The Difference Between Protestant and Orthodox Views | Jonathan Pageau

Summary

Stephen Wong's transcript delves into the contrasting views on salvation between Protestants and Orthodox Christians. Protestants often emphasize the concept of substitutional atonement, where Christ's sacrifice absolves humanity of sin, leading to salvation through faith. In contrast, Orthodox Christianity sees salvation as a healing process, where Christ's presence in human nature combats the deathly effects of sin, with the ultimate goal being theosis—union with God and participation in divine life.

Takeaways

• 🔄 Protestants and Orthodox Christians have different views on salvation.
• 🌐 Many Protestants emphasize the concept of 'substitutional atonement', where Jesus' sacrifice is seen as a substitution for humanity's sin.
• 🍇 The idea of 'original sin' is central to the Protestant view, where Adam's sin affected all of humanity.
• 🔥 The Old Testament sacrificial system is seen as a precursor to Jesus' sacrifice in the Protestant perspective.
• 🙏 Salvation in Protestant belief is through faith in Jesus' sacrifice, which appeases God's wrath.
• 🌿 Orthodox Christians view salvation as a healing process rather than a legal transaction.
• 💉 The Orthodox perspective sees humanity as suffering from the consequences of sin, which is death and a tendency to sin.
• 🌟 Christ's role in Orthodox belief is to assume human nature and fill it with divine presence, offering healing.
• 🍞 Salvation involves participating in sacraments and living in communion and love, which are part of the healing process.
• 🛑 The Orthodox ultimate goal of salvation is theosis, the process of becoming united with God and participating in divine life.
• 🎓 The Orthodox do not see salvation as a declaration of righteousness but as a transformative journey towards unity with God.

Q & A

What is the central theme of the discussion in the transcript?

The central theme of the discussion is the difference between Protestant and Orthodox Christian views on the concept of salvation.

According to the transcript, what is the Protestant view on the concept of 'substitution' in salvation?

The Protestant view, as described in the transcript, is that of 'substitutional atonement' where Jesus took on the sins of humanity, acting as a substitute sacrifice, and belief in this sacrifice leads to salvation.

How does the transcript describe the Old Testament sacrificial system in relation to sin and salvation?

The Old Testament sacrificial system is described as a way to compensate for humanity's sin, offering things instead of oneself to God to avoid the deserved death due to sin.

What is the Orthodox Christian perspective on salvation as presented in the transcript?

The Orthodox Christian perspective on salvation is described as a healing process, where Christ's presence in human nature helps in overcoming the effects of sin and death, leading to a life of communion and love.

What is the concept of 'theosis' mentioned in the transcript, and how does it relate to the Orthodox view of salvation?

Theosis is the ultimate goal of salvation in the Orthodox view, which is the process of becoming united with God, participating in His divine life to the extent possible.

How does the transcript explain the impact of Adam's sin on humanity according to the Orthodox Christian view?

According to the Orthodox Christian view in the transcript, Adam's sin introduced death into the world, creating a state of being where the body is in danger and prone to sin due to various desires.

What role do the sacraments play in the Orthodox Christian view of salvation as per the transcript?

In the Orthodox Christian view, sacraments play a crucial role in the healing process of salvation, allowing individuals to participate in Christ's presence and thus heal from the effects of sin.

How does the transcript contrast the Protestant and Orthodox views on the role of faith in salvation?

The transcript contrasts the views by stating that while many Protestants believe in salvation by faith in the substitutionary sacrifice of Christ, Orthodox Christians see salvation as a healing process that involves participation in the sacraments and love for others.

What is the significance of participating in communion according to the Orthodox Christian view in the transcript?

Participating in communion is significant in the Orthodox Christian view as it is a means of healing and participating in the divine life of Christ, contributing to the process of salvation.

How does the transcript describe the process of overcoming sin and its effects in the Orthodox Christian view?

The transcript describes the process as one of healing from passions and desires through participation in the sacraments, love for others, and ultimately achieving theosis, or union with God.

Outlines

00:00

😇 Protestant and Orthodox Views on Salvation

Stephen Wong discusses the contrast between Protestant and Orthodox Christian perspectives on salvation. Protestantism often emphasizes the concept of 'substitutionary atonement,' where Jesus' sacrifice is seen as a substitution for humanity's sin, inherited from Adam. This view posits that belief in Jesus' sacrifice leads to salvation. In contrast, Orthodox Christianity views salvation as a healing process, where humanity, affected by Adam's sin, is in a state of 'death.' Christ's role is to restore humanity through sacraments and love, aiming for theosis—a union with God. Wong explains that Orthodox Christians believe in transformation through participation in Christ's divine nature, rather than a legalistic declaration of righteousness.

Keywords

💡Protestant

Protestants are a branch of Christianity that originated from the Reformation in the 16th century. They emphasize the authority of the Bible, salvation by faith alone, and the priesthood of all believers. In the script, 'Protestants' are mentioned in contrast to Orthodox Christians, highlighting their different views on salvation, particularly the concept of 'substitutional atonement'.

💡Orthodox Christian

Orthodox Christians belong to the Eastern Orthodox Church, which is one of the oldest Christian traditions. They are known for their rich liturgical practices and emphasis on the Holy Trinity, the sacraments, and theosis. The script discusses the Orthodox view of salvation as a healing process and the concept of theosis, which is central to their understanding of spiritual growth and union with God.

💡Salvation

Salvation, in a Christian context, refers to the deliverance from sin and its consequences, typically through faith in Jesus Christ. The script explores the different perspectives on salvation between Protestants and Orthodox Christians, with Protestants focusing on 'substitutional atonement' and Orthodox Christians viewing it as a healing process leading to theosis.

💡Substitutional Atonement

Substitutional atonement is the theological concept that Jesus Christ took on the sins of humanity and suffered in our place, allowing believers to be saved from the punishment for sin. The script explains this as a central belief among many Protestants, where salvation is achieved through faith in Christ's sacrificial death.

💡Original Sin

Original sin is the Christian doctrine that humanity inherits a tainted nature and a proclivity to sin as a result of Adam's disobedience in the Garden of Eden. The script mentions original sin in the context of how it 'infected humanity with sin' and necessitates the sacrificial system in the Old Testament.

💡Sacramental System

The sacramental system refers to the religious rites and ceremonies that are seen as channels of divine grace. In the script, it is mentioned as a way to compensate for the consequences of sin in the Old Testament, with Christ's sacrifice being the ultimate expression of this system in Christian belief.

💡Healing

In the context of the script, healing is not just physical but also spiritual, referring to the process of overcoming the effects of sin and death in our lives. Orthodox Christians view salvation as a form of healing, where Christ's presence in our lives helps us overcome the passions and desires that lead us away from God.

💡Theosis

Theosis, or deification, is the process of becoming more like God through participation in divine life. It is a central concept in Orthodox Christianity, as explained in the script, where the ultimate goal of salvation is to be united with God, participating in His life to the fullest extent possible.

💡Sacraments

Sacraments are sacred rites and ceremonies that are believed to have been instituted by Christ for the spiritual benefit of Christians. The script mentions sacraments as a means of participating in Christ's healing presence and contributing to the process of theosis in Orthodox Christianity.

💡Passions

Passions, in the script, refer to the intense emotions or desires that can lead individuals away from God's will, such as lust, greed, or the desire for self-preservation. The Orthodox view of salvation involves healing from these passions, which are seen as a form of slavery to the world.

Highlights

Difference between Protestant and Orthodox views on salvation.

Protestants focus on the concept of atonement by substitution.

Adam's sin as the origin of humanity's inherited sin.

Old Testament sacrificial system as compensation for sin.

God's anger directed at humanity, with Christ as the substitution sacrifice.

Salvation through faith in Christ's sacrificial atonement.

Orthodox view of salvation as a healing process.

Sin's introduction through Adam leading to a life of death.

Human bodies as susceptible to sin due to the inclination towards self-preservation.

Christ's role in assuming human nature and offering divine presence.

Participation in sacraments and communion as part of the healing process.

Love of others as essential to the healing from the life of death.

Salvation as overcoming worldly desires and passions.

Theosis as the ultimate goal of salvation in Orthodox Christianity.

Becoming united with God through participation in divine life.

Salvation is not just a declaration but a transformative process.

Applause and music indicating the end of the significant discussion.

Transcripts

all right so stephen wong says what is

the difference between protestants and

orthodox christians views on salvation i

mean that would be a very long

post and a very long answer i'm not sure

i could get through there but an easy

way for people to understand let's say a

little bit of the difference is that

let's say many products and not all

products but many protestants really

focus on the idea of a

substitution you know and an atonement

by substitution which is the idea that

that when adam sinned he kind of

infected humanity with sin

and that we deserve to die

uh and so the the sacrificial system in

the old testament was a way to

compensate for that was the way to offer

things instead of yourself because

you're supposed to die because you know

that god's anger was kind of

directed towards you to kill you and so

the idea is that god put all his anger

on christ and he is the substitution the

substitutional whatever uh sacrifice

and uh and that's how we are saved so if

we believe in that

then we are saved because we can enter

into that sacrifice

and uh so that's like

i'm like i said not all products believe

that but it's definitely a

a basic idea and that you're saved by

faith so you if you believe that if you

believe god believe that this sacrifice

is is true then then you are saved by it

and so

orthodox really don't see

salvation like that at all they see

salvation as a form of healing a form of

that that through the sin of adam death

entered into the world and so we live in

these bodies of death which

which are pulling us in different

directions you know because you your

body is in danger then you have a

propensity to sin because you can be

convinced that your desire to eat or you

desire for sex or your desire to protect

yourself is all-encompassing and so you

feel comfortable taking things from

others because you're doing it to

to protect yourself or to to bolster

your your your dead life let's say

and that christ came to

assume human nature fill it up with his

presence um and that participating in

that through the sacraments through

communion through love of each other is

a healing process for

our life of death let's say so that's

what salvation is salvation is actually

healing from these passions from these

desires from these the slavery that we

have uh

you know with things of the world and

that the ultimate version of that is not

just to be

declared holy you're declared saved or

you know going to heaven when you die

but is really to become god through

participation to be united fully

to god to participate in his life to the

extent that that's possible

and so that's the ultimate goal of

salvation is theosis it's to become

to be united with god

[Applause]

[Music]

you