FILM INDO YANG BERHASIL BIKIN GUA SUJUD, SAKING BAGUSNYA‼️🔥 | REVIEW "1 KAKAK 7 PONAKAN" (2025)

Summary

In this insightful review, the speaker reflects on an Indonesian film, sharing their mixed but overall positive response. They commend the film's emotional depth, especially in certain characters like Ano, whose dialogue provokes strong emotional reactions. However, they critique the character of Mas Eka, feeling that his resolution was abrupt and somewhat forced, detracting from the film's otherwise grounded reality. Despite this, they rate the film highly within Indonesian cinema, noting its minimal flaws and celebrating its emotional impact, giving it a solid 9/10 rating.

Takeaways

• 😀 The speaker critiques the character of Mas Eka for feeling overly artificial and less grounded in reality compared to the other characters.
• 😀 The resolution of Mas Eka's character is seen as sudden and unsatisfactory, particularly in comparison to the other characters' story arcs.
• 😀 The speaker finds the film to have a philosophical and deep tone, but feels that Mas Eka's character undermines this depth.
• 😀 The character of Ano is praised for being humorous and emotionally engaging, with certain lines from Ano bringing the speaker to tears.
• 😀 The film is recognized as being very strong within the context of Indonesian cinema, with minimal weaknesses overall.
• 😀 Despite flaws in the character development of Mas Eka, the speaker still rates the film highly, giving it a score of 9/10.
• 😀 The speaker mentions that the last time they watched a film of this caliber was when they first fell in love with films on this level.
• 😀 The speaker acknowledges the emotional impact of the film, especially in how it effectively makes the viewer laugh and cry.
• 😀 Although the film isn't perfect, the speaker considers it a significant achievement in the Indonesian film industry.
• 😀 The speaker ends with a positive outlook, expressing excitement for future content and thanking the audience for watching.

Q & A

What is the primary critique of the character Mas Eka in the film?

The reviewer feels that Mas Eka's character, although real and plausible in real life, becomes somewhat artificial and cheap in the context of the film. They specifically mention that the resolution of his character feels sudden and disconnected from the others.

Why does the reviewer think the film feels philosophical and deep?

The reviewer feels the film has a philosophical quality due to its emotional depth and how it explores human experiences and relationships, particularly through Mas Eka's character. However, they also express frustration with how the character's arc is resolved too abruptly.

How does the reviewer compare this film to other Indonesian films?

The reviewer considers this film to be one of the best in Indonesian cinema, calling it a 'god' in comparison to other local films. They acknowledge minor weaknesses but feel these do not detract significantly from the film’s quality.

What emotional reaction does the reviewer mention regarding the character Ano?

The reviewer expresses a strong emotional reaction to the character of Ano, particularly when a seemingly humorous line transforms into a poignant moment. This moment triggers unexpected tears, showing the character's emotional depth.

What does the reviewer think about the film's overall storytelling?

The reviewer believes the film's storytelling is generally strong, offering an emotional rollercoaster that evokes deep feelings. However, they criticize the resolution of Mas Eka's character arc for feeling unnatural and disconnected.

Why does the reviewer rate the film 9/10?

The reviewer rates the film 9/10 because they feel it is a solid, well-crafted film with minimal flaws. Despite some reservations about Mas Eka's character, they still find it emotionally impactful and entertaining.

How does the reviewer feel about the film’s humor?

The reviewer notes that while the film contains humorous moments, particularly with the character Ano, these moments are capable of switching to deeper, emotional scenes that resonate strongly, showing the film's balance of humor and drama.

What is the significance of the dialogue involving Ano, according to the reviewer?

The reviewer points out a specific line by Ano—'Next time, if Ano is sick, Ano just hold on, Ano doesn’t want to bother you, you dog'—which initially comes across as funny but later becomes unexpectedly emotional, highlighting the film's ability to evoke multiple emotions.

What is the reviewer's overall opinion of the film?

The reviewer feels that while the film is not perfect, it is an exceptional piece of work in the context of Indonesian cinema. They appreciate the emotional impact and overall quality but have some reservations about certain character developments.

How does the reviewer describe the final resolution of Mas Eka's character?

The reviewer describes the resolution of Mas Eka's character as 'sudden' and 'broken,' feeling that it contrasts too much with the grounded nature of the rest of the film. They are unsatisfied with how his storyline concludes compared to the other characters.