Neoliberalism: The story of a big economic bust up | A-Z of ISMs Episode 14 - BBC Ideas

Summary

Neoliberalism, an ideology championed by Friedrich Hayek, emphasizes individual liberty and minimal government interference in markets. It has been both celebrated for promoting entrepreneurship and criticized for leading to uncontrolled globalization and economic inequality. The debate between Hayek and Keynes has shaped economic policies, influencing figures like Reagan and Thatcher, and even Pinochet. Despite the 2007/8 financial crisis tarnishing its reputation, neoliberalism's impact on our globalized world is undeniable.

Takeaways

• 💡 Neoliberalism was sparked by Austrian economist Friedrich Hayek in the mid-1930s as a response to classical liberalism.
• 🏛️ It advocates for minimal external interference in markets, such as taxes, regulations, and levies, to protect individual liberty and private property.
• 🌐 Neoliberalism promotes a market-oriented philosophy, influencing how people view the world and daily transactions.
• 🗣️ The term 'neoliberalism' is often used pejoratively to criticize economic globalizers, bankers, or governments with austere public spending.
• 🤝 Neoliberalism suggests that privatization is more effective than state control in delivering public services.
• 🤝 The ideological debate between Hayek and Keynes is foundational to modern economic thought, with Hayek favoring minimal government intervention.
• 🌟 Keynesianism, in contrast, supports government involvement to stimulate demand, productivity, and employment.
• 📉 Neoliberalism gained traction in the late 1970s amid public sector strikes and concerns over stagflation, influencing figures like Reagan, Thatcher, and Pinochet.
• 💸 The 2007/8 financial crisis led to skepticism about deregulation and neoliberalism, as taxpayers had to bail out banks.
• 🌍 Neoliberalism is criticized for its role in rapid, uncontrolled globalization, favoring corporations over nations and prioritizing innovation over continuity.

Q & A

What is neoliberalism?

Neoliberalism is an economic ideology that emphasizes individual liberty, protection of private property, and the freedom of markets from external interference such as taxes, regulations, and levies. It suggests that markets can produce a philosophy or a way of thinking all of their own.

Who is Friedrich Hayek and what is his connection to neoliberalism?

Friedrich Hayek was an Austrian-born economist who is considered one of the founding figures of neoliberalism. His ideas in the mid-1930s laid the groundwork for the ideology, which he built upon classical liberalism and the defense of individual liberty.

How does neoliberalism view the role of the market in society?

Neoliberalism views the market not just as an absence of interference but as a force that can produce its own philosophy or way of thinking. It encourages looking at the world and daily transactions through a market-oriented lens.

What is the common misconception about neoliberalism today?

Neoliberalism is often used as a term of abuse, hurled by opponents at economic globalisers, bankers, or governments that limit spending on public works or welfare. However, it is more than a dirty word; it represents a mindset and approach to how state and market interact.

What is the significance of the term 'neo' in neoliberalism?

The term 'neo' or 'new' in neoliberalism has morphed into a way of signaling a departure from traditional economic models and a shift towards market-oriented solutions and policies.

How does neoliberalism approach public services?

Neoliberalism emphasizes privatization over state control as the best way to deliver public services, suggesting that the market can provide more efficient and effective solutions.

What was the economic debate between Friedrich Hayek and John Maynard Keynes?

The debate was centered on the role of government in the economy. Keynes argued for government intervention to increase demand and reduce unemployment, while Hayek dismissed this view, advocating for minimal government interference in the market.

Which economic ideology was more dominant after World War Two, Keynesianism or neoliberalism?

Keynesianism was more dominant after World War Two, promoting government intervention in the economy to stabilize economic activity and employment.

What economic conditions in the 1970s led to a resurgence of interest in neoliberalism?

Public sector strikes and concerns about 'stagflation'—a combination of stagnation and inflation—led to a resurgence of interest in neoliberalism as a way to revitalize struggling economies.

Which political figures are known for embracing neoliberalism?

Ronald Reagan and Margaret Thatcher are known for embracing neoliberalism, along with the dictator Augusto Pinochet in Chile, although his adoption of the ideology raised questions about its democratic implications.

How did the 2007/8 financial crash affect the perception of neoliberalism?

The financial crash led to a more critical view of deregulation and neoliberalism, as it was taxpayers who had to bail out the banks, leading to a negative reputation for the ideology.

What is the broader cultural impact of neoliberalism?

Neoliberalism has led to fast-paced, uncontrolled globalization, prioritizing corporations over nations, and valuing innovation over continuity, which has shaped the current globalized world of startups, easy money movement, and cross-border company operations.

Outlines

00:00

🌐 Neoliberalism: Origins and Impact

The paragraph introduces neoliberalism as an ideology that originated from Austrian economist Friedrich Hayek in the mid-1930s. It is rooted in classical liberalism, emphasizing individual liberty and minimal external interference in markets. Neoliberalism promotes a market-driven philosophy and way of thinking, influencing daily life and transactions. Despite being used pejoratively today, it has been a significant influence on governments and entrepreneurs, advocating for privatization over state control. The paragraph also discusses the historical debate between Hayek and Keynes, with the latter advocating for government intervention in the economy. The rise of neoliberalism in the late 1970s is attributed to figures like Ronald Reagan, Margaret Thatcher, and Augusto Pinochet. The 2007/8 financial crisis led to skepticism about deregulation, and neoliberalism has been criticized for its role in uncontrolled globalization, often favoring corporations over nations.

Keywords

💡neoliberalism

Neoliberalism is an economic and political ideology that emphasizes free markets, deregulation, and minimal government intervention in the economy. It is rooted in classical liberalism and was popularized in the mid-20th century by economists like Friedrich Hayek. The video script mentions Hayek's influence on neoliberal thought and how it has been both revered and scorned, depending on one's perspective on its impact on society and the economy.

💡Friedrich Hayek

Friedrich Hayek was an Austrian-born British economist and philosopher who is one of the key figures in the development of neoliberal thought. He advocated for individual liberty, free markets, and limited government intervention. The video script describes his 'light bulb moment' in the 1930s as the origin of neoliberalism, which has since influenced governments and entrepreneurs.

💡classical liberalism

Classical liberalism is a political ideology that emphasizes individual rights, limited government, and free markets. It was prominent in the 18th century and laid the groundwork for neoliberalism. The video script connects neoliberalism to classical liberalism by highlighting the shared values of individual liberty and the protection of private property and markets from external interference.

💡market

In the context of the video, the market refers to the economic system where supply and demand dictate the allocation of goods and services. Neoliberalism views the market as not just an absence of interference but as a guiding philosophy for transactions and daily life. The script uses the phrase 'I’m in the market for a beer' to illustrate how the concept of the market has been internalized in everyday language.

💡privatisation

Privatisation is the process of transferring ownership of public services or assets to the private sector. Neoliberalism advocates for privatisation over state control as a means to deliver public services more efficiently. The video script suggests that neoliberalism has led to a mindset that prioritizes private enterprise and market solutions over government provision of services.

💡John Maynard Keynes

John Maynard Keynes was a British economist whose ideas contrasted with those of Hayek. Keynes believed in government intervention to manage economic cycles and stabilize markets. The video script describes the intellectual rivalry between Keynes and Hayek, with Keynesianism being the dominant economic philosophy for a time after World War Two.

💡Keynesianism

Keynesianism is an economic theory提倡政府干预经济以实现充分就业和稳定增长，与新自由主义形成对立。The video script positions Keynesianism as the counterpoint to neoliberalism, with Keynes arguing for government involvement in the economy to stimulate demand and reduce unemployment, in contrast to Hayek's laissez-faire approach.

💡stagflation

Stagflation is a rare economic condition characterized by stagnant economic growth, high unemployment, and high inflation, which was a problem in the 1970s. The video script mentions stagflation as a factor that led to a reevaluation of Keynesian policies and a turn towards neoliberalism as a solution to economic stagnation.

💡Ronald Reagan

Ronald Reagan, the 40th President of the United States, was a proponent of neoliberal policies. The video script notes his embrace of neoliberalism, which included deregulation and tax cuts, as part of a broader trend towards neoliberal economic policies in the late 20th century.

💡Margaret Thatcher

Margaret Thatcher, the first female Prime Minister of the United Kingdom, was another key figure in implementing neoliberal policies. The video script highlights her role in advancing neoliberalism through measures such as privatization of state-owned industries and deregulation of financial markets.

💡Augusto Pinochet

Augusto Pinochet was a Chilean dictator who also adopted neoliberal economic policies. The video script points out the controversial nature of neoliberalism's association with Pinochet, suggesting that while the ideology may promote economic freedom, it does not inherently ensure democratic freedoms.

💡financial crash of 2007/8

The financial crash of 2007/8, also known as the Global Financial Crisis, was a severe worldwide economic downturn. The video script connects this event to a growing skepticism of neoliberal policies, particularly deregulation, as it led to a situation where taxpayers had to bail out banks that had taken excessive risks.

Highlights

Neoliberalism is an ideology inspired by Friedrich Hayek that emphasizes individual liberty and minimal external interference in markets.

It is rooted in classical liberalism and defends private property and market freedom.

Neoliberalism suggests that markets can produce their own philosophy and way of thinking.

The concept of 'being in the market for something' reflects the internalization of market values.

Neoliberalism is often used as a derogatory term for economic globalizers and governments that limit public spending.

It promotes privatization over state control as the optimal method for delivering public services.

The rise of neoliberalism sparked a significant debate between Hayek and Keynes on the role of government in the economy.

Keynes advocated for government intervention to stimulate demand and reduce unemployment.

Hayek criticized Keynes and their ideas form the basis of modern economic policy debates.

Keynesianism dominated post-World War Two economics, but neoliberalism gained traction in the late 1970s due to economic stagnation.

Leaders like Ronald Reagan and Margaret Thatcher embraced neoliberal policies.

Neoliberalism's association with dictator Augusto Pinochet raises questions about its democratic credentials.

The 2007/8 financial crash led to skepticism about deregulation and neoliberalism's role in it.

Neoliberalism is criticized for its contribution to uncontrolled globalization and prioritizing corporations over nations.

Despite its controversies, neoliberalism has shaped the modern globalized world of startups and cross-border companies.

Friedrich Hayek's ideas continue to influence economic policies and global market dynamics.

The video encourages viewers to subscribe and stay updated for new content.

Transcripts

The A-Z of isms… neoliberalism.

Friedrich Hayek, a tweedy, Austrian-born economist,

had one of those light bulb moments in the mid 1930s

and switched on an ideology that unites its enemies in scorn,

but has inspired governments and entrepreneurs down the decades -

neoliberalism.

The idea was built on the classical liberalism of the 18th Century

and a defence of individual liberty..

protecting private property and the freedom of markets

from external interference -

taxes, regulations, levies -

as much as possible.

Neoliberalism argued

that the market wasn't just an absence of interference,

it could produce a philosophy or a way of thinking all of its own.

That meant looking at the world and at transactions in daily life

through the eyes of the market.

You can glimpse this, for instance,

when I say, “I’m in the market for a beer” -

showing that we’ve internalised the idea of a market for other values.

Nowadays, you probably hear the word neoliberalism

used more as a term of abuse -

hurled by opponents at economic globalisers, nasty bankers

or governments limiting spending on public works or welfare.

The word neo, or new,

has morphed into a way of signalling...

It’s the nearest thing economic terminology has to a rotten tomato.

But neoliberalism isn’t just a dirty word -

it’s an entire mindset of approaches

to the way state and market interact with our aspirations -

emphasising privatisation over state control,

as the best way to deliver public services.

The advent of neoliberalism

led to one of the great punch-ups of economists -

between Hayek and his best frenemy John Maynard Keynes.

Keynes argued that government should get involved

in increasing demand to keep productivity up,

and unemployment down.

Hayek dismissed Keynes as “knowing very little about economics”,

and he wrote a snotty book review of one of Keynes’s major works.

Despite their bickering though,

their competing ideas - Keynesianism and neoliberalism -

remain the seesaw of big thinking in practical economics.

Keynesianism won for a good while after World War Two,

but by the end of the 1970s,

public sector strikes and worries about “stagflation” -

an ugly combo of stagnation and inflation -

persuaded some mould-breakers to look back to neoliberalism

as a way to perk up flagging economies.

Ronald Reagan and Margaret Thatcher led the way in embracing the notion.

And, so did the ruthless dictator Augusto Pinochet in Chile -

which rather marked down the democratic scorecard

of neoliberalism.

The financial crash of 2007/8

created a more testing mood towards de-regulation

and neoliberalism gained a bad rep,

because it was taxpayers who had to bail out the banks.

But there’s a broader, cultural reason

neoliberalism gets it in the neck right now.

Inevitably, it leads to such fast-paced,

uncontrolled globalisation,

because it does away with barriers to trade and to financial flows.

It prizes the innovative above continuities.

So you could say it puts the corporation above the nation.

But the globalised world we inhabit -

one of start-ups, the ability to move money and borrow cheaply,

and companies operating across borders -

owes a lot to the Austrian, Friedrich Hayek,

and his light bulb moment.

Thanks for watching! :)

Don’t forget to subscribe and click the bell to receive notifications for new videos. See you again soon!