Can Capitalism Solve World Hunger?
Summary
TLDRThis video script critiques the capitalist system's role in perpetuating world hunger, despite sufficient food production. It highlights food waste at various stages, from farm to consumer, driven by market prices and commodification. The script also discusses the impact of globalization and international policies on local agriculture, creating dependency and scarcity. The narrator emphasizes that individual actions are insufficient to solve systemic issues, suggesting that capitalism's focus on profit over abundance is the core problem.
Takeaways
- 🚀 Elon Musk's viral tweet about donating $6 billion to solve world hunger was not followed through as promised, and the money was donated to an anonymous charity instead.
- 🌍 World hunger is a massive problem affecting 829 million people, with 25,000 people dying of starvation daily and half of all deaths in children under 5 being caused by a lack of basic nutrients.
- 📈 Despite enough food being produced to feed 10 billion people, the issue is not food production but how food is treated as a commodity and the resulting food waste.
- 🍅 Around one third of the food produced globally is wasted, totaling about 1.3 billion tons per year, with waste occurring at all stages of the supply chain.
- 🌾 Farmers often leave food to rot in the ground due to market price fluctuations, making it unprofitable to harvest, and they may also artificially limit supply to raise prices.
- 🥦 Aesthetic standards in the food industry lead to the discarding of produce with blemishes or bruises, treating food as a commodity rather than a necessity.
- 🏪 Grocery stores contribute to food waste by overbuying to create an illusion of abundance and discarding food near or past expiration dates, often destroying it to avoid liability.
- 🏘️ Food deserts exist where access to fresh food is difficult, often in poorer areas where setting up grocery stores or public transportation is less profitable.
- 🌳 The global capitalist economy has led to the exploitation of resource-rich but money-poor countries, creating a dependency on wealthier nations for food and resources.
- 🌐 The current system of capitalism prioritizes profits over feeding people, making it incompatible with solving world hunger as it relies on scarcity for economic gain.
Q & A
What was Elon Musk's viral tweet about and what was the outcome?
-Elon Musk's viral tweet was about his willingness to donate $6 billion if someone could show him how it could solve world hunger. The outcome was that someone did provide a plan that could save 42 million people on the brink of starvation. However, Musk asked for more details and stopped tweeting about it once the details were provided, ultimately donating the money to an anonymous charity instead of the organization that could have saved those lives.
What is the current global situation regarding world hunger?
-World hunger is a massive problem affecting approximately 829 million people, which is about 10% of the global population. Each day, around 25,000 people die of starvation, and half of all deaths in children under 5 are caused by a lack of basic nutrients. The numbers have been increasing in recent years, with countries like Yemen, South Sudan, Ethiopia, and Nigeria facing brutal famines.
Why does world hunger persist despite sufficient food production?
-World hunger persists not because of a lack of food production, but due to how food is treated as a commodity. Issues like food waste, commodification, and the prioritization of profits over human needs contribute to the problem. We currently produce enough food to feed 10 billion people, but the distribution and waste of food are significant issues.
What is the role of food waste in the global hunger problem?
-Food waste plays a significant role in the global hunger problem. About one-third of the food produced globally never gets eaten, which equates to 1.3 billion tons of waste every year. This waste occurs at various stages of the supply chain, from farms to grocery stores, and is often driven by economic factors rather than actual need.
Why do farmers leave food to rot in the ground?
-Farmers often leave food to rot in the ground due to market price fluctuations. When prices drop over a growing season, the value of produce declines, making it unprofitable to hire the labor required to harvest the food. Farmers may also artificially limit the supply of food to raise prices, leading to waste.
How does the commodification of food affect food waste?
-The commodification of food leads to waste because food is treated as a product to be sold rather than a necessity to be consumed. This results in practices like overbuying by grocery stores, discarding food that doesn't meet aesthetic standards, and prioritizing sales over reducing waste.
What is the impact of 'ugly produce' delivery services on food waste and food banks?
-While 'ugly produce' delivery services like Imperfect Foods or Misfit Markets seem to address food waste, they often outbid food banks and other food service organizations, snatching up slightly imperfect produce for cheap. This diverts produce that wasn't going to be wasted away from those in need, potentially hurting food banks and not effectively solving the food waste problem.
Why do grocery stores contribute to food waste?
-Grocery stores contribute to food waste by relying on the illusion of abundance as a selling tool and by holding onto food until the last second determined by expiration dates. They often overbuy produce to use as window dressing, knowing that a significant portion will be thrown away. Additionally, they may destroy food rather than give it away to avoid potential liability from food poisoning lawsuits.
What are 'food deserts' and how do they contribute to food insecurity?
-Food deserts are areas where access to food, especially fresh produce, is particularly difficult. They are typically found in poorer areas where setting up a grocery store or public transportation to a grocery store is less profitable. The absence of grocery stores in these areas contributes to food insecurity, as residents have limited access to affordable, nutritious food.
How has capitalism influenced global hunger and food production?
-Capitalism, as the dominant economic system, prioritizes profits and scarcity, which is incompatible with the goal of feeding everyone. Wealthy countries have used economic policies to exploit developing countries, undermining their agricultural capacity and creating a dependency. This has led to situations where countries cannot autonomously produce their own food, despite having the resources, leading to increased global hunger.
Outlines
🤔 The Myth of Solved World Hunger
This paragraph humorously addresses the myth that Elon Musk solved world hunger by donating $6 billion, which was intended to save 42 million people from starvation. The narrative then shifts to highlight the actual alarming statistics of global hunger, emphasizing that despite producing enough food for everyone, about a third of it is wasted. The focus is on the commodification of food and how it contributes to food waste and hunger. The paragraph also points out the irony of food waste at various stages of the supply chain, from farms to consumers, and the economic motivations behind these practices.
🍅 The Ugly Truth About Food Waste
This paragraph delves into the issue of food waste, particularly at the farm and grocery store levels. It discusses how market pressures and aesthetic standards lead to the discarding of food that is not 'pretty enough.' The paragraph also critiques the business models of companies that sell 'ugly produce,' arguing that they often outbid food banks and exacerbate the problem. Grocery stores are highlighted for their role in food waste, using the illusion of abundance to drive sales and discarding food near its expiration date to maintain this illusion. The paragraph underscores the systemic issues in food distribution that prioritize profits over feeding people.
🏘️ Food Deserts and the Global Hunger Problem
This paragraph explores the concept of food deserts, areas where access to fresh produce is limited, and attributes their existence to economic decisions that prioritize profitability over necessity. It discusses how these areas are often located in poorer neighborhoods, where setting up grocery stores is less profitable. The paragraph also connects the local food waste and hunger issues to broader global problems, explaining how international economic policies have historically disadvantaged developing countries, leading to a dependency on wealthier nations for food. The narrative criticizes the capitalist system for creating scarcity and undermining local agricultural capacities.
🌐 Capitalism and the Inequality in Food Distribution
The final paragraph focuses on the role of capitalism in global hunger, arguing that the system's focus on profit and scarcity is incompatible with the goal of feeding everyone. It describes how wealthy countries have historically exploited developing nations for natural resources, leading to a loss of autonomous agricultural capacity. The paragraph provides examples of how this exploitation has led to local food insecurity and environmental damage. It concludes by emphasizing the need to address the systemic issues in food production and distribution, rather than blaming individuals for food waste.
Mindmap
Keywords
💡World Hunger
💡Food Insecurity
💡Commodification of Food
💡Food Waste
💡Supply and Demand
💡Food Deserts
💡Capitalism
💡IMF and World Bank
💡Agricultural Subsidies
💡Food Banks
💡Overconsumption
Highlights
Elon Musk's viral tweet about donating $6 billion to solve world hunger and the subsequent lack of action.
World hunger affects approximately 829 million people, a number equivalent to 10% of the global population.
Around 25,000 people die daily from starvation, and half of all child deaths under 5 are due to a lack of basic nutrients.
Food insecurity in the U.S. affects at least 38 million people and around 8% of children.
Globally, we produce enough food to feed 10 billion people, indicating a problem with food distribution rather than production.
Approximately one third of global food production is wasted, totaling 1.3 billion tons annually.
Food waste occurs at all stages of the supply chain, not just at the consumer level.
Farmers often leave food to rot in the ground due to market price fluctuations making labor costs unprofitable.
Pandemic-related economic crashes led to food being destroyed while people experienced shortages.
Aesthetic standards lead to the discarding of 'ugly' produce, contributing to food waste.
Companies that sell 'ugly' produce may actually be diverting food away from food banks and those in need.
Grocery stores contribute to food waste by relying on the illusion of abundance and by discarding food past its sell-by date.
Food deserts are areas with limited access to fresh produce, often resulting from decisions that prioritize profit over necessity.
The global capitalist economy has created dependencies that undermine local food production in favor of profit.
Western countries and China have been involved in undermining the agricultural capacity of the global south.
The capitalist system's drive for profit is at odds with the goal of eliminating world hunger.
Individual action alone cannot solve systemic food waste and hunger issues.
Storyblocks is a platform providing royalty-free assets for video production, essential for the creation of this content.
Transcripts
this episode is made possible by story
blocks i gotta be honest i don't even
know why i'm making this video elon musk
already solved world hunger last year
you remember he had that viral tweet
where he said he'd donate 6 billion
dollars if anyone could tell him how it
would work then someone actually did
tell him how and figured out that six
billion dollars while not ending world
hunger would save a whopping 42 million
people on the brink of starvation
roughly the population of spain and then
musk freaked out and asked for more
details and completely coincidentally
stopped tweeting about it immediately
once those details were actually
produced and it started to look like he
would actually have to follow through on
something for once instead of being a
little clout goblin trying to cover up
whatever horrible thing he did that week
but then instead of following through he
donated those six billion dollars to an
anonymous charity while the organization
that was going to let me remind you save
42 million people got nothing oh and
then it turned out that the whole thing
was probably just a tax avoidance scheme
wait did i say musk already solved world
hunger my bad i got confused the thing
is that in theory everyone wants to
solve world hunger it's a massive 829
million people sized problem that's
roughly 10 of everyone alive right now
just to put that in perspective if you
put all those people in the largest
stadium in the u.s michigan stadium
they'd spill out everywhere and be upset
with you
but in all seriousness the numbers are
genuinely alarming each and every day
around 25 000 people die of starvation
and it's estimated that half of all
deaths in children under 5 3.1 million
deaths a year are caused by a lack of
basic nutrients and tragically it's not
just that the numbers of this global
disaster are awful in recent years
they've actually started going up
several countries in particular like
yemen south sudan ethiopia and nigeria
are currently facing brutal famines here
in the u.s food insecurity affects at
least 38 million people and around 8
percent of children the problem with
these ghastly statistics is that there's
no good reason for them to be so dire we
actually have enough food for everyone
by some estimates we currently produce
enough to feed 10 billion people not
only more than the roughly 7.8 billion
people on the planet right now
but enough for the extreme estimate of
what the global population might get to
at some point in the future in other
words we don't have a food production
problem what we really have is a problem
of how we treat food and that is as a
commodity
the first place we need to start looking
for solutions to world hunger is in food
waste and how that relates to the
commodification of food
around one third of the food we produce
globally never gets eaten which is equal
to about 1.3 billion tons of waste every
year while we're often told that this is
a consumer problem something we're doing
wrong at home if we just steal this
graphic from the very talented are
changing climate we can see that waste
isn't just happening in this final stage
but rather all along the supply chain
let's start at the farm
around 16 of the food that is produced
gets wasted right at the beginning part
of that is unavoidable but a lot of it
can be explained by just a few
ridiculous facts
the first is that farmers leave a
tremendous amount of food to rot in the
ground in total about 34 of the food
grown according to at least one study
that's not because that food is bad it's
the same as all the other food they've
grown
it's because of something really dumb
market prices dropping over the course
of a single growing season between early
season and late season the value of
produce just declines in response to
things like an increase in the supply
these lower prices make hiring the labor
required to pull the food from the
ground too expensive since it no longer
delivers enough of a profit therefore
farmers can't afford the final step of
the farming process and are even
incentivized to artificially limit the
supply of food to raise the price back
up which they do by letting it literally
rot
in both cases whether it's not being
able to afford labor or playing the
supply and demand game it's prices that
put farmers in an uncomfortable position
all the time effort and resources that
went into growing the food doing the
hard part of making the things we eat
goes to waste not because it is no
longer needed as we know from how many
people are food insecure
but because price fluctuations make it
no longer profitable it's absurd
during the pandemic we saw just how bad
this can get when farmers dumped literal
truckloads of milk and destroyed entire
fields of crops at the same time as
americans experienced one of the most
sudden food shortages in living memory
you probably remember that food banks
had lines around the block people needed
food and the food was there for the
taking but an economic crash suddenly
made it unprofitable to provide it so it
was destroyed it's like if you did all
the work to buy i don't know random
example a social media company and then
tried to pull out at the last second
after the stock price had dropped
because you're not a very good
businessman
except somehow food waste isn't nearly
as silly as something like that we're
talking about how people get fed here
okay let's see my to-do list
go to work go to work go to work go to
work go to work those are the first
visible problems with subjecting food to
market pressures and then there's all
the food that's thrown out because it's
not pretty enough farmers know that in
order to fetch the highest prices from
their buyers and their buyers from
individual consumers in turn they need
to discard produce that has any
blemishes bruises or aesthetic flaws
here again we see the issue with
treating food like a commodity with the
standards of industrial production a lot
of food gets wasted not because it's
inedible or unsafe but because it's not
competitive enough a notion that's hard
to even wrap your head around when what
we're talking about here is a zucchini
the zucchini isn't competing hard enough
think about that for a second
interestingly you might think that this
is actually a case where the market has
come up with a solution to this problem
in the last few years we've seen a
sudden explosion in at-home delivery of
quote-unquote ugly produce with brands
like imperfect foods or misfit markets
these brands have capitalized on this
growing knowledge about food waste and
seem to be doing something good about it
but unfortunately a closer look into
these companies reveals that their
business model isn't actually solving
this problem what these brands actually
do is outbid food banks and other food
service organizations and snatch up the
slightly uglier produce for cheap in
order to sell it for more directly to
consumers in other words ugly food at
home delivery diverts produce that
wasn't going to be wasted away from
those in need meaning we still have an
ugly food problem but now it's also
hurting food banks continuing along the
food supply chain the next important
place that food gets wasted is in
grocery stores here food gets wasted in
two big ways the first is because
grocery stores rely on the illusion of
abundance as a selling tool the apple at
the top of a glossy red pyramid built
with the decaying flesh of its brothers
is more appealing to us than the last
apple in the box decaying all on its own
like a sad little loner we are reluctant
to buy the last piece of produce because
we assume something is wrong with it
instead of the more reasonable
conclusion that it just happens to be
the only one left so grocery stores make
sure it never gets to that point grocery
stores are more motivated by sales than
by reducing waste meaning they'll
overbuy to use produce as nothing more
than window dressing knowing full well
that a big chunk of what they've bought
will just go in the trash and let's talk
about just how much goes in the trash
that's point number two you've probably
seen these clips of grocery store
dumpsters filled to the brim with food
perfect beautiful often completely
sealed in a pristine plastic package
ready to eat food you've probably also
seen that sometimes these stockpiles
will get locked drenched in bleach or
even guarded by police here again we see
the problem of food being treated as a
commodity grocery stores hold on to food
until the very last second they can sell
it something that's usually determined
by an expiration date that isn't
standardized or regulated in most places
in the u.s and that producers not only
determine on their own most of the time
but have an incentive to undershoot as
much as possible so stores will restock
faster and buy more
for grocery stores the minute the food
is no longer a product in their eyes
regardless of how good the food inside
the packaging is it is immediately
considered waste it is useless to the
grocery store so it makes no difference
if it gets destroyed without a way to
treat food humanely without a network in
place that can properly use the food
while it's good instead of only treating
the food as something that absolutely
needs to be bought and sold the atomized
units of the farm the grocery store and
the consumer each respond to their own
incentives rather than work together
with the collective interest of feeding
everyone and not wasting the food that
took so much effort to produce everyone
is just trying to maximize their profits
and or minimize their costs even when
that means throwing perfectly good food
away
when you look online to try to find an
explanation for why in the world this
food gets bleached or guarded by
apparently heartless people with guns
the one you'll usually find is because
it could become a liability for grocery
stores if someone gets poisoned and they
decide to sue
while this explanation makes some sense
there's no clear evidence it's the
motivation behind bleaching dumpsters
and yet it nonetheless reveals our
structural problem
as a unit looking out only for its
monetary self-interest the grocery store
can only treat food and by extension
potential lawsuits as economic inputs as
numbers that need to be balanced out by
maximizing sales and minimizing costs
this precludes it from feeding people
who need to be fed because feeding for
free brings in no money and if they sue
could theoretically even cost money
there is no overarching structure that
handles food distribution only prices
and that means destroying food is fine
so long as it doesn't cost anyone money
this logic of prioritizing profits is
also why nearly 40 million americans
live in food deserts while we can talk
about grocery store waste for hours on
end the absence of grocery stores is
also a problem if this is your first
time hearing the term food deserts are
places where food is especially
difficult to access especially fresh
produce and it's a distinction typically
determined by the distance and available
transportation between households and
grocers unlike what the term food desert
implies however these are not natural
phenomena food deserts are the product
of decisions made by governments and
business owners their place is usually
where poorer americans live and
therefore places where setting up a
grocery store or some sort of public
transportation system to get to a
grocery store is less profitable not
less necessary just less profitable
putting a whole foods somewhere only a
few people will afford it makes less
fiscal sense than building a second one
in a wealthy neighborhood even though
the food supply is already abundant
altogether the incentives that appear at
the farm and at the grocery store or at
the place where the grocery store should
have been means that a lot of food never
makes it into our hands and that is a
big part of the reason we have a global
hunger problem but the final stage of
the food supply chain is where most of
the food waste tends to happen
once we've bought the food and it's on
our plate there's a good chance it won't
make the short journey up to the biggest
of our face holes awareness of this fact
has been growing in the past few decades
with public messaging campaigns
emphasizing our need to waste less and
using many of the same statistics you've
seen in this video a similarity of a lot
of these anti-waste campaigns though is
their focus on guilting people shaming
those who don't eat all the food they
buy which is to say all of us telling us
it is our fault that so much food is
being wasted and while it is true that
we can make an effort to waste less and
should be aware of how much of what we
buy goes in the trash pinning this
problem on the individual is a clever
way to try to avoid a more systemic
question like with climate change the
blame for very big problems is often
pinned on atomized individuals because
it takes the blame off a system that is
measurably more at fault as i explained
in this video consumer decisions are
made within a context that facilitates
and often outright necessitates hurting
the environment in these campaigns we
can see how the same goes for food waste
we live in a world built for over
consumption and therefore for food waste
since the 1960s and 70s supermarkets
have stocked 10 times more large-sized
food products plates have increased 36
percent in size refrigerators have
gotten 30 percent bigger and cost half
as much entire companies like costco
have popped up to sell food in excessive
bulk and we are of course under a
constant barrage of ads inciting us to
consume more and it's not just that
there's tremendous pressure to purchase
more and subtle nudges that make
reasonable consumption seem like it's
too little it's often simply cheaper to
over buy and waste than to buy in
appropriate quantities two for one deals
and now with 30 more slogans on our
shredded cheese bags make that clear
virtually everything is pushing us
towards over consumption it's simply not
enough to resist these pressures at the
individual level not only does this
individualistic approach fail to
recognize the incredible amount of money
poured into advertising and marketing to
achieve this specific goal at the end of
the day it leaves intact a system that
incentivizes producers to target some of
us for overconsumption while leaving
others out to dry individual action
isn't the problem the drive to always
increase profits is
up until now this video has been focused
on what hunger looks like in one country
the us although we can easily find
parallels to what's happening here in
many other individual countries there
are forces that make hunger a more
global problem and to understand those
we have to go back a few years when the
modern global capitalist economy was
entering its present form
starting in the late 70s and 80s two
international institutions led by
western countries the imf and the world
bank started going around the world and
offering resource-rich but money-poor
countries a deal these institutions told
countries that if they wanted to be a
part of the international economy and
maybe get a loan to get them started
they would have to make certain economic
adjustments to fit in with the big boys
in simple terms simple because the
little red bar is about to hit the
rightmost wall of the youtube video and
then i stopped existing countries had to
open up their economies to international
competition they had to invite
international companies to buy up and
control their natural resources
privatize their domestic industries and
generally speaking let the free market
do its thing as you might expect
entering a global competition in which
wealthy countries have a big leg up and
you're told to let the market do
whatever it wants with little to no
intervention meant that plenty of
countries entered into an exploitative
relationship with the wealthy countries
of the global north these wealthy
countries better off after centuries of
robbing the rest of the world used these
deals to siphon off natural resources
from developing countries they then used
these natural resources process them and
sell back the processed products to
developing nations at a higher cost in
agriculture this has meant small-scale
farmers in the global south who have
little to no state investment because of
the adjustments to their economies made
in the 80s technological setbacks and in
some cases less hospitable environments
are asked to compete with european and
american farmers who by contrast benefit
from protectionist tariffs heavy state
subsidies and access to more productive
technology simply put wealthy countries
can bring the prices down on their crops
where others can't except by lowering
wages in practice this makes farmers in
the global south poorer and less able to
buy the processed food they need they
can't feed themselves with the crops
they grow since those are destined for
export this means western countries
sometimes disappointingly joined by
china have effectively killed the
autonomous agricultural capacity of
entire continents over decades and now
that that's done have moved in to
replace it with their own western and
chinese companies move in and set up
their own agribusiness to divert food
produced in africa out of the continent
a lot of the hunger that we see in the
world today is explained by the fact
that a forced dependency has been
created between the wealthy and the poor
that entire countries can no longer
autonomously produce their own food
despite it often growing within their
own borders the process has gotten so
ridiculous that in gambia wild
hand-caught fish is being processed by
foreign-owned factories into a fine
powder that gets exported to feed
farm-raised fish
wild fish are being caught to feed
farmed fish as a result the bonga a fish
that used to be so abundant that it was
distributed freely has gone missing from
gambian diets the bonga has been
overfished the local environment has
been incredibly damaged and locals are
facing food insecurity because the
profits of this industry do not end up
in their hands and the farm-raised fish
is too expensive
what we see in all these examples is an
inhumane way to produce and distribute
food
at the core of the world hunger problem
is the reality that you can't make money
when something's abundant scarcity is
the name of the capitalist game and
capitalism is currently the only force
organizing our food production and
distribution the abolition of scarcity
aka feeding everyone isn't compatible
with this system so long as that's true
so long as capitalism is allowed to
survive we have no hope of solving world
hunger
over the years i've had a lot of people
ask me how i make my videos particularly
they want to know where i get all my
footage the answer is story blocks
storyblocks is one of the most
well-known platforms for sourcing
royalty-free assets like stock footage
after effects templates music images and
sound effects for people like me who
need to cover a lot of material but
don't have the budget of hollywood films
or big production houses being able to
lean on story blocks and their massive
library of content is a game changer it
allows me to make the videos i want to
make without sacrificing my vision due
to time budget or resource constraints
if i'm being perfectly honest there's no
way i could make my videos without
storyblocks and the footage they provide
i use a ton of stock footage in my
videos so i'm constantly downloading
shots from storyblocks and the best part
is the vast majority of their catalog
doesn't scream stock footage like a lot
of other sites their footage is high
quality professional and covers just
about every topic you could ever need
from aerials to city life to professions
manufacturing and more and if you do
happen to want a meme shot they have
those too if you're looking to get
started making videos like mine i highly
recommend you give storyblocks a try
they've got flexible subscription plans
for every budget and if you're like me
and you need literally hours of stock
footage their unlimited all-access plan
gives you the freedom to download and
use as many assets as you want so if
you'd like to help support my channel
and get access to one of my absolute
favorite video production resources
visit storyblocks.com second thought and
give it a try today
if you enjoyed this video consider
dropping a like if you hated it a thumbs
down you can check out my previous
content by clicking the links on your
screen thanks for watching and i'll see
you next week
[Music]
関連動画をさらに表示
Malnutrition and World Hunger: A Guide To Global Issues | Global Citizen
Biyayang hatid ng mga ‘pagpag’ na pagkain (Full episode) | Reporter’s Notebook
GM crops are not the answer to world hunger
The Real Trap of Consumerism
Understanding the Food Supply Chain
Food and Textiles Studies G9 U2L1 Definition of sustainable food production and consumption
5.0 / 5 (0 votes)