Elijah Craig C924 vs Larceny C924: Which Barrel Proof Should You Buy?

Summary

In this episode of SLB Basement Bourbon Bar, the hosts review the latest releases from Larceny and Elijah Craig Barrel Proof. They discuss the mixed reactions to the new Larceny label, highlighting its nutty and honey notes, and the creamy mouthfeel that surprises them. The Elijah Craig, at a higher proof, presents sweet caramel and earthy undertones, showcasing its complexity. The hosts express their appreciation for both bourbons, debating their merits and sharing personal tasting experiences. They also touch on their charity event for Riley Children's Hospital, emphasizing community engagement alongside bourbon appreciation.

Takeaways

• 😀 The hosts discuss the recent releases of the Larceny and Elijah Craig Barrel Proof bourbons, highlighting their availability issues in Indiana.
• 🥃 The Larceny bourbon features a new label design that has received mixed reviews from the community.
• 👃 The hosts describe the aroma of Larceny as nutty with honey and a refined grain note, comparing it to honey-roasted nuts.
• 🔥 Larceny is noted for its high viscosity and warmth, with an initial pleasant sweetness that transitions to a pronounced alcohol burn.
• 👍 Both hosts express surprise at their positive impressions of the Larceny Barrel Proof, with one considering it a favorite among recent releases.
• 📏 The Elijah Craig Barrel Proof (C924) has a higher proof at 129, with a more traditional flavor profile that includes sweet notes of brown sugar and marshmallow.
• 🍭 The aroma of Elijah Craig includes candy-like notes, with a rich complexity that sets it apart from previous releases.
• 🔄 The hosts discuss the potential for a blind tasting of different Elijah Craig releases to compare flavors and preferences.
• 💡 A significant point raised is the importance of non-chill filtering in higher-end bourbons, which the hosts advocate for.
• 👏 The session concludes with praise for both bourbons, noting their unique characteristics and overall quality, encouraging viewers to share their opinions.

Q & A

What are the main bourbons discussed in this video?

The main bourbons discussed are the Larceny Barrel Proof and Elijah Craig Barrel Proof, specifically the C9 24s.

What are the proof levels of the bourbons mentioned?

The Larceny Barrel Proof is 125.1 proof, and the Elijah Craig Barrel Proof is 129 proof.

What are the hosts' initial thoughts on the new label design for Larceny?

The hosts have mixed feelings about the new label design, with one stating that they are not a huge fan, finding it clashes in a weird way and does not look clean.

What kind of notes do the hosts detect in the Larceny Barrel Proof?

They detect nuttiness, honey, and a refined grain note, describing it as having aromas similar to honey glazed almonds or honey-roasted nuts.

How do the hosts describe the mouthfeel and finish of the Larceny Barrel Proof?

They describe the mouthfeel as very viscous and creamy, coating the mouth, and the finish as nutty with a little bitterness, reminiscent of walnuts.

What is the charity event mentioned in the video?

The charity event is for Riley Children's Hospital, and the hosts are donating over 100 bottles to support this cause.

How do the hosts feel about the Elijah Craig Barrel Proof compared to the Larceny?

One host prefers the Elijah Craig Barrel Proof, citing it as having a great mouthfeel and sweetness throughout the palate, while the other finds both bourbons to be good.

What specific tasting notes do the hosts find in the Elijah Craig Barrel Proof?

They note a bright, confectionery aroma with cotton candy, marshmallow, brown sugar, and molasses, along with an earthy note at the back.

What do the hosts suggest doing with the Elijah Craig Barrel Proof and Larceny in the future?

They suggest conducting a blind tasting of Elijah Craig and Larceny to compare their preferences.

What is the overall sentiment regarding both bourbons at the end of the video?

The overall sentiment is positive, with both bourbons being described as solid releases from Heaven Hill, encouraging viewers to drink responsibly.