"Nothing You See is Real" | Donald Hoffman

Be Inspired
19 Apr 202108:01

Summary

TLDRThis video script explores the concept that our perception of reality, including space and time, is merely a visualization tool, not the ultimate reality. It compares our experience to playing a VR game like Grand Theft Auto, where we only perceive what we 'render' in our minds. The script suggests that consciousness is exploring endless possibilities beyond our three-dimensional understanding, and our current experiences are just a small part of the vast potential. It challenges us to consider how consciousness projects into our space-time reality and encourages us to use our limited imagination to speculate about the unfathomable beyond our 'headset' of perception.

Takeaways

  • 🌌 **Space-Time as a Visualization Tool**: The speaker suggests that space and time are not the ultimate reality but rather tools we use to visualize and interact with the world.
  • 🎮 **VR Analogy**: Our perception of reality is compared to a VR game, where we are so immersed that we mistake the game for reality.
  • 🧠 **Consciousness Beyond Physicality**: Consciousness is not tied to physical objects like the brain; it is an experience that is rendered when we 'look' at it.
  • 🚗 **Selective Rendering**: Just as we only see objects in a VR game when we 'render' them, our brains only perceive certain aspects of reality when we focus on them.
  • 🤔 **Exploration of Consciousness**: Humans explore various aspects of consciousness through art, science, and other activities, each contributing to the broader exploration of consciousness.
  • 🌐 **The Illusion of Space-Time**: The speaker posits that our lives are within a space-time simulator, and our experiences are projections from a deeper, non-physical reality.
  • 🔮 **Limitations of Human Perception**: We are limited to perceiving three dimensions and a limited spectrum of colors, which is a tiny fraction of what consciousness might experience.
  • 🧘 **Meditation and the Unknown**: The process of meditation can be both healing and terrifying as it involves letting go of known concepts and facing the unknown.
  • 🔄 **Dynamics of Consciousness**: Consciousness is in a constant state of exploration and evolution, always moving beyond current understanding.
  • 🔍 **Backward Projection**: The speaker suggests that by understanding our experiences within the 'headset' of space-time, we might infer something about the nature of consciousness beyond it.

Q & A

  • What is the main analogy used in the script to describe our perception of reality?

    -The main analogy used is comparing our perception of reality to a VR (Virtual Reality) headset, suggesting that our understanding of space and time is just a visualization tool and not the ultimate reality.

  • Why does the script mention 'grand theft auto'?

    -The script uses 'grand theft auto' as an example to illustrate how people can become so immersed in a virtual world that they forget about the reality outside of it, similar to how we might be overlooking the true nature of reality beyond our perception.

  • What is the significance of the statement 'my brain doesn't even exist unless I render it'?

    -This statement emphasizes the idea that the physical brain is only a part of our experience when we consciously perceive it, suggesting that consciousness and perception play a crucial role in defining our reality.

  • How does the script describe the relationship between physical objects and consciousness?

    -The script describes physical objects as part of our visualization tool, existing in space and time only when we render or perceive them, while consciousness is the underlying reality that is not limited to these constructs.

  • What is meant by 'garbage collecting' in the context of the script?

    -In the context of the script, 'garbage collecting' refers to the process of the mind discarding or ignoring certain perceptions or thoughts when they are no longer needed or relevant to our current experience.

  • Why does the script suggest that we are in a 'simulator'?

    -The script suggests that we are in a 'simulator' to convey the idea that our experiences within space and time might be a limited projection of a deeper, more complex reality that we are not fully aware of.

  • What role do desires play in the exploration of consciousness according to the script?

    -Desires, such as the love for music or art, are portrayed as intrinsic drivers that propel consciousness to explore and experience various aspects of reality, contributing to the overall exploration of consciousness.

  • How does the script differentiate between actions in the 'headset' and actions in 'ultimate reality'?

    -The script differentiates by suggesting that actions within the 'headset' (our perceived reality) are simple and understandable within that context, while actions in 'ultimate reality' might involve complex processes that we cannot comprehend, like toggling voltages in a supercomputer.

  • What is the challenge the script poses regarding the exploration of consciousness?

    -The challenge is to understand how consciousness, which is exploring endless possibilities, can be mathematically projected into the limited framework of space and time, and how we can use our understanding within this framework to speculate about the nature of consciousness beyond it.

  • Why does the script mention the limitations of human imagination?

    -The script mentions the limitations of human imagination to highlight our inability to fully comprehend the vastness and complexity of consciousness and its exploration of reality, encouraging us to seek tools and theories to expand our understanding.

Outlines

00:00

🌌 The Illusion of Space-Time

The speaker begins by challenging the conventional understanding of space and time as fundamental realities, suggesting instead that they are merely tools for visualization. They liken our perception of reality to a virtual reality (VR) headset, which provides a limited and distorted view of the true nature of existence. The speaker emphasizes that what we perceive directly, such as our physical bodies and the world around us, is just a rendering of a deeper, more complex reality that we cannot directly observe. They argue that consciousness itself is not bound by physical objects or the constructs of space and time, and that our experiences, such as emotions and aspirations, are part of a 'VR experience' that is not physically observable. The analogy of a video game player who is unaware of the underlying computer processes that enable their in-game actions is used to illustrate how our actions within the space-time framework are just a small part of a much larger, more intricate process that we cannot fully comprehend.

05:00

🔮 Exploring the Depths of Consciousness

In the second paragraph, the speaker delves into the concept of consciousness as an ongoing exploration that transcends our limited perception of reality. They suggest that consciousness is not confined to the physical world but is part of a larger, possibly infinite, network of experiences and possibilities. The speaker acknowledges the fear and challenge of venturing into the unknown, which involves letting go of familiar concepts and embracing the unknown. They propose that there is a projection of consciousness into our space-time reality, which we can attempt to understand by reflecting on our experiences within the 'headset' of our perceptions. The speaker expresses a desire to expand their understanding beyond the limitations of their imagination, using tools and theories to speculate about the nature of reality beyond the constraints of our three-dimensional perception. They conclude by emphasizing the importance of exploring these deeper theories to gain insight into the true nature of consciousness and its place in the universe.

Mindmap

Keywords

💡Space-time

Space-time is a concept in physics that combines the three dimensions of space with the one dimension of time into a single four-dimensional continuum. In the video, space-time is described as a visualization tool, akin to a VR headset, that we use to perceive reality. The speaker suggests that the true nature of reality we interact with is not like space-time, implying that our perception of it is limited and may not fully represent the underlying reality.

💡Visualization tool

A visualization tool is a means or method used to represent or interpret complex data or concepts in a more understandable format, often graphically. The video script uses the analogy of VR (virtual reality) to describe space-time as a visualization tool that we use to perceive reality. It suggests that our perception of reality is mediated through this tool, much like how a VR headset creates a virtual world for us to experience.

💡Consciousness

Consciousness in the video is discussed as an entity that is exploring and experiencing reality beyond the limitations of space-time. It is portrayed as something that is not confined to physical objects like the brain but is instead a broader, more complex phenomenon that is exploring various forms of expression through individuals, such as art, music, and science.

💡Grand Theft Auto

Grand Theft Auto is a video game series used in the script as a metaphor for how our perception of reality might be limited to the 'game' of space-time, similar to how someone playing the game might lose track of the real world. The speaker suggests that we might be making a 'rookie mistake' by assuming that our perception of reality, much like the game, is the ultimate reality.

💡Rendering

Rendering in the context of the video refers to the process of creating an image or scene from a model by means of computer programs. It is used metaphorically to describe how we perceive reality—only seeing or 'rendering' aspects of it when we focus on them, similar to how a video game only renders details when they are in the player's view.

💡Simulator

The term 'simulator' is used to describe the idea that our existence within space-time might be akin to being inside a simulated environment. The speaker suggests that we are in a 'space-time simulator,' and our experiences are part of a larger, more complex reality that we cannot fully perceive.

💡Garbage collection

Garbage collection is a term from computer science referring to the process of automatically detecting and disposing of objects that are no longer in use. In the video, it is used metaphorically to describe how we might 'delete' or disregard aspects of reality that we are not currently perceiving or interacting with.

💡Evolutionary theory

Evolutionary theory is a key concept in biology that explains the diversity and adaptation of life through natural selection and genetic variation. In the video, the speaker mentions that evolutionary theory is a 'headset theory,' meaning it is a framework for understanding change and development within the space-time context, but it does not explain the nature of consciousness beyond space-time.

💡Meditation

Meditation is a practice where an individual uses a technique, such as focusing their mind on a particular object, thought, or activity, to achieve mental clarity and emotional calmness. The video discusses meditation as a way to explore consciousness beyond the confines of conventional thought and experience, suggesting it as a method to access deeper levels of reality.

💡Dimensions

Dimensions in the video refer to the spatial and temporal aspects of reality. The speaker talks about our limitations in perceiving beyond three dimensions and the difficulty in imagining higher dimensions, which is used to illustrate the limitations of our current understanding and the potential for consciousness to explore beyond these constraints.

💡Projection

Projection in the context of the video is used to describe the idea that our experiences and consciousness are projected into the space-time reality we perceive. The speaker suggests that there is a projection from the realm of consciousness into the space-time we interact with, and by understanding this projection, we might gain insights into the nature of consciousness beyond our current perceptions.

Highlights

Space and time are visualization tools, not the ultimate reality we're interacting with.

Our perception of reality is limited by our 'headset', which is like a VR system.

Physical objects, including our bodies, are not conscious; consciousness is a separate phenomenon.

Consciousness is like a kid in a candy store, exploring endless possibilities.

Our current understanding is limited to three dimensions and a small range of colors.

Consciousness is exploring all possibilities, beyond what we can imagine.

Evolutionary theory is a 'headset' theory, not applicable to consciousness beyond space and time.

The challenge of understanding consciousness involves letting go of our known concepts.

Meditation can be both healing and terrifying as it involves letting go of thoughts and entering the void.

Consciousness projects into space-time, and we interact with projections of others' experiences.

Our current experiences are trivial compared to the vast possibilities of consciousness.

The exploration of consciousness is ongoing and constantly going beyond what it knows.

The process of understanding consciousness involves stepping outside of our limited 'headset'.

The speaker acknowledges their own limitations in imagination and seeks tools to help expand their understanding.

The ultimate reality might involve trillions of voltage togglings, far beyond our simple understanding of cause and effect.

Our current theories are fallible, but they can help us open our minds to deeper theories of reality.

Transcripts

play00:00

[Music]

play00:00

space time

play00:03

the sun and the moon physical objects

play00:05

everything that we see inside of space

play00:07

and time

play00:08

is just our visualization tool the

play00:10

reality we're interacting with is

play00:12

nothing like the visualization tool

play00:14

there's nothing like space and time

play00:16

[Music]

play00:20

we've made the rookie mistake of

play00:22

assuming that our headset

play00:24

vr our visualization tool

play00:27

is the final reality it's just a rookie

play00:29

mistake it's like someone who's played

play00:30

grand theft auto so long

play00:32

they have no idea there's a reality

play00:33

besides grand theft auto we're like that

play00:35

right now

play00:42

if you just look at your face in the

play00:43

mirror

play00:45

if you look what you see directly

play00:48

is just skin hair and eyes that's all

play00:51

that's all you see

play00:52

and if you looked inside if someone

play00:54

opened your skull up and

play00:55

you just see neurons and and so forth

play00:58

but what you know firsthand that you

play01:00

cannot see

play01:01

is your hopes your dreams your

play01:04

aspirations your love of music your

play01:05

your mood it's all in vr experience

play01:09

no physical object including my body

play01:12

is conscious strictly speaking

play01:16

my brain isn't conscious because my

play01:17

brain

play01:19

in fact doesn't even exist unless i

play01:21

render it right so if you're playing

play01:23

grand theft auto i'm playing a vr

play01:25

version of i got

play01:26

the steering wheel in front of me i'm

play01:27

holding the steering wheel if i look to

play01:28

the side

play01:29

i no longer render the steering wheel

play01:31

and there is no steering wheel

play01:33

when i look here i render it and now

play01:34

there is a steering wheel the same thing

play01:37

is true strictly speaking of neurons and

play01:39

brains

play01:40

they're there when you render them

play01:41

they're not there when you don't it's a

play01:43

vr

play01:44

system that you render objects in space

play01:46

and time

play01:47

as you need them because they're part of

play01:49

your visualization tool and then you

play01:51

garbage collect them you delete them

play01:52

when you don't need them

play01:53

your life in my life right now is we're

play01:55

in a simulator a space-time simulator

play01:57

and we've been given like an ai system

play01:59

we've been given

play02:00

certain intrinsic desires so my wife is

play02:04

an artist

play02:05

so there's billions of humans and there

play02:07

are billions of different ways that we

play02:09

explore in music

play02:10

in art and literature in science various

play02:13

kinds of science

play02:14

meditation so we're it's sports there

play02:17

are all sorts of ways that consciousness

play02:19

is exploring through us and there is not

play02:22

like one is the best

play02:24

i don't know what we're doing outside of

play02:25

space and time that's part of what i

play02:26

want to understand is what are we

play02:28

actually doing

play02:29

we don't see i don't know what i'm

play02:31

actually doing i know what i'm doing

play02:33

under

play02:33

a description like i'm moving my hand

play02:36

right now and if i grab a steering wheel

play02:37

in my car

play02:38

i know what i'm doing under a space-time

play02:41

description but i don't know

play02:43

in ultimate reality what i'm really

play02:45

doing it's just like

play02:47

the vr player when they turn the

play02:48

steering wheel in grand theft

play02:50

auto they know what they're doing in the

play02:52

language of the game i'm turning a

play02:54

steering wheel

play02:55

but what they're really doing in terms

play02:57

of the super computer right which in

play02:59

that metaphor would be the deeper

play03:00

reality

play03:01

they're toggling voltages and magnetic

play03:03

fields and circuits

play03:04

that they have no idea there's there's

play03:06

probably trillions of voltage togglings

play03:08

going on

play03:09

for one turn of the wheel all they see

play03:11

is a turn of the wheel

play03:13

that's their notion of cause and effect

play03:16

trivial

play03:16

the real cause and effect is trillions

play03:19

of voltages getting toggled

play03:21

in fractions of a second it's much much

play03:23

more complicated

play03:25

so when i talk evolution i'm

play03:28

only going to be talking about assuming

play03:30

the headset

play03:31

now i'm within the framework of the

play03:33

headset because evolutionary theory

play03:35

is only a headset theory it's not a

play03:37

theory of consciousness beyond space and

play03:40

time

play03:40

consciousness is like a kid in a candy

play03:43

store

play03:44

it's a never-ending exploration that

play03:47

is in principle never-ending

play03:50

we call tom and don are just parts

play03:54

of this overall exploration

play03:57

of of consciousness and all of its

play03:59

possibilities

play04:00

our little bit that we're exploring

play04:02

right now as rich as it seems to us

play04:05

is trivial compared to all the

play04:07

possibilities that girdle says

play04:09

are out there i can imagine a square

play04:14

i can imagine a cube now go up one more

play04:17

dimension

play04:18

imagine a cube in four dimensions my

play04:21

brain

play04:21

halts and my mind catches on fire

play04:24

nothing happens

play04:25

that's only four dimensions i can't even

play04:26

go to four dimensions i mean how

play04:29

that that's terrible is it's just an

play04:31

incredible limitation

play04:32

i can only see three dimensions of color

play04:35

red green dimension blue yellow and so

play04:37

forth

play04:38

there are some pigeons that have four

play04:40

color receptors presumably they're in an

play04:42

extra dimension of color

play04:43

that i can't even imagine what it's like

play04:45

can you imagine a specific color you've

play04:47

never seen before

play04:48

as rich as our world seem we know that

play04:51

there's

play04:52

a rich possibility of conscious

play04:54

experiences that we can't even

play04:56

concretely imagine but consciousness

play04:58

itself

play05:00

on this theory is exploring all these

play05:02

possibilities

play05:04

and right now we're sort of stuck on

play05:05

this little headset

play05:07

three dimensions small amount of color

play05:09

that we can see and so forth

play05:12

we thought it was the whole world no

play05:13

it's just it's a little headset

play05:16

it's a it's a prism my imagination is

play05:18

stuck in only three dimensions my colors

play05:20

are stuck in a

play05:20

certain range now here's the challenge

play05:23

suppose we

play05:24

chase that down so we say okay there's

play05:26

going to be this

play05:27

ongoing dynamics of consciousness

play05:30

constantly

play05:32

going beyond what it knows but there's

play05:35

going to be a

play05:37

dark side to it because going into the

play05:39

unknown means

play05:40

letting go of what you know and that can

play05:42

be terrifying

play05:43

where literally you don't have concepts

play05:46

all of your current concepts

play05:48

are inadequate for those who meditate i

play05:50

mean when you go into

play05:52

silence it's both healing and terrifying

play05:55

right if you really let go of all

play05:58

thoughts

play05:59

you and go into the void it's it's sort

play06:02

of it can be scary like

play06:04

you want to go back into you grab back

play06:05

on your it's a life jacket

play06:07

right you grab on to your teddy bear

play06:09

your thoughts

play06:10

how would consciousness precisely this

play06:14

this vast social network project

play06:16

mathematically into space time

play06:18

clearly there's a projection i'm

play06:20

interacting with tom's consciousness

play06:23

i'm not seeing that consciousness i'm

play06:24

seeing skin hair and eyes

play06:26

i'm seeing a space-time projection i'm

play06:27

not actually seeing your emotions i'm

play06:29

not seeing your mood

play06:31

but i am genuinely interacting

play06:34

with your experiences it's a genuine

play06:36

interaction

play06:37

and so there is a projection from this

play06:39

conscious realm

play06:41

into space time we can take what we

play06:44

understand in the headset

play06:45

and pull it backwards if we can project

play06:49

from consciousness to the headset

play06:50

then we can try at least to go from the

play06:52

headset and pull backwards

play06:54

it's a fallible enterprise but it may

play06:57

help us to open our minds

play07:02

to the possibilities for deeper theories

play07:04

of what's going on outside the headset

play07:06

so so the reason i'm doing this is

play07:08

because i

play07:10

i can't even imagine a specific color

play07:12

that i've never seen before i can't

play07:14

imagine in four dimensions

play07:15

in other words i take it as a given that

play07:18

i'm

play07:19

deeply deeply limited in my imagination

play07:23

and i need all the tools i can get to

play07:26

help me step outside of my headset and

play07:30

try to guess the unfathomable

play07:33

outside of there

play07:56

so

play08:00

you

Rate This

5.0 / 5 (0 votes)

Связанные теги
Space-TimeConsciousnessRealityVR MetaphorPhilosophyExistentialMind ExplorationCognitive LimitsEvolutionMetaphysics
Вам нужно краткое изложение на английском?