Jordan Peterson - The DISASTROUS CONSEQUENCES of GROWING UP WITHOUT a FATHER
Summary
TLDRThe speaker emphasizes the vital role fathers play in a child's development, especially for boys. Without a father figure, children may seek masculinity in unhealthy ways, like joining gangs. Fathers provide encouragement, support, and standards for success, which is crucial for children to thrive. The speaker critiques the modern notion that all family structures are equal, arguing that children benefit from having two parents. The conversation touches on how a lack of a father can lead to victimization culture and delinquency, stressing the importance of responsibility in shaping character and providing meaning in life.
Takeaways
- 👨👦 Fatherless boys often seek masculinity in peer groups or gangs, which can lead to negative consequences due to lack of proper guidance.
- 📚 Boys without fathers can still find positive male role models through education, books, sports heroes, and media, though it's difficult to replace the role of a father.
- 👨👩👧👦 The idea that all family structures are equal is refuted, as children tend to fare better with two parents, though the specific makeup of the parents can vary.
- ⚠️ Single-parenthood becoming normalized can lead to societal degeneration, as it increases the risks of unhealthy parent-child relationships.
- 💡 Marriage should primarily be for the benefit of children, not just the adults involved, reinforcing the importance of stable family structures.
- 🤝 A father's confidence in his child provides a unique gift of support and encouragement, fostering resilience in the child.
- 👩🍼 Mothers typically provide early trust-building and nurturing, but the father's role in encouragement and strength is vital as the child grows.
- 🧑🏫 Children benefit greatly from having at least one positive role model to imitate, and lacking this may lead them toward victimization or unhealthy group identities.
- 👨⚖️ Fathers should impose high standards on their children, balancing discipline with support to foster growth and responsibility.
- 💪 Responsibility gives life meaning, and young men, in particular, crave this sense of purpose and are driven by the need to bear responsibility.
Q & A
What does the speaker suggest happens to boys who lack fathers?
-The speaker suggests that boys who lack fathers often seek masculinity in their friends or by joining gangs. They try to fill the gap of missing father figures, but due to their lack of maturity and guidance, this often leads to poor decisions.
Why does the speaker believe it's important for children to have two parents?
-The speaker argues that children are better off with two parents because it provides them with a balanced source of support and authority. They believe single parenthood becoming the norm is a sign of societal degeneration.
What role does the speaker attribute to fathers in the upbringing of a child?
-The speaker attributes the role of support, encouragement, and confidence-building to fathers. A father who believes in his child and supports their efforts provides a unique gift that helps the child face challenges with confidence.
How does the speaker describe the potential risks in single-parent families?
-The speaker mentions the risk of relationships between a single parent and their child becoming too close, leading to blurred lines and emotional enmeshment. This can create an unhealthy dynamic due to the lack of distributed responsibility.
What does the speaker believe is the danger of normalizing single parenthood?
-The speaker believes normalizing single parenthood is dangerous because it neglects the empirical data showing that children benefit from having two parents. They argue that marriage and family should prioritize the well-being of children, not just the adults.
What does the speaker imply about the role of responsibility in life?
-The speaker implies that responsibility is what gives life meaning, particularly for young men. Carrying the burden of responsibility helps individuals feel a sense of purpose and worth, countering feelings of inadequacy and helplessness.
How does the speaker describe the psychological impact of a father’s rejection?
-The speaker suggests that when a father rejects or fails to form a relationship with their child, it is as if the child is rejected by civilization itself. This can lead to deep psychological harm, making it hard for the child to recover and feel worthy.
What alternatives does the speaker suggest for boys without father figures?
-The speaker suggests that boys without father figures can find masculine role models in education, books, movies, or sports heroes. The father’s role can be fragmented and distributed across the community, but it's still a challenge for the child.
What message does the speaker believe young men need to hear?
-The speaker believes that young men need to hear the message that they have potential, and they should strive to bring out the best in themselves. This involves taking responsibility, facing challenges, and aiming for personal development.
How does the speaker view the relationship between a father and authority?
-The speaker views a father as a figure who should impose high standards on their children, always judging their behavior with the aim of fostering their best qualities. The father should provide both care and encouragement while pushing the child to succeed.
Outlines
👨👦 The Role of Father Figures and the Impact of Their Absence
This paragraph explores the detrimental effects of fatherlessness on children, especially boys. Boys without fathers often try to compensate by forming gangs, creating a version of masculinity that lacks proper guidance. The speaker argues that while boys can find father figures in friends, education, media, or sports, the absence of a father figure creates significant challenges. The text criticizes modern societal norms that claim all family structures are equally beneficial to children, highlighting the importance of two-parent households. The speaker also reflects on the potential risks of overly close parent-child relationships in single-parent families and how societal degradation is linked to the normalization of single parenthood. Finally, the paragraph emphasizes that marriage is primarily for the benefit of children, rather than the married couple, and stresses the critical role fathers play in providing confidence and support to their children.
📚 The Influence of Positive Role Models vs. Victimhood Culture
This paragraph discusses the importance of children, especially those who are neurologically intact, having at least one positive role model to imitate. The absence of such figures often leads to the default adoption of a victimhood mentality, which may bring short-term benefits like avoidance of responsibility, but has long-term negative consequences. The speaker reflects on their upbringing in a working-class community, noting how delinquent behavior often comes with rationalizations. These rationalizations are dangerous as they justify antisocial actions. The absence of a father figure, seen as the embodiment of societal order, can leave individuals feeling worthless and rejected by civilization. A father's role should be to impose high standards on their children, not out of tyranny but to bring out their best potential. The speaker argues that people, particularly young men, crave this kind of responsibility and guidance to help them develop self-respect and purpose.
Mindmap
Keywords
💡Fatherlessness
💡Masculinity
💡Gangs
💡Authority
💡Single Parenthood
💡Marriage
💡Encouragement
💡Responsibility
💡Victimization Culture
💡Role Models
Highlights
Boys without fathers often seek masculine identity through gangs, which can be detrimental as they lack proper guidance.
The father plays a critical role in supporting and encouraging children, instilling confidence that helps them face challenges.
The claim that all families are equal is challenged; empirical data supports the idea that having two parents is better for children.
Marriage is primarily for the children, not the parents, and people need to grow up and recognize this responsibility.
Lack of a father's belief in their child's potential makes it very hard for the child to thrive.
Fathers provide unique encouragement and confidence-building that is vital for children to overcome life's adversities.
Mothers establish trust early on by being the primary caregivers, but fathers play a complementary role in developing resilience.
A child's development benefits from at least one positive role model, preferably within their immediate environment.
In the absence of positive role models, children may default to victimized group identities or adopt antisocial behaviors.
Avoiding responsibility or antisocial behavior provides short-term benefits but results in long-term consequences.
Rejection by a father or the lack of a relationship can lead to a feeling of being cast out by society, making recovery difficult.
Fathers should impose high standards on their children, encouraging their best qualities to emerge while remaining supportive.
A father’s role is to push their child out into the world with strength while offering care when necessary.
Responsibility is what gives life meaning, particularly for young men, who crave the challenge of carrying a load.
For men, responsibility is essential for self-respect and meaning, driving them to face challenges and grow stronger.
Transcripts
no but the kids who lack fathers i mean
first of all they can find that to some
degree in their friends and that's often
what fatherless boys do in particular
they they go into gangs and they
generate the missing masculinity in the
game well that's not so good because
like what the hell do they know
well they don't know anything right
they're just stupid kids and they're
like 15 years old and their testosterone
is pumping and they're trying to get the
hell away from their mother which is
what they're supposed to do and and
they're not in the right position to
exercise any authority over themselves
so that's that's not good they can find
it in education they can find it in
books they can find it in movies they
can find it in sports heroes and so
forth because the image of the father is
fragmented and distributed among the
community but it's very very difficult
to not have a father and you know one of
the things that we're doing in our
society which i think is i think it's
absolutely appalling is that we're
making the case that all families are
equal it's like sorry no wrong
then there's no empirical data
supporting that proposition by the way
it's much better for kids to have two
parents now who those parents are that's
a whole different issue i think it's the
same issue you know i mean i think that
another danger that emerges mrs freud's
of course famous observation is that you
know if if there's mom and child or
father and child that relationship can
get a little closer than it should
and then the lines get blurry and mixed
and i'm not saying that that happens to
everyone obviously but but it's still a
danger that's inherent in the situation
they're thrust together too tightly
without sufficient resources and so the
responsibility has to be distributed
more and like i really do think that
it's the sign of the degeneration of a
society when
that when when single parenthood becomes
anything approximating the norm it's not
a good idea then the part of the reason
i believe that and i think this has to
do with the um overwhelming selfishness
of of of modern life is that marriage
isn't for the people who are married
it's for the children obviously and like
if you can't handle that grow the hell
up
it's a hell of a thing not to have the
confidence of your father
it's really really hard on people you
know if your father is someone who says
to you you can do it i really believe
that you can do it i'll support you in
what you're doing i think that you can
sort it out and then acts towards you in
that way that's a gift that really
almost no one else can provide you with
mothers obviously provide i think they
provide the same kind of gift but
earlier you know because the mother has
to take care of the infant when the
infant is just completely dependent and
so and this is erickson's idea too eric
erickson is the mother is
is the person who establishes the
relationship that allows the developing
person to manifest trust real trust
while you're being carried for crying
out loud you know you can be dropped and
the mother's also the source of food but
the father seems to be something like
the
and i'm being
i'm obviously parsing these things
farther apart than they can need to be
because the father can play a nurturing
role and the mother can play an
encouraging role but
we'll keep it simple for now the father
seems to be the thing that supports and
encourages and says well yeah you know
you're little and small and all of that
and you're subject to destruction and
and and bullying and social pressure and
all that but i know you can do it i know
you can do it and there's a force in
that that's unbelievable and people who
don't have that have a have a hell of a
time it's actually one of the things
that's quite fun about doing
psychotherapy because you get people who
have damaged father figures
that so the father is an encouraging
figure and allows the individual at
least in principle to support the
catastrophe of being voluntarily
if and i believe this like it's one of
the things i've noticed about kids who
are let's say neurologically
intact
these are
there's lots of reasons why
people can develop psychological
disorders and some of them are physical
but imagine that you take a child who's
physically healthy
and you put them in a given environment
my my intuition has been that
the child needs to have at least one
positive role model within
uh imitation distance now sometimes he
or she can sort of piece that together
fragmentarily also from popular media
images you know the images of the heroes
in movies and so on but it's really
helpful to have at least one person in
your immediate environment who is
manifesting the pattern that
characterizes individual success and so
maybe it's something like
if that positive role model isn't there
then the easiest default is to a
victimized group identity
you know of secondary gains
and so if we're going to be
critical in our analysis about
victimization culture
we might ask well what benefits does it
bring to the people who adopt it
so and you know those can and when i
mean benefits i i don't mean long-term
iterative high
quality benefits i mean short-term
payoffs let's say you know how it is if
you have work to do and you avoid it
that's a short-term payoff it's a
benefit
and because you don't have to do the
work now there's a medium to long-term
cost but i'm very curious about
about the the element of victimization
culture that justifies
i think anti-social and avoidant
behavior is probably the right way of
putting it now you know where i grew up
i grew up in a working-class community
and i had friends and associates who
were who ranged from you know pretty
decent kids to pretty solidly planted in
the delinquent camp
and generally the more delinquent types
had a whole handful of rationalizations
for their behavior
and
and it's it's very dangerous to have
those rationalizations at hand because
most forms of antisocial behavior
or avoidant behavior for that matter
very bad medium to long term strategies
because if your father rejects you or
doesn't form a relationship with you
it's as if the spirit of civilization
has left you
outside the walls as of little worth
it's very difficult for people to
recover from that so the father should
be an encouraging force but can be a
tyrannical and crushing force and so
that's very
that's a very difficult thing to get
right partly because
if you're my son
then i should impose the highest
standards of behavior on you and i
should always be judging what you're
doing
i should be judging it with with the aim
of making the best in you come forward
no i'm going to make you strong so any
number of things can happen to you and
when you're when you need some care i'll
be there but otherwise like out into the
world with you that's the right attitude
and for the father it's like get your
bloody act together but i'm on your side
it's because not because i want to
destroy you or demean you or push you
down in the dominance hierarchy because
i want the best in you to emerge and so
you need standards it's like what are
you doing wasting your life there's way
more than that to you get your act
together and bring it out and that's a
message that people really want to hear
if they have any sense at all and
generally they do want to hear it
here you are
suffering away
what makes it worthwhile right
you know you're completely out you're
completely you have no idea what you're
you it's almost impossible to describe
how bad an idea that is
responsibility
that's what gives life meaning
it's like lift a load
then you can tolerate yourself right
because look at you're useless
easily hurt easily killed why should you
have any self-respect
that's the story of the fall
pick something up and carry it pic make
it heavy enough so that you can think
yeah well useless as i am at least i
could move that from there to there this
responsibility thing that's a whole new
order of this is that young men are so
hungry for that it is unbelievable and
the thing is for men there's nothing but
responsibility
Посмотреть больше похожих видео
Baby Mama With 11 Kids By 8 Men Proves Why Anti-Baby Mama Culture Is On The Rise | The Coffee Pod
The real importance of sports | Sean Adams | TEDxACU
Improving early child development with words: Dr. Brenda Fitzgerald at TEDxAtlanta
When parents disagree on parenting styles - Dr. Ann-Louise Lockhart
What a step father is NOT
Supporting the whole child for the whole world: Moe Caroln-Anderson at TEDxBend
5.0 / 5 (0 votes)