The Truth About The Lumix S9
Summary
TLDRビデオ脚本を分析し、その要約を提供します。このビデオでは、Lumix S9カメラについての議論が中心です。多くのユーチューバーがこのカメラについて真実を曲げたと批判されていますが、実際のカメラの利点と欠点について客観的に分析し、評価します。また、カメラの価格帯やその他のカメラと比較して、なぜS9は価値があると思われる人もいるのか、そしてなぜ人々が不満を持つのかを考察します。最後に、ビデオ制作者である彼自身の意見を述べ、S9が彼にとって適切でない理由を説明します。
Takeaways
- 📷 Panasonic Lumix S9は、コミュニティ内で議論の的となり、多くの人が注目しているカメラモデルです。
- 🔥 過去のビデオで誤解があり、実際はS9についての真の意見を述べなかったと主張しています。
- 👍 Lumixカメラは評価が高いとされ、特にGH5はその人にとって最高のカメラモデルだと述べています。
- 🤔 S9は客観的に見る必要があり、それがこのビデオの目的として挙げられています。
- 💰 S9は1500ドルの価格帯でフルフレームボディで4Kや6Kの撮影が可能で、ハイブリッドズームオプションを持つなどの特徴が紹介されています。
- 👀 S9は特に新しいビデオクリエイターや高校卒業生など、新しいカメラを探している人に適したオプションになる可能性があるとされています。
- 🚫 S9にはいくつかの問題点も指摘されており、特にビデオの記録制限が2024年には許容できないと批判されています。
- 🔍 他のカメラモデルと比較して、S9は記録制限や電子ビューファインダーの欠如、機械式シャッターの欠如などによって他のモデルに劣るとの意見も述べられています。
- 👨💼 YouTuberやコンテンツクリエイターはビジネスとして活動しており、時には製品を評価する際に注意を払う必要があると指摘されています。
- 💬 コミュニティからのフィードバックを受け入れるべきで、それが製品の改善につながるとの見解が示されています。
- 🙌 最後に、視聴者がビジネスと倫理のバランスを理解し、YouTuberも視聴者もお互いにリスペクトし合っていくべきだと結びつけています。
Q & A
ビデオではどのようなトピックが話し合われたのか?
-ビデオでは、Lumix X9(S9)というカメラについての議論が中心で、特にYouTubeコミュニティ内でそのカメラに対する様々な意見が議論されました。
Lumix S9についての主な意見は何ですか?
-Lumix S9は、価格や機能面での価値があると同時に、いくつかの問題点も指摘されています。特にビデオでの記録制限や欠如する電子ビューファインダーなどが提到的缺点として挙げられます。
ビデオで述べられた「elephant in the room」とは何を指していますか?
-「elephant in the room」とは、議論を避けてきたが重要な問題を指しており、この場合はLumix S9についての議論です。
Lumix S9がどのような価格帯で販売されているとビデオで述べられていますか?
-ビデオではLumix S9が1500ドルの価格帯で販売されていると述べられています。
ビデオではなぜLumix S9が初心者や家族に適していると言及されていますか?
-ビデオでは、Lumix S9がフルフレームカメラでありながら手頃な価格帯にあり、家族にPanasonicカメラがいる場合や初心者にとっては価値があると述べられています。
ビデオではYouTuberたちがなぜ批判を受けているのか説明していますか?
-ビデオでは、YouTuberたちがLumix S9に関する批判的な点を軽減したり、マーケティングのために選ばれた観光地でのビデオを紹介することで信頼性に疑問が投げかけられたと説明しています。
ビデオの主張として、技術製品が完璧なことはないという考えはなぜ重要だと述べられていますか?
-技術製品が完璧でないことは、製品の初期バージョンにおいて問題が発生する可能性があることを意味し、消費者がその点を理解し製品の選定を行う際に考慮する必要があると述べられています。
ビデオで紹介されたLumix S9の代替製品には何がありますか?
-ビデオではLumix S5 Mark IIやSony a7c、Sony zv1、Canon R5などのカメラがLumix S9の代替製品として紹介されています。
ビデオの主題は単にカメラのレビューにとどまっているわけではありませんが、その主題は何か?
-ビデオの主題はカメラのレビューに加えて、YouTuberと視聴者との信頼関係、そして製品レビューにおける倫理と真実性のバランスにも触れています。
ビデオではLumix S9に対する個人的な意見とは何ですか?
-ビデオではLumix S9に対する個人的な意見として、記録制限が2024年には許されるべきではないと述べられています。また、代替製品の方が優れていると主張しています。
Outlines
📷 Lumix S9カメラの評価とコミュニティの反応
ビデオクリエイターは、Lumix S9カメラに関する議論を開始し、以前のビデオで誤解を招いたことを認める。彼はLumixカメラを高く評価し、特にGH5を推している。しかし、S9に関しては、コミュニティ内でuproarが起きており、その中には正しいものもあればそうでないものもあると述べる。クリエイターは、S9を客観的に見据えて、人々がこのカメラを愛する理由と怒る理由について話す。また、自分が実際にこのカメラについてどのように考えるかについても触れる。
🤔 YouTuberとLumix S9の評判に関する問題点
クリエイターは、YouTuberたちがLumix S9に関する評価を誤った方法で行い、それがコミュニティ内で問題になっていると指摘する。特に、Lumixが過去のニコンの写真を使用してカメラを宣伝しているという噂についても触れる。また、日本旅行中の体験に基づく評価が、カメラの実際の性能と一致しない可能性があることも指摘する。クリエイターは、YouTuberたちがビジネスとして振る舞うことと、視聴者が彼らを信頼する境界について話し、両者がお互いに理解する必要があると結びつける。
🚫 Lumix S9の欠点と市場への期待
クリエイターはLumix S9の欠点を指摘し、2024年にはカメラに録画制限があることが許されるものではないと主張する。また、EVFの欠落や機械式シャッターの非搭載についても批判する。彼はS9が自分のニーズに合わないと結論づけ、Lumix S5 Mark IIやソニーのa7cなどの他のカメラとの比較も行う。クリエイターは、製品が改善されるためにはフィードバックを受け入れる必要があると述べ、Lumixに向けて製品を改善するよう促す。
👋 Lumix S9に関する総括と今後の展望
ビデオの最後に、クリエイターはLumix S9に関する自分の見解を締めくくり、今後はこのカメラについて話すことはないと宣言する。彼は視聴者がこのトピックに関する意見を持つことを期待し、フィードバックを歓迎する姿勢を示す。また、YouTuberとしての立場とビジネス側の立場をバランスさせる重要性を再確認し、視聴者とYouTuberがお互いに理解し合っていくべきだと結びつける。
Mindmap
Keywords
💡Lumix X9
💡Lumix S9
💡uproar
💡PG-13
💡4K/6K
💡hybrid Zoom
💡Lut feature
💡overheat
💡recording limit
💡viewfinder
Highlights
Addressing the uproar caused by the Lumix S9 in the YouTube community.
Clarifying that the previous video was not about the S9, despite audience speculation.
Lumix S9 has caused a divide in opinions within the community.
The speaker's appreciation for Lumix cameras, particularly the GH5.
The importance of objectivity when discussing camera features.
Lumix S9's features such as 4K/6K recording and hybrid zoom.
Lumix S9's appeal for beginners and those in the Lumix ecosystem.
The speaker's perspective on the S9's overheating and recording limitations.
Acknowledging that no camera is perfect, especially when first released.
Criticism of YouTubers for potentially misleading reviews of the S9.
Concerns about the authenticity of autofocus testing in Lumix marketing.
The impact of personal experiences on camera reviews and trust.
The speaker's personal opinion that the S9 is not suitable for them.
Comparison of the S9 with other cameras like the Lumix S5 Mark II and Sony a7c.
The importance of calling out issues to improve future products.
A call for balance between ethics and truth-telling in product reviews.
The speaker's decision to stop discussing the S9 and focus on other topics.
Transcripts
so I think
um I think we you know we gotta kind of
address the elephant in the room here
right which is going to
be this this this Lumix X9 man Lumix S9
so my last video apparently a lot of
yall thought that like that's what I was
talking about like heavy in that video
and I wasn't to be honest I wasn't
talking about the S9 at all like I you
know just a little bit but not to like
give my my full true thoughts on it
right um because apparently this has
caused a lot of uproar it definitely has
caused an uproar in the community in the
YouTube Community um some stuff was
warranted some stuff wasn't you know
what I mean this you know opinion it's
opinion based that's what YouTube is
however today I want to take a look at
this objectively speaking right because
honestly I love Lumix cameras I had that
gh5 which is still to me the goat if I
was just want to spend my money forly I
go buy another one you know what I mean
like to keep it a buck but I love
everything about the lumit uh I love
everything about my gh5 I had a G7 I had
a G9 like I was a Lumix I was lumus gang
you feel what I'm saying shout out to
Big Cook but my my rule of thumb is this
as we're talking about this camera
objectively if it does not apply then
let it fly you feel what I'm saying like
understand this man with this camera
stuff every camera that's coming out
right now is not made specifically for
you but that also doesn't mean that we
get to give camera passes even if they
may be lackluster in some areas so we're
going to take a look at that today and
it's kind of determ
a couple things about this camera number
one the first thing will to be is why
people may love this camera number two
is going to be why people may be upset
with YouTubers in regards to this camera
and then number three we'll get into
what I actually truly think about this
camera now for those who are new to my
channel let me go ahead and just kind of
give you all some housekeeping rules
here just so you all can know my channel
is PG-13 meaning that we say things such
as hell damn ass it's PG-13 so we
get the occasional F bomb I'm going to
save that for later but other than that
everybody who subscribed to my channel
is at least like 30 and up so we get to
have real conversation like adults i w
hear none of that down in the
comments like oh my God I couldn't I
couldn't watch this video CU of the
cursing like you're an adult I know you
curse if you don't then it's not for you
it's okay welcome welcome to the show I
am your host Shan be nice let's get into
this conversation and since it's a late
night grab you a cup of wine or
something like that shouldn't be too
long but you know it's going to get me
to talk a little bit more truthfully now
why would people love the Lumix S9 first
of all it's you know at the $1500 price
point full frame body does 4K does 6K
takes great steals it has this hybrid
Zoom option when you get to like kind of
take a 28 mil lens and turn to like
something ridiculous like a 640 mil lens
it has a Lut feature type of thing where
you kind of like cycle through L kind of
like how Fuji has like their own like
you know their recipes for the film
emulations where you can kind of create
your own fil film emulations using you
know LS on your camera and just take
pictures to your LS like I mean don't
get me wrong
if someone was just starting out right
so let's just say I have a kid maybe who
just finished 8th grade maybe who's you
know maybe who's going to high school
maybe graduated high school maybe even
graduated high school and they they're
trying to you know they want a camera
they've been doing some reach they're
like man I really want a fullframe
camera you know what I mean this may be
a valuable options for people especially
if somebody's like in your family like
you know who has lumus Camas right let's
say they got family members that are
Lumix Die Hard Lumix fans this is a
camera that Lumix needed this is the
first one out so it's a first one going
to be crazy no I mean if we look at you
know some of Sony's first attempts to
thing like if we look at the Sony zv1
that that camera wasn't perfect when it
first came out if you look at the Canon
R5 that camera wasn't perfect when it
first came out now in all fairness you
know this they kind of been doing
like this for a while but I think that
was kind of first time doing like 8K Raw
on the camera so it was overheating
things like I'm stting out to say that
like when first come out there's
going to be issues like we have to
realize that there's not going to be a
perfect product there's not a single
piece of technology out there that does
not have its faults okay let's go ahead
and just set that Baseline right there
so for somebody who doesn't care about
those faults this this camera may be a
perfect buy for them especially at that
price point and it has a face autofocus
I mean Panasonic has done everything
that essentially we wanted within this
camera I'm not going to say we I don't
want that but what I am saying for
somebody who does who who has been
looking at the camera like this this is
a great valuable option for them um
who's not you know who's not looking to
record content for long and we also have
to keep in mind that because the the way
the humans attention spans are getting
shorter and shorter and shorter you know
a 10 minute 15 minute time recording
limit may not be such a huge deal for
them you know what I mean like again
you're looking at it from your case
needs your your knee case but everybody
doesn't have the same knee case this may
be for somebody who's like on the road
traveling real quick want to get a
couple quick clips and they good and
they gone now that we've looked at that
objectively on why the S9 is a valuable
option for some let's kind of talk about
why it may not be so valuable and why
YouTubers kind of so much flag behind
this camera okay may have to take
another sip of this wine for that also
what do you think about the lighting set
I I actually try I'm trying to I try
like I'm trying I tried with the
lighting set up I really did why were
people finding so much issues with
YouTube YouTubers in regards to this
camera it's not that the content
creators and YouTubers were not um being
truthful about the camera right it's
just the way that it was done and I
think that's the problem when it comes
into like YouTube and ethics thing and
stuff like that and even when lumus
right the that happened with Jared
undone as far as like you know them only
want to rock with him if he going to
talk positive about the camera and I
don't know how true this is but
apparently there's been reports that the
bird photos like for the the autofocus
for like the birds and like that
like apparently that was taking on a
Nikon camera from way back when I guess
and Lumis is using those you know images
to Market their new camera now I'm not
going to lie to you if this is
true yeah I'm going use it now that's
some if this is true if this
is true but if it's not you know again
if it doesn't apply Let it Fly but if it
is come on Lumis bro like that's
unacceptable and then on top of that you
know let's let's think about this right
because some people was kind of like you
know even with the Japan thing which
jald touched on it was a simple fact
that like for example if I had a wedding
let's say I did a wedding and at this
wedding the ceremony was the
getting ready was the portrait
session was I already got no photos
but it comes to reception time got that
open bar me and my homies having a good
time I don't give a about none of
that no more like I about that when I
get to it you know what I mean right now
having a great time this wed it's fun we
we feeling good we got juices flowing
like the same could be said if you send
me on a trip to Japan if you send me on
a trip to Japan I'm with I'm there with
my boy Neil Lopez uh purpose Lind uh Big
Cook uh I'm there like big cook at like
my homie home he he was a cool YouTuber
but like Neil that's my man Neil Lopez I
make sure I link I make sure I link
these YouTubers down description below
I'm if if I'm there with my boy Ben L
Tech like if I'm there with my homies I
don't give a about this camera for
real for real like I'm I'm there having
a good time we looking up we snapping
look cold I got my Luts in like
yeah so you're going to get some
positive you're going to get some
positive feedback on that camera like
just's just go ahead and keep it a buck
now down the line like a wait a
minute I don't know man like when I turn
this motherucker I want to be overheat
like you know you you may run into
situations like that but you know I'm
liquoring you up essentially like and
it's no different than if you know what
I'm saying if one of these dudes running
games on these little chick let me tell
you right now put y on game right now if
you take a chick's mind her body will
follow it's no different than anything
else like this is just the name of the
game if I get you in your right your
right mind State you going to say what I
need you to say like you going to agree
what what I need you agree on you
goingon to like what I need you to like
cuz you feeling good I've done
psychological one-on-one on you and it's
working out that's just how the
Works bro it just is what it is and this
is the perfect example of don't hate the
player hate the game so you have people
getting upset with these YouTub because
they're like since they gloss over like
some of the biggest cons for this camera
it makes them kind of come off as
untrustworthy or like they're being paid
or bought now nine times of the 10 these
YouTubers were not paid to be on this
trip like more than likely these are the
personal expenses they did for
themselves kick it with their homies but
the consumer the viewer who is not privy
to that type of knowledge it's not a
good look for them right it just it just
doesn't look like I don't know about
that I don't know how I feel about that
especially you have a big name calling
out a company like Lumix for like shady
practices and like that and the
reason why did what they did is just not
a good look so to me the YouTubers have
to understand the consumers the
reviewers I mean they have to understand
the Watcher standpoint the viewer
standpoint but also the the viewer also
has to understand that one at the end of
the day this is a business and sometimes
especially with YouTube I'm just going
to keep it a buck with you sometime
ethics don't always line up with truth
it's that why it's that why I'm talking
that today it's that wine what are
my thoughts my own personal thoughts on
the camera before we get before we get
there man if you all enjoying the
content man please please give it a like
thumbs up comment subscribe all that
good CH know the drill it's your
boy Shan be nice if you all want to
learn more about video production like
BTS and stuff what I do I'm a
documentary filmmaker I do corporate
interviews that's the Brooks media
channel Brooks media with two s's you
have S you ain't spelling it right so
quick little plug now my thoughts about
this camera and I want to hear y
thoughts about this too before I get
into M like comment down below what's y'
thoughts about this camera but for me
it's not for me right the the the
biggest issues for me is like cuz in in
my opinion in my opinion and in 2024
it's inexcusable in 2024 no camera
should not should have a recording limit
period I don't give a I don't care
what it is no camera should have a
recording limit the zv1 if I remember if
I remember correctly the zv1 don't have
one the zve
E10 they don't have one the Canon R8
doesn't have one U like there's so many
cameras like essentially at the around
this price point I mean even though it's
not full frame the a6700 you know
what I'm saying like that got a
viewfinder like you know what I'm saying
like so you got that part right there
and then on top of that you remove the
viewfinder so let's just say if this was
for the Enthusiast the the travel the
Travel Photographer or the travel
filmmaker it to me because of the Retro
style looks more like a Travel
Photographer but if I'm a Travel
Photographer I'm an Enthusiast I need a
evf I want an evf so not giving the evf
for this camera not having a mechanical
shutter if I remember correctly on this
camera like in my opinion that's pretty
huge oh sorry that's two that's
two on my bad let me take that back
that's pretty that's pretty bad that's
pretty huge that's pretty huge to me I
just feel like there's more that they
could have like you know even if it say
a 30 minutes but a 15 minute recording
limit on a 4 on 4K absolutely not that
is inexcusable so for me that's not a
camera for me you know what I mean like
to be real it's probably makes even more
sense just go grab you Al lumus S5 whole
time though like whole time though it
makes more sense you go grabb alumin S5
matter of fact we can look the up
right now
okay I'm sorry you want the autofocus so
let's look at the Lumis s52 the Lumis
s52 right now used on adarama is 1538
eBay
1430 um you can get it from Macy's brand
new for $ 1797 Lumix like who who who
are you trying to aim at with this
camera then because then on top of that
Sony end up dropping a price on their
Sony
a7c if I'm not mistaken on one of those
cameras they end up dropping the price
for it to be closer to Lumix and again
all these cameras that I mentioned the
lumus S5 Mark II and a Sony a7c both of
them have viewfinders neither one of
them have record limits both of them has
mechanical shutters so you telling me
for extra what $2 $300 and in some cases
damn near cheaper I can give me a better
camera nah dog that S9 listen in my
opinion like in my opinion non
objectively speaking that camera ain't
it it just ain't it y'all can call it
what y'all want y' can sit there and try
to like n man this going to be cold
I understand that they was trying to
battle food fui but they missed the mark
and it's okay to tell them they missed
the mark because that mean when luminus
S9 Mark I come out that
going to be fire it's going to be fired
but if you sit there try to hold their
hand through the process and saying like
oh no man it's cool like this is what I
mean by the viewers and the YouTubers
like that trust boundary thing it's like
nah be like call that ass out because
that camera is not it for I guess you
could say for most people who don't know
about cameras but in my
opinion right even if we come like from
an objectively speaking standpoint in my
opinion if you're doing any research on
cameras you're going to come across
other cameras like the lumus S5 Mark I
the Sony a7c the Sony
a6700 however you start looking at
cameras you're going to start to notice
like man wait a minute so these cameras
don't have record limits these cameras
got meical shutters these got EVS why am
I looking at this camera why am I
looking at this camera so for you like
that I think that was the biggest issue
for people like and and and having a
level of distrust for their F their
favorite viewers because they feel like
like they felt them they felt them cuz
it's like cuz the thing is there are
other cameras out that they they would
give harder to but this Lumis S9
lowkey they kind of letting ride
and I I feel the viewers on that bro
like for me I don't have I don't have a
dog in this fight I don't give a
about Lumis cameras like you know what
I'm saying like to the point where like
I'm not going to buy I'm happy I'm
content with all three cameras that I
have I don't need no extra cameras but
if I if I'm watching you and I see that
you kind of like giving this camera a
lot of passes it's going to rub me the
wrong way let's just keep it a buck it's
going to run me the wrong way when you
not calling out that needs to be
called out to make the next version
better y'all holding lum's hands does
not give y'all a better product keep
that in mind keep that in mind if you
want them to get better how you think
boxes get better from they last fights
the coach tell them like n bro you need
to do this like yeah you cold you cold
you got hands but you still to improve
on these areas that kind of was not what
was done at least from what I saw so
with that being said though man I want
to like make this video even longer than
it's already is you feel what I'm say
saying but I do think that we do have to
find a balance between ethics and Truth
telling when it comes to trying to one
still get our bag right like so viewers
I would tell you this let me go ahead
and sum this up viewers understand that
these like for some YouTubers like this
is their job okay this is their job they
got a quarter to meet they got to
do like they have to it's some they got
to play ball a little bit no different
than you got to play ball at your job
you can't sit there and talk to
your supervisor like if he on some on
some BS you got to like you know what
I'm saying like some you just got to
like accept you know what I'm saying
it's no different than YouTubers so you
got to sometimes get them a little Grace
as well YouTubers but also understand
that your viewers have the right to feel
the way that they feel and if it's a
business you analyze your market and see
how you can change it how can you make
it better for the next one you don't get
pissy at them and try to like defend it
all like no just take the feedback
back analyze right your wrongs move
forward that's simple but I'm really
interested in hearing what y'all think
about this whole topic as a whole I
think I'm done with it I won't be
talking about the S9 no more I a got
about that cam I want to say other
than that it's your boy Shan be nice oh
feel so good to say that it's your boy
Shan be nice and I'm out man deuces
5.0 / 5 (0 votes)