12 Tahun Berlalu, Apa Kabar Gorong-gorong Jokowi? | Narasi Daily

Summary

The video explores the Jakarta flood issues and the role of former governor Joko Widodo (Jokowi) in addressing them. It highlights his visit to a drainage system near Bundaran HI, where he assessed the cause of recurrent flooding. Despite the visit and his suggestion for improvements, the drainage system's capacity remained insufficient, and flooding persisted. The video critiques the lack of significant follow-up actions on Jokowi's recommendations, even after 12 years, amidst growing environmental challenges like rising sea levels and land subsidence. The piece concludes with a call to reconsider the need for integrated urban planning solutions.

Takeaways

• 😀 Jokowi visited a drainage system (gorong-gorong) 12 years ago, marking a significant moment in Indonesia's political landscape.
• 😀 The drainage system was located near Bundaran HI and the German Embassy, though some sources mentioned the Mandarin Oriental Hotel.
• 😀 Jokowi's visit to the drainage system was prompted by recurring flooding issues in Jakarta, especially around Bundaran HI.
• 😀 During the visit, Jokowi noted the drainage pipes were too small to manage the floods effectively.
• 😀 Jokowi discussed the need for wider drainage pipes, with an ideal diameter of 1 meter, to prevent flooding in Jakarta.
• 😀 Despite Jokowi's suggestions, the drainage system in the area showed no major changes from 2013 to 2023.
• 😀 Flooding continued in Jakarta even after Jokowi's visit, with incidents recorded in 2015 and 2016, showing that the flooding problem persisted.
• 😀 Jokowi's visit sparked no significant follow-up action, and there has been no major rehabilitation of the drainage system in the years that followed.
• 😀 Political transitions from Jokowi to Ahok, Anies, and Heru didn't bring substantial improvements in Jakarta's drainage infrastructure.
• 😀 Over the 12 years since Jokowi's visit, Jakarta has faced increasing rainfall, rising sea levels, and sinking land, exacerbating the city's flooding problems.
• 😀 The lack of an integrated master plan for Jakarta's drainage system and urban planning remains a critical issue, preventing effective long-term solutions.

Q & A

What is the significance of the underground tunnel (gorong-gorong) mentioned in the video?

The underground tunnel (gorong-gorong) is a key location in Jakarta, symbolizing the political changes in Indonesia. It was notably visited by Joko Widodo (Jokowi) 12 years ago during his early political career, drawing attention to the issue of flooding and infrastructure challenges in the city.

Why did Joko Widodo visit the underground tunnel?

Jokowi visited the tunnel to inspect the cause of frequent flooding around Bundaran HI. He identified that the tunnel was too small to accommodate the volume of water, which contributed to the area's flood problems.

What did Jokowi say about the tunnel's size and what action did he suggest?

Jokowi remarked that the diameter of the tunnel was too small and suggested that expanding its size was necessary to improve the drainage system. He mentioned that a diameter of 1 meter would be ideal and that the tunnel should be square-shaped.

What was the state of the flooding around Bundaran HI after Jokowi's visit?

Despite Jokowi's inspection, flooding continued to occur in the area. One example is the flood on January 17, 2013, just a month after his visit. This highlights the ongoing infrastructure issues in Jakarta despite the attention given to the problem.

How did the flooding problem evolve over the years following Jokowi's visit?

The flooding problem persisted even years after Jokowi's visit, with significant floods recorded in 2015, 2016, and even affecting the Presidential Palace. Despite changes in leadership, the issue of flooding remained largely unaddressed, with no major rehabilitation of the drainage system.

What does the video suggest about Jakarta's urban planning and drainage systems?

The video suggests that Jakarta's urban planning and drainage systems have not seen significant improvements despite the years of discussion about the issue. There is an ongoing lack of a comprehensive and integrated master plan for the city's drainage and infrastructure.

What has been the impact of political leadership on the issue of flooding?

The video suggests that while political leadership has changed, with Jokowi followed by Ahok, Anies, and now Heru, there has been little progress in addressing the flooding issue. The lack of a long-term, unified plan has resulted in the persistence of the problem.

Why is there frustration about the lack of follow-up after Jokowi's inspection of the tunnel?

There is frustration because Jokowi's visit to the tunnel did not lead to any concrete actions or improvements. The video emphasizes that, despite his inspection and suggestions for an expanded drainage system, there was no real implementation or integrated planning to address the issue.

How has Jakarta's physical environment changed over the past 12 years?

Over the past 12 years, Jakarta's physical environment has changed significantly, with increasing rainfall, rising sea levels, and sinking land. These factors have exacerbated flooding problems, further complicating the city's drainage challenges.

What is the core message about Jakarta's flooding issue and future action?

The core message is that Jakarta continues to face severe flooding problems despite political attention and interventions. The lack of a coordinated, long-term plan for drainage and urban development has led to a recurring cycle of floods and failed solutions, leaving citizens questioning if meaningful change will ever occur.