ROMAN ROQUE - ANG MANGHUHUWAD NG KASAYSAYAN
Summary
TLDRThe video discusses the role of Roman Roque in historical forgeries during the Philippine-American War, specifically his involvement in fabricating documents used to capture General Emilio Aguinaldo. Roque's skills in forgery were also linked to the controversial retraction document allegedly signed by Jose Rizal, questioning its authenticity. Additionally, the script touches on other documents related to Andres Bonifacio, casting doubt on their legitimacy. The video highlights how these forged documents may impact our understanding of history and raises questions about the authenticity of key historical events and figures.
Takeaways
- 📜 History is composed of documented events that shape our understanding of the past, but false documents can distort historical narratives.
- 👤 Roman Roque is introduced as a key figure known for his expertise in forging documents.
- 📝 Roque forged a document used by American forces to deceive and capture Emilio Aguinaldo during the Philippine-American War.
- 🇵🇭 Roque worked as a clerk and interpreter for General Frederick Funston, the American general involved in Aguinaldo's capture.
- 📩 The forged letter, supposedly from General Lacuna, was used to trick Aguinaldo into accepting fake reinforcements, leading to his capture.
- ✒️ Roque's skills in forgery are documented in General Funston's memos, highlighting his role in crafting fake official papers.
- ✍️ Allegations also exist that Roque was involved in forging José Rizal's retraction letter, though this remains controversial.
- ❓ Roque is rumored to have created five fake copies of Rizal's retraction, though one was confiscated by church officials.
- 📚 Some documents related to Andres Bonifacio are also suspected to have been forged by Roque, adding to historical disputes.
- ⚖️ Three key documents are associated with Roque’s forgeries: the letter used to capture Aguinaldo, Rizal's alleged retraction, and disputed documents regarding Bonifacio.
Q & A
What is the significance of Roman Roque in the historical narrative presented?
-Roman Roque is portrayed as a skilled forger who played a pivotal role in crafting fake documents used by American forces to deceive Filipino revolutionaries, including leading to the capture of Emilio Aguinaldo.
How did Roman Roque contribute to the capture of Emilio Aguinaldo?
-Roman Roque created a fake letter supposedly from General Urbano Lacuna, which convinced Aguinaldo that reinforcements were arriving. This deception allowed American forces disguised as prisoners to infiltrate Aguinaldo’s camp and capture him.
What role did Lazaro Segovia play in the events described?
-Lazaro Segovia was a Spanish collaborator who aided in the operation by helping American forces access Aguinaldo's communications and facilitating the forgery efforts of Roman Roque.
Why is the document allegedly signed by Jose Rizal controversial?
-The document, said to be a retraction by Rizal of his writings against the Catholic Church, is controversial because no concrete evidence proves he signed it. Some suspect it was forged, possibly by Roman Roque.
How did Roman Roque’s skills in forgery extend beyond Aguinaldo's capture?
-Roman Roque allegedly forged several documents, including a retraction letter attributed to Jose Rizal and potentially some documents linked to Andres Bonifacio, adding to the controversies surrounding their legacies.
What was the reaction of General Frederick Funston to Roman Roque’s forgery skills?
-General Funston was impressed by Roque’s ability to create convincing forged documents, including a letter signed by General Lacuna, which played a key role in deceiving Aguinaldo and his forces.
What was the impact of Cecilio Segismundo's surrender on the American campaign?
-Cecilio Segismundo, a trusted envoy of Aguinaldo, surrendered to the Americans, providing crucial intelligence about Aguinaldo’s location in Palanan and weakening the Filipino resistance.
What controversial role did Roman Roque allegedly play concerning Jose Rizal's retraction?
-Roman Roque allegedly forged Jose Rizal’s retraction document, which purportedly showed Rizal renouncing his anti-church writings. This claim remains controversial due to lack of definitive evidence.
How does Roman Roque’s story intersect with that of Andres Bonifacio?
-Roman Roque is linked to allegations that some documents about Andres Bonifacio were forged, casting doubt on certain aspects of Bonifacio’s story. These documents reportedly originated from Epifanio de los Santos.
Why are the forged documents attributed to Roman Roque considered controversial in Philippine history?
-The forged documents attributed to Roman Roque, including the letters associated with Rizal, Aguinaldo, and Bonifacio, are controversial because they have the potential to alter key aspects of historical narratives, leading to debates about their authenticity and the true course of events.
Outlines
📜 The Questionable Authenticity of Historical Documents
The paragraph discusses the nature of history as a record of past events, shaped by existing documents. However, it raises the issue of what happens when some of these documents are forged. The introduction presents Roman Roque, described humorously as a 'great con artist,' who played a role in shaping certain historical narratives. It also mentions the surrender of Filipino forces during the Philippine-American War and Roque's involvement in the American forces as a clerk and interpreter under General Frederick Funston in Nueva Ecija. This leads to the plot involving Roque's role in the creation of a forged document used to capture Filipino President Emilio Aguinaldo.
✍️ Forged Retraction of Jose Rizal and Roman Roque's Role
This paragraph transitions to the controversial retraction of Jose Rizal, who was a critical figure against the Catholic Church and Spanish rule in the Philippines. It highlights the suspicion surrounding whether Rizal actually signed a retraction document, which would have recanted his views against the Church. Roque, after successfully forging documents for the capture of Aguinaldo, was allegedly tasked with forging Rizal's retraction under the guidance of the clergy. The paragraph details Roque's account of being approached to create multiple copies of the fake retraction, including a personal reflection on being paid for his work. Roque’s role in forging other controversial documents, including those related to Andres Bonifacio, is also introduced.
Mindmap
Keywords
💡Kasaysayan
💡Roman Roque
💡Emilio Aguinaldo
💡Forgery
💡Cecilio Segismundo
💡José Rizal
💡Retraction of Rizal
💡Nueva Ecija
💡American Colonial Rule
💡General Frederick Funston
Highlights
History is a record of events written based on existing documents and becomes narratives that shape our perception of past events.
The accuracy of history can be affected if some documents are forged.
Roman Roque is introduced as a figure known for his skill in document forgery.
Roque surrendered to the American forces and served as a clerk and interpreter under General Frederick Funston.
Funston used Roque’s forgery skills to create a fake document from General Lacuna, leading to the capture of Emilio Aguinaldo in Palanan, Isabela.
Roque's forgeries impressed General Funston, contributing significantly to the successful American operation.
Suspicion arises that Roman Roque also forged Jose Rizal's retraction letter, which supposedly renounced his writings against the Catholic Church.
The alleged forgery of Rizal’s retraction remains a controversial topic, with no definitive evidence supporting the claim.
It is suspected that Roque forged several copies of Rizal’s retraction letter, with one supposedly being kept for himself but later confiscated by the priests.
Roque claimed he was paid the equivalent of two months' salary for his forgery work on Rizal's letter.
Roman Roque disappeared from San Isidro, Nueva Ecija, for about two weeks after his work on the Rizal document.
There are claims that documents related to Andres Bonifacio were also forged by Roman Roque, raising questions about their authenticity.
The alleged forged documents related to Bonifacio were linked to historian Epifanio de los Santos, adding more controversy.
Roque's work as a forger has left a lasting impact on the authenticity of several important historical documents in the Philippines.
The study concludes that while Roque’s involvement in forging the document for Aguinaldo's capture is certain, the authenticity of the Rizal retraction and Bonifacio documents remains controversial.
Transcripts
ang tinatawag na kasaysayan ay Tala ng
mga pangyayari na isinulat base sa mga
eksistido mga dokumento at nagiging mga
naratibo na humuhubog ng ating pagtanaw
ukol sa mga naging kaganapan sa
nakalipas subalit Papaano kung ang ilang
mga dokumento ay hinuwat lamang Ano ang
magiging epekto nito sa ating
tinatanggap na kasaysayan sa
kasalukuyan sa pagkakataon pong ito ay
amin pong ipapakilala sa inyo si Roman
Roque ang maituturing na dakilang
[Musika]
manghuhuthot
[Musika]
na rin po ang notification Bell at
mag-like
hinihikayat po namin kayo na kung
mayroon po kayong paksa na gusto po
ninyong talakayin sa aming mga pag-aaral
ay pakisulat na lamang po sa comment
para po aming masaliksik sa mga susunod
na
panahon sa panimulang taon
1 ang hukbo ng Republika ng Pilipinas sa
pamumuno nial Aguinaldo ay unti-unti ng
natalo ng superior na sandatahan ng
hukbong Amerikano at nagsimula na silang
sumuko sa mga
mananakop
isa sa mga opisyal ng hukbong Pilipino
na sumuko sa mga amerikano ay ang isang
opisyal mula sa probinsya ng Nueva Ecija
na si Roman
roque sa kanyang Pagsuko si Roque ay
nagl sa hukbong Americano bilang clerk
at interpreter sa headquarter ni general
Frederick fon ston na nasa bayan ng San
Isidro na noon ay kabisera ng nasabing
probinsya
Noong Pebrero 8 19 da at isa sumuko sa
mga Amerikano ang anim na mga pagod na
jilla sa pamumuno ni Cecilio segismundo
isang Ilocano at pinagkakatiwalaang sugo
ni aguinaldo na may dalang mahahalagang
sulat at isinuko ito kay lieutenant
Taylor ipinaalam ni segismundo na si
Aguinaldo ay may hindi hihigit sa lamp
gwardya sa punong tanggapan ni aguinaldo
na nasa Palanan sa bulubunduking
lalawigan ng Isabela sa hilagang
silangan ng Luzon malapit sa
dalampasigan ng
pasipiko sa pamamagitan ng
pakikipagsabwatan ng isang Espanyol na
si Lazaro segovia ay nalaman nila ang
mga nilalaman ng sulat ni aguinaldo na
isinuko ni seis mundo sa mga
Amerikano isa sa mga detalye sa sulat ay
ang paghingi ni aguinaldo ng
reinforcement para sa kanyang punong
himpilan sa
Palanan Halos isang taon na ang
nakalipas sa isang pagsalakay ng mga
Amerikano sakuta ni Heneral urbano
lacuna ay nakakuha sila ng mga dokumento
at blangkong mga opisyal na papel ng
nabanggit na
Heneral naisip ni Heneral Von ston na
maari niyang mapasok ang himpilan ni
aguinaldo sa Palanan sa pamamagitan ng
isang hinuwat na
dokumento sa pamamagitan ni Lazaro
segovia ginamit nila ni fon ston ang
Kahusayan ni Roman roque sa panghuhuwad
at Nakagawa ito ng isang pekeng
dokumento na nagsasabi na magpapadala si
L cuna ng re indorsement para sa
himpilan ni aginaldo sa
Palanan maging si fon ston ay namangha
sa Kahusayan ni Roque sa paghahanda ng
pekeng dokumento na may lagda ni Luna na
gagamitin nito para makapagdala ng bogos
na reinforcement sa Palanan katunayan
ang Kahusayan ni Roque ay naging bahagi
ng memo ni general fon ston na
nagdedetalye sa ginawa ni Roque na
panghuhuwad
inorganisa ni fon ston ang isang pangkat
na dadak kay Aguinaldo sa Palanan na
binubuo ng mga opisyal na Amerikano na
magkukunwaring mga bihag ng bogos na
reinforcement at ang mga opisyal na
Filipino na akto na pinuno ng mga
sundalong
makabebe ang bogos na reinforcement ay
bumaba ng kasig giran at Naglakbay ng
ilang araw hanggang makarating sa
himpilan ni aguinaldo kung saan naganap
ang pagdakip ng mga
Amerikano ang susunod naman sa ating
listahan na sinasabing iginawa ni Roman
Roque ng huad na dokumento ay si Jose
Rizal malaman natin na ang mga nobela ni
Rizal na Noli metangere at elf Phil bism
at halos ang kanyang mga sinulat ay
nagtataglay ng maanghang na tuligsa sa
simbahang Katoliko magmula sa ugali ng
kanyang mga kaparang Espanyol hanggang
sa pagbatikos niya sa mga pangunahing
nitong dogma inaakala nila na ang mga
ideya ni Rizal ay magiging higit na
impluwensyal sa kanyang
[Musika]
kamatayan
nang patayin si rizal isa sa mga
ipinaluto simbahan na si Rizal ay
pumirma ng isang retraksyon na Binabawi
ang kanyang mga sinulat laban sa
simbahan subalit walang maipakitang
dokumento sa ganito nagkakaroon ng
suspetsa ang ilan na hindi lumagda si
rizal ng traksyon
sinasabi na dahilan sa napabalitang
paraan ng pagdakip kay Aguinaldo sa
pamamagitan ng huad na sulat kinuha nila
ang pagkakataon para sa pinakahihintay
na Sandali para sa mga arkitekto ng
retraksyon ni Rizal nilapitan nila si
Lazaro segovia na noon ay tagapamahala
ng isang sentro ng asukal sa Mindoro na
pag-aari ng mga clero ay muling
inatasang kunin si Roman Roque Makalipas
ang Ilang buwan nang Ipagdiwang ni Don
Antonio Abad isang kilalang residente ng
San Isidro Nueva Ecija ang kanyang ika
negatibo l5 kaarawan noong Agosto 13 19
at is si Roman Roque na Malapit na
kapitbahay at kaibigan ng mga Abad ay
kabilang sa mga bumati ng sa may
kaarawan sa pakikipag-usap sa ni Roque
sa nakakatandang panauhin ibinunyag nito
na siya ay sinundo ni Lazaro segovia
mula sa San Isidro di nagtagal matapos
ang balita ng pagka kadak kay
Aguinaldo dinala siya sa Maynila at
pinatuloy sa hotel katro Nations sa
Intramuros kung saan siya nagtrabaho sa
pagpapanday ng sulat at pirma ni Rizal
Nakagawa siya ng humigit kumulang limang
kopya ng pekeng sulat na inihanda ng mga
pari anya naisip niyang itago ang isa
para sa kanyang sarili ngunit kinuha ang
kanyang kopya dahil ang mga pari ay
nangangailangan ng karagdagang kopya
siya ay nagtrabaho sa paghuwad sa loob
ng halos s araw naalala niya nang
tanungin kung magkano ang ibinayad sa
kanya para sa trabaho ibinunyag niya na
ibinigay sa kanya ang katumbas ng
kanyang sweldo sa loob ng dalawang buwan
sa serbisyo ng gobyerno naalala ng mga
residente ng San Isidro na halos
Dalawang linggo nawala si roque sa
kanilang
bayan maging si Andres bonfacio ay
isinasabit sa
kontrabanda kanyang libro na inventing
Hero na ang Ilang mga dokumento ukol kay
bonfacio na nagmula kay efipanio de los
Santos ay huad ginamit ni me ang
akusasyon na ito upang
matandang Kapitolyo sa San Isidro Nueva
Ecija sa panahon na si efipanio de los
Santos ang Gobernador at si Roman Roque
naman ang siyang sekretaryo ng nasabing
probinsya sa paglalagom ng pag-aaral na
ito mayroong tatlong dokumento na
sinasabing hinuwat ni Roman Roque Una
ang sulat ni lunan na ginamit sa
pagdakip kay Aguinaldo na tiyak na
ginawa nito subalit ang dalawang
dokumento ang retraksyon ni rizal at ang
ilang sulat ni Bonifacio ay hanggang sa
ngayon ay nasa katayuang kontrobersyal
dahilan sa mayroon mga pangkat na
pumapanig sa posibilidad at pangkat na
kontra naman sa posibilidad nito
ito
Посмотреть больше похожих видео
HISTORY EP 003 BUTO NG SUPREMO
Case Study 3: Did Rizal Retract?
CHAPTER 3.4: Did Rizal Retract? ( THE BALAGUER TESTIMONY & THE TESTIMONY OF CUERPO DE VIGILANCIA )
The Tejeros Convention: Bakit nagalit si Bonifacio?Ano ang mga kaganapan sa kumbensiyon ng Tejeros?
Retraction of RIzal: Did He or Did He Not? / By Ms. Frenz Obispo
RIZAL AS AN AMERICAN SPONSORED HERO | PART 2
5.0 / 5 (0 votes)