USA purchased anonymously, provide unlimited data, and support privacy-focused nonprofit founded by hero who challenged National Security Letters.
Mindmap
Keywords
💡SIM card
💡location tracking
💡hotspot
💡connectivity
💡anonymity
💡Calyx Institute
💡baseband processor
💡split tunneling
💡public WiFi
💡voip number
Highlights
SIM cards track your location and online habits.
Cell providers sell your location data to anyone who wants it.
Proactive SIMs can send hidden messages without your knowledge.
Bypassing VPNs allows phone OSs to expose activity to the internet.
Public WiFi adds anonymity compared to using a SIM.
Hotspots let you separate SIM functions across devices.
Hotspots reduce location tracking compared to phone SIMs.
Calyx Institute hotspots offer anonymity and unlimited data.
Hotspots have downsides like carrying multiple devices.
No cell number means using VoIP apps instead.
Hotspots can have slower reconnect times than phones.
Support Calyx Institute for their privacy work.
Assess if no SIM is right for your needs.
Tweak phone settings to reduce SIM privacy risks.
Explore tools to improve your digital privacy.
Transcripts
Your phone is more than just a communication tool; it's a powerful tracking device,
and the SIM card inside is a key reason why. This tiny chip is your gateway to connectivity
on the go, allowing you to receive calls, messages, and use the internet as you travel.
But it also tracks your every move, logs your every call,
and quietly observes your online habits. We do all kinds of sensitive activities on our phones,
and the SIM plays a big role in allowing that activity to be monitored,
often without our explicit awareness or consent.
Do you know how much information your cell phone is really collecting about you and your location?
I don't actually have a SIM card in any of my phones,
and in this video I'll explain the reasons why.
I'll also talk about alternative ways that you can still have connectivity
on the go without a SIM in your phone, such as using an anonymous Calyx hotspot.
And I'll also dive into the downsides of not having a SIM in your phone. A warning
right off the bat: this setup isn't for everyone. I'll go over some drawbacks so
that you can decide for yourself what is the right choice for you.
Let's start with understanding what a SIM card is. It's a tiny chip that
we either insert into our phone, or it's already embedded in the phone as an eSIM,
that allows us to do things like make calls, send messages, and use the internet.
We get one when we sign up for a cell plan, and each SIM is tied to a unique identity,
called an IMSI, or International Mobile Subscriber Identity. This is your digital
fingerprint in the cellular world. It links all your network activity to your subscriber account.
Now here are 3 reasons why this small card sitting in your pocket might be more of a
privacy concern than you realize, starting with location tracking.
As you move, your SIM card is in constant communication with various cell towers to
maintain network connectivity. The time and signal strength of your phone's connection
as it comes into range of different cell towers is recorded, tracking your movements.
This data is linked to your IMSI, making it a personalized map of your daily activities.
Essentially, cell providers know where we are at all times.
They can pinpoint exactly where you are and what you’re doing,
they can actually direct an ad to you.
This location data is not only used for things like targeted advertising,
Cell providers actually have a long and notorious history
of selling your location data to basically anyone who wants it.
The next reason why you might be cautious about the privacy implications of SIM cards is that
proactive SIMs can initiate the sending of hidden messages to the cell network that you can't see.
How does this work? Well, while most people think of their cell phone as a single computer,
The typical smartphone has actually has three computers in it.
David Allan Burgess, a telecom expert that’s worked in both signals intelligence and
commercial equipment, explained to us what these computers are. First,
It has the, the application processor
This is the computer that most people think of as their cell phone,
it usually runs Android or iOS and it’s the part that people interact with.
And then below that, there's something called a baseband processor that manages
the telecommunications functions of the phone. And, you know, it actually makes
telephone calls and connects to your mobile operator for cellular data sessions. And then
below that there's the SIM, which is actually a full computer system.
It's got its own operating system. It's got its own file system.
While the "computer" within a SIM card is extremely limited in terms of its functionality,
the SIM IS able to do certain tasks autonomously,
without the need for intervention from the phone's main processor. And It turns out…
There can be communication going on between the baseband processor
and the SIM. That's not visible to the application processor.
So basically you have the part of the phone that you interact with; Android, iOS, Graphene -- the
part with all the apps and settings that has a screen showing you what's going on.
But meanwhile there are 2 other components,
or computers, talking to each other, the baseband processor, and the SIM.
And proactive SIMs have the capability to initiate commands -- they can tell the mobile device to
perform specific tasks, like sending out an SMS, or starting a data session. All without
you knowing, because these actions bypass the part of the phone that you interact with.
Now it's not as nefarious as you might think -- communication between the baseband processor,
initiated by the SIM, and the cell network
is actually a completely normal part of your cell functionality.
But it's still true that we really have no idea what's in these messages
that the baseband processor sends out, because they're encrypted.
That's not the weird part though. What makes me cautious is that
cell providers don't want to talk about what's in these messages.
No one at AT&T talks publicly about what this stuff is. It's not documented anywhere.
David has been involved in court cases that hinge on knowing what’s
in these hidden messages, and still cell providers won’t talk about it.
Even getting someone from AT&T to answer the most basic questions about this was
clearly not something they wanted to do. They certainly wanted to say as little as possible.
There's a lot of suspicion about how powerful these baseband processors
really are and to what extent they allow surveillance through our phones.
Theoretically, according to some of the Snowden revelations, it, it may be able to turn the mic
on or the camera on or remotely. It may be able to turn the phone on when it's in an off state.
Some of the stuff you hear is true and some of it's not true. And there's no
way to separate truth from fiction in the end. You don't really know.
Nick Merrill, the founder of the Calyx Institute, a privacy-focused non profit,
says that at the end of the day all we can really do is speculate.
All that stuff is proprietary. It's, it's closed. You can't know what's going on in there.
we're really never gonna get visibility into it.
Open source baseband processors that people could use as alternatives don't even exist,
so this isn't something that the average person can even control.
I just wanted to highlight how little we know about what the
baseband processor and SIM are actually doing on our devices,
and that they have this degree of autonomy on a device where we're doing a lot of personal
stuff. But it's just one of 3 reasons why I'm cautious about having a SIM card in my phone.
So let's move on to the 3rd reason, which is the risk of inadvertent
split tunneling by centralized too much control on a single device.
What do I mean by this? Well, when you have a SIM in your phone,
your device is your internet gateway.
On top of that, your device is where you do a lot of personal activities.
Your phone's OS is in control of it all.
This can present issues like when using a VPN.
The idea behind a VPN is that all the traffic leaving your device is sent
through an encrypted tunnel, and routed to a VPN server first before hitting the broader internet.
This is helpful for privacy because it helps stop snooping on this activity, and also
hides your IP address from the websites you visit.
But some of your traffic might be leaked from your device directly to the internet,
instead of going through the encrypted tunnel. This is an
example of split tunneling, and it could happen without you realizing.
The Mysk research team discovered that on iphones, there are a bunch of apps
that bypass your VPN and send data directly to Apple servers including: Stocks, Health, Home,
Wallet, Messages, FindMy, Fitness, Shortcuts, Apple Music, Freeform,
Settings, Contacts, Weather, and all push notifications.
Apple's terms of service for VPNs actually states that they
may bypass your VPN intentionally for some essential system services.
This isn't just an issue with iOS -- They found that Android also
communicates with Google services outside an active VPN connection.
So the 3rd problem of having a SIM in your phone, is that when your phone's OS controls your apps,
your internet gateway, and your VPN, if it wants to bypass your VPN it can. There are
ways to have more control over your VPN, though, which we'll go over in a moment.
Those are 3 of the reasons why I decided not to keep a SIM in my phone,
but I can hear some of you thinking, doesn't that make the phone useless?
The whole point of a mobile phone is so that you can have connectivity on the
go. If you don't put a SIM in your phone, how are you meant to still have that connectivity?
You'd use WiFi instead. With an internet connection, your phone can function almost
entirely as usual, even without a SIM. You could use all the same apps you normally would,
you could still use your favorite messenger apps to communicate,
and instead of using a cell number that you'd get with a SIM card, you'd download a voip app,
and people could call and message you using that voip number instead.
Ok great! So when I'm at home or work I could just connect to my
wifi networks there. But what about when I'm out and about?
I have some friends who actually don't like having constant connectivity on the go,
and if they need to talk to someone they'll find the nearest public
wifi to briefly connect. These days public wifi is everywhere,
so it's not hard to quickly find a connection. The privacy benefit of this is two-fold.
First, you can now keep your phone in airplane mode at all times which stops
it constantly chattering with cell towers and recording your location. Instead you'd
connect with wifi over a VPN which is more private for your location,
and you'd only do this when you actually want connectivity. It’s like only turning
on the light switch in a room when you enter the room, and turning it off again when you leave.
Second, using public wifi to connect to the internet can add a layer of anonymity, compared
with using your cell network to connect. When you connect through a SIM card, your IMSI and IMEI
are unique identifiers that tie all your network activity including internet activity, calls and
messages together and associate them with you. By comparison, public WiFi networks often don't
require an account linked to your personal identity in order to access the internet.
Wifi networks do collect the mac address of your device, but modern smartphones often
randomize these MAC addresses so that you can't be tracked across different Wi-Fi connections.
But there are also downsides to this approach. For example,
you might be in an emergency where you need an internet connection but can't find one.
You might need internet when driving around.
And on top of that, connecting to public wifi isn't particularly secure. You can
beef up your security and privacy by making sure you always use a VPN,
but there are possible malware risks or man in the middle attacks that could occur.
So let's look at another option, the mobile hotspot. It's a separate device
that you carry around with you, that can give you internet wherever you are. This is what I use.
It gives out wifi connection, or some of them have ethernet if you need that.
You can put it in your pocket and basically you can use as much internet as you want.
If I go work in a coffee shop, I always have my own internet that I can trust. I
don't concern myself with is the Starbucks wifi secure or will it be slow or whatever.
The hotspot itself contains a SIM and that's
how it's able to connect you to the internet on the go.
But hold up, if I'm carrying around a SIM anyway, why not just have it in my phone?
There are a few reasons why siloing the SIM in a separate device can be useful
There are definitely different privacy gains you can make by having a hotspot like this,
including having, uh, a VPN client on the hotspot so that all the traffic is encrypted.
If you have a SIM in a separate device, and run your VPN on this separate device
instead of on your phone, you're separating functions across two
different devices and your phone's os no longer controls the gateway and VPN.
Because of this your phone's OS is no longer able to bypass the VPN,
and expose activity directly to the internet without you realizing.
A second reason why siloing the SIM in a separate device can be useful
is because of those secret messages sent to the cell network that we spoke about earlier.
When your SIM is in a hotspot, it's the hotspot's baseband processor that
talks to the cell network. Your hotspot is typically ONLY used for internet connectivity,
while your phone is a super sensitive device where you do a ton of private activities. So if the
hidden messages being sent to the cell network ARE reporting on any activity on the device,
which is a big if, the hotspot is going to have a lot less personal activity to report.
It's also important to note that when you use a hotspot, it's your hotspot's IMEI
and IMSI that are the point of contact with the cellular network, and these are not going to be
as closely tied to your personal identity as the SIM on your phone and your phone's
IMEI. Especially if you purchase your hotspot anonymously, which we'll talk about in a moment.
On top of that, when you use a hotspot,
your cell provider gets a lot less granular insight into your activities.
A SIM in your phone generates very specific usage patterns as well as
call and message logs that often reflect very personal habits and preferences.
Cell providers can also sometimes infer which apps
you're using and activities you're doing on the device.
But when you use a hotspot, they mainly just get data volume and traffic patterns.
And if the hotspot is used by multiple devices or for different purposes,
this further dilutes the usage pattern associated with it.
While the data transmitted with both setups is essentially the same,
the hotspot can reduce the ease of directly profiling your individual behavior.
A third reason why siloing the SIM in a separate
device can be useful is to reduce location tracking.
Now, a SIM in your hotspot is still going to report your location to cell towers.
So what I do is, when I do need a connection, I turn on the hotspot briefly,
and I connect it to my phone with a cable, but I turn it off again when I'm not using it,
and I can even put it in a faraday bag if I'm concerned. This dramatically reduces
the amount of chatter between my phone and cell networks, and I can still use the phone offline,
for things like offline maps and camera. Keep in mind you can achieve basically the
same ends by just putting your phone in airplane mode when you're not using it.
There are 2 more perks of using a hotspot that I want to mention, but they apply specifically
to hotspots purchased from the Calyx Institute, the privacy organization I mentioned earlier. No,
they're not sponsors of the show, they're just a fantastic organization you should know about,
and they offer 2 BIG benefits with their hotspots that other providers don't,
if you're based in the USA. First you can purchase their hotspots and service completely anonymously.
Our memberships don't require you to give personally identifiable information.
We go to a bunch of events every year and people sign up and they pay with
cash. We've also made it possible for people to pay with cryptocurrencies.
And they accept about a hundred different coins on their website including privacy coins
There was a lot of people asking us for Monero support and Zcash support. So we
added that it's a neat backdoor into not needing to comply with, like, know your
customer kind of rules to get a phone number. Sometimes people just wanna close the curtains
when they want to be private and open them when they want to, you know, share.
And second, you get unlimited data, so you can use these hotspots for all your devices
including streaming on your computer.
Most hotspots you get from a phone company have a limit. Whether it's two gigabytes a month,
10 gigabytes a month, after that, it either stops or it goes slow.
We have these hotspots that have no practical limit on it.
How is Calyx able to offer these services?
We got hooked up with another nonprofit that has, uh, a license on a piece of the radio spectrum.
It's based on this FCC program, the United States Federal Communications
Commission. This program called Educational Broadband Spectrum.
Basically in the 1960s, the FCC in America allocated a portion of the radio spectrum to
educational purposes, . And this EBS is less congested compared to other commercial bands,
so this might be why organizations that use it
are able to allow more generous data plans than other providers.
The deal that we have doesn't have that limit on it.
This is great news for people who want to use these hotspots for all their internet needs,
on their phones and their computers.
They have unlimited internet service on them.
We've discussed the benefits of using a hotspot instead of having a SIM in your phone,
but we should definitely go over the downsides too, because as I mentioned at the start,
this isn't going to be the right solution for everyone. I'll talk from personal experience,
as I've been using a phone without a SIM for about a year now.
First, I have to carry around multiple devices:
I have my phone and my hotspot, and for some this will be an issue.
Can't say it's the most convenient thing. . I mean, like, I, I like to carry my phone in my
pocket and it's like the one thing that I have, I wouldn't want to carry more stuff than I needed.
Personally, I don't notice this downside.
I have a small bag I carry with me anyway,
and the hotspot is really compact, so I just keep it in my bag and it's completely fine.
Next: cell number. If you don't have a SIM, then you don't have a
number associated with your SIM that people can use to call your phone.
But this doesn't actually stop people calling and messaging you,
you could have a voip number instead. We go over the privacy benefits of using a
voip number instead of a cell number in other videos, and that's what I do.
It's also worth noting that:
On our hotspots. They actually can take incoming SMS, so they have a phone number
assigned to the SIM card. It's not a normal sim card, so you can't make phone calls on it. It's
data only. But the devices can get, um, like two factor authentication codes sent to them.
Finally there's connectivity: The connectivity of my hotspot itself is fantastic.
But you know how when you're driving around, sometimes your phone goes in and out of range?
But it's not a big deal because it quickly reconnects? Well when you use a hotspot,
the lag before reconnecting can be more of an issue.
While the hotspot itself will reconnect super quickly, the phone then takes some
additional moments to reconnect to the hotspot. And then if you're like me,
you have a VPN that then needs to reconnect too.
One way to mitigate this wait is to tether the phone to the hotspot
with a physical cable instead of using wifi. There is still a slight delay,
but it's less. I'd say this is the biggest downside of a hotspot.
All in all I love this set up for my life, and for me the benefits outweigh the downsides. For
others, this will be too inconvenient, so you should make the right choice for your life.
Now if you do decide to purchase a hotspot, and you're in the USA, I highly recommend you get
yours from the Calyx Institute. Not just because of the anonymous purchase options and unlimited
data that I already mentioned, but because Calyx is a great privacy-focused organization.
You don't purchase these devices directly,
it's technically membership based and you instead give a tax-deductible donation.
They become a member. And one of the benefits
you can get, you can opt into is we'll send you one of these mobile hotspots,
Supporting them also means helping them maintain all kinds of free public services.
You're supporting us building and operating a free VPN running tor exit nodes,
building this encrypted Android OS this private Android oss, and all these different activities.
They also run a free private message relay called jabber.
Why would you want to support, uh, Verizon or at and t all these phone
companies that are sort of antagonistic to your privacy when you could instead support
a nonprofit organization that's trying to innovate new, more private things.
Here, here! I completely agree with that sentiment.
We have the power to vote with our money and support organizations that
align with our values. But I also want to mention that the founder of calyx,
Nick Merril, is actually a privacy hero of mine.
He was the first person to ever publicly challenge what's called a National Security Letter. He spent
12 years of his life fighting government overreach and exposing this warrantless mass surveillance.
It was that experience that led him to start this privacy-focused institution
in the first place, and I really wish him and Calyx all the best.
My, like my work has purpose and my life has purpose. And, uh, to try to help people all
around the world, uh, be as free as they can. You can do something that like matters and that makes
you happy. Um, so yeah, come join the revolution. That's, that's what I wanna say to everyone.
So to summarize, having a SIM card in your phone has a lot of privacy
downsides. You can mitigate these by removing the SIM from your phone,
and using a hotspot for connectivity instead. This is what I do, but there are certainly tradeoffs,
and you'll have to assess whether this is something that's right for your life.
Alternatively you can at least mitigate some of the privacy risks of SIM cards by tweaking
settings on your phone to help stop location tracking, and we explain all that in the
previous video in this series. In the meantime, don't feel overwhelmed with phone privacy.
There are so many awesome tools out there for you to explore if you're concerned about your
digital privacy, and hopefully these videos are helpful for learning about some of them.
NBTV is a non-profit that is able to create free educational content
thanks to community donations. If you'd like to support the work that we do,
visit nbtv.media/support. We also have a book "beginner's introduction to privacy"
if you're just starting out, which also supports our channel. Thanks for watching,
sharing our message, and supporting our channel. We really appreciate all of you.
So if you've stuck around till the end, here are some personal tips from me,
and the experience I’ve had with hotspots. The biggest perk for me is travel. So,
whether I’m in an Uber, a train or bus, or sitting in a plane on the tarmac;
I have internet connectivity everywhere. I can go to any cafe and know that I will have unlimited
internet access that will not be interrupted. This is a huge perk for me. I work a lot,
so I need that internet connectivity and a hotspot is just a great tool for providing that. Uh,
it is worth noting that Calyx only works in the USA, but Hotspots, in general,
are actually worth considering no matter where you are. So, that is all. Go and explore.
Посмотреть больше похожих видео
खोए/चोरी हुए फोन को ट्रैक करें | Track SIM status | Track IMEI number | Sanchar Saathi[HINDI] #viral
Don't Use Google For Photo Backup!
SER 100% ANÓNIMO en INTERNET en SOLO 9 PASOS
ZTE MU5120 Overview - 5G on a friendly budget
International Cell Phone Travel Tips | Save MEGA $$$ on Roaming!
Cellphone Surveillance Explained - Stingray/IMSI Catchers
5.0 / 5 (0 votes)