計畫不是策略

Summary

This video distinguishes between strategy and planning, explaining that while planning focuses on activities within a company's control, strategy involves making integrated choices to win in a competitive field. Many businesses mistakenly combine the two into 'strategic planning,' but real strategy requires a coherent, outcome-driven approach that involves risk and uncertainty. The speaker uses Southwest Airlines as an example of effective strategy, emphasizing that strategy is about positioning to win, not just participating. To succeed, companies must embrace uncertainty, continuously refine their strategy, and stay focused on competitive outcomes.

Takeaways

• 📝 Strategic planning and strategy are often confused, but they are not the same.
• 🎯 Strategy is a coherent set of choices aimed at positioning a company to win in a competitive environment.
• 🔍 Planning is often about resource allocation, like building factories or hiring people, but it lacks the coherence of a strategy.
• 🏆 A strategy specifies a competitive outcome, focusing on how a company will win in the marketplace, unlike planning, which focuses on controllable costs.
• 💡 Strategy requires a theory of how the company will outperform competitors and deliver value to customers.
• 📊 A plan can make a company feel comfortable, but comfort does not lead to winning in the long run.
• ✈️ The example of Southwest Airlines shows how a clear strategy can outpace competitors who are focused only on planning.
• 🧠 Strategy involves risk and uncertainty, as it cannot be proven in advance, unlike a plan that lists actionable items.
• 🔄 Strategy should be flexible, with leaders continuously monitoring and adjusting based on how the market and competition evolve.
• 📄 A good strategy should be simple, clear, and able to fit on a single page, with defined goals, capabilities, and management systems.

Q & A

What is the main difference between planning and strategy, according to the script?

Planning involves setting out specific actions or activities a company will engage in, whereas strategy is an integrated set of choices that positions a company to win on a chosen playing field. Planning focuses on tasks, while strategy focuses on achieving competitive outcomes.

Why does the script suggest that 'strategic planning' is often misunderstood?

The script suggests that 'strategic planning' is misunderstood because most so-called strategic plans are actually just lists of activities or goals without a coherent strategy. These plans lack a theory of how to position the company to win in the market.

What does the script define as a strategy?

A strategy is defined as a coherent set of choices that positions a company on a playing field of its choice in a way that allows it to win. It includes a theory of why the company should be on a particular field and how it will outperform competitors.

What is the problem with focusing only on planning without a strategy?

The problem with focusing only on planning is that while it might outline various activities a company will do, it lacks the coherence and competitive focus that a strategy provides. As a result, the planned activities might not lead to success or competitive advantage.

How does the script illustrate the difference between planning and strategy using airlines?

The script contrasts the planning of major US airlines with Southwest Airlines' strategy. While the major carriers focused on planning their routes and expansions, Southwest had a strategy aimed at winning by offering lower costs and more convenience, which allowed them to grow rapidly and capture market share.

What is one of the key challenges of creating a strategy, as mentioned in the script?

One key challenge of creating a strategy is dealing with uncertainty. A strategy aims for an outcome that relies on customer behavior, which the company cannot control. Managers must accept the risk and uncertainty associated with strategy, unlike the predictability of planning.

Why is planning described as more comfortable than strategy?

Planning is described as more comfortable because it deals with internal decisions the company controls, such as how much to spend on a factory or how many people to hire. Strategy, on the other hand, requires taking risks on external factors like customer preferences, which the company cannot control.

What advice does the script give for developing a strong strategy?

The script advises laying out the logic of the strategy clearly, specifying what needs to be true for it to succeed, and being prepared to adjust the strategy as the market and conditions evolve. This allows for flexibility and continuous improvement of the strategy.

How does the script suggest companies should approach strategy refinement?

The script suggests that strategy should be treated as a journey. As a company watches the market and observes what works and what doesn’t, it should tweak and refine the strategy, making improvements based on real-world results.

What example does the script use to show the importance of having a clear strategy?

The script uses Southwest Airlines as an example. While other airlines were focused on planning activities, Southwest had a clear strategy that allowed it to offer lower costs and greater convenience, positioning it as a winner in its market segment.

Outlines

00:00

🤔 The Difference Between Planning and Strategy

The speaker distinguishes between planning and strategy, explaining that while planning has been around for a long time, it's not the same as strategy. Strategic planning often combines the two but misses the essence of true strategy. Most business strategies are actually plans—a set of actions without a coherent theory of how to win in the market. A proper strategy, however, is an integrated set of choices positioning a company on a specific playing field to succeed. It requires a clear, coherent theory and actions, unlike planning, which focuses on resource allocation without a strategic direction.

05:00

✈️ Southwest Airlines’ Winning Strategy

Southwest Airlines is highlighted as an example of successful strategy execution. Instead of following the traditional hub-and-spoke model of other airlines, Southwest focused on point-to-point travel, using only one type of aircraft (Boeing 737) to simplify operations. They chose not to offer meals and encouraged online bookings, all of which reduced costs. As a result, they could offer lower prices than competitors. While major airlines focused on expanding their fleets or securing more gates, Southwest focused on winning by targeting a specific segment, growing rapidly, and eventually dominating the U.S. air travel market.

Keywords

💡Planning

Planning refers to the process of outlining activities that an organization intends to carry out. In the context of the video, the speaker highlights that planning has been around for a long time and often focuses on internal operations, such as building new plants or hiring employees. Planning deals primarily with resource allocation and is more focused on actions that the company can control.

💡Strategy

Strategy is defined as a coherent set of choices that positions an organization on a competitive playing field with the aim of winning. The speaker emphasizes that strategy is different from planning because it involves making calculated decisions to achieve a competitive advantage. Strategy requires a theory about why a particular approach will work and focuses on long-term outcomes, rather than just internal activities.

💡Strategic Planning

Strategic planning, as described in the video, is often a misnomer, where organizations combine planning with strategy. The speaker argues that many businesses falsely label their planning efforts as strategic planning, when in reality they lack a true strategic focus. Instead, these plans are often just lists of operational goals without a coherent strategy.

💡Coherent Theory

A coherent theory in the context of strategy refers to a clear and logical reasoning that explains why a specific set of choices will lead to competitive success. The speaker argues that a strategy must be based on a theory that can be translated into actionable steps, aligning all parts of the business to achieve success in a particular market.

💡Competitive Outcome

A competitive outcome is the end goal of a strategy, which involves outperforming competitors and achieving a superior position in the market. The speaker stresses that strategies should aim for competitive outcomes, which are dependent on external factors like customer preferences, rather than merely focusing on internal operations.

💡Customer Focus

Customer focus refers to the necessity of understanding and meeting customer needs as a central part of a successful strategy. The video contrasts planning, which is internally focused, with strategy, which requires anticipating and responding to customer demands to win in the marketplace.

💡Hub and Spoke vs. Point to Point

Hub and Spoke and Point to Point are two different airline route models. The video uses Southwest Airlines' strategy of flying point to point as an example of strategic thinking. While traditional airlines used the Hub and Spoke model (flying from central hubs), Southwest chose point to point, which allowed it to reduce costs and improve efficiency, ultimately leading to its competitive success.

💡Cost Control

Cost control refers to managing the expenses within a company, which is often a primary focus of planning. The speaker points out that companies feel more comfortable controlling costs, as they are within their control, unlike customer preferences or market dynamics. However, this focus on internal costs doesn't necessarily lead to success without a broader strategy.

💡Comfort Trap

The comfort trap is a term used by the speaker to describe the tendency of managers to rely on planning because it feels more secure and controllable. Planning allows managers to focus on tangible tasks like spending resources, but this comfort can prevent them from pursuing riskier but potentially more rewarding strategies that are centered on market outcomes.

💡Winning Strategy

A winning strategy is one that not only sets clear goals but also identifies how an organization will outperform its competitors. The video uses Southwest Airlines as an example of a company with a winning strategy. By making clear choices, such as flying point to point and lowering costs, Southwest positioned itself as a leader in the airline industry.

Highlights

Planning and strategy are often mistakenly conflated, but they are fundamentally different.

Strategy is an integrated set of choices that positions a company on a playing field of its choice to win.

Strategy requires a coherent theory about why a company should play on a particular field and how it will be better than its competitors.

Strategic planning in many companies is a list of activities, not an actual strategy.

Planning often focuses on controllable costs and resources like building factories or hiring staff, but lacks the competitive outcome focus of strategy.

A strategy specifies an outcome, such as achieving customer preference over competitors, which is harder because it involves factors outside direct control.

Planning is comforting because it deals with predictable, controllable resources, while strategy involves uncertainty and risk.

Southwest Airlines succeeded by having a clear, coherent strategy—lower costs through flying point-to-point, using one aircraft type, and avoiding extras like meals.

While competitors were busy planning, Southwest had a winning strategy that allowed it to grow and dominate.

Most competitors were 'playing to participate' rather than 'playing to win,' focusing on incremental gains instead of competitive positioning.

Strategy involves making decisions based on what must be true for a company's theory to work, and adapting when those conditions don't play out.

Good strategy involves acknowledging that you can't guarantee success but understanding the risks and making bold choices.

Companies must focus on laying out the logic behind their strategy to allow for adjustments as conditions change.

A successful strategy should be simple enough to be written on a single page and regularly reviewed and refined.

Planning without a coherent strategy is a way to guarantee losing; strategy provides the best possible chance of winning.

Transcripts

this thing called planning has been

around for a long long time people would

plan out the activities they're going to

engage in more recently has been a

discipline called strategy people have

put those two things together to call

something strategic planning

unfortunately those things are not the

same strategy and planning so just

putting them together in callate

strategic planning doesn't help what

most strategic planning is in the world

of of business uh has nothing to do with

strategy it's got the word but it's not

it's a set of

activities that the company says it's

going to do we're going to improve

customer experience we're going to open

this new plant we are going to start a

new talent development program a whole

list of them and they all they all sound

good but the results of all of those are

not going to make the company happy

because they didn't have a strategy

[Music]

so what's a strategy a strategy is an

integr set of choices that positions you

on a playing field of your choice in a

way that you win so there's a theory

strategy has a theory here's why we

should be on this playing field not this

other one and here's how on that playing

field we're going to be better than

anybody else at serving the customers on

that playing field that theory has to be

coherent it has to be doable you have to

be able to translate that into actions

for it to be a great strategy

planning does not have to have any such

coherence and it typically is what

people in manufacturing want the few

things they want to build a new plant

and the marketing people want to launch

a new brand and the talent people want

to hire more people that tends to be a

list that has no internal coherence to

it

and no specification of a way that that

is going to accomplish collectively some

goal for the

company see planning is quite comforting

plans typically have to do with the

resources you're going to spend so we're

going to build a plant we're going to

hire some people we're going to launch a

new product those are all things that

are on the cost side of businesses who

controls your costs who's the customer

of your costs the answer is you are you

decide how many square feet to lease how

many uh raw materials to buy how many

people to hire those are more

comfortable because you control them a

strategy on the other hand specifies an

outcome a competitive outcome that you

wish to achieve which involves customers

wanting your product product or service

enough that they will buy enough of it

to make the profitability that you'd

like to uh make the tricky thing about

that is that you don't control them you

might wish you could but you can't they

decide not

you that's a harder trick so that means

putting yourself out and saying here's

what we believe will happen we can't

prove it in advance we can't guarantee

it but this is what we want to have

happened and and that we believe will

happen it's much easier to say I'll

build a factory I will hire more people

Etc then I will have customers end up

liking our offering more than those of

competitors the tricky thing about

planning is that while you're

planning chances are at least one

competitor is figuring out how to

win when US Air carriers were busily

planning you know what routs to fly and

da da da there was this little company

in Texas called Southwest that had a

strategy for

winning and you know at first that

looked largely irrelevant because it was

Tiny what Southwest Airlines was aiming

for was an outcome

what they wanted to be is a substitute

for

Greyhound a way more convenient way to

get around at a price that wasn't

extraordinarily much greater than a

greyhound uh bus Southwest said

everybody else is flying Hub and spoke

they have hubs and they fly Hub and

spoke we're going to fly point to point

so that we don't have aircraft waiting

on the ground because you only make

money when you're in the air we're going

to only fly

737s one kind of aircraft so that our

gates are set up for those our systems

are set up for those our training our

simulations are set up we're not going

to offer meals on on the flights because

we're going to specialize in in short

flights we're not going to book through

travel agents we're going to encourage

people to book online because that's

less expensive for everybody and more

convenient so their strategy ended up

being having a substantially lower cost

than any of the major carriers so that

they could offer substantially lower

prices because it had a way of winning

it got bigger and then bigger and then

bigger and then bigger and bigger and

bigger and bigger until it flies the

most passenger seat miles in

America the major

carriers um were not trying to win

against one another they were all

playing to play as I say they were

playing to participate maybe maybe maybe

buy more planes get more gates maybe

grow some not having a theory of here's

how we could be better than our

competitors and that was fine until

somebody came along and said here's a

way to be better than everybody else for

this segment uh and so that segment then

goes it's gone and the main playing

toplay players have to have to share a

smaller pie that's left over after

Southwest takes whatever share it

wants if you're trying to escape this

planning trap this Comfort trap of doing

something that's comfortable but not

good for you uh how do you

start the most important thing to

recognize is that strategy will have

angst associated with it it'll it'll

make you feel somewhat nervous because

as a man manager chances are you've been

taught you should do things that you can

prove in advance you can't prove in

advance that your strategy will succeed

you can look at a plan and say well all

of these things are doable let's just do

those because they're within our control

but they won't add up to much in

strategy you have to say if our theory

is right about what we can do and how

the market will react this will position

Us in an excellent way just accept the

fact that you can't be perfect on that

and you can't know for sure and that is

not being a bad manager right that is

being a great leader because you're

giving your organization the chance to

do something great the second thing I do

is is say lay out the logic of your

strategy uh clearly what would have to

be true about ourselves about the

industry about competition about

customers for this strategy to work why

do you do that it's because you can then

watch the world unfold right and if

something that you say is in the logic

that would have to be true for this to

work is not working out quite the way

you hoped it'll allow you to tweak your

strategy and strategy is a journey what

you want to have is a mechanism for

tweaking it toning it and refining it so

it gets better and better as you go

along another thing that helps with

strategy is not letting it get over

complicated it's great if you can write

your strategy on a single page here's

where we're choosing to play here's how

we're choosing to win here the

capabilities we need to have in place

here are the management systems and

that's why it's going to achieve this

goal this aspiration uh that we have

then you lay out the logic what must be

true for that all to work out the way uh

we hope go do it uh and watch and tweak

as as you go along that may feel

somewhat more worry making angst making

than planning but I would tell you that

if you plan that's a way to guarantee

losing if you do strategy it gives you

the best possible chance of

[Music]

winning