Capital gains tax debate rages in Parliament: “Promising to tax, borrow and spend us into fairness”
Summary
TLDR九年前,总理承诺可以不受控制地花钱,并且富人会为此买单,中产阶级不必支付。然而,结果是,最富有的加拿大人的净资产翻了一番,而九成中产阶级加拿大人支付了更多的税。住房成本翻倍,76%的中产阶级青年认为他们永远买不起房。两百万人因负担不起食物而排队到食品银行。总理的政策导致中产阶级生活成本增加,但保守党认为他的做法只保护了富人。辩论中提到的政策变化包括对富人出售盈利投资征税,用于住房、牙科保健等项目,但中产阶级依然面临更高的税负。
Takeaways
- 📈 过去九年,加拿大总理承诺通过无节制的支出,让富人负担费用,但结果是中产阶级的税负增加,生活成本上升。
- 💰 总理上任以来,加拿大最富有人群的总净资产翻倍,而中产阶级的税负和生活成本也相应增加。
- 🏠 76%的中产阶级青年认为自己买不起房子,200万人因为薪水不足以支付食物而排队领取食物银行的援助。
- 🤔 鉴于总理在过去9年中已经违背了这一承诺,为什么人们应该相信他这次会有所不同?
- 🔄 保守党领袖试图为富人争取利益,尽管他们出售的是盈利丰厚的投资,却只被要求支付更多的税。
- 🏘️ 政府正在投资更多在住房上,以确保年轻人有与前几代人相同的机会。
- 🦷 过去6周内,政府为超过20万老年人提供了牙科护理服务,并且增加了儿童护理空间。
- 💼 小企业主即使只有1元的投资收益,也要支付更高的税,没有免税额度。
- 🌱 政府的“污染定价”政策为80%的加拿大人提供了更多的资金,通过加拿大碳税退税。
- 📉 保守党在资本收益税率问题上沉默了两个月,现在选择站在最富有的加拿大人一边,反对需要更多住房和更好待遇的年轻加拿大人。
- 📊 根据加拿大统计局的数据,自总理上任以来,最富有的加拿大人的净资产翻倍,因为税收总是落在中产阶级身上。
Q & A
九年前,总理承诺了什么关于支出和税收的政策?
-九年前,总理承诺他可以无节制地支出,并且会有富人支付账单,而中产阶级不需要支付。
根据总理的说法,最富有的加拿大人的净资产在过去九年中发生了什么变化?
-根据总理的说法,自他上任以来,最富有的加拿大人的总净资产翻了一番。
为什么76%的中产阶级青年认为他们永远买不起房子?
-因为住房成本在过去九年中翻了一番,而中产阶级的税负也增加了。
为什么有200万人因为中产阶级薪水而无法负担食物,而需要在食品银行排队?
-这是因为生活成本上升,而中产阶级的收入并没有相应增加,导致他们无法负担基本生活费用。
为什么保守党领袖在投票支持富人利益时会陷入困境?
-因为保守党领袖试图为富人争取税收优势,这与他们声称代表中产阶级利益的立场相矛盾。
政府如何计划为年轻人提供更多住房机会?
-政府计划通过对出售非常有利可图的投资的富人征收更多税款,以投资于住房,使年轻人有与前几代相同的机会。
政府最近六周为老年人提供了哪些额外的医疗服务?
-政府最近六周为超过20万老年人提供了牙科护理服务。
为什么政府认为对富人征收更多税款是公平的?
-政府认为,当富人出售非常有利可图的投资时,应该支付更多的税款,以资助对住房、牙科护理和其他社会服务的投资。
为什么保守党在资本收益税率问题上保持沉默了两个月?
-保守党可能不想讨论这个问题,因为他们选择站在富人一边,反对需要更多住房和更好生活条件的年轻人和老年人。
政府的碳污染定价政策对大多数加拿大人有什么影响?
-政府的碳污染定价政策为80%的加拿大人提供了更多的资金,通过加拿大碳回扣实现。
为什么保守党被指责为反对公平?
-保守党被指责为反对公平,因为他们认为护士或水管工应该比百万富翁支付更高的税率。
为什么有人认为总理的税收政策是“疯狂”的?
-因为总理的税收政策在住房短缺时征税房屋建筑商,在医疗短缺时征税医生,在食品价格危机时征税农民,并且在经济萎缩时征税小企业创造就业机会的人。
为什么有人认为总理的税收政策会导致加拿大生活水平下降?
-因为根据加拿大统计局的数据,自总理上任以来,他的政策已经导致加拿大人每人失去了4200美元的工资,使中产阶级的生活状况变得更糟。
Outlines
😠 中产阶级税负加重与贫富差距扩大
该段落讨论了加拿大总理九年前承诺的无节制开支政策及其后果。总理声称,尽管开支增加,但会有富人来支付账单,而中产阶级不必承担更多。然而,事实上,加拿大最富有人群的净资产自他上任以来翻了一番,而中产阶级的税收和住房成本也翻了一番,导致76%的中产阶级青年认为他们永远买不起房子。此外,还有200万人因为中产阶级薪水买不起食物而排队领取食物银行的救济。演讲者批评总理的税收政策总是落在中产阶级身上,而不是富人,并且质疑为何每次提到中产阶级,他们就会变得更穷。
🤔 保守党对公平税收政策的反对
这段内容批评保守党在税收政策上的立场,指出他们选择站在最富有的加拿大人一边,而不是支持需要更多住房和更好机会的年轻加拿大人,以及需要牙科护理的老年人。演讲者提到,总理提出的污染定价政策实际上为80%的加拿大人提供了更多的资金,并通过加拿大碳回扣计划实现。保守党被指责为保护富人的利益,而不是投资于住房、牙科护理和其他加拿大人需要的领域。此外,还提到了对小企业主、房屋建筑商、医生和农民增税的问题,这些都在经济萎缩的背景下进行。
😡 保守党的税收政策选择与后果
这段内容强调了保守党在资本收益税率问题上的沉默,以及他们最终选择与最富有的加拿大人站在一起,反对中产阶级。演讲者指出,保守党的政策选择将对加拿大人的生活标准造成严重影响,预计加拿大将迎来四十年来最严重的生活水平下降。自2015年以来,自由党的政策已经导致加拿大人每人失去了4200美元的工资。演讲者呼吁保守党支持公平的税收政策,而不是让护士或水管工比百万富翁支付更高的税率。
Mindmap
Keywords
💡总理
💡中产阶级
💡富人
💡住房成本
💡食物银行
💡税收
💡资本利得税
💡碳税
💡小企业
💡生活标准
Highlights
9年前总理承诺无节制支出,富人会支付账单,但中产阶级无需支付。
总理上任以来,加拿大最富有人群的净资产翻倍。
N9和N10政策导致中产阶级支付更多税款,住房成本翻倍。
76%的中产阶级青年认为自己永远买不起房。
200万人因为中产阶级薪水买不起食物而排队领取食物银行。
保守党领袖试图为富人争取优势,投票支持他们的利益。
要求富人在出售盈利投资时支付更多税款,以投资于年轻人的住房。
过去6周内为超过20万老年人提供牙科护理。
增加儿童护理空间,支持加拿大人。
总理承诺通过征税、借贷和支出实现公平,但数据显示最富有的加拿大人变得更富有。
中产阶级支付更高的碳税,小企业税增加打击了水管工和电工。
每次提到中产阶级,他们的经济状况就变得更糟。
“污染定价”政策为80%的加拿大人提供更多的资金。
保守党选择站在最富有的加拿大人一边,而不是需要更多住房和牙科护理的年轻人。
即使是1元的投资收益,小企业主也要支付更高的税。
在住房短缺期间,总理想要对房屋建筑商征税;在医疗短缺期间,想要对医生征税。
在食品价格危机期间,总理想要对农民征税。
在G7国家中,加拿大经济萎缩最严重,总理想要对小企业创造就业的人征税。
保守党过去8周避免谈论提高资本收益税率,现在选择站在最富有的加拿大人一边。
财政部长即将对加拿大人征收另一项扼杀就业、削减工资、提高价格的税。
加拿大正面临四十年来最严重的生活水平下降。
90%的中产阶级家庭现在支付更多的所得税,自2015年以来自由党的政策使加拿大人每人损失了4200元的工资。
保守党今天必须选择立场,他们选择了反对公平。
保守党认为护士或水管工应该比百万富翁支付更高的税率。
加拿大人正在观察,现在看到了保守党选择的立场。
Transcripts
nine years ago the Prime Minister
promised he could spend uncontrollably
and there'd be a rich guy on a hill
somewhere who would pay the bill the
middle class wouldn't have to pay what
is the result according to him the total
net worth of the richest Canadians has
doubled since he took office meanwhile
N9 and 10 middle class Canadians are
paying more tax housing costs have
doubled so 76% of middleclass Youth
believe they'll never afford a home 2
million people line up at a food bank
because they can't afford to eat on a
middle class salary given that he
already broke this exact same promise
over 9 years why should we believe him
this
time if it didn't have real world
impacts on Canadians it would almost be
amusing to watch the conservative leader
tie himself in nuts to try and justify
voting in favor of advantages for the
wealthy Canadians when they sell really
profitable Investments we are asking
them to pay a little bit more so we can
invest more in housing for young people
to be able to have the same kinds of
opportunities previous generations did
we're delivering dental care for over
200,000 seniors in just the last 6 weeks
we're delivering more spaces in child
care we're stepping up for Canadians
they're stepping up for the
rich real world impacts that's what we
have today after 9 years of this prime
minister promising to tax borrow and
spend us into fairness but according to
the stat scan data he put out himself
since he became prime minister of the
net worth of the wealthiest Canadians
has doubled why because the taxes he
puts always land on the middle class
nine and 10 middle class people are
paying higher taxes the vast majority of
Canadians than 100% of middle class are
paying higher carbon tax and his last
round of small business tax hikes hit
plumbers and electricians not the rich
why is it that every time he mentions
the middle class they get
poor our price on pollution delivers
more money to eight out of 10 Canadians
right across the country with the Canada
carbon rebate uh and today Mr Speaker
There's an opportunity for everyone in
this house to stand up and ask the
wealthiest Canadians to pay a little
more when they sell extremely profitable
Investments we are doing that on this
side of the house the conservatives will
be protecting the advantage that is
there for the wealthiest Canadians while
we invest more in housing while we
invest more in Dental Care while we
invest more in Canadian who need it if
you are a small business owner you have
even $1 of investment gain you pay this
higher tax that the prime minister is
promising because there's no exemption
inside the
300,000 small businesses and it's
incredible that during a housing
shortage he wants to tax home builders
during a healthcare shortage he wants to
tax away our doct doctors during a food
price uh crisis he wants to tax our
farmers and while our economy is
shrinking more than any other con
economy in the G7
he wants to tax our small business job
creators Mr Speaker isn't this the
definition of
insanity for8 weeks since we put our
budget forward the conservatives have
been incredibly careful not to say a
thing about the capital gains uh rate
that we're raising uh they didn't want
to talk about it for two full months and
today when they are choosing to vote
with the wealthiest Canadians and
against young Canadians who need more
housing young Canadians who need a
better break seniors who need Dental
Care uh they're all trying to spin it in
nine different ways the reality is they
have an opportunity to vote with
middleclass Canadians and they're
choosing to vote against
them the Finance Minister is about to
impose another job killing wage cutting
price hiking tax on Canadians and she
wants us to believe the latest fairy
tale that somehow we'll all be better
off if the Prime Minister just raises
taxes again we've heard this for 9 years
let's take a look at the result Canada
is on track for the worst decline in
living standards in four decades 9 out
of 10 middle- class families now pay
more in income taxes and stats Canada
says that liberal policies since 2015
have cost Canadians $4,200 in lost wages
per worker they've made the middle class
worse off with their last eight budgets
why should anyone believe that the ninth
time is the
charm for the past eight weeks we have
watched the an edifying spectacle of the
conservatives squiggling and
squirming
deflecting and debating but today they
have no choice today they had to pick a
side and we're seeing now the side that
they have chosen the conservatives are
coming out against fairness they think a
nurse or a plumber should pay tax at a
higher rate than a multi-millionaire
Canadians are watching Canadians now see
whose side the conservatives are
[Applause]
5.0 / 5 (0 votes)