Kata Sujiwo Tejo Tentang Sound Horeg Sebagai Budaya | Catatan Demokrasi tvOne

Summary

This transcript discusses the challenges and cultural dynamics surrounding public events in a local community. It highlights the balance between traditional practices and modern concerns, especially regarding sound disturbances. The conversation touches on community deliberations, social contributions, and the impact of noise, such as during religious or cultural events. There’s also a broader commentary on public reactions to noise and visual distractions, including political campaigning and social media perceptions. The debate incorporates diverse viewpoints on noise, community needs, and cultural preservation, framed within a lively exchange of opinions and reflections.

Takeaways

• 😀 Local community events in Catan Demokrasi can cost between 20 to 35 million for a 2-day duration, with each day lasting 7 to 8 hours.
• 😀 Contributions for events come from the community, and there is a consensus built from the local levels, including RT and RW.
• 😀 Complaints about community events mainly come from those who are unaware of the reality on the ground, especially regarding sound systems in village areas.
• 😀 Proceeds from entrance fees and parking during events are often allocated for social purposes, such as funding orphanages and mosque construction.
• 😀 The local community itself decides on the organization of events, including the sound levels, not event organizers (EO).
• 😀 Complaints about noise from elderly or babies are acknowledged, but the community has agreed to balance these concerns with event coordination.
• 😀 A viral image showing damage from an event was attributed to lack of coordination, not the event itself.
• 😀 The sound issues, particularly 'horek' sound, are seen as a cultural phenomenon rather than just noise, with the presence of subwoofers causing vibration effects.
• 😀 A 135 decibel reading from an event was measured, which is lower than the threshold for sound complaints but still loud, comparable to the sound of an airplane.
• 😀 The script discusses the balance between respecting different forms of sound in the community, including religious calls to prayer, and the impact of events like those held in temples or by political campaigns.

Q & A

What is the purpose of the event at Catan Demokrasi?

The event at Catan Demokrasi is intended to bring local people together for a community gathering and is designed to raise funds for social activities, such as supporting orphanages, mosque construction, and purchasing ambulances.

How long is the event, and how is it structured?

The event lasts for 2 days, with the first day lasting 7 hours and the second day lasting 8 hours, for a total of 15 hours.

Is there a significant amount of money involved in organizing the event?

No, the maximum contribution for the event is around 70 million Rupiah, with contributions being made by neighborhood units (RT) and individuals as part of the community culture.

How are the community’s concerns about the event addressed?

The community members participate in deliberations and reach a consensus on issues like noise and event management. This collaborative approach ensures that any concerns, such as disturbances to elderly people or babies, are considered and managed.

Why do some people complain about the event?

People who complain are typically those who are unaware of the realities of the situation. Some complaints focus on noise or sound issues, but these concerns arise from misunderstandings of the purpose and the community’s role in organizing the event.

What role does the sound system play in the event, and how is it managed?

The sound system plays a major role in the event's entertainment, but its use is limited by the local community’s agreement on appropriate volume levels. The sound system, known for its strong vibrations, is sometimes referred to as 'sound horek,' which is a Javanese term.

What happens when the sound system causes disturbances?

When disturbances occur, such as the noise affecting local residents, the community seeks to manage the situation through coordination and socialization, ensuring that the event aligns with local expectations.

What issues were raised about the event during the discussion?

The main issues discussed included noise levels, particularly from the sound system, and how the event might disturb local residents. There were also concerns about the lack of coordination between the organizers and the local committee.

What is the cultural significance of the 'horek' sound?

The 'horek' sound, which is associated with the subwoofer vibrations of the sound system, is considered a form of local wisdom and is accepted in the community. It's part of a broader cultural experience, even though it can be disruptive if not managed properly.

How do local authorities view the events and the 'horek' sound?

Local authorities, like the MUI (Indonesian Ulema Council), have mixed views. While some see the event as a cultural tradition, others, including religious figures, believe that the loud sound can interfere with worship and the comfort of the community.