ALICE ROBERTS & MICHAEL TOMASELLO - What Makes Us Human?

Summary

This script explores the complexity of intelligence beyond a linear scale, highlighting unique cognitive abilities in animals like squirrels and birds for memorization, and apes for understanding physical causality. It emphasizes the distinctiveness of human intelligence through our capacity for collaborative communication, which is integral to cultural development. Without social interaction and cultural engagement, human intelligence would remain underdeveloped, akin to that of apes, illustrating the innate expectation of culture in humans, much like fish expect water.

Takeaways

• 🧠 Intelligence in animals is not a linear scale but a complex array of different abilities.
• 🐿 Squirrels and birds excel in memory, particularly in recalling the locations where they hide their nuts.
• 🦍 Apes are adept at understanding physical space and causality, similar to human children.
• 🤝 Humans stand out due to our collaborative nature, combining efforts to achieve more than we could individually.
• 🗣️ Communication is pivotal for human intelligence, enabling us to work together and create new resources.
• 🏝️ Isolated human development, without social interaction, results in intelligence akin to that of apes.
• 🧒 Human beings are predisposed to learn from, communicate with, and collaborate with others, which is crucial for our intelligence.
• 🦈 Just as fish are born expecting water, humans are born expecting culture, which is integral to our identity.
• 🤝 Cooperation is a cornerstone of human culture and a key factor in our success as a species.
• 🌐 At the core of being human lies our culture, which is intertwined with our ability to cooperate effectively.

Q & A

What misconception about animal intelligence does Michael Tomasello suggest we should discard?

Michael Tomasello suggests we should discard the idea of a ladder of intelligence that goes from low to high, implying that animals can simply be ranked on it. Instead, he emphasizes that different animals have different types of intelligence.

Which animals are considered the best memorizers according to the transcript?

The transcript mentions squirrels and birds that hide their nuts in various locations as the best memorizers, as they can remember dozens of locations, more than humans can.

What cognitive abilities do apes possess that are similar to human children?

Apes are particularly good at understanding the physical world, especially in terms of spatial awareness and causal relations, such as when using tools and understanding what causes movement.

What distinguishes human intelligence from that of other species, according to the transcript?

Human intelligence is distinguished by our ability to collaborate and communicate effectively, creating new resources and achieving things that neither individual could do alone.

What would be the intelligence level of a child raised in isolation without social contact?

The intelligence of a child raised in isolation would be very similar to that of other apes, as they would not have developed the natural human intelligence that comes from learning from, communicating with, and collaborating with others.

How does Alice Roberts describe the relationship between human culture and our ability to cooperate?

Alice Roberts states that at the heart of being human is our culture, and it goes hand in hand with our ability to cooperate, suggesting that culture and cooperation are intrinsically linked.

What does the transcript suggest about the innate expectations of fish and humans regarding their environments?

The transcript suggests that fish are born expecting water, equipped with fins and gills, while humans are born expecting culture, indicating that humans are naturally inclined to engage with and learn from their cultural environment.

What role does communication play in the development of human intelligence, as discussed in the transcript?

Communication plays a crucial role in the development of human intelligence, as it enables collaboration and the creation of new resources, which are essential for the advancement of our cognitive abilities.

How does the transcript define intelligence in the context of different species?

The transcript defines intelligence as a complex and varied set of cognitive abilities that are specific to different species, rather than a single, universal scale of intelligence.

What is the significance of the physical world understanding for apes, as mentioned in the transcript?

The understanding of the physical world, including space and causal relations, is significant for apes as it allows them to use tools effectively and navigate their environment, which is a key aspect of their intelligence.

How does the transcript relate the development of human intelligence to cultural and social factors?

The transcript relates the development of human intelligence to cultural and social factors by highlighting that without social contact, teaching, culture, tools, and language, the natural human intelligence would not develop, emphasizing the importance of these factors in shaping our cognitive abilities.

Outlines

00:00

🧠 Redefining Intelligence

The script begins with a discussion on the concept of intelligence, challenging the notion of a linear hierarchy. It emphasizes that intelligence is multifaceted and varies among species. Alice Roberts and Michael Tomasello highlight the unique abilities of animals like squirrels and birds in memorization, and apes in understanding physical space and causality. The human advantage is not in individual cognitive abilities but in our collaborative nature, which allows us to create and innovate collectively. Tomasello stresses the importance of social interaction for the development of human intelligence, suggesting that without it, our cognitive abilities would be akin to those of other apes. The segment underscores the role of culture in shaping our intelligence and the innate human expectation of a cultural environment.

Keywords

💡Intelligence

Intelligence refers to the capacity for learning, reasoning, understanding, and applying knowledge. In the video, it is discussed in the context of different species, emphasizing that intelligence is not a linear scale but a complex set of abilities that vary among animals. For example, squirrels and birds are highlighted as excellent memorizers, which challenges the notion of a single 'ladder of intelligence'.

💡Ladder of Intelligence

The 'ladder of intelligence' is a concept that suggests a hierarchy or ranking of cognitive abilities from lower to higher forms. Michael Tomasello argues against this idea in the script, stating that intelligence is not a simple progression but a diverse set of skills unique to each species, which is crucial for understanding the complexity of cognitive abilities in the animal kingdom.

💡Memorization

Memorization is the process of remembering and recalling information. The video script points out that squirrels and birds, which hide nuts in various locations, have exceptional memorization skills, remembering dozens of locations better than humans can, illustrating the specialized intelligence of these animals in this particular cognitive task.

💡Apes

Apes are a group of primates known for their advanced cognitive abilities. In the script, it is mentioned that apes are particularly adept at understanding the physical world, including spatial relationships and causality, such as when using tools. This ability is likened to that of human children, highlighting the closeness in cognitive development between apes and humans in certain areas.

💡Causal Relations

Causal relations refer to the connections between events where one event (the cause) brings about another event (the effect). The script discusses how apes excel at understanding these relations, especially in the context of tool use, which is a significant aspect of their intelligence and a key to their survival and adaptation.

💡Collaboration

Collaboration is the process of working together to achieve a common goal. The video emphasizes that what sets humans apart is not individual intelligence but the ability to collaborate and communicate effectively with others. This collective intelligence allows for the creation of new resources and solutions that would be impossible for individuals to develop alone.

💡Communication

Communication is the act of conveying meaning from one entity to another through signs, signals, or behavior. In the script, it is identified as a fundamental aspect of human intelligence, enabling us to share knowledge, ideas, and work together, which is essential for the development of culture and societal progress.

💡Culture

Culture encompasses the beliefs, customs, arts, and way of life of a particular group or society. Alice Roberts in the script states that being human is intrinsically linked to culture, which is a product of our ability to cooperate and share knowledge, making it a central theme of what defines our species.

💡Isolation

Isolation refers to the state of being separated from others. The script uses the hypothetical example of a child raised in isolation on a desert island to illustrate the importance of social contact for the development of human intelligence, emphasizing that without interaction and cultural influence, our cognitive abilities would be significantly limited.

💡Evolution

Evolution is the process by which species change over time through genetic variation and natural selection. The script suggests that humans have evolved to learn from, communicate with, and collaborate with others, which is a key factor in the development of our unique intelligence and cultural capabilities.

💡Natural Intelligence

Natural intelligence refers to the innate cognitive abilities that an organism possesses. The script points out that without the influence of culture, tools, and language, a human raised in isolation would have a natural intelligence similar to that of other apes, indicating that our intelligence is not solely a product of our biology but also of our environment and social interactions.

Highlights

We often consider ourselves the most intelligent species, but the definition of intelligence requires careful consideration.

The traditional 'ladder of intelligence' from low to high is an oversimplification; different animals possess unique forms of intelligence.

Squirrels and birds excel in memory, remembering numerous nut hiding locations better than humans.

Apes demonstrate a keen understanding of the physical world, particularly in spatial awareness and causal relationships.

Apes' intelligence in tool use and understanding of cause and effect is comparable to that of human children.

What truly distinguishes humans is our collaborative abilities, creating and achieving more together than we could individually.

Communication and collaboration are at the core of human intelligence, enabling us to create new resources collectively.

Isolated human development, devoid of social interaction, results in intelligence akin to that of apes, highlighting the importance of cultural influence.

Humans, unlike other animals, are born with an innate expectation of culture, which plays a crucial role in our intelligence and development.

Human intelligence is not solely innate but is significantly shaped by our ability to learn from, communicate with, and collaborate with others.

The absence of culture, tools, and language in an isolated upbringing would stunt the development of natural human intelligence.

Fish are born expecting water, showcasing the idea that different species have evolved to expect and interact with their environments in specific ways.

Being human is intrinsically linked to our culture, which is a fundamental aspect of our species' identity and development.

Cooperation is a key element of human culture, enabling us to achieve more through collective effort.

The transcript emphasizes that intelligence in animals, including humans, is multifaceted and cannot be reduced to a simple hierarchical scale.

The development of human intelligence is intertwined with our social nature and the cultural tools and language available to us.

The transcript suggests that intelligence is a product of both biological evolution and cultural development.

Transcripts

(Alice Roberts) We like to think that we are the most intelligent species on the planet,

but we have to be careful what exactly we mean by intelligence.

(Michael Tomasello) The first thing we have to get rid of when we think of animal intelligence

is the idea that there is a ladder of intelligence that goes from low to high, and animals can just be placed on it.

It is actually much more complicated than that. Different animals have different intelligence's.

The best memorizers in the world are squirrels and birds that hide there nuts in different locations

and can remember dozens and dozens of locations, more than we can.

In the case of apes, what we think they are specially good at cognizing things about the physical world.

At understanding space, and causal relations. Like when using tools, what causes something to move, ...

They are very good at that and not that different than human children in that kind of understanding.

What makes us really different is our ability to put our heads together

and to do things that neither of us could do alone.

To create new resources that neither of us could create alone.

It is really all about communicating, and collaborating and working together.

If you raise a child on a desert island with no social contact, so no teaching, any contact with humans…

their intelligence as an adult would be very similar to that of other apes. It'll be a little bit different,

but they've evolved to learn from others, to communicate with others, to collaborate with others,

and if there was no one there, and no culture, and no tools and no language,

then that natural human intelligence then wouldn't develop.

Fish a born expecting water. They've got fins, they've got guilds, they are born expecting water,

and humans are born expecting culture.

(Alice Roberts) At the heart of being human is our culture.

And something that goes hand in hand with human culture is our ability to cooperate.

Subtitles by the Amara.org community