Asus TUF F15 VS Acer Nitro 5 😳 COMPARISON & GAMING TEST 📛 RTX 3060 & Intel i7-12700H Edition

Summary

This video compares two mid-range gaming laptops: the Asus TUF Gaming F15 and the Acer Nitro 5. Both feature Intel's 12th gen CPU and Nvidia RTX 3060 GPUs, but key differences include RAM type, screen quality, and cooling performance. The Asus offers DDR5 RAM, a better screen, and stronger build quality, making it more versatile for creative tasks. The Acer is slightly cheaper and performs similarly for gaming, though its screen and cooling are less optimized. The video helps viewers choose the best option based on their specific needs.

Takeaways

• 💻 Both Acer Nitro 5 and Asus TUF F15 are top contenders for mid-range gaming laptops, making it hard to pick between them.
• 🚀 Both laptops are equipped with the latest Intel 12th Gen 14-core processors, featuring smart power distribution between performance and efficient cores for optimal power and battery management.
• 🎮 They both come with Nvidia RTX 3060 GPUs, but the Asus TUF F15 has a slight edge with a 140W power configuration, compared to the Acer Nitro 5's 130W.
• ⚡ The Asus TUF F15 features faster DDR5 RAM (4800 MHz), while the Acer Nitro 5 has DDR4 RAM (3200 MHz), giving Asus the edge in handling heavier tasks like rendering and coding.
• 🖥️ Asus TUF F15 has a better screen, making it more suitable for creative work, while the Acer Nitro 5's display is more suitable for gaming and general use.
• ❄️ The Asus TUF F15 has better airflow issues solved by elevating the back slightly, while the Acer Nitro 5 may require a cooling pad for optimal performance under heavy loads.
• 🔊 Both laptops are loud under heavy load but quiet during light tasks, thanks to efficient power switching technology.
• 💪 The Asus TUF F15 has better build quality and is more durable, making it suitable for tasks beyond gaming, while the Acer Nitro 5 is a solid budget-friendly gaming laptop.
• 🔋 Both laptops have similar battery life, ranging from 5-6 hours in mixed usage to around 7.5 hours when watching media.
• 🎯 If you're focused solely on gaming, the Acer Nitro 5 is a more affordable choice, while the Asus TUF F15 is a better all-around performer, especially for creative work.

Q & A

What is the primary difference between the Asus TUF Gaming F15 and Acer Nitro 5 in terms of GPU?

The primary difference is that the Asus TUF Gaming F15 has a 140W TGP configuration for its Nvidia RTX 3060, while the Acer Nitro 5 has a slightly less powerful 130W TGP configuration.

Why does the Asus TUF Gaming F15 feel faster than the Acer Nitro 5 during intensive tasks?

The Asus TUF Gaming F15 uses the newer DDR5 RAM at 4800MHz, while the Acer Nitro 5 is limited to DDR4 RAM at 3200MHz. This faster memory makes the Asus TUF more responsive during intensive tasks like gaming, rendering, and compiling code.

Can the RAM in these laptops be upgraded to a different type?

No, the RAM types are not interchangeable. Laptops that come with DDR4 RAM cannot be upgraded to DDR5 due to different pin layouts.

How do both laptops handle storage upgrades?

Both laptops come with a 512GB PCIe NVMe SSD and offer the option to upgrade storage easily by installing an additional drive in the second unoccupied slot.

How do the Asus TUF Gaming F15 and Acer Nitro 5 perform in terms of gaming?

In most games, there is a 4-7% difference in frame rate, with the Asus TUF Gaming F15 slightly outperforming the Acer Nitro 5 due to its higher TGP GPU and faster DDR5 RAM. Both laptops support VR and can handle live streaming at medium to high settings.

What are the main differences in the display quality between the Asus TUF Gaming F15 and Acer Nitro 5?

The Asus TUF Gaming F15 has a better display with an 8090:5 panel, offering better response times and refresh rates. In contrast, the Acer Nitro 5's display is less bright and less color-accurate, making it less suitable for creative work but still fine for gaming and general use.

How do the cooling systems of the Asus TUF Gaming F15 and Acer Nitro 5 compare?

The Asus TUF Gaming F15 has smaller feet, which limits airflow when placed on a desk, but raising the back by an inch or two can improve cooling significantly. The Acer Nitro 5, on the other hand, requires a cooling pad or undervolting the GPU to prevent overheating in performance mode.

Which laptop has better build quality and portability?

The Asus TUF Gaming F15 has slightly better build quality and is more durable, making it a better choice for students or users who need to carry their laptop around frequently.

How do the keyboards and overall design compare between the two laptops?

The Asus TUF Gaming F15's keyboard and overall design are preferred by the reviewer, though this is subjective. Both laptops have accurate touchpads, but neither offers advanced features like Biometrics or fingerprint scanners.

Which laptop is better for gaming-only purposes, and why?

For gaming-only purposes, the Acer Nitro 5 is a more cost-effective option. Its performance is almost on par with the Asus TUF Gaming F15, and it can handle gaming well without the need for the extra features and higher price of the Asus model.

Outlines

00:00

🎮 Battle of Mid-Range Gaming Laptops: Asus vs. Acer

The video highlights a comparison between the mid-range gaming laptops from Acer and Asus, focusing on making it easier for viewers to choose the best option. Both laptops feature the same powerful 12th gen Intel CPU with 14 cores, which intelligently switches between performance and efficient cores to save battery life. They also have the Nvidia RTX 3060 GPU, with Asus's version having a slightly higher power configuration (140W vs. 130W). This minor difference doesn't significantly impact performance but does contribute to a price difference. Asus comes with DDR5 RAM, while Acer uses DDR4, making Asus faster in high-demand tasks like gaming and rendering. Both have 16GB RAM and offer easy storage upgrades. The Asus machine generally feels more responsive under heavy loads.

05:00

🔥 Cooling and Performance Challenges

This section delves into the cooling and thermal performance of both laptops. While both perform well under standard mode, they overheat and throttle under performance mode due to different issues. The Asus TUF Gaming F15's minimalistic design limits airflow, which can be mitigated by elevating the laptop slightly to reduce internal temperatures. On the other hand, the Acer Nitro 5 requires a cooling pad or undervolting, which is not ideal for maximizing its potential. Both laptops are noisy under heavy loads but quiet during light tasks. The Asus TUF Gaming F15 is noted for better build quality, making it more durable and suitable for students. Other aspects like keyboard design, speakers, and battery life are similar, with both laptops providing around five to six hours of mixed-use battery life.

Keywords

💡12th Gen Intel Processor

The 12th generation Intel processor is a key feature in both laptops discussed in the video. This CPU features a hybrid architecture with 'performance cores' and 'efficient cores' that help balance power and efficiency depending on the task. The inclusion of this processor makes both the Acer and Asus models powerful and capable of handling gaming and intensive workloads. It is a central component in understanding the performance differences between the two laptops.

💡Nvidia RTX 3060

The Nvidia RTX 3060 is the GPU installed in both laptops. This graphics card, with 6GB of VRAM, provides the necessary power for gaming and graphic-intensive applications. However, there is a slight difference in wattage between the two models—140W in the Asus TUF F15 and 130W in the Acer Nitro 5. This contributes to the price and performance variations discussed in the video.

💡DDR5 vs DDR4 RAM

The Asus TUF F15 comes with DDR5 RAM, operating at 4800 MHz, while the Acer Nitro 5 uses DDR4 RAM, which is limited to 3200 MHz. This distinction is important because DDR5 is faster and more efficient than DDR4, making the Asus laptop better suited for more demanding tasks like 3D rendering and compiling code. This memory difference is one of the reasons why the Asus model feels more responsive during heavy workloads.

💡Graphics Power (TGP)

TGP, or Total Graphics Power, refers to the wattage that the GPU can consume. In this video, the Asus TUF F15 has a 140W TGP while the Acer Nitro 5 has a 130W TGP. While the difference in performance is minor (around 4-7% depending on the game), the TGP impacts both the pricing and the GPU’s heat output during extended use, making it a notable comparison point between the two laptops.

💡Display Quality

The video highlights the differences in display quality between the two laptops, with the Asus TUF F15 having a better-quality display compared to the Acer Nitro 5. The Asus screen is more suitable for gaming and everyday use due to its better response time and refresh rate, though it is still not ideal for creative tasks requiring color accuracy. This is a major factor when choosing between these laptops, especially for users who value screen quality.

💡Cooling System

Cooling systems are essential for maintaining performance in gaming laptops, and the video compares how the Asus TUF F15 and Acer Nitro 5 manage heat. The Asus model has small feet, leading to less airflow, but can improve performance with a simple height adjustment. On the other hand, the Acer Nitro 5 requires more complex solutions like a cooling pad or GPU undervolting to avoid overheating. This is crucial for users who plan to use these laptops under heavy loads.

💡Overheating and Throttling

Both laptops suffer from overheating and throttling under high performance modes. Overheating causes the laptops to reduce their processing speeds, which is referred to as throttling. The video discusses how both machines handle this issue and provides solutions such as raising the Asus model for better airflow and using a cooling pad for the Acer model. This aspect is key for gamers and users working with resource-intensive applications.

💡Max Switch

The Max Switch feature allows users to disable the integrated GPU in favor of the dedicated Nvidia RTX 3060 GPU, boosting frame rates by up to 7% in games. However, this comes at the cost of increased battery drain. The inclusion of this feature makes both laptops more versatile for gaming but less ideal for battery-intensive mobile tasks.

💡Build Quality

The build quality of the Asus TUF F15 is noted to be slightly better than the Acer Nitro 5. The video describes the Asus model as more durable and suitable for users like students who need a laptop that can withstand frequent travel. This aspect may not directly affect performance, but it plays a role in the overall user experience and longevity of the device.

💡Battery Life

Both laptops offer impressive battery life for gaming laptops, lasting around 5-6 hours in mixed usage and up to 7.5 hours when streaming content. This is a notable feature for users who need their laptops to last on the go. The video emphasizes that while these are gaming laptops, they can still perform well in non-gaming scenarios without constant access to power.

Highlights

Both Acer and Asus have designed impressive mid-range gaming laptops, making it hard to choose between them.

Both laptops feature the powerful Intel 12th Gen 14-core chip, offering a smart mix of performance and efficiency cores.

Both machines come with Nvidia RTX 3060 GPUs, with Asus TUF F15 having a slightly higher power configuration (140W) than the Acer Nitro 5 (130W).

Asus TUF F15 uses DDR5 RAM (4800 MHz), while Acer Nitro 5 sticks with DDR4 (3200 MHz), leading to better responsiveness in heavy tasks for Asus.

Both laptops have 16GB of RAM, upgradeable to 32GB, which is adequate for most tasks.

Storage is identical with both models offering 512GB PCIe NVMe Gen 4 SSDs and room for an additional drive.

In gaming performance, the Asus TUF F15 outperforms the Nitro 5 by a small margin (4-7% better frame rates).

Asus TUF F15 comes with a better screen for gaming and work, although it’s not ideal for creative tasks like video editing.

Acer Nitro 5’s display is less vibrant and accurate, but still suitable for gaming and basic tasks.

The cooling systems in both laptops are problematic under heavy loads, with the Asus benefiting from lifting the back for better airflow.

Acer Nitro 5 requires additional cooling solutions, like a cooling pad, to prevent overheating during intense usage.

Both laptops have good battery life, lasting 5-6 hours during mixed usage and up to 7.5 hours during video streaming.

Both devices lack biometric features like fingerprint scanners or IR webcams.

The build quality of the Asus TUF F15 is considered slightly better, making it more durable for daily travel.

Asus TUF F15 is recommended for a wider range of tasks, especially creative work, while Acer Nitro 5 is ideal for budget-conscious gamers.

Transcripts

so this year both companies Acer and

Asus did a fantastic job designing their

products and they made it particularly

difficult to choose the best option

between their absolute winners mid-range

gaming laptops in this video I will do

everything that's in my power to make it

easier for you

this time I won't be listing all their

respects only the facts and differences

that actually matter

also don't expect me to praise them too

much because even though they're the

best they still have their flows

first they come with the same CPU inside

it's the newest 12th gen 14 core chip

from Intel which is extremely powerful

and power efficient it uses different

types of cores which are called

performance cores and efficient cores

and the laptop switches between them

depending on the task it's a very smart

move until pulls off in their new

processor lineup makes living much

easier by correctly Distributing power

and saving battery resources next they

both come with Nvidia rtex 3060 rocking

6 gigs of vram on board but there is a

little difference between them the TUF

at 15 packs a 140 Watts total Graphics

power configuration of this GPU and

Nitro 5 is rocking slightly less

powerful version which is 130 Watts tgp

it doesn't make a major difference

neither in performance level nor in

temperatures and reloads but I think

it's one of the main reasons why the

Asus laptop is a bit more expensive

anyway this combo of CPU and GPU is

great and I don't think they're a better

pieces of Hardware to install in these

machines for the month later on we'll

also discuss how it performs in games

and here comes the first major

difference Asus duf gaming F15 comes

with the newest ddr5 type of Random

Access Memory working at 4 800 megahertz

when Acer Nitro 5 is only limited to

ddr4 3200 megahertz frequency type of

memory and these are not interchangeable

meaning if a laptop comes with a ddr4

type Ram right out of the box you cannot

upgrade it to ddr5 type of ram because

they have different pin layouts both

machines pack 16 gigs RAM and I think it

is enough for 95 of the tasks you could

possibly do with the laptop but when you

put them face to face when you do

something heavy like compiling codes

rendering 3D objects editing movies and

even gaming Asus actually feels more

responsive and fast

also yeah they both have two Ram slots

inside and it's operable up to 32 gigs

total talking about storage both laptops

fits are 512 gigabytes capacity pcie and

vme four generation drives and with such

fast units all operations involving

ingredient writing information files

that are performed rapidly fast also

each of the laptops provide a sweet

opportunity to easily upgrade storage by

installing another drive into the second

untaken slot painless upgrade is always

a great bonus

alright so we'll finish with the

hardware so now it's time to discuss

performance in games all titles were

tested by me personally and 1080p

resolution with the graphics settings

set to high preset not Ultra and

prankless picking I wouldn't call this

four to seven percent difference in

frame rate significant in some games you

could actually switch it to ultra

settings plus they both feature a Max

switch which allows to completely

eliminate the integrated into Graphics

boosts up the FPS by approximately seven

percent but makes the battery drain

faster

pretty cool feature if you know what

you're doing

and of course both laptops support VR

and are capable of live streaming games

at medium to high graphics

now one of the biggest difference is

these machines have is the screen and

it's always a painful aspect for me

because most cheap and mid-range laptops

they always feature this garbage screens

that I cannot even look at when a screen

of Asus TUF at 15 pretty much meets my

standard requirements 80905 panel has

almost made my eyes leak out it is not

bright and not color accurate enough for

my purposes but at least it has better

than average response time and high

refresh rate so I'd say it's suitable

for gaming

gaming and work with documents maybe

definitely a bad suit for Creative work

so yeah if you prefer better screens

that are actually Pleasant to look at

and those that you can use for making

different sorts of designs and in videos

and photos and so on maybe making some

extra money with that or something Asus

is an absolute winner here or maybe just

get a nice and vibrant external monitor

along with nitro5 or such projects it's

up to you

the next thing you need to know about is

the difference in cooling systems and

temperatures this laptops work at Under

loads while testing them in standard

mode both machines performed well

without succeeding permissible

temperatures however running tests and

playing games and performance mode they

both overheat and throttle due to

different reasons the problem with Asus

duf at 15 is that its feet are too small

and they don't create much of a space

underneath the laptop for nice airflow

when it's sitting on a desk

yes it has very low profile it's

minimalistic and it looks cool but when

you're into something heavy and unit at

top of the notch performance level

forget about its minimalism and bump up

the back of the laptop by an inch or two

it'll make a huge difference and with

this simple trick internal temperatures

will drop by as much as 10 degrees on

both turbo and performance modes

unfortunately with Acer Nitro 5 it's not

that easy the only ways to keep this

laptop away from troll land in

performance mode is to use a cooling pad

or undervolt the GPU and the latter one

doesn't make any sense at all to be

honest because if you're gonna do it

cutting the maximum power of this level

you shouldn't buy it in first place and

maybe look for a weaker laptop because

it's like keeping Abyss in a cage

both laptops are pretty loud under loads

but quiet on idle and performance simple

tasks once again all thanks to that

smart power distribution and switching

to efficiency CPU cores when needed also

just a little tip Asus TUF app 15 has

slightly better build quality I think

it's more durable and a better suit for

throwing into your bag as a student for

example

all other differences this laptops have

I wouldn't call them game changing they

are rather subjective for example I

really like the keyboard of TUF at 15 as

well as its overall design

it's not something that important it's

just some personal both laptops have

average speakers nothing special they

lack Biometrics like an IR webcam or a

fingerprint scanner and their touchpads

are pretty accurate also they have about

the same levels of battery life about

five to six hours in a mixed usage and

up to seven and a half hours watching

Netflix at medium brightness which is an

incredibly impressive result for laptops

of this class now the moral of this

story well let me put it like this I

feel like Asus TUF gaming F15 is a more

versatile laptop overall it's suitable

for a wider range of tasks plus as to me

it was a much more pleasant experience

spending time with it all thanks to

better screen and ergonomics however if

I wasn't making these videos for YouTube

and you know involved in the oldest

creative work I think I wouldn't care

that much about the screen and Acer

Nitro 5 screen is just fine for gaming

watching something and dealing with

personal things and although it does rig

our GPU and not the later generation Ram

it handles all tasks as good as Aces

once again as long as it is not involve

creative work so yeah don't overthink

although it's a little bit more

affordable it's still very good

also worth mentioning if you're getting

a laptop for a gaming only and maybe

building a full-size gaming setup is the

laptop in its heart definitely do not

overpay for TUF F50 Nitro 5 will do the

job as good links are the best deals on

both laptops are in the description box

down below they are updated every hour

and if there are any new discounts from

reliable sellers I will update the link

and you won't miss this discount so

maybe add this video to watch later

playlist so you won't lose it

also make sure to drop a like below the

video it'll help me out a lot Maybe

YouTube will recommend this video to

more people follow for more useful

content and if you need any help

choosing a laptop for yourself ask your

questions in the comment section down

below

peace out