L'Ucraina ha perso tutto. Quando una guerra finisce male male.

Summary

In this video, the speaker discusses the unfolding events in Ukraine and their implications for Europe. He critiques the European Union's handling of the situation, claiming it has been humiliated by Russia and the U.S. He also reflects on his early predictions about the war, particularly his assertion that Ukraine would ultimately be defeated. The speaker points out the failures of key European leaders, like Giorgia Meloni, and highlights how the media and political discourse in Italy have failed to adequately address the responsibilities surrounding the war. The video culminates in a critical reflection on the fate of Ukraine, the collapse of its aspirations for NATO and EU membership, and the geopolitical ramifications for Europe.

Takeaways

• 😀 The video discusses a recent meeting between U.S. Secretary of State Marco Rubio and Russian Foreign Minister Sergey Lavrov in Riyadh, Saudi Arabia, aimed at easing tensions between the U.S. and Russia.
• 😀 The speaker predicted early in the war that Russia would overpower Ukraine, and that Ukraine would eventually be defeated and broken up, which aligns with current events.
• 😀 The speaker critiques the European Union's involvement in the war, arguing that it has become irrelevant and humiliated by the Russia-U.S. negotiations.
• 😀 The speaker expresses disappointment in the EU’s handling of the situation, emphasizing that it was supposed to be a project for peace but is now promoting war policies.
• 😀 Trump’s insults toward Zelensky are highlighted as a significant development, marking a sharp reversal from earlier expectations and signaling a major humiliation for Ukraine and its supporters.
• 😀 Giorgia Meloni's stance against diplomacy with Putin is criticized, with the speaker noting that she and others in Italy have long rejected dialogue with Russia despite its strategic necessity.
• 😀 The speaker accuses the Italian media of operating like a dictatorship, specifically regarding coverage of international politics, and compares it to media control seen in Belarus.
• 😀 The video includes a critical article about the EU’s miscalculation regarding Russia's strength and its failure to stop the war or predict the outcomes accurately.
• 😀 Trump’s focus on securing negotiations with Putin is seen as a strategic move to manage the collapse of the Ukrainian front and avoid further embarrassment for the U.S.
• 😀 The speaker reiterates the failure of NATO's policies in Ukraine, highlighting the dire state of the country, including military losses and political instability, with Ukraine on the brink of losing everything it fought for.

Q & A

What does the speaker criticize about the current state of the European Union?

The speaker criticizes the European Union for failing to act in accordance with its founding principles of peace. He argues that the EU is engaging in policies of war instead of promoting peace, which undermines its original mission.

How does the speaker describe the relationship between the U.S. and Russia during the current conflict?

The speaker explains that the U.S. and Russia are negotiating behind Europe's back to end the conflict in Ukraine, which results in the EU's humiliation. He suggests that the U.S. and Russia are working together while the EU has been sidelined.

What were the speaker's early predictions about the war in Ukraine?

The speaker predicted that Russia would overwhelm and dismantle Ukraine, and that the U.S. and Russia would ultimately end the war by negotiating with each other, bypassing the European Union. These predictions have largely been accurate according to the speaker.

What is the speaker's view on Giorgia Meloni's stance regarding the war in Ukraine?

The speaker criticizes Giorgia Meloni for initially supporting a hardline stance against Russia and rejecting diplomatic dialogue with Putin. However, he notes that Meloni has remained silent as the situation has worsened, and he argues that there has been no critical discussion about her role in Italy's handling of the crisis.

How does the speaker perceive the media in Italy regarding the Ukraine conflict?

The speaker claims that the Italian media is corrupt and operates similarly to a dictatorship when it comes to international politics. He argues that the media is not providing critical coverage of the government's actions, particularly with regard to Ukraine.

What does the speaker say about Trump's role in the Ukraine conflict?

The speaker suggests that Trump is trying to salvage the situation by negotiating with Putin, effectively sidelining the EU. He criticizes Trump for insulting Zelenskyy and argues that Trump’s actions are a result of the U.S. being 'on its knees' in front of Russia.

What is the significance of the article published by the speaker in the 'Fatto Quotidiano'?

The article discusses the humiliation of the European Union, highlighting how the EU's initial assumptions about Russia's military strength were wrong. It points out that Russia has proven much stronger than expected, and the EU's efforts to counter Russia have failed.

How does the speaker view the future of Ukraine?

The speaker believes that Ukraine has lost the war and will face further humiliation. He predicts that Ukraine will lose its sovereignty and its position as a key European state, and its prospects for joining NATO or the EU are now dim.

What does the speaker say about the role of U.S. military aid in the conflict?

The speaker suggests that U.S. military aid has been insufficient to prevent Ukraine's defeat. He claims that for every NATO bullet Ukraine fires, Russia fires ten, and the balance of power has swung in Russia’s favor due to U.S. failure to invest adequately in the conflict.

What does the speaker mean by 'the collapse of the Ukrainian front'?

The speaker is referring to the deteriorating military situation in Ukraine, with soldiers and generals reportedly acknowledging that Ukraine’s defense is crumbling. He suggests that the collapse of Ukraine's military front could lead to the end of the country's sovereignty.