The Faltering Economy of Argentina | Economics Explained

Summary

The video script narrates Argentina's economic journey, from being one of the world's wealthiest nations at the turn of the 20th century to its current state of instability and potential failure. It explores the factors behind Argentina's economic booms and subsequent declines, including political corruption, asymmetrical trade deals, and nationalization of industries. The script also delves into theories about Argentina's paradoxical economic pattern compared to similar nations like Canada and Australia, and discusses the recent currency crisis that threatens the country's economic sovereignty.

Takeaways

• 🌍 Argentina has experienced significant economic growth and decline throughout its history, with periods of prosperity followed by severe downturns.
• 📉 The recent economic crash in Argentina has resulted in high inflation and widespread poverty, contrasting its previous growth.
• 🔄 Argentina's economy has been characterized by cycles of growth and decline over the past century, continuing an unfortunate trend.
• 🏆 Despite its economic challenges, Argentina has advantages such as a skilled workforce, abundant natural resources, and a geography conducive to industry and agriculture.
• 💡 Nobel laureate Simon Kuznets once remarked that Argentina is a unique case among the world's economies, along with developed, underdeveloped, and Japan.
• 📈 The early 20th century saw Argentina as one of the wealthiest countries, with wealth derived from agriculture and European investment.
• 🤝 European immigration and investment fueled Argentina's growth, but wealth was unevenly distributed and corruption was rampant.
• 🕊 World War I and the Great Depression disrupted Argentina's economy, leading to stagnation and unrest due to reduced investment and demand for luxury goods.
• 📉 Argentina's political instability and a series of one-sided trade deals contributed to the decline of its primary industries and foreign investment.
• 🌐 The nation's political and economic policies have often swung between extremes, damaging long-term stability and confidence.
• 💼 Various theories attempt to explain Argentina's economic instability, including the failure to adapt to the end of geographical expansion, political system inadequacies, and issues with property rights.

Q & A

What was the economic situation in Argentina during the last decade mentioned in the script?

The script describes a period of unprecedented and sustained growth for Argentina, where the economy quintupled in size and average incomes doubled, significantly improving the quality of life for its citizens.

How has Argentina's economy historically been characterized in the last 100 years?

Historically, Argentina's economy has been characterized by periods of massive growth followed by huge declines, making the recent economic downturn a continuation of this trend.

What factors contributed to Argentina's economic boom at the turn of the 20th century?

Argentina's economic boom was attributed to high-end agriculture, an influx of investment from Europe and America, modern commercial farming techniques, and massive European immigration.

What issues arose from the wealth distribution during Argentina's period of growth?

The wealth was distributed very unevenly, primarily benefiting European immigrants and corrupt politicians and business leaders, which led to social unrest and economic instability.

How did World War I impact Argentina's economy?

World War I led to a long period of stagnation for Argentina due to the reduced investment and demand for exports from war-torn European countries.

What were the consequences of the one-sided trade deals Argentina established with European nations?

The one-sided trade deals primarily benefited corrupt politicians and led to the loss of Argentina's primary industries to foreign powers, accelerating the nation's decline.

Who was Juan Peron and what economic reforms did he introduce?

Juan Peron was elected and introduced sweeping economic reforms with a focus on nationalizing heavy industry, similar to strategies used by other leaders during that time period.

What is the 'Argentine Paradox' and what does it refer to?

The 'Argentine Paradox' refers to the debate among economists about the reasons behind Argentina's continued economic instability despite its wealth and potential for growth.

What are some theories proposed for Argentina's economic decline compared to similar nations like Canada and Australia?

Theories include Argentina's failure to seek alternatives to geographical expansion, its political climate and systems being less equipped for globalization, and issues with property rights and nationalizing assets.

How has Argentina's currency crisis affected its economy in recent times?

The currency crisis has led to a plummeting stock market, a lack of confidence from investors, and a shift towards a dual currency economy with the US dollar being used for major transactions.

What is the potential long-term consequence if Argentina loses control over its own currency?

If Argentina loses control over its currency, it could become a 'dead state walking,' unable to raise taxes, provide fiscal stimulus, or borrow in its own currency, leading to a potential complete economic implosion.

Outlines

00:00

📈 Argentina's Economic Rise and Fall

This paragraph discusses Argentina's economic history, highlighting its rapid growth and subsequent decline. Once one of the wealthiest countries, Argentina's economy has been characterized by periods of significant growth followed by sharp downturns. Despite having a healthy population, strong natural resources, and a conducive landmass for industries, Argentina has repeatedly fallen into economic instability. The paragraph also mentions the country's resilience through financial crises and political instability, including the quick succession of five presidents in two weeks. It sets the stage for exploring the causes behind Argentina's economic booms and declines.

05:02

🌐 Impact of Global Events on Argentina's Economy

The second paragraph delves into the effects of global events on Argentina's economy, particularly the stagnation period following World War I and the Great Depression. It discusses the country's reliance on foreign investment and luxury exports, which suffered during these events. The paragraph outlines the leadership's attempts to revive growth through one-sided trade deals, which ultimately accelerated the nation's decline. It also touches on the political instability that arose from these economic issues, leading to a series of coups and the rise of Juan Peron, who introduced nationalized heavy industry reforms. The paragraph emphasizes the cyclical pattern of sweeping reforms and the lack of stability and confidence they fostered.

10:02

🏛 The Argentine Paradox and Economic Theories

This paragraph explores various theories that attempt to explain Argentina's economic instability. It contrasts Argentina's journey with that of Australia and Canada, which maintained their prosperity. The first theory by Guido Di Tella suggests Argentina's failure to find alternatives to geographical expansion as a key difference. The second theory points to Argentina's political climate and systems, inherited from Spain, which may not have been as well-equipped to handle globalization as the British Westminster style of government found in Canada and Australia. The third theory, from a 1992 paper by researchers at the University of Madrid, focuses on the issue of property rights and the negative impact of nationalizing and privatizing assets repeatedly. The paragraph also discusses the challenges Argentina faced in borrowing for growth due to its unstable political and economic environment.

15:04

💵 Argentina's Currency Crisis and Economic Future

The final paragraph addresses Argentina's most recent economic crisis, which began with a currency crisis. It explains how the Argentine peso was previously pegged to the USD to control inflation but became a free-floating currency after the government ran out of reserves during the 2001 crisis. The paragraph discusses the high-interest rates offered by Argentina to attract savings in pesos and the increasing use of USD for major transactions, effectively creating a dual currency economy. It warns of the potential consequences if Argentina loses control over its own currency, including the inability to raise taxes, provide fiscal stimulus, or borrow in its own currency, which could lead to a state of economic collapse.

Keywords

💡Sustained Growth

Sustained growth refers to a prolonged period where an economy experiences a consistent increase in size and output. In the video, it is mentioned that Argentina experienced an unprecedented period of sustained growth, quintupling in size in the last decade. This concept is central to understanding the economic trajectory of the country before its recent downturn.

💡Financial Crises

A financial crisis is a situation where the value of assets drops dramatically, often resulting in a shortage of credit. The script highlights Argentina's resilience through financial crises, indicating periods of severe economic instability that the country managed to navigate despite significant challenges.

💡Inflation

Inflation is the rate at which the general level of prices for goods and services is rising, and subsequently, purchasing power is falling. The video describes a period of heavy inflation in Argentina, which has contributed to the current economic hardship and is a key factor in the nation's economic struggles.

💡Poverty

Poverty refers to the condition of lacking sufficient financial resources to meet basic needs such as food, housing, and clothing. The script mentions widespread poverty as a result of Argentina's economic downturn, illustrating the human impact of the country's economic challenges.

💡Economic Booms and Declines

Economic booms and declines refer to periods of rapid economic growth and contraction, respectively. The video script describes Argentina's historical pattern of experiencing massive growth followed by significant declines, which is a central theme in understanding the country's economic history.

💡Failed State

A failed state is a nation that has lost its ability to provide basic services and ensure the safety and well-being of its citizens. The video suggests that Argentina is teetering on the edge of becoming a failed state, indicating the severity of its current economic and political situation.

💡Natural Resource Reserves

Natural resource reserves refer to the deposits of valuable natural resources such as minerals, fuels, and fertile land. The script mentions Argentina's strong natural resource reserves as one of its advantages, which are typically a source of wealth and economic potential.

💡Corruption

Corruption is the dishonest or fraudulent conduct by those in power, typically involving bribery or manipulation for personal gain. The video describes how corruption among politicians and business leaders in Argentina contributed to an uneven distribution of wealth and economic instability.

💡Trade Deals

Trade deals are agreements between countries to reduce trade barriers, such as tariffs, and improve trade relations. The script discusses one-sided trade deals that Argentina made with European nations, which ultimately served the interests of corrupt politicians rather than the nation's broader economic health.

💡Nationalization

Nationalization is the process by which a government takes ownership of an industry or asset that was previously privately owned. The video refers to nationalization as a policy implemented by Juan Peron to build out nationalized heavy industry, which had both short-term benefits and long-term consequences for Argentina's economy.

💡Currency Crisis

A currency crisis is a situation where there is a rapid and significant depreciation of a country's currency. The script describes Argentina's recent currency crisis, which was triggered by political changes and has led to a loss of confidence in the Argentine peso, further complicating the nation's economic challenges.

💡Dual Currency Economy

A dual currency economy is a situation where two currencies are used simultaneously within a country, often due to a lack of confidence in the local currency. The video explains that Argentina now effectively has a dual currency economy, with major transactions being conducted in US dollars, which is a significant indicator of the country's economic instability.

Highlights

Argentina experienced an unprecedented period of growth, quintupling in size in the last decade.

Despite financial crises and political instability with 5 presidents in two weeks, Argentina's re-investment led to a doubling of average incomes.

Argentina's economy has historically seen cycles of massive growth followed by declines, continuing an unfortunate trend.

Simon Kuznets categorized economies into developed, underdeveloped, Japan, and Argentina, highlighting Argentina's unique economic situation.

Argentina's economic booms were driven by high-end agriculture and investment from Europe and America.

European immigration contributed to Argentina's wealth but also brought political and social challenges.

World War I and the Great Depression led to a period of stagnation for Argentina due to reduced investment and luxury consumption.

Argentina's leadership sought trade deals with Europe to reignite growth, but these were often one-sided and corrupt.

Juan Peron's election brought economic reforms focused on nationalizing heavy industry, similar to other leaders of the time.

Argentina's political instability and nationalization of foreign assets deterred international investment.

The nation's economic policies swung between command economics and laissez-faire capitalism, destabilizing the economy.

The Argentine Paradox suggests that Argentina's economic instability is due to its failure to seek alternatives to geographical expansion.

Political and legal systems inherited from Spain may have contributed to Argentina's less stable governance compared to ex-British colonies.

Property rights issues and nationalization cycles have made Argentina an unattractive investment, affecting its ability to borrow for growth.

Argentina's currency crisis is exacerbated by a lack of control over its own money and a dual currency economy.

The nation's inability to use its own currency for major transactions could lead to a dead state walking scenario.

Transcripts

This is Argentina, a South American nation which has been home to an unprecedented period

of sustained growth quintupling in size in the last decade.

This nation has seen remarkable resilience through financial crises and even though it

cycled through 5 presidents in two weeks, its continued re-investment in itself has

paid off many times over as average incomes have doubled in the same time period to create

fantastic increases in the quality of life for all the citizens of the nation.

Or at least that would have been the video we were making a few years ago.

Unfortunately today the economy of Argentina tells a very different story.

Just as quickly as the economy soared to these lofty heights it has crashed back down bringing

about a period of heavy inflation and widespread poverty.

But perhaps this shouldn’t be a huge surprise, in the last 100 years the economy of Argentina

has been categorized by periods of massive growth followed by huge declines making the

most recent decades little more than a continuation of that unfortunate trend.

This is a real shame because Argentina obviously has a lot going for it, from a healthy population

of productive workers, strong natural resource reserves and even a landmass that is very

conducive to foundational industries like manufacturing and agriculture.

But despite all of these advantages Argentina has time and time again fallen into this unfortunate

pattern, and is now teetering on the edge of becoming a full-blown failed state.

Nobel prize-winning economist Simon Kuznets is said to have remarked in the early 1970’s

that there are four types of economies in the world, developed, underdeveloped, Japan

and Argentina.

We have already explored what makes Japan so weird, but to unravel the mystery of Argentina

we are going to have to understand a few specific issues.

What has caused the various economic booms over the years?

What has caused the subsequent economic declines?

And why is this most recent downturn just a little bit different?

Once we have done all of that we can get to the fun stuff and put Argentina on the economics

explained national leaderboard, hows that for

a 2020 grand final.

Intro Add

It may sound unbelievable today but at the turn of the 20th century argentina was one

of the 10 wealthiest countries in the world. Its domestic industries which revolved primarily

around high-end agriculture had benefited greatly from an influx of investment from

Europe and America and the nation was able to adopt modern commercial farming techniques.

This worked especially well considering those same countries that invested so heavily were

also fantastic export markets who through their own economic growth had developed quiet

the taste for red meat, which before this time was seen as a bit of a luxury.

This growth was further accelerated by massive European immigration into the nation which

brought with it even more money from the people looking to set up their new lives.

Overall this was fantastic and by 1905 the average argentinian was about as wealthy as

the average citizen of France Britain or Germany, and only slightly poorer than the average

American.

There was a slight asterisk next to this success though which was that the politicians and

business leaders who oversaw this growth were extremely corrupt and the wealth the nation

was growing was distributed very unevenly and went primarily to the aforementioned european

immigrants.

This wouldn’t have necessarily been a problem in the long run because the nation was still

getting wealthier and even people at the bottom were enjoying an increased standard of living

but of course it didn’t.

World war one was a let’s say interesting time for argentina, the country remained totally

neutral but that does not mean that it was not heavily influenced by the fallout of the

war.

For starters due to the massive influx of european immigrants, many of whom were from

nations now at war with one another. it found that its population was rather, hostile.

A much more tangible effect was that all of the nations that had been pumping investment

capital into argentina and then buying up all of their exports were now broke on account

of having to fight in the largest and bloodiest war in history up until that time.

This pushed the country into a long period of stagnation that was only worsened by the

great depression in 1929.

luxuries like red meat on the dinner table and foreign investment quickly fell out of

style.

This was a real problem for the leadership of the nation. Not only were they no longer

able to make themselves incredibly wealthy off the success of Argentina, but the people

of the nation who were enjoying the second-hand wealth were becoming increasingly restless.

A solution was needed and fast, so a series of trade deals were set up with European nations

to try and reignite the growth of the previous decades.

Unfortunately, these trade deals were, very one sided, and they served primarily to solve

the issue of corrupt politicians not getting rich, rather than the problems of the nation

losing its primary industries.

The most famous example of such a deal gave britain with it’s asymmetrical flag exclusive

rights to sell coal to Argentina and also gave the British companies the right to buy

up and control the Argentinian meat industry.

Sure this gave the country a small boost in exports which were very important but it also

gave away Argentina’s primary industry to a foreign power which was terrible.

It was such a poorly planned out deal that corruption was really the only reason that

leaders from Argentina would be compelled to agree to such onerous terms.

Either way these deals further accelerated the decline of the nation which gave rise

to heightened civil unrest and a series of political coups.

Political instability resulting in the forceful removal of a government is never a good look

to the international community and foreign investment in the nation quickly dried up.

This was a real problem because at this time the nation was desperately trying to industrialize

other sectors of the economy to make up for the meat industry which was increasingly falling

into the hands of international companies.

This eventully led to the election of Juan Peron who introduced sweeping economic reforms

with a particular interest on building out nationalized heavy industry. Which sounds

an awful lot like someone else you might know from this time period.

For what it’s worth this tactic of nationalise everything that was owned by foreigners and

pumping money into building out industry did sort of work for a while, but once other nations

had recovered from the second world war they were very cranky that all of their foreign

assets had been stolen.

To add insult to injury Argentina was more than happy to extend an open invitation to

German Nazi’s that the world had just fought so hard to defeat.

For this reason nobody wanted to invest in Argentina or buy any of the stuff they were

making in their fancy new factories and for a nation as heavily dependant on exports and

foreign investment as Argentina this was a major blow.

The nation quickly became very poor once again and the radical new leaders popularity fell

along with it, leading to yet another political coup from a successive lineup of strong figurehead

leaders with the secret solution to fix the nation.

At this point you should start to get an idea of the narrative of Argentina in the 20th

century. Sweeping reforms to correct minor issues meant more harm was done than good

and these damages were subsequently “fixed” by more sweeping reforms that did more harm

than good.

The nation ping-ponged its way through the remainder of the twentieth-century pinging

from total command economics to ponging of basically le-ze faire capitalism.

Now any regular viewers of this channel will know what I am going to say next. This kind

of back and forth decimated the Stability of the nation and the confidence that people

had in it.

People dont’t want to invest or start families, careers and businesses in a country that could

be flipped on it’s head in the next election. They don’t want to save for retirement under

a regime that could plunder their piggy bank and international organisations don’t want

to throw money into a nation that will give them nothing in return.

So yeah yeah stability and confidence, no huge surprise their, but what if we looked

a little bit deeper. Remember Argentina was a very wealthy and stable nation, so what

was it that caused their decline, while other similar nations like canada and Australia

sailed on with their prosperity intact to this day.

Well to answer that we have to look at the

Argentine Paradox

The actual reason behind Argentina’s continued economic instability is a point of much debate

between a host of economists. just like the 3-decade long stagnation of japan nobody really

knows for sure. But there are a few prevailing theories for both.

Economists have primarily looked at the Argentinan journey in contrast to Australia and Canada

specifically who were all very similar entities at the turn of the last century. They all

had modest populations, they all had a large population of European settlers and they all

had a healthy collection of natural resources and farmland.

So the question was what made the difference.

The first proposal put forward by Guiadio Di Tella an Argentinian economist and businessman

was that the main difference between Argentina and other settler societies such as Australia

and Canada was its failure to seek adequate alternatives to compensate for the end of

geographical expansion with the definitive closing of the frontier.

100 years ago these countries were all far less utilized than they are today where almost

every square inch of land is accounted for in some way primarily agriculture. Back in

the day, these nations all had policies if you could go out and find a piece of unused

land and make it work as a farm it was all yours.

The problem was that Argentinian farmland is much more arrible than farmlands in Australia

or Canada and also by virtue of the country been smaller, much less available.

This overtime meant that Argentina had fewer farmers with more land and influence, rather

that more farmers with less influence. Throw in a healthy dose of anti-competition and

corruption and tada, suddenly the core industry of this nation is built on a fundamentally

unstable platform.

Another popular theory is that the nation’s political climate and systems were not as

well equipped to handle the new political landscape of an increasingly globalized world.

Canada and Australia both effectively have political and legal systems passed down from

the british westminster style of government. Now this system is by no means perfect but

it does promote stability and balance of power above all else.

It also promotes systems are put in place to deal with international entities since

you know, the British were very into that.

By contrast, Argentina had it’s political systems passed down to them primarily from

Spain which takes a more run and gun approach to international policies and has much less

of an institutional emphasis on political stability.

This is a slightly controversial theory, but for what it’s worth ex British colonies

have an average GDP per capita almost 50% higher than ex-Spanish colonies.

But, perhaps the most compelling argument came from a 1992 paper published by a research

team at the University of Madrid which highlighted that property rights were the big thorn in

the side of Argentina.

Remember how the nations assets kept on getting claimed by the state, and then privatised

and then claimed by the state and privatesed over and over again? Well it turns out that

makes people really not want to invest in your country, which is really bad.

Borrowing for growth is an essential part of managing a healthy industrial economy,

but that health heavily relies on what terms you get from that borrowing.

On an individual level, if you were a skilled worker like a doctor, or a dentist or even

a tradesman and someone offered you a business loan at 2% interest over a 40 year period

to open your own operation, you would be silly not to take that deal.

So long as you provide a good service you should easily be able to make these repayments

and be wealthier in the long term as a business owner rather than an employee.

On the other hand, if someone offered that same loan but it had to be paid back with

20% interest over a 5 year period, well suddenly it is a lot less tempting.

Not only is the interest higher but the entire thing needs to be paid back quicker which

means those month to month repayments could easily be much more than the business will

ever make.

The same kind of tossup exists on a national level. Historically very stable nations like

the USA and yes even Australia and Canada here can borrow money at very low interest

rates over a very long time.

But if investors look at Argentina they are going to see all of this nationalizing business

and be pretty scared to invest. If they do put their money into the nation they are going

to want high returns, and also going to want to have it out quickly before some new government

gets any ideas.

So in the long term australia and canada got to be the happy little business owners, and

Argentina had to forever be the national equivalent of an employee who couldn’t catch a break

due to their poor credit score.

Of course, there were many historical footnotes that accelerated these problems, not least

of which was starting a war with their longest and most loyal trading partner but some combination

of these three factors are the foundation of the nation’s economic woes.

Or atleast they were, because today, argentina might be facing a very different problem a

Currency crisis

The most recent crisis was kicked off as many have been before it when it became obvious

that argentina would elect a new president that had a political stance that was more

left-wing than his incumbent opposition.

A day after the primary election took place te argentinian stock market plummeted more

than 48% as investors feared they could be in for yet another round of nationalization.

The difference this time is that it’s currency has been thrown into jeopardy with no real

plan to save it.

In the early 1990’s the argentine pesa was pegged to the USD at a rate of approximately

3 to 1. This was enacted in an attempt to ward off inflation and it worked, decently

well.

Currency pegs involve the home nation in this case argentina keeping massive piles of foreign

currency that they are fixing to in this case USD’s. By being there to always honor the

3 to 1 exchange rate the market more or less falls into line because no buyer will accept

less than 3 peso’s per one dollar and no seller will accept less than one dollar for

their 3 peso’s.

We have explored how currency pegs work in much more detail in our video on Entropia

universe of all things so if you are still confused go and watch that.

But in short so long as people believe that a government can honor the currency exchange

they say, that’s what the currency conversion will be and sometimes this works so well the

government doesn’t even need to get involved. People just exchange at the agreed price of

their own volition.

Unfortunately this system fell apart during the last economic crisis in 2001, where people

rushed to exchange their peso’s to USD’s until the exchange board completely ran out

of reserves at which point the Argentine Peso effectively became a free-floating currency

despite the government still trying their best to prop it up.

Those efforts include offering the highest interest rates in the world. Ever feel short

changed by bank’s in your country only giving you half a percent interest on your savings

if you are lucky? Well in argentina you can get as much as 25%, the only catch is that

you need your deposits held in Argentinian peso’s.

The reason that this has become such a problem now is that this attempt to control the Argentine

peso has done very little but introduce lots of American money into circulation.

Given the historic instability of the nation and a rapidly declining value of the peso

people are moving to do more and more of their business in American dollars rather than Argentinian

monopoly money. Today Argentina effectively has a dual currency economy.

Argentine peso’s are still used for regular day to day activities like buying groceries

or paying for a taxi, but major transactions like buying a house or a car or even getting

paid are done in American dollars.

If this becomes widespread enough people will eventually not recognise peso’s for anything

and Argentina will become the largest economy in the world to not have control over it’s

own money.

Using a foreign currency is fine for small nations that don’t have the capacity to

truely run their own internal economic policies, places like monaco, and even Montenegro get

away with this just fine.

But if Argentina can not raise taxes, or provide fiscal stimulus or borrow in it’s own currency

it will effectively become a dead state walking, just one bump away from complete implosion

and if history is anything to go off, there are plenty of bumps ahead.

Ranking

Now it’s time to put Argentina on the economics explained national leaderboard, however, we

will now be doing that on our second channel that I bet most of you didn’t know we had.

Go and subscribe to that one as well because we will be using that channel a lot more this

year than we have been, for fun little economic curiosities that we weren’t able to make

full video’s out of as well as national rankings from here on out, plus well whatever

else I feel like putting on there.

Now spoiler alert, Argentina is not going to get a great score, but will it be bottom

of the list, well you’ll have to find out.

Fortunately, you can do a much better job of setting yourself up for prosperity by automating

your savings.

With acorns...

Outro add