Flat-Earther accidentally proves the earth is round in his own experiment

Trend Tracer

13 Aug 201900:52

Summary

TLDRIn this video, an experiment is conducted to test the curvature of the Earth. The participants are observing a light from a distance, determining whether the Earth is flat or curved. They expect to see the light at 17 feet if the Earth is curved, but if they can see it at 23 feet, it suggests a flat Earth. As the experiment progresses, the light isn't visible until it is lifted higher, implying a curved Earth. The results are met with intrigue and reflection.

Takeaways

🔍 The experiment is designed to test visibility of light through different holes at certain heights.
🧑‍🔬 The first part of the experiment involves seeing through a hole to check if the light is visible from a distance.
🌍 The height of the light is important to test the curvature of the Earth versus a flat Earth theory.
📏 The expected height for visibility if the Earth is flat is at 17 feet off the water.
🧐 If the Earth is curved, the light should only be visible when it is raised to a height of 23 feet.
🚶 One person, Enrique, is responsible for holding and adjusting the height of the light.
🚗 The team instructs Enrique to move further down with the light to test visibility.
❌ Initially, the team cannot see the light at the expected height of 17 feet, challenging the flat Earth assumption.
🔦 Enrique is told to raise the light higher above his head to see if it becomes visible.
🤔 The final observation is that when the light is lifted high above Enrique's head, it becomes interesting, suggesting possible curvature.

Q & A

What is the context of the experiment being discussed in the script?
-The experiment appears to involve testing whether the Earth is flat or curved by measuring if light can be seen at different heights and distances.
What is the significance of the light being at 17 feet in the experiment?
-If the light is visible at 17 feet, it suggests the Earth is flat because there is no obstruction due to the curvature of the Earth.
What would it mean if the light is only visible at 23 feet?
-If the light is only visible at 23 feet, it would indicate that the Earth is curved, as the higher elevation would be required to account for the Earth's curvature blocking the lower light.
Why is Enrique asked to lift the light higher?
-Enrique is asked to lift the light higher because they are unable to see the light at the lower height, and lifting it might allow the observers to see it, supporting the idea that the Earth is curved.
What is the key observation that is being awaited in the experiment?
-The key observation is whether the light can be seen when it is held at 17 feet or if it needs to be raised, which would suggest either a flat or curved Earth.
What does the statement 'the earth is flat if he's holding it up at 17 feet' imply?
-This statement implies that if the light is visible at 17 feet without any obstruction, it would support the hypothesis that the Earth is flat, as there would be no curvature to block the light.
Why is it 'interesting' when Enrique lifts the light above his head?
-The reaction of 'interesting' occurs because lifting the light higher might reveal whether the curvature of the Earth is obstructing the view at lower heights, potentially confirming the Earth's curvature.
What is the expected outcome if the Earth is curved?
-If the Earth is curved, the observers should only be able to see the light when it is raised above 17 feet, as the Earth's curvature would block the light at lower levels.
What is the role of distance in this experiment?
-The distance of 17 feet and 23 feet is crucial to the experiment because it allows the observers to test whether the curvature of the Earth is affecting the visibility of the light over a given distance.
What does this experiment aim to prove or disprove?
-This experiment aims to prove or disprove the curvature of the Earth by determining whether light can be seen at specific heights and distances, which would be affected by the Earth's shape.

Outlines

00:00

🔭 Flat Earth vs Curved Earth Experiment Setup

This paragraph describes the setup of an experiment to test whether the Earth is flat or curved. The experiment involves observing a light held at different heights through a hole. If the observer can see the light at 17 feet off the water, it would suggest that the Earth is flat. However, if the light is only visible when raised to 23 feet, it would indicate the Earth’s curvature. The participants are in the process of testing these two heights, and the lack of visibility of the light at a lower height prompts one of them to suggest lifting the light higher.

Mindmap

Keywords

💡Backup experiment

The term 'backup experiment' refers to an alternative or secondary test designed to verify the primary hypothesis, in this case, to confirm the curvature of the Earth. The experiment involves observing light from a certain distance and at specific heights to see if the curvature of the Earth affects the light's visibility. This concept is central to the video’s discussion on proving or disproving the shape of the Earth.

💡Hole

In the context of this experiment, the 'hole' likely refers to an aperture or opening through which the observer looks to see if the light passes through at a certain distance. The hole serves as a precise point of alignment in the experiment, and its use helps in determining whether the Earth is flat or curved based on the visibility of the light through multiple holes.

💡Light

The 'light' is the source used in the experiment to test the Earth’s curvature. The light's position and height are crucial to determining whether it can be seen through the holes at specific distances. If the Earth is flat, the light should be visible at a constant height; if the Earth is curved, adjustments in the light's height will be necessary for it to remain visible.

💡17 feet

The figure '17 feet' represents a specific height off the water at which the light should be visible if the Earth is flat. This measurement is critical in setting the parameters for the experiment, as it determines the expected line of sight for a flat Earth model. If the light cannot be seen at 17 feet, it may suggest that the Earth is curved.

💡23 feet

'23 feet' refers to a height above the water at which the light must be lifted to remain visible if the Earth has curvature. This contrasts with the 17-foot height that would be expected for a flat Earth. By adjusting the light’s height, the experiment seeks to test whether the Earth’s surface curves and affects visibility over long distances.

💡Curved Earth

'Curved Earth' is the central concept being tested in the experiment. It is the hypothesis that the Earth’s surface is spherical or curved rather than flat. The experiment tests this by adjusting the height of the light source and observing whether the curvature affects visibility over a distance. If the Earth is curved, the light should only be visible at a higher elevation.

💡Drive down

The phrase 'drive down' refers to the instruction given to someone to move to a different location along the experiment’s path to further test the hypothesis. This action is part of the observational process, where the position of the light is altered and checked to see if the curvature or flatness of the Earth impacts the experiment’s results.

💡Enrique

Enrique is the individual assisting in the experiment, possibly holding or adjusting the light at different heights as instructed. His role in the experiment is to physically manipulate the light source to test whether its visibility is affected by the Earth’s curvature. His actions are crucial in validating the experiment's outcome.

💡Lift up

'Lift up' refers to the action of raising the light higher above Enrique’s head to test the hypothesis that the Earth is curved. The need to lift the light indicates that the curvature of the Earth would block the light at lower heights, and by raising it, the team hopes to see whether the light becomes visible again.

💡Interesting

The word 'interesting' is used as a reaction to the result of the experiment. It signals a moment of realization or discovery, as the test yields data that could support or refute the hypothesis of a curved Earth. This reaction reflects the importance of observation and interpretation in scientific experiments.

Highlights

Experiment involves observing light through holes at different heights to test the curvature of the Earth.

The observation is made at a distance of 17 feet off the water.

A claim is made that if the Earth is flat, light should only be visible at 17 feet.

The light is held at 23 feet high to test this claim.

The visibility of light at 23 feet is used as evidence for the Earth's curvature.

The experiment involves a backup scenario to observe the light through another hole.

The experiment is conducted at a location 17 feet off the water.

The light is held up by a participant named Enrique.

Enrique is instructed to lift the light above his head.

The visibility of the light above Enrique's head is noted as 'interesting'.

Music is played during the experiment, possibly to add drama or to mark a transition.

The experiment aims to provide visual evidence for the Earth's shape.

The experiment is designed to challenge the flat Earth theory.

The height at which the light is held is a critical variable in the experiment.

The experiment uses simple tools and methods to test a fundamental scientific theory.

The dialogue suggests a collaborative approach to conducting the experiment.

The experiment is conducted in an outdoor setting, possibly near a body of water.

The experiment seeks to debunk the idea that the Earth is flat by observing light at different elevations.