Timberland really trash? 60 years later (Timberland Pro)

Summary

This video revisits the iconic Timberland Premium 6-inch waterproof boots to assess if they hold up as work boots or are more about fashion and hype. The host dissects the boots' history, materials, and construction while comparing them to other popular boots in the same price range. Although Timberlands are reliable for waterproofing and durability, their comfort and value fall short compared to competitors. Ultimately, the video concludes that Timberlands are more of a 'tribute boot' for style rather than a practical work boot.

Takeaways

• 👢 Timberland's Premium 6-inch Waterproof Boot is one of the most recognizable boots globally, but there are questions about whether it lives up to the hype as a functional work boot.
• 🔍 The reviewer has cut apart over 300 pairs of boots and spent $60,000 on footwear to better understand their construction and quality.
• 📜 Timberland’s history dates back to 1952 when Nathan Schwartz purchased the Abington Shoe Company. The iconic yellow nubuck Timberland boot was launched in 1973.
• 🧪 The nubuck leather used in Timberland boots is waterproof due to silicone infusion, making it more durable and waterproof than boots with just a waterproof lining.
• 💼 Timberland has shifted from a work boot company to a fashion symbol, especially after being bought by VF Corporation, which also owns brands like Vans and The North Face.
• ⚒️ While the upper leather quality of the Timberland boot is decent, the midsole and insole are made from cheaper materials, including compressed cardboard and fiberboard.
• 🌱 Timberland incorporates eco-friendly practices, such as using recycled bottles to create the fabric lining inside their boots.
• 🧱 Despite the steel shank in the boot, the reviewer found it to be of low quality, bending easily and making the boot less suitable for heavy-duty work.
• 🏗️ Compared to other boots in the same price range, like Ariat and Carolina, Timberlands are considered overpriced for the quality and comfort they offer.
• 👟 Overall, the Timberland boot is viewed as more of a fashion tribute boot than a practical work boot, especially for urban streetwear rather than construction or heavy labor.

Q & A

What makes Timberland boots recognizable?

Timberland boots, especially the six-inch waterproof version, are iconic due to their design and the distinctive yellow nubuck leather that became synonymous with the brand. They also gained popularity in the 90s through association with the New York rap scene.

How did Timberland become a famous brand?

Timberland started in 1952 when Nathan Schwartz bought into the Abington Shoe Company. In 1973, the company introduced the waterproof boot, and in 1978 it changed its name to Timberland. By the 80s and 90s, Timberland boots had become a fashion statement, especially in Europe and the New York rap scene.

What is the significance of the waterproof leather in Timberland boots?

Timberland's waterproof leather is unique because it is infused with silicone, making the leather itself impermeable to water without the need for a waterproof lining. This provides better long-term durability compared to other boots that rely on a waterproof lining, which can degrade over time.

What is the primary drawback of Timberland's six-inch boot construction?

One primary drawback is the use of compressed cardboard underneath the insole, which is less durable than leather and may start to break down over time. This, along with the thin fiberboard used for the shank, reduces the boot's overall durability and comfort for long-term use.

How does the Timberland boot compare to other work boots?

The Timberland boot is considered less durable and comfortable compared to other work boots in its price range, such as Ariats, Blundstones, and Jim Greens. These other boots offer better materials and comfort for similar or even lower prices.

What is nubuck leather, and why is it used in Timberland boots?

Nubuck leather is full-grain leather that has been lightly sanded to give it a soft, microfiber-like texture. It became popular due to Timberland's use, offering a stylish look while maintaining the waterproof qualities needed for outdoor wear.

Why is Timberland considered more of a 'tribute boot' than a true work boot?

The Timberland boot is considered a 'tribute boot' because it maintains the classic design and style of work boots but lacks the durability and functionality of modern work boots. It is primarily worn for fashion rather than for demanding work environments.

What innovations did Timberland bring to the boot-making industry?

Timberland helped pioneer the use of injection molding, which allowed rubber soles to be fused to leather uppers without stitching, improving the waterproofing of their boots. This innovation was introduced in the 1960s and helped set Timberland apart.

What is Timberland's stance on eco-friendly manufacturing?

Timberland incorporates eco-conscious practices by using leather audited by their own Leather Working Group and recycled materials like fabric made from plastic bottles. However, some materials, such as the recycled foam used in the heel, are seen as lower quality compared to traditional materials.

Why might resole options for Timberland boots be limited?

Resoling Timberland boots is challenging due to the way they are constructed, with the upper and sole fused together through injection molding. The complex construction makes it difficult for cobblers to remove and replace the sole without damaging the boot.