Why Layne Norton Changed His Mind on Fasting and 4 Other Topics

Thomas DeLauer Podcast
9 Dec 202350:58

Summary

TLDRIn this informative discussion, Dr. Lane Norton shares his evolving perspectives on health and fitness topics over the past five to seven years. From reconsidering the benefits of branched-chain amino acids (BCAAs) for muscle synthesis to reevaluating the role of LDL cholesterol in heart disease, Norton candidly discusses his changed viewpoints. He also addresses the impact of fasting on muscle growth, the effectiveness of different types of cardio, and the nuances of training periodization. Sponsored by Element, Norton highlights the importance of electrolyte balance and the role of supplementation in his nutritional journey.

Takeaways

  • 🧠 Dr. Lane Norton has changed his stance on several topics over the years, showing his adaptability to new research and evidence.
  • 💊 Initially a proponent of BCAA supplementation, Norton now believes that for most people with adequate protein intake, BCAAs do not offer additional benefits in muscle protein synthesis.
  • 🥤 Sponsored by Element, Norton discusses the benefits of their electrolyte products, highlighting the importance of the right balance of sodium, potassium, and magnesium for hydration and muscle function.
  • 🍽 Norton emphasizes the importance of protein timing and quality, especially for those who fast, suggesting that essential amino acids can be beneficial post-fasting to reduce catabolism.
  • 🕊️ Discussing EAAs, Norton points out their utility for specific populations like plant-based dieters and fasters, enhancing meal quality and aiding in recovery from fasting.
  • 🚫 Norton has revised his opinion on fasting, acknowledging that it does not negatively impact muscle growth when combined with adequate protein and calorie intake.
  • 🏋️‍♂️ Norton's perspective on the timing of workouts relative to meals has evolved, suggesting that personal preference and comfort are as important as metabolic state for performance.
  • 🔄 He also addresses the LDL cholesterol debate, now convinced that lower LDL levels are associated with reduced heart disease risk, contrary to his previous views.
  • 🍳 Norton discusses the impact of diet on cholesterol levels, advocating for mindfulness in saturated fat consumption due to its influence on LDL levels.
  • 🏃‍♂️ The role of exercise in fat loss is also covered, with Norton noting that while exercise can increase hunger and calorie intake, it still contributes to a calorie deficit when not compensated for by overeating.

Q & A

  • What is the main topic of discussion in the video script?

    -The main topic of discussion in the video script is the changes in Dr. Lane Norton's perspectives on various health and fitness topics over the years, including branched-chain amino acids (BCAAs), fasting, LDL cholesterol, and exercise practices.

  • What is Dr. Lane Norton's current stance on BCAA supplementation?

    -Dr. Lane Norton now believes that BCAA supplementation may not be necessary for most people, especially when they are already consuming adequate protein. He used to advocate for BCAAs but has since changed his view based on more recent research findings.

  • What are the specific situations where Dr. Norton thinks EAAs or BCAAs might still be beneficial?

    -Dr. Norton suggests that EAAs or BCAAs might be beneficial for plant-based dieters who struggle to get enough essential amino acids or those who fast and want to prevent catabolism after an overnight fast, particularly if they train in the morning or dislike having a full stomach.

  • How has Dr. Norton's view on fasting evolved over time?

    -Dr. Norton initially believed that fasting was not a good idea for those looking to build muscle due to its potential to depress muscle protein synthesis. However, recent studies have shown no significant difference in muscle mass between those who practice intermittent fasting and those who do not, as long as protein intake is adequate.

  • What is the significance of the Mendelian randomization trials mentioned in the script?

    -Mendelian randomization trials use genetic polymorphisms to assess the causal relationship between LDL cholesterol levels and heart disease risk. These trials have shown a clear correlation between higher lifetime exposure to LDL and increased risk of heart disease, influencing Dr. Norton's views on LDL's role in heart health.

  • What dietary changes has Dr. Norton made in light of his new understanding of LDL cholesterol?

    -Dr. Norton now advises keeping saturated fat intake below 10% of total calories and has started taking a statin medication to manage his naturally higher LDL levels, despite making lifestyle changes.

  • What is the relationship between HDL cholesterol and heart disease risk according to the script?

    -While higher HDL cholesterol is generally associated with better metabolic health, Mendelian randomization trials have shown that naturally higher or lower levels of HDL do not significantly modify heart disease risk.

  • How does Dr. Norton approach the topic of exercise and its impact on appetite and energy expenditure?

    -Dr. Norton acknowledges that while exercise can increase appetite and energy expenditure, on average, it has an anorectic effect and results in a net calorie deficit when not rigorously tracking calorie intake. However, individual responses may vary, and some people may need to adjust their exercise routines based on their personal experiences.

  • What is the role of Auto regulation in Dr. Norton's current training approach?

    -Auto regulation allows Dr. Norton to adjust his training intensity and volume based on his body's feedback, such as how he feels on a particular day or how weights are moving during warm-up sets, leading to a more flexible and sustainable training approach.

  • What is Dr. Norton's perspective on periodization in training?

    -Dr. Norton believes that periodization can be useful for optimizing recovery and managing training volume over time. However, he does not see it as inherently superior to consistent, hard training without strict periodization.

  • How does Dr. Norton's experience with a parasite infection relate to the broader discussion on weight loss and health?

    -Dr. Norton's experience with a parasite infection, which led to rapid weight loss, serves as a reminder that while quick fixes can be effective, they are not sustainable or enjoyable. It reinforces the importance of consistency and hard work in achieving long-term health and fitness goals.

Outlines

00:00

🤔 Personal Evolution and Nutritional Sponsorship

Dr. Lane Norton discusses his personal changes in beliefs over the years and introduces the video's sponsorship by Element, praising their Citrus salt for its refreshing taste and electrolyte balance. He explains his usage of the product, particularly the sodium, potassium, and magnesium content, and how it caters to his specific needs depending on whether he is fasted or not. The conversation also touches on the importance of tracking nutritional intake to manage appetite and the role of electrolytes in performance and health.

05:00

💊 Reconsidering BCAA and EAA Supplementation

The speaker reflects on his previous stance on branched-chain amino acids (BCAA) and essential amino acids (EAA) supplementation, acknowledging that while he once advocated for their use, he has since revised his opinion. He explains that research indicates BCAA and EAA supplementation does not significantly enhance lean muscle mass when adequate protein is already consumed. He also discusses the potential benefits of EAA for specific populations, such as plant-based dieters and fasters, and how these supplements can support muscle protein synthesis and reduce catabolism.

10:01

🕉 Changing Perspectives on Fasting and Muscle Building

The paragraph delves into the evolving understanding of fasting's impact on muscle building. Initially, the speaker was against fasting for those looking to build muscle due to its suppressive effect on muscle protein synthesis. However, recent studies have shown no significant difference in lean tissue accrual between those who practice intermittent fasting and those who do not, provided they consume adequate protein and calories. The speaker emphasizes the importance of individual body composition and personal experience when considering fasting for muscle growth.

15:03

🏋️‍♂️ The Impact of Fasting on Training and Performance

The discussion continues with the effects of fasting on workout performance and muscle catabolism. The speaker shares personal anecdotes and scientific insights, suggesting that while fasting may not be optimal for all, it can be a useful tool for appetite control and calorie management. He also addresses the psychological aspects of fasting, such as feeling sluggish after a big meal before training, and the importance of individual preferences and experiences in crafting a training regimen.

20:03

🧬 LDL Cholesterol Revisited: A Shift in Understanding

The speaker recounts his change in perspective regarding LDL cholesterol. He used to believe that LDL was a significant causative factor in heart disease, but recent studies, particularly Mendelian randomization trials, have led him to reconsider this view. He explains that while LDL can penetrate the endothelium, the overall cholesterol deposition is similar regardless of particle size. The speaker also addresses the role of HDL cholesterol and the potential for reverse causality in studies involving elderly or cancer patients.

25:04

🍳 The Role of Saturated Fat in Diet and Health

This paragraph explores the relationship between saturated fat intake and health outcomes, particularly LDL cholesterol levels. The speaker discusses the impact of saturated fat on insulin resistance and liver fat, citing studies that suggest saturated fat may be a stronger contributor to these issues than sugar. He also touches on the emotional aspects of dietary choices and the difficulty of changing established dietary habits, emphasizing the importance of a balanced and nuanced approach to nutrition.

30:04

🚴‍♀️ The Debate Over Fasted Cardio for Fat Loss

The speaker examines the common belief that fasted cardio is more effective for fat loss due to increased fat burning during exercise. However, he points out that studies show no significant difference in fat loss between fasted and fed cardio when total daily calorie expenditure and intake are equated. The speaker also shares his personal experience, moving from a strict fasted cardio routine to a more flexible approach based on individual preference and the importance of not losing muscle mass during cardio sessions.

35:06

🏋️‍♂️ Periodization Training: Effectiveness and Adaptation

The paragraph discusses the concept of periodization training and its effectiveness in bodybuilding and strength training. The speaker used to be a strong proponent of periodization but has since found the research on its benefits to be lacking. He now favors a flexible approach to periodization that includes auto-regulation, allowing for adjustments based on how the body feels and performs on any given day. The speaker emphasizes the importance of consistency and hard work over trying to optimize training programs.

40:08

🤝 Conclusion on Consistency and Personalized Approach

In the concluding paragraph, the speaker reflects on the importance of consistency in achieving long-term goals, whether in diet or exercise. He shares his journey of losing a significant amount of weight and emphasizes that it was not about finding easy hacks but about doing the hard work consistently. The speaker also discusses the value of personalized approaches to training and diet, using tools like bar velocity devices for objective feedback and adjusting training intensity based on recovery and performance.

45:09

📲 Outward Nutrition and Carbon Diet Coach App

The final paragraph shifts focus to the speaker's professional endeavors, including his Instagram presence, the Outward Nutrition website, and the Carbon Diet Coach app. The speaker highlights the app's ability to automate personalized nutrition coaching, offering various diet options and adjusting recommendations based on user progress. He also addresses misconceptions about his stance on low-carb diets and emphasizes the importance of offering diverse dietary options through his app.

Mindmap

Keywords

💡Branched-Chain Amino Acids (BCAAs)

Branched-Chain Amino Acids (BCAAs) refer to three essential amino acids: leucine, isoleucine, and valine. They are crucial for muscle protein synthesis, particularly leucine which is known to stimulate this process. In the script, Dr. Lane Norton discusses changing his perspective on BCAA supplementation, noting that while he once advocated for their use, more recent research suggests they may not provide additional benefits for muscle growth when adequate protein is already consumed in the diet.

💡Essential Amino Acids (EAAs)

Essential Amino Acids (EAAs) are a subset of amino acids that the human body cannot synthesize on its own and must be obtained through diet. EAAs are vital for various bodily functions, including muscle repair and growth. The script mentions EAAs in the context of supplementation for specific populations, such as plant-based dieters or those who fast, to ensure they receive adequate amounts of these nutrients.

💡Fasting

Fasting is the abstention from food for a certain period, which can have various health and physiological effects. Dr. Norton discusses his evolving view on fasting, particularly in relation to muscle building and maintenance. He mentions that while fasting can suppress muscle protein synthesis, studies have shown no significant difference in muscle gain between those who fast intermittently and those who do not, provided they consume adequate protein and calories.

💡 LDL Cholesterol

LDL Cholesterol, often referred to as 'bad cholesterol,' is a type of lipoprotein that can contribute to plaque buildup in the arteries, potentially leading to cardiovascular disease. The script discusses how Dr. Norton's view on LDL has changed, moving from skepticism about its role as a causative factor in heart disease to acceptance based on evidence from mendelian randomization trials and other research.

💡Saturated Fat

Saturated Fat is a type of fat found primarily in animal products and some plant-based oils, like coconut oil. It has been linked to increased LDL cholesterol levels. In the script, Dr. Norton talks about his shift in perspective on saturated fat, acknowledging that while it was once considered harmless, current research suggests it may contribute to heart disease and should be consumed mindfully.

💡Statins

Statins are a class of drugs used to lower blood cholesterol levels, particularly LDL cholesterol, and are often prescribed to prevent cardiovascular disease. Dr. Norton mentions taking a statin himself due to naturally high LDL levels, despite lifestyle modifications, indicating a personal acceptance of their use based on individual health considerations.

💡Periodization

Periodization is a training method used to organize workout routines over time to maximize performance and recovery. It often involves varying intensity, volume, or type of training. Dr. Norton discusses his change in perspective on periodization, suggesting that while it can be useful for recovery, it may not be inherently superior to consistent, hard training without strict periodization.

💡Autoregulation

Autoregulation in training refers to the practice of adjusting workout intensity or volume based on individual feelings and readiness on a given day, rather than strictly following a predetermined plan. The script highlights the importance of autoregulation in training to avoid overtraining and injury, aligning with the theme of adapting to one's body's needs for optimal performance and recovery.

💡Constrained Energy Expenditure

Constrained Energy Expenditure is a model suggesting that the body maintains a relatively stable energy expenditure regardless of changes in physical activity levels. The script touches on this concept when discussing the idea that increased exercise might not lead to significant fat loss if it results in reduced spontaneous physical activity or increased food intake.

💡Cardio

Cardio, short for cardiovascular exercise, refers to physical activities that raise heart rate and improve heart and lung function. The script discusses the debate between fasted and fed cardio, concluding that there is no significant difference in fat loss outcomes when total daily calorie intake and expenditure are considered.

💡Protein Synthesis

Protein Synthesis is the process by which the body creates new proteins, which is crucial for muscle growth and repair. The script uses the concept of protein synthesis to illustrate the balance between muscle building and breakdown, emphasizing that both processes occur simultaneously, and that the net result depends on the relative rates of each process.

Highlights

Sponsorship by Element, a brand offering various flavors of electrolytes with a focus on the perfect ratio of sodium, potassium, and magnesium.

Dr. Lane Norton's change of perspective on Branched Chain Amino Acid (BCAA) supplementation, recognizing its limited effectiveness without adequate protein intake.

The importance of BCAAs for specific populations such as plant-based dieters and those who fast, and their role in overcoming the refractory phenomenon of muscle protein synthesis.

Shift in opinion regarding fasting and its impact on muscle building, with new research suggesting no significant difference in muscle gain between fasting and continuous feeding.

Discussion on the role of Essential Amino Acids (EAAs) in plant-based diets and their potential to enhance meal quality.

The potential benefits of EAAs for individuals who fast and the physiological comparison between high protein diets and fasting.

Personal experience and the realization that personal mileage may vary with dietary and training practices, emphasizing the importance of individual responses.

The evolving understanding of LDL cholesterol's role in heart disease and the influence of genetic factors on LDL levels.

The impact of saturated fat on LDL cholesterol levels and the reconsideration of dietary guidelines regarding fat intake.

The use of statins by Dr. Norton to manage his naturally high LDL levels despite lifestyle modifications.

The nuanced view on the relationship between diet, LDL levels, and heart disease risk, including the role of dietary cholesterol versus LDL cholesterol.

The myth-busting around the necessity of consuming high amounts of saturated fat and the potential for overconsumption to contribute to insulin resistance.

The reevaluation of periodization training and its actual impact on muscle mass and strength gains.

The introduction of auto-regulation in training as a flexible approach to periodization, allowing for better recovery and adaptation.

The emphasis on the importance of consistency and hard work in achieving long-term health and fitness goals.

Outward Nutrition and Carbon Diet Coach app, tools created by Dr. Norton to help individuals with their nutrition and fitness journey.

Transcripts

play00:00

right Dr Lane Norton you and I both

play00:02

changed our minds on a lot of things but

play00:04

you were steadfast in your ways for

play00:06

quite some time on a number of different

play00:07

topics I want to kind of put you on the

play00:09

spot and say like what are five things

play00:12

that you've changed your mind on over

play00:14

the last five six seven years where

play00:16

people might say holy crap I never would

play00:17

have thought that from today's video is

play00:19

sponsored by element

play00:21

lmnt I'm a fan of their Citrus salt it's

play00:24

super refreshing they have their

play00:26

grapefruit salt which is a delicious

play00:27

flavor they have their watermelon salt

play00:30

bunch of different flavors so that link

play00:31

gets you a free variety pack with any

play00:35

purchase so when you purchase any kind

play00:36

of electrolytes from element you get a

play00:38

free variety pack when you use that link

play00:40

down below and that has that perfect

play00:41

combination has 1,000 Mig sodium 200

play00:44

potassium 60 magnesium which is why I

play00:46

use it it's the perfect ratio that I

play00:47

like specifically for me that way I can

play00:49

use a full packet if I'm fasted I'll use

play00:51

a half packet if I'm not fasted and then

play00:53

drink the other half a little bit later

play00:55

on throughout the course of the day so

play00:56

it's drink LM nt.com Thomas whether you

play01:00

are fasted or not it's a super low or

play01:03

zero calorie way to get some flavor and

play01:06

to kind of kill your appetite as well so

play01:08

check them out that link is down below

play01:09

in the top line of the description um

play01:11

you're going to have to help me keep

play01:12

track

play01:14

so I think you know number one something

play01:17

that I was known for and that I had in

play01:21

my previous supplement line was Branch

play01:24

amino acid

play01:25

supplementation now I still think

play01:27

there's there's some cases where BCA or

play01:30

EAS may make sense for very specific

play01:33

populations but you know probably 15 10

play01:39

even like up to 5 years ago I would kind

play01:42

of say you know I think there is value

play01:43

in supplementing branchy amino acids and

play01:46

for my reasoning was well you know we

play01:48

know that Lucine is the amino acid that

play01:51

stimulates muscle protein synthesis it's

play01:52

one of the BCAAs typically in BCA

play01:55

formulas it is provided in a 2:1:1 ratio

play01:59

to loose to one isoline one veiling

play02:02

reason for that is that tends to be

play02:04

that's how they are metabolized in that

play02:06

ratio they've actually shown that if you

play02:08

have you know if you have too much

play02:10

Lucine you'll actually kind of deplete

play02:13

levels of isol Lucine and veiling so

play02:16

anyways I was big on supplementation

play02:18

because I'm like okay you know per on a

play02:20

per calorie anabolic Buck you're you

play02:22

know getting a pretty strong Bang there

play02:25

um and one of the things I said also was

play02:28

I recommended taking you know a b a

play02:30

supplement between

play02:31

meals because in my research and some

play02:34

other

play02:35

labs without getting you know too far

play02:37

into the weeds we showed this kind of

play02:39

like refractory phenomenon of muscle

play02:41

protein synthesis which essentially is

play02:43

just that um if you give a dose of

play02:46

protein we show that protein synthesis

play02:48

goes up and comes back down and it comes

play02:52

back down even in the face of elevated

play02:55

levels of blood amino acids uh elevated

play02:58

mour signaling

play03:00

um and pretty much like all anabolic

play03:02

signaling apparatus is still turned on

play03:04

in the

play03:05

cell um and essentially we showed that

play03:08

we could kind of overcome that we could

play03:11

extend out muscle protein synthesis by

play03:13

giving

play03:14

bcas but when you look at the the

play03:17

research where they have adequate

play03:19

protein and they give bcas on top of it

play03:23

you just don't see any differences in

play03:24

lean mass and I mean they've done this

play03:26

in lab animals too where they're

play03:28

controlling like so much

play03:30

of the animals diet because

play03:32

humans I'm for human studies over animal

play03:34

studies but I always tell people if you

play03:38

want like human studies with high

play03:40

subject number and high level of control

play03:42

it's going to be really short duration

play03:44

if you want uh High control and long

play03:48

duration it's going to be very few

play03:50

subjects and if you want long duration

play03:53

High subject number it's going to be

play03:54

very low control and if you want High

play03:56

subject number High control long dur a

play04:00

it's going to be Lab Rats it's going to

play04:02

be animals like you just can't do it in

play04:04

humans

play04:06

um and so unless you've got you know

play04:08

Millions upon millions of dollars to

play04:10

really put down on a study and even then

play04:13

I mean good luck finding the and even

play04:14

then I mean like how long you know when

play04:16

people complain about this stuff I'm

play04:18

like well are you going to sign up to

play04:20

have somebody to tell you what to do for

play04:21

two years and what to eat like no you're

play04:23

not going to do that put you in a

play04:24

metabolic Ward for five years yeah

play04:26

exactly food jail right so

play04:30

when we even the animal trials where

play04:33

they're giving supplemental BCAA and

play04:36

they're having these animals resistance

play04:38

train and yes you can get Lab Rats to

play04:40

resistance train

play04:42

um and you know they just don't see it

play04:45

it just doesn't seem to make a

play04:46

difference if you have enough protein so

play04:49

my first supplement line uh that was a

play04:53

collaboration between myself and

play04:54

bodybuilding.com you know like 7 eight

play04:56

years ago we included BCA a in our

play05:00

recovery

play05:01

product and now in my recovery product

play05:03

without work nutrition I don't have them

play05:05

because I just said well I can't justify

play05:08

this you know like um even though for a

play05:11

long time I was beating that drum I had

play05:14

to say Hey listen I was wrong about that

play05:16

you know um and then another thing would

play05:19

actually be uh fasting so backy it's a

play05:23

perfect bridge for that because I

play05:24

actually have a question on the BCA like

play05:26

first of all like any Merit to eaas at

play05:28

all or is it in the same boat

play05:30

okay so actually this is a good segue so

play05:32

I think two particular situations first

play05:35

one is um if you're dealing with um you

play05:39

know plant-based folks who have

play05:42

difficulty getting in

play05:44

enough um essential amino acids through

play05:46

their diet and for whatever reason don't

play05:51

want to supplement with a protein powder

play05:54

I mean there are some decent plant

play05:55

protein powders out there isolated plant

play05:57

protein powders um but but if you add

play06:00

EAS to meals um I mean you're

play06:04

essentially enhancing the quality of

play06:06

that meal right so that's a that's a

play06:08

quick and easy way if somebody didn't

play06:10

want to like do a lot of like math and

play06:13

combinations of proteins and all that

play06:14

kind of stuff they could just kind of

play06:16

eat their normal you know vegan diet and

play06:18

then add you know 10 grams of essential

play06:20

amino acids on top of it each

play06:22

meal um next subgroup would be people

play06:25

who fast um you know if they want to

play06:29

kind of bring themselves out of

play06:31

catabolism after you know an overnight

play06:34

fast or whatnot and they're going to

play06:35

train in the mornings May or maybe

play06:38

people even who just don't like feeling

play06:40

like they've got a lot of you know food

play06:42

on their stomach uh

play06:44

EAS very you know I mean they're

play06:47

basically pre-digested you don't have

play06:49

your body pretty much can just absorb

play06:51

them into the small intestine don't have

play06:53

to do anything with them and so I I

play06:56

think for those folks it can be helpful

play06:58

and I what I would say is like you know

play07:00

you could just drink a way Shake I mean

play07:02

people worry about fasting and what I

play07:06

tell people is like you know high

play07:08

protein diets and fasting in terms of

play07:10

metabolic signals are not really that

play07:12

far apart like if you're talking about a

play07:14

protein like just a high protein meal I

play07:16

mean the one thing you could argue is

play07:17

well they stimulate insulin you know

play07:19

that sort of thing but it kind of boils

play07:21

back to like all right why are we

play07:22

fasting right like I think the research

play07:26

pretty clearly shows now fasting is a

play07:28

great tool for a lot of people or time

play07:30

restriction to you know narrow down

play07:33

their eating window and reduce their

play07:34

calorie consumption but in terms of like

play07:39

physiologically when you're equating

play07:41

calories between diets on a weekly

play07:43

basis no difference in fat loss and the

play07:47

claims about autophagy and whatnot are

play07:49

pretty tenuous because we do know that

play07:51

again normal caloric restriction will

play07:53

increase autophagy exercise increases

play07:55

autophagy fasting increases

play07:57

autophagy we don't know if it does more

play08:00

than you know these other things so what

play08:04

I'll say is like Hey listen like really

play08:07

to me if you're doing it to control your

play08:08

appetite what's wrong with having a way

play08:10

shake or just an isolated protein Source

play08:12

before you go train if you're you know

play08:15

if if building muscle is something

play08:16

that's important to you um and so then

play08:19

you know whether whey or essential amino

play08:21

acids you know those are have utility

play08:24

for people who may want to time restrict

play08:26

their food intake so they can control

play08:28

their calories are still concerned with

play08:30

like trying to maximize their muscle

play08:31

mass so so fasting or fasting or not is

play08:34

their benefit to having locing whether

play08:37

it's eaa's way or even Branch chain

play08:40

amino acids in that case is there any

play08:41

Merit to having it pre-training whether

play08:43

you're training fast it or not I think

play08:45

if you're training fasted I mean there

play08:48

could be Merit to it but not necessarily

play08:50

more Merit than you would have just

play08:52

having a regular protein Source but

play08:53

above staying fasted perhaps yeah I mean

play08:55

if you if that's important if you want

play08:57

to you know stay fast although you can

play09:00

argue that all right you're you're

play09:01

ingesting amino acid so you're

play09:03

technically not fasted right um but

play09:06

again it's like I I boil back to it's

play09:08

like well why are why are we doing

play09:10

fasting right it's kind of like

play09:12

um when I guess kind of a weird

play09:15

comparison would be like okay if you're

play09:16

doing a ketogenic diet but then you're

play09:18

buying like these ketogenic ice creams

play09:20

that have more calories than the normal

play09:21

ice cream it's like okay we're kind of

play09:24

missing the point of ketosis here right

play09:26

like the point is to control your

play09:27

appetite and reduce your calorie take at

play09:29

least if you're you know unless you're

play09:31

using it for treatment of something like

play09:32

epilepsy or something like that um you

play09:35

know the point should be to you know use

play09:37

it as an appetite control

play09:39

tool so I did change my mind about

play09:41

fasting as well from the perspective of

play09:44

you know 10 years ago if you asked me

play09:46

about fasting I'd say well you know I

play09:48

don't think it's a good idea for people

play09:49

who want to build muscle because you

play09:51

know we've shown that even an an

play09:54

overnight fast will depress muscle

play09:55

protein synthesis and so now if you're

play09:58

extending that out further

play10:00

you know I don't know if you're going to

play10:00

be able to make up for

play10:02

this there's been a couple studies now

play10:04

at a grant Tinsley's lab um where I

play10:07

think he's at Texas A&M where they've

play10:10

done you know I think it's 8 to 12 week

play10:12

resistance training studies where people

play10:14

either do kind of your traditional 168

play10:16

intermittent fasting uh with resistance

play10:19

training or they do continuous feeding

play10:22

and they've shown no differences in the

play10:24

acrel of lean tissue so a couple caveats

play10:27

to

play10:28

that

play10:29

8 to 12 weeks not a super long time not

play10:32

saying it's a bad study it's not a bad

play10:33

study at all but you know differences in

play10:36

muscle mass are slow so if you we kind

play10:39

of talking about this earlier if you

play10:40

inject me with true serum and ask me do

play10:43

I think that you know any form of

play10:45

fasting is optimal if you want to be the

play10:47

most muscular person you possibly can be

play10:50

no but that's not most people either

play10:53

right if you're just worried about

play10:55

growing muscle and you know staying lean

play10:57

and you find it intermittent fast

play10:59

fasting is a useful tool for that you

play11:01

can absolutely still build muscle

play11:03

intermittent fasting especially if

play11:04

you're getting enough protein getting

play11:06

enough total

play11:08

calories and the one thing I will say

play11:10

about this study was they made sure they

play11:12

had them train during their feeding

play11:14

window and they did advise them to get

play11:16

like three good servings of protein in

play11:20

Peter AA makes a really good point about

play11:22

intermittent fasting which you know on a

play11:24

practical level he said you know I have

play11:26

seen people kind of start to lose lean

play11:28

mass intermittent fasting but it's since

play11:31

we're compressing their feeding window

play11:33

they tend to just eat less protein they

play11:35

tend to eat kind of like a similar diet

play11:37

they normally would just less and so you

play11:41

know if lean mass is a is a

play11:44

consideration you know if you're

play11:45

narrowing your feeding window you do

play11:47

want to make sure you're getting you

play11:48

know a couple of you know high quality

play11:51

protein doses in if again lean mass as a

play11:53

consideration but I have changed my tune

play11:56

that okay 168 inm fasting

play12:00

doesn't seem to be significantly

play12:02

different from kind of regular feeding

play12:04

if you're getting enough

play12:05

protein and I would like to see a study

play12:08

where you know they have people trained

play12:09

fasted outside their feeding wind

play12:11

outside the feeding window compared to

play12:14

continuous feeding that would be

play12:15

interesting I don't know if it'll be

play12:17

different um I think a lot matters on

play12:20

like the body composition of the person

play12:22

as well right like I mean it's for me

play12:24

I'm I'm lean now and I'm very skeptical

play12:27

about doing longer 75 990 minute

play12:31

workouts without fuel now right because

play12:34

now I mean I don't even have a base

play12:36

layer to really pull from as much and

play12:37

I'm not trying to sound like a a cocky

play12:39

jerk saying that I'm just saying like

play12:40

it's there's when I was you know 50 60

play12:43

pounds overweight it was just less of a

play12:46

concern that allowed repository for fuel

play12:48

yeah so it's like for me it's like okay

play12:50

now yeah I've kind of changed my tune a

play12:52

little bit too like on my heavier

play12:53

resistance training days that might be

play12:54

longer higher volume I am going to eat

play12:56

first you know I am going to have maybe

play12:58

some cream of rice or some honey or some

play13:00

fruit or something along with a way

play13:01

Shake right I will have something to

play13:02

buffer that and it's uh I can't say it's

play13:05

made a huge difference in my performance

play13:06

but I feel like it's at least making it

play13:09

so that I'm not catabolizing quite as

play13:10

much because there was a stage there

play13:11

where I was like yeah I was pushing

play13:13

these like metcons like really starting

play13:15

to go kind of heavy into that world and

play13:16

I was doing all fast in like 90 minutes

play13:18

I'm starting to think okay strength is

play13:20

dropping body composition is great but

play13:21

strength is dropping all these like buy

play13:23

signs are indicating that okay this is

play13:25

not working I need to like throw a

play13:26

wrench in here a little bit so I think

play13:28

there's I think the state that

play13:29

somebody's in might make a difference as

play13:31

well yeah I think it's important to

play13:33

point out to like the the concept of

play13:35

your mileage may vary right so when when

play13:38

I when I talk about studies or when

play13:40

people report studies what we're

play13:41

reporting is averages right so I think a

play13:45

lot of people take their personal

play13:47

experience they hear what a study says

play13:49

they go oh that's BS because I you know

play13:52

I experien something different no you

play13:55

there's outliers you could experience

play13:57

something different right so for example

play14:00

on average if you look at feeding before

play14:03

exercise versus fasting the research is

play14:05

pretty clear you perform better when

play14:07

you're when you're fueled now that

play14:09

doesn't mean that everyone performs

play14:11

better um some people and I think it's

play14:14

it's probably more so psychological they

play14:16

just don't like the feeling of you know

play14:18

being heavy or having food on their

play14:20

stomach anecdotally I noticed a lot of

play14:22

women tend to kind of gravitate towards

play14:24

that they don't want big meals before

play14:25

they go in and train and so but if you

play14:28

know that then that's fine and this is

play14:32

the the disconnect I think sometimes

play14:34

between evidence-based stuff Bro Science

play14:38

and where the two need to meet which is

play14:40

I'll say okay if I've got a new

play14:43

person I'm probably going to start them

play14:46

you know at the averages because on

play14:49

average that's most likely to work best

play14:51

for them but if they're telling me yeah

play14:53

I feel like crap I feel sluggish um you

play14:56

know but I feel better if I don't have

play14:57

as much food or no food I'm not going to

play15:00

like doggedly make them stick with that

play15:03

you know it's like okay cool well then

play15:04

we'll do that right because to me

play15:06

adherence in them feeling good during a

play15:07

workout maybe it is psychological but

play15:10

who cares it's still that's working for

play15:12

them so I think that's where those two

play15:14

worlds really clash and especially when

play15:17

some people hear what I

play15:20

say or they they they listen to how do I

play15:25

want to say this words come out of my

play15:27

mouth but their interpretation of those

play15:29

words is quite different right and I

play15:31

think we all want our personal

play15:33

experience validated you know and

play15:36

um I think that's what I've tried to do

play15:39

a better job of is saying hey here's

play15:41

what the data says but like if this

play15:45

works for you by all means do it if if

play15:48

you whatever fasting ketogenic

play15:52

diet if if you have found that to be

play15:54

your experience that that works better

play15:56

for you by all means do it where we're

play15:59

going to have problems if is if you take

play16:01

your personal experiences to why

play16:02

everyone should be doing this and why

play16:04

it's better that's when we're going to

play16:06

have issues so that's one thing I

play16:08

changed my mind about another thing I

play16:09

changed my mind about was uh LDL

play16:11

cholesterol so I people don't really

play16:14

know this because I spend so much time

play16:16

kind of like fighting against the the

play16:18

crazier end of the low carbon carnivore

play16:20

Community but the lab I came out of was

play16:23

like not ketogenic but lower carish I

play16:26

mean Don Layman was know a big proponent

play16:29

of higher protein um controlling

play16:32

carbohydrate intake but you know he

play16:34

would say like Lane for somebody like

play16:36

you I've seen you train you train like

play16:37

two three Don used to go to the same gym

play16:39

as me which was fun um he's like you

play16:42

train for two or three hours like a

play16:43

madman yeah of course you can you know

play16:45

consume a higher amount of carbohydrate

play16:47

and calories without having negative

play16:49

effects you know and I think that's what

play16:51

some people don't always understand but

play16:54

one thing I will say is like well I can

play16:55

trade that way because I'm fueled that

play16:57

way as well you know like these these

play16:59

things are not necessarily

play17:01

disconnected

play17:03

but one of the things that was being

play17:07

discussed and talked about when I went

play17:10

into the lab there was you know it seems

play17:13

that it's not necessarily the LDL

play17:15

cholesterol it's the HDL to LDL ratio

play17:18

also like LDL oxidation you know oxidize

play17:22

particles of LDL can more easily

play17:24

penetrate the

play17:26

endothelium and now you know we have so

play17:29

much data that's come out especially the

play17:31

melan random randomization trials that I

play17:35

I changed my tune where I do feel like

play17:37

LDL or I I don't feel I do feel

play17:41

confident that the LDL is a causitive

play17:45

factor for heart disease and let me

play17:47

explain that

play17:50

um so we know that LDL cholesterol can

play17:53

penetrate the endothelium whether it's

play17:55

oxidized or not now people will say well

play17:57

oxidize LL penetrates the endothelium

play18:00

it's more about the oxidized level of

play18:02

LDL yes small oxidized particles of LDL

play18:07

can penetrate the endothelium more

play18:11

easily but they carry less overall

play18:13

cholesterol large particles don't

play18:16

penetrate as easy but they carry more

play18:18

cholesterol what you end up with in

play18:20

terms of net cholesterol deposition in

play18:22

the endothelium is pretty similar

play18:25

amounts um if you and and the mandilon

play18:29

randomized trials we're talking about

play18:31

are it's actually kind of brilliant the

play18:33

way this

play18:34

works one of the big problems with

play18:37

looking at LDL cholesterol and heart

play18:39

disease in general is you're you're not

play18:41

talking about something you can really

play18:43

do a randomized control trial on and

play18:46

here's why what's the longest you can do

play18:48

a randomized control trial maybe a year

play18:51

two years heart disease is a lifetime

play18:54

exposure issue you know um if you have

play18:58

high LDL versus low LDL it's not the

play19:00

difference between dying at 30 and dying

play19:03

at 70 it's the difference between dying

play19:05

at you know 67 and 75 you know it's it's

play19:10

kind of like uh investing so uh I use

play19:14

this example if you have one person who

play19:17

invests in a mutual fund and it gets

play19:20

8% you have another person invest in

play19:22

mutual fund it gets 10% and you check

play19:24

how much money they have have after 2

play19:26

years it's going to be kind of similar

play19:29

but if you check after 40 years it's

play19:31

going to be a massive difference well

play19:33

the problem is you can't do a 40-year

play19:35

randomized control trial now mandelian

play19:39

randomization uses the fact that people

play19:43

based on genetic

play19:45

polymorphisms can naturally secrete

play19:48

higher or lower levels of

play19:50

LDL and so they've done studies where

play19:53

they've kind of looked at all right what

play19:54

is the person's lifetime exposure to LDL

play19:58

and how does that correlate with the

play20:00

risk of heart disease and I mean you can

play20:03

pretty much draw like a straight line

play20:04

through the levels of LDL cholesterol

play20:07

and their risk of heart

play20:09

disease now some people will say well

play20:11

it's not really LDL it's apol

play20:13

lipoprotein B yes but apob and LDL tend

play20:17

to they go together um you can't really

play20:20

disconnect them

play20:22

so the other the other thing that would

play20:24

be kind of that was kind of convincing

play20:27

for me was if you look at because some

play20:30

people will say well that's not

play20:31

accounting for inflammation it's not

play20:33

accounting for HDL

play20:35

okay we have drugs that increase HDL we

play20:38

also have mandilon randomized trials on

play20:41

people who secrete more or less

play20:43

HDL it doesn't modify heart disease risk

play20:46

now what HDL is is an indicator of

play20:49

metabolic health so all things being

play20:51

equal you're absolutely better off

play20:53

having higher HDL not because HDL itself

play20:56

is protective but because in order to

play20:58

have high HDL you probably have good

play21:01

insulin sensitivity markers of metabolic

play21:04

Health you're just healthier

play21:06

overall so in the I think they did a

play21:09

subsection of the firmingham data where

play21:11

they looked at okay low inflammation

play21:14

High

play21:15

inflammation low LDL high LDL at at both

play21:20

high and low levels of

play21:23

inflammation in each subcategory people

play21:25

who had low LDL still had lower rate

play21:28

so if you were high inflammation you're

play21:31

you're going to have a higher

play21:33

risk but of those if you the those that

play21:36

had low LDL versus high LDL had a lower

play21:40

risk in that subcategory then if you're

play21:42

low inflammation still the same thing

play21:46

then if we look at same thing with HDL

play21:48

High HDL versus low HDL in each

play21:52

subcategory people who had low LDL still

play21:54

had lower risk so to me if you're

play21:58

kind of controlling some of these other

play22:00

variables and you're still seeing this

play22:02

show up pretty consistently to me that

play22:04

was very convincing and again I was

play22:07

somebody who for years I mean I even I

play22:10

even went through some of my old slides

play22:12

of talks I gave 10 years ago where I

play22:14

said you know saturated fat I'm not

play22:16

worried about it doesn't matter now I'm

play22:18

kind of like H I don't want to say like

play22:21

completely avoid saturated fat um but I

play22:25

I do tell people hey it does increase

play22:27

LDL so just be mindful of it like try to

play22:30

keep it below 10% that sort of thing um

play22:33

10% total calories or 10% of fat

play22:35

calories 10% total calories um and then

play22:37

if you're somebody like me so I have I

play22:40

kind of secrete higher LDL naturally so

play22:42

my LDL hangs out around 150 um and

play22:46

that's even with eating you know 60 70

play22:48

grams of dietary fiber a day um with

play22:51

being a pretty lean person uh

play22:54

exercising and then um and then keeping

play22:58

calories my saturated fat is usually

play23:00

probably around 8% of total

play23:02

calories um and so that's that's

play23:05

actually why and this is really going to

play23:07

get me in trouble I started actually

play23:08

taking a looto Statin um because of this

play23:11

this information and now again I was

play23:12

somebody who was like look at the side

play23:14

effects on statins you know um some

play23:17

people do get Sarco um not sarcopenia

play23:22

but muscle pain from statins uh I

play23:25

haven't had really any side effects uh

play23:27

and it's um fortunately I've been on

play23:30

Prav stattin and as a timi I think it's

play23:32

called um and my H my LDL has gone down

play23:35

by like 40% so um you know for again I'm

play23:40

not saying people should be on statins

play23:42

but you know for me personally even with

play23:44

modifying everything I could through

play23:46

lifestyle I was still pretty high and it

play23:49

what's really interesting about some of

play23:50

these medilan randomization studies they

play23:52

even show you know going from like

play23:55

lowish LDL say 90 or 100 to like even

play24:00

lower 30 or 50 you still get a reduction

play24:03

in

play24:03

Risk so I don't like making like real

play24:06

strong statements but it does appear

play24:08

that like the lower you can kind of get

play24:10

your LDL the the better in terms of

play24:13

heart disease now I'll I'll do the

play24:16

Devil's Advocate argument as well which

play24:18

is well if you look at uh elderly people

play24:21

or people who have cancer people with

play24:24

high LDL live

play24:26

longer what you're looking at is kind of

play24:29

a malnutrition issue usually um people

play24:32

who are malnourished from cancer CIA

play24:36

have lower levels of LDL because of that

play24:39

and also tend to die earlier because

play24:41

cancer kexi is actually one of the

play24:43

biggest mortality risk for

play24:45

cancer um so yeah I you know those tend

play24:49

to be like reverse causality sorts of

play24:51

things and then people say well you know

play24:54

cholesterol does these good things in

play24:55

your body yes cholesterol does do good

play24:56

things in your body but your body with

play24:59

pretty much zero intake of saturated fat

play25:02

or cholesterol can make all the

play25:03

cholesterol it needs so you're not going

play25:05

to be deficient in cholesterol can you

play25:08

can you uh is there evidence that you

play25:10

can offset some of that by being in a

play25:12

more severe deficit or not oh yeah like

play25:15

if you if you lose body fat your blood

play25:17

numbers will improve so even if you're I

play25:19

mean this is purely hypothetical right

play25:21

if someone were to consume a higher

play25:23

saturated fat diet but they were eating

play25:25

at a pretty severe deficit is there

play25:27

arguably a lesser impact so this is

play25:30

where you really get into the Nuance

play25:31

which I like right

play25:35

so you have to kind of compare apples to

play25:37

apples which is okay person eating High

play25:40

saturated fat diet in a severe deficit

play25:42

versus person eating a highs saturated

play25:44

fat diet in a maintenance or Surplus

play25:48

absolutely you can expect this person to

play25:49

have lower LDL who's eating a deficit

play25:53

but we do see people who go from kind of

play25:56

like a more mixed diet or I mean you've

play25:58

seen you see this in like some of the

play26:00

the carnivore like message

play26:02

boards they say wow I've lost 50 PBS but

play26:05

my LDL is 400 you know now you're this

play26:10

is where I really try to tell people I'm

play26:12

like hey like you can hold two opposing

play26:16

things in your hand which is you may be

play26:19

overall healthier right now from losing

play26:22

that 50 lbs doing a carnivore diet that

play26:24

may be

play26:26

true you also have raised your risk of

play26:28

heart disease your

play26:31

or you also have a higher risk of heart

play26:34

disease having this really high LDL than

play26:37

you would if you lost that same 50 lbs

play26:39

but also had low LDL right so I think a

play26:42

lot of people have trouble disconnecting

play26:44

these two things and then the other

play26:46

problem is PE you don't feel it like you

play26:50

can be totally normal and be 90% blocked

play26:55

somewhere I mean you see this all but

play26:57

athletes athletes who have you know

play27:00

whatever a family history or genetic

play27:02

condition who are performing great and

play27:04

all of a sudden heart attack right so

play27:08

people will say well I started this diet

play27:10

my LDL is high but I've never felt

play27:13

better that's not how LDL works right um

play27:17

yeah it's not sludge running through

play27:19

your veins right right right so you know

play27:23

overall you know I I I I know that this

play27:25

is very unpopular in the spere and in

play27:28

the um you know the the carnivore

play27:31

Community but even if you talk to

play27:33

somebody like Dominic deino yeah I mean

play27:36

Dom he's he used to be like well put

play27:39

butter in your coffee and now he's kind

play27:40

of like H yep you know putting olive oil

play27:42

or you know olive oil um you know like

play27:46

eggs are fine Dom eats tons of eggs like

play27:48

you open up his fridge Dom has like a

play27:51

thousand eggs you know eggs and his

play27:53

chicken livers which they're just

play27:55

disgusting oh but the point there too is

play27:58

like interesting disconnection which is

play28:00

LDL and dietary cholesterol not the same

play28:03

thing right so eggs for example I I'm

play28:08

not concerned about the dietary

play28:09

cholesterol intake really really not and

play28:11

actually like people love to make fun of

play28:14

the food guidelines but they do change

play28:17

with the science which like it used to

play28:19

be hey avoid eggs limit eggs because

play28:21

they have too much cholesterol and now

play28:23

the dietary guidelines are like

play28:26

basically we can't say the dietary

play28:28

cholesterol is a concern saturated fat

play28:31

appears to be a concern because it can

play28:32

modify

play28:33

LDL but dietary cholesterol one it

play28:36

doesn't appear to be really that

play28:38

bioavailable two it may modify blood

play28:41

levels of total cholesterol but it

play28:44

appears to be really really small so

play28:47

anyways my point being like somebody

play28:49

even Dom who's in the ketos sphere you

play28:52

know has kind of walked back his

play28:54

position on

play28:55

that and I'm like hey that these why do

play28:58

these two things have to be entangled

play29:00

like why do we have to Def and I think a

play29:01

lot of it's just kind of people who want

play29:04

the excuse

play29:06

that it's almost like you get so

play29:09

entrenched where it's like carbs are bad

play29:12

Fat's good and it doesn't matter the

play29:14

type of fat but it does yeah it's like

play29:16

you can have the same argument kind of

play29:18

coming like the opposite direction from

play29:20

like a flexible dieting crowd that would

play29:21

just be like sometimes they resign to

play29:23

the fact

play29:24

that sometimes it's as simple as wanting

play29:27

to eat certain foods right like it's

play29:29

just the emotional response we have

play29:31

because we like our certain foods and

play29:33

like coming out of the low car world I

play29:35

can tell you straight up that like when

play29:37

you get rid of sugar you kind of start

play29:39

looking for something else right so it's

play29:41

like the higher saturated fat stuff is

play29:43

appealing because and you're like I mean

play29:45

probably in a deep like fundamental

play29:47

tribal level you're like don't take that

play29:49

away from me too you know right like I

play29:51

know as a former fat guy right like you

play29:54

got rid of the sugar that was cool that

play29:56

was fine okay but Le I can have 20

play29:58

pieces of bacon exactly right so I

play30:00

understand that right and the other side

play30:01

is like okay sure well you know whatever

play30:04

you do like yeah you know don't take

play30:05

away my Pixie sticks or whatever I I

play30:07

don't think anyone's ever said that but

play30:09

uh yeah so I mean it's like it's

play30:10

understandable from an emotional side

play30:12

how you just want to defend that and you

play30:14

know there's a lot of evidence too

play30:16

suggesting that the high amounts of

play30:18

saturated fat are also an equally strong

play30:20

contributor if not unfortunately even a

play30:23

stronger contributor to insulin

play30:24

resistance than excess sugar right

play30:27

that's what people don't want to talk

play30:28

about like when you know it's like when

play30:30

these people freak out about fructose

play30:32

and and liver fat I'm like okay but we

play30:36

have studies comparing straight up like

play30:41

fructose

play30:42

overfeeding uh saturated fat overfeeding

play30:45

I think fructose overfeeding increased

play30:48

liver fat by like I don't know like 20%

play30:50

or something like that which by the way

play30:51

wasn't really different from overfeeding

play30:53

any other source of carbohydrate

play30:55

saturated fat increased like

play30:58

78% and if you compare straight up they

play31:02

actually did a study where they um

play31:05

overfed polyunsaturated fats versus

play31:08

saturated fats and they saw um like that

play31:13

that's where I pulled that number from

play31:15

78% greater I think it was 78 I want to

play31:18

say it was a 78% greater increase in

play31:20

liver fat compared to polyunsaturated

play31:24

fats it could be an absolute increase of

play31:26

7 % but either way it was greater than

play31:29

the increase from polyunsaturated fat so

play31:31

I apologize if I butchered the study a

play31:33

little bit but then when people go the

play31:36

big you know what the big um thing

play31:39

people always get hung up on that study

play31:40

when I when I talk about it they're like

play31:42

oh well they cooked them in muffins as

play31:46

part of muffins you're really going to

play31:47

tell me that this study with muffins is

play31:49

I'm

play31:50

like so these are highly processed stuff

play31:54

that you guys freak out about and

play31:56

they're with poly saturated fats and

play31:58

they heated it which is like this is

play32:00

like the trifecta of everything that you

play32:02

guys say that sea dolls are bad for

play32:04

right um so yeah when you look at you

play32:07

know kind of I know we're kind of

play32:11

tanging here but um I did a a kind of a

play32:15

post on seed oils recently which I was

play32:18

always I was like man I know that this

play32:20

is going to like I saw that one the

play32:21

title like the video you guys are going

play32:23

to hate the most hated video I think it

play32:25

was like over a thousand comments or

play32:26

something like that

play32:28

um and I was like listen if you if you

play32:33

overfeed polyunsaturated fats or Omega

play32:35

sixes yeah you see you see problems but

play32:39

you see that when you overfeed pretty

play32:40

much anything anything yeah what happens

play32:42

when you replace it one to one saturated

play32:46

fat versus polyunsaturated fats Omega

play32:48

sixes

play32:50

specifically and I mean it's pretty

play32:52

consistent you either see a neutral or

play32:55

positive effect on metabolic IC Health

play32:57

like liver fat insulin

play33:00

sensitivity um even like gut microbiome

play33:03

stuff um the the you tend I think you

play33:07

tend to use more bile or the bile in

play33:10

products with saturated fat apparently

play33:13

are somewhat toxic to some of the good

play33:15

bugs in the

play33:17

microbiome so again I'm not saying that

play33:20

people should completely avoid saturated

play33:22

fat I don't think they need to do that

play33:24

I'm just saying hey when you look

play33:26

straight up

play33:28

saturated fat appears to be somewhat

play33:31

problematic especially if you're

play33:32

overeating it right maybe don't just go

play33:34

willingly at it just for the sake of

play33:36

maybe we shouldn't be dumping butter in

play33:37

our coffee you know all right so that's

play33:39

three so let's move on number four okay

play33:41

number four um see I can't

play33:45

count uh

play33:48

cardio um so fasted versus fed all right

play33:54

so this is a case where I have I was on

play33:57

this extreme went to this extreme and

play34:00

then eventually came back to Center

play34:02

which is um at first when I first

play34:06

started um in bodybuilding like age 19

play34:09

early 2000s I was like fasted cardio low

play34:12

intensity you burn more fat empty

play34:15

stomach you're going to you're going to

play34:17

burn more

play34:18

fat and you do you do burn more calories

play34:21

from fat doing that way as a

play34:24

percentage but when they do as I like to

play34:27

say human randomized control trials

play34:30

where they have one group doing fasted

play34:32

cardio one group doing fed cardio but

play34:34

equating calories throughout the day and

play34:36

equating the work with the cardio they

play34:39

don't see differences in Fat Loss how

play34:42

could this be they're burning more fat

play34:44

well fat burning and fat loss are not

play34:47

the same things fat burning is part of

play34:50

what is needed in order for you to lose

play34:52

fat but it is also the balance between

play34:56

the amount of fat you burn versus the

play34:57

amount of fat you store CU both

play34:59

processes are always happening at the

play35:00

same time people don't realize this they

play35:02

think metabolism is kind of like on and

play35:03

off switches what I tell people is it's

play35:06

kind of like opposing dimmer switches

play35:08

right like you're just changing the the

play35:09

relative rates of each uh I mean great

play35:12

example of that is protein synthesis

play35:13

versus degradation neither one like

play35:15

shuts down it's just when you're losing

play35:19

muscle mass your rates of degradation

play35:21

are higher than your rates of synthesis

play35:23

when you're gaining muscle mass your

play35:24

rates of synthesis are higher than

play35:26

degradation over period of

play35:28

time so when they look at okay if you do

play35:32

fasted versus fed cardio what tends to

play35:35

happen is since you burn well one your

play35:39

feeding window is shorter right because

play35:41

if you did fasted cardio I mean it's an

play35:44

hour or two extra that you're waiting to

play35:46

eat right and now during your feeding

play35:48

window you're consuming more

play35:51

calories when you're doing fed cardio

play35:54

you've kind of spread out your feeding

play35:55

window a little bit and so since you

play35:57

burn more fat during

play36:00

exercise when you're not exercising

play36:03

you're eating more calories you burn

play36:05

less fat the rest of the day when you're

play36:09

fed you burn less calories from fat but

play36:12

the rest of the day you're eating less

play36:14

you burn more calories from fat so it

play36:18

ends up not really being a difference in

play36:19

fat loss I mean we've seen it time after

play36:21

time in randomized control

play36:23

trials now I went too far to the Other

play36:26

Extreme which was okay you're going to

play36:28

lose muscle if you're doing fasted

play36:29

cardio you know why would you do that

play36:32

you know you need to have some some food

play36:34

before you go out like I used to you

play36:36

know I used to be so dogmatic about this

play36:38

if I had cardio in the morning I would

play36:39

go and eat my full breakfast before I

play36:41

went for a walk you know and now again

play36:45

there's been enough studies where I'm

play36:46

like okay it's it's not going to make

play36:48

you lose muscle so you know what I tell

play36:50

people is hey if you like just getting

play36:53

up and getting it

play36:55

done it's fine

play36:57

right if you want to eat beforehand also

play37:00

fine you know do what you prefer um so

play37:03

that's another thing I've changed my

play37:04

mind on intensity would matter there too

play37:05

though right I me because like one thing

play37:07

that I found

play37:08

is well where do you draw the line right

play37:10

where if I'm going to need a lot of

play37:14

brute strength I'm going to like

play37:16

performance is of concern right I'm

play37:19

saying okay well so I'm going to eat and

play37:22

I exert X more calories during my

play37:24

workout because I'm fueled or I'm sure

play37:27

there are those kinds of situations but

play37:30

it's probably in that cohort you're

play37:32

looking more at the athlete crowd right

play37:34

someone that's actually because I think

play37:35

people like you and I both know that

play37:37

resistance training doesn't burn that

play37:39

many calories like people think they go

play37:40

in there and they're burning a ton but

play37:42

you know if someone is I'm going to use

play37:43

an example of Crossfit because it's the

play37:45

only thing I can think of that's just

play37:46

like a just a probably the most

play37:48

monstrous amount of calories if you were

play37:50

to actually combine you know in that

play37:52

particular case like sure like maybe

play37:54

being fueled is the difference between

play37:56

them burning 600 versus 500 but then at

play37:58

the end of the

play37:59

day do we have sort of a self-governing

play38:02

mechanism in the brain that sort of

play38:04

wants to find homeostasis with our

play38:06

calories no matter what because that's

play38:07

what I know it's only Road model stuff

play38:09

that I've seen with that but they've

play38:10

seen it even with fasting right where

play38:11

they deprive rodents for a couple of

play38:14

days and then like three weeks later

play38:17

somehow they've all ended up the same

play38:19

right the rats that didn't eat they were

play38:21

fast and maybe their body composition

play38:22

changed in the short term but then over

play38:24

time everyone balanced back out

play38:27

um yeah that's kind of

play38:30

like the constrained energy expenditure

play38:35

model which which basically

play38:37

says you know the amount of calories you

play38:40

burn per day isn't really going to

play38:43

change a ton even if you exercise

play38:45

because if you exercise what tends to

play38:48

happen is your BMR and your spontaneous

play38:51

physical activity goes down right so

play38:55

there is some truth to that there is a a

play38:58

compensation uh but it's it's not

play39:03

as rigid as the constrained energy

play39:06

expenditure model would have you believe

play39:07

so um for example uh Herman poner

play39:11

published a study he's a Duke and um

play39:15

basically showed that for every 100

play39:17

calories you burn from physical activity

play39:19

um your BMR compensates like 28 calories

play39:22

or something like that so you don't you

play39:24

if you think you burned 100 calories

play39:25

from exercise

play39:27

your take-home at the end of the day

play39:29

probably isn't that but it's still

play39:31

probably better than you would have

play39:33

had by not exercising it's like paying

play39:36

taxes yeah you I said 30% the side you

play39:39

know um yeah exactly so you know I

play39:45

think now some people again this is

play39:49

where your mileage may vary right some

play39:51

people say man if I increase my exercise

play39:53

I just get so hungry that I end up

play39:56

eating more right part of me is like H I

play40:00

think that you think you're hungrier

play40:02

because you're exercising more but may

play40:05

maybe it is maybe it is if we look at

play40:07

the average across

play40:10

studies

play40:12

exercise on the whole has actually an

play40:15

anorectic effect now not that you

play40:18

consume less calories than you normally

play40:19

would it's again if you burn 100

play40:21

calories from exercise you compensate by

play40:24

consuming more Cal like if you just let

play40:26

people eat freely but the compensation

play40:28

isn't complete it's you consume a few

play40:31

more calories but you still burned more

play40:33

than you end up consuming again on

play40:35

average right but when you combine the

play40:38

the compensation in your energy

play40:40

expenditure with the compensation in

play40:42

what you're eating if you're not like

play40:43

kind of tracking your calories

play40:45

rigidly you know the effect is less than

play40:49

what you predict which is why it's LED

play40:50

some people who are kind of dogmatic to

play40:52

say well see exercise doesn't cause fat

play40:55

loss it's not good for fat loss

play40:57

no it it is um but again if you're

play41:00

someone who you know that if you go and

play41:02

you train hard for an hour or two hours

play41:05

or whatever it is and now you're so

play41:07

wiped out that you just sit on the couch

play41:08

the rest of the day and you're so hungry

play41:10

that you just end up eating more than

play41:12

you would have well then maybe a little

play41:14

bit less

play41:15

exercise you know might be better for

play41:17

you again this is where we have like

play41:21

scientific studies that are kind of a

play41:22

guide that can give us guidelines but

play41:25

you know if you know you as an

play41:28

individual fall outside that then do

play41:31

what you know works for you but just

play41:33

don't assume that everybody else is like

play41:35

that right exactly man all right um so

play41:38

we got four got four what's the big one

play41:39

to round it out so I used to be um very

play41:43

big on periodization training in terms

play41:47

of you know it's going to produce more

play41:49

muscle mass be

play41:51

stronger uh the research on

play41:55

periodization

play41:57

for um bodybuilding and

play42:00

strength is pretty disappointing in

play42:03

terms of like actually producing more

play42:05

lean mass and more strength um the

play42:08

research pretty much shows that the

play42:11

studies that show that like forms of

play42:14

periodization produce more muscle mass

play42:16

are confounded by the fact that those

play42:18

people did more volume um now I think

play42:22

here's the caveat I think periodization

play42:24

can be useful to allow you to do more

play42:28

volume over time because if you're

play42:30

periodize if if you're periodizing

play42:34

appropriately um it's kind of building

play42:38

in these times where you're doing a

play42:39

little bit less allowing yourself to

play42:41

recover you know if you're just jimro it

play42:44

and going in and going hard every single

play42:46

session I mean you may not be recovering

play42:51

appropriately and you might end up

play42:53

having acute injuries um your

play42:55

performance May decrease you know what I

play42:58

really like is kind of like a flexible

play43:00

model of

play43:01

periodization that also has components

play43:03

of Auto regulation with it which is

play43:05

essentially something like the following

play43:06

which is

play43:08

um if I normally squat on Monday right

play43:13

and I go in and I'm warming up and I'm

play43:15

really sore and it just feels like crap

play43:18

you know everybody's had those days

play43:20

where you're like warming up and you're

play43:21

like man I don't have it today then I'm

play43:24

just going to move that session to

play43:25

another day

play43:26

like I'll just I'll I'll do that on

play43:28

another day or if like like yesterday I

play43:30

was on a plane for 5 hours I'm not going

play43:33

to get off the plane and go squat you

play43:35

know like I've had that experience

play43:37

before it's not it's not a great idea

play43:39

been there um so really what the

play43:43

research shows is that it matters way

play43:47

less and it may not matter at

play43:49

all how you structure your weekly

play43:52

workouts what matters is just getting

play43:53

the work in during the week

play43:56

so I'll throw things all around like I

play43:58

have my kind of outline of how I want to

play44:00

do things but like I said if I have a

play44:03

heavy gym session on tap for squats and

play44:05

I go in and I know I just don't have it

play44:07

that

play44:08

day okay maybe I'll wait another day or

play44:12

two days and go in and do it later when

play44:13

I feel better then I can do more weight

play44:17

uh put the muscle under more tension and

play44:19

over time maybe that leads to more gains

play44:21

right and then uh just Auto regulation

play44:25

in terms of you know you're just going

play44:28

to go through times where stuff doesn't

play44:30

move as well especially when it comes to

play44:32

like powerlifting you know it's I saw a

play44:35

meme yesterday from there's an account

play44:36

called subpar powerlifting memes and

play44:38

they they're actually pretty funny and

play44:40

it has like a toggle of three buttons

play44:43

squat bench press deadlift and which are

play44:46

going well and you can only have two

play44:48

green at the same time right

play44:51

like like when you're a beginner yes all

play44:53

of them are going to improve but as you

play44:55

get more advanced this has been my

play44:58

experience very much it's very rare that

play44:59

all three lifts are feeling good at the

play45:01

same time for me you know it's usually

play45:03

like uh squats and bench are going well

play45:06

and deadlifts feel like ass you know or

play45:08

deadlift and squat is going well and

play45:10

bench press is not going well you know

play45:12

it's just it's hard to get consistent

play45:14

improvements on all of them so I think

play45:17

when I was younger I would really get

play45:19

hung up on trying to force myself to hit

play45:22

weights that I had in my mind and it got

play45:23

me in a lot of trouble and now go and

play45:26

it's actually easier cuz I use a a bar

play45:28

velocity device called a rep one

play45:30

strength pretty cool yeah so I people in

play45:33

every video are like what is that you

play45:34

know um basically by measuring bar

play45:37

velocity I know what certain weights

play45:40

should move at on average for me and so

play45:43

when I'm warming up if I hit up my you

play45:46

know my heavy my heaviest warm-up set

play45:48

and I'm like my velocity is down by 20%

play45:51

I'm like and it and also it doesn't feel

play45:54

good I'm like okay I just don't have it

play45:56

today I'm I don't doggedly stick to that

play45:59

like today I was doing bench press and I

play46:01

did my last heavy warmup which was

play46:03

315 and it was about 15% slower than

play46:07

usual but I misg groved it I didn't get

play46:10

in the right spot on the bench like I

play46:11

just felt like it didn't feel heavy but

play46:14

it was slower so I'm like okay I'm G to

play46:18

I'm not going to go with a big increase

play46:20

but I'm going to go ahead and go for a

play46:22

weight that I know should be there

play46:24

because I I don't think that it's

play46:26

necessarily a problem but having um that

play46:30

to just give a little bit more objective

play46:32

feedback has really helped me and so

play46:34

again like I'll just Auto regulate my

play46:36

sessions where it's like okay if I've if

play46:39

I'm hitting them if it feels good the

play46:41

numbers are moving fast it's like okay

play46:43

I'm going to be more aggressive today

play46:44

right I'm obviously recovering well um

play46:48

for whatever reason I'm in a good spot

play46:50

at this

play46:51

session and you don't need a bar

play46:53

velocity unit to do that you can video

play46:55

your your lifts I mean just even your

play46:57

subjective feedback is important um and

play47:01

so just learning to kind of take what's

play47:05

there especially as you get more

play47:06

advanced is really important because so

play47:09

many of my injuries have occurred or

play47:13

aggravation of those injuries have

play47:14

occurred when I was trying to force

play47:16

myself to hit weights that I probably

play47:19

had no business trying to hit on those

play47:21

particular days so bringing it back to

play47:24

periodization I think period is still a

play47:26

useful tool from the perspective that it

play47:30

can help you set up your training in

play47:32

such a way that you can optimize your

play47:34

recovery better but I don't think

play47:37

there's anything inherently present in

play47:39

it that makes it Superior to just going

play47:43

in and training hard and the the one

play47:45

thing I love this from Mike isra I saw

play47:47

this a couple years ago which

play47:49

was you can try to optimize your program

play47:53

as much as you want 9 5% of it is going

play47:56

in and training hard you can't out

play47:58

science hard training like you have to

play48:00

you have to go hard like that and

play48:02

there's I see that with so many people

play48:04

whether it's diet whether it's training

play48:06

it's like how do I get the stuff I want

play48:09

without doing hard things and it's like

play48:13

good luck you know maybe you have some

play48:16

small success but for the most part I

play48:18

mean when you how much weight did you

play48:20

lose overall getting sick with the

play48:23

parasite from your I just recently had a

play48:25

parasite talking about that so I lost 17

play48:27

lbs with the parasite but it's a great

play48:29

way to lose that actually is an easy way

play48:31

it's just not

play48:32

fun no I lost about 100 pounds yeah yeah

play48:35

H and my guess is like looking back the

play48:38

bulk of it was it's just you

play48:40

consistently doing stuff every day and

play48:41

building habits that changed your life

play48:43

right it was all consistency right

play48:45

exactly so I think that you know we love

play48:49

to get hung up on hacks and tricks and

play48:53

mechanisms and stuff and all that

play48:55

stuff's cool and there are some things

play48:56

out there they that might have a small

play48:58

effect but really the the blunt force to

play49:02

change things is just you being willing

play49:04

to get uncomfortable and do hard stuff

play49:05

over time definitely man well on that

play49:08

note man that's a uh where can everyone

play49:09

find outwork nutrition where can

play49:11

everyone find you and uh yeah man yeah

play49:14

so um you know Instagram is kind of my

play49:16

digital business card uh just biolane on

play49:19

Instagram and then outward nutrition is

play49:21

just outward nutrition.com um and then I

play49:24

also have helped create a nutrition app

play49:27

called carbon diet coach uh which

play49:29

basically takes like the coaching I do

play49:33

and kind of automates it into an app and

play49:36

um that's been extremely successful

play49:39

we've had tons of people use it I mean

play49:42

they won't let me say the actual number

play49:43

but it's a lot um and it's got great

play49:46

reviews in the App Store super easy to

play49:48

use and um the cool thing about it is

play49:50

yeah you track your food and all that

play49:51

kind of stuff but the app not only gives

play49:55

you you recommendations to hit but then

play49:57

it modifies those recommendations based

play49:59

on how you progress which makes it

play50:02

different from things like my fitness

play50:03

pal which will give you one time

play50:05

calculation but it's not going to modify

play50:06

based on how you progress so um that's

play50:09

been cool to see how many people that

play50:10

can help um because it it really like I

play50:14

love like our coaching team where we we

play50:17

have one-on-one coaching and that's

play50:19

nothing will ever replace like having

play50:20

another human being as support but for

play50:23

people who can't afford that level um

play50:25

you know having something at 10 bucks a

play50:26

month which is what carbon is I mean

play50:28

that's a you know great option no

play50:30

definitely and it's got keto application

play50:32

stuff that I've used it a time pretty

play50:34

awesome we have a keto option we have a

play50:36

low carb option we have a low fat option

play50:38

we have balanced we have plant-based

play50:40

it's so funny one of the things I tell

play50:41

people it's like how can you say that

play50:43

I'm anti- low carb when literally the

play50:46

only VAR diet variation that has two

play50:48

options on my app is low

play50:51

carb you have a fiary obligation to not

play50:54

be low exactly as always man thanks

play50:56

brother absolutely

Rate This

5.0 / 5 (0 votes)

関連タグ
Nutrition AdviceSupplementationHealth TipsFitness MindsetProtein SynthesisIntermittent FastingElectrolyte BalanceMuscle GrowthHealth ScienceWellness Journey
英語で要約が必要ですか?