Gold Experience Requiem vs Made in Heaven | Who Would Win?

Summary

The video script explores the hypothetical battle between Jojo's Bizarre Adventure characters: Giorno Giovanna's Gold Experience Requiem and Pucci's Made in Heaven. It delves into their abilities, with Requiem's 'Return to Zero' and 'Infinite Death Loop' facing off against Made in Heaven's time acceleration. The script discusses various win scenarios, from Requiem's dominance to Made in Heaven's narrative purpose of achieving happiness, concluding that while both have strengths, Requiem's power seems insurmountable.

Takeaways

• 🤔 The debate between Gold Experience Requiem and Made in Heaven's power has been ongoing for nearly 20 years.
• 👥 The characters in question are Jodoro, the son of Dio, and Pucci, Dio's best friend.
• 🌀 Made in Heaven is a Time-accelerating Stand that can manipulate the universe's gravity to speed up time, even shortening Jodoro's time stop.
• ⚔️ Gold Experience Requiem has abilities like infinite deaths, Return to Zero, and retains powers from its previous forms like Life Giver and Selfie.
• 📈 Made in Heaven's time acceleration isn't instantaneous but gradually increases until the universe resets.
• 🔮 Pucci's Stand, Made in Heaven, allows him to see the fate of those who live into the new universe he creates.
• 💡 Gold Experience Requiem's Return to Zero is a causality manipulation ability that can undo any action or invert cause and effect.
• 🌌 The infinite death loop is an after-effect of Requiem's victory, trapping the defeated in an endless cycle of death.
• 📚 Stand guides suggest Gold Experience Requiem might be the strongest Stand, with the power to nullify all other abilities.
• 🕰️ There's a narrative implication that Requiem energy allows control over living souls, suggesting a power beyond typical Stand abilities.

Q & A

What is the main debate discussed in the video?

The main debate discussed in the video is whether Gold Experience Requiem or Made in Heaven would win in a fight, a question that has been pondered by fans for nearly 20 years since the ending of Part 6, Stone Ocean.

What are the key reasons why this debate is significant?

The debate is significant because it involves two characters who are on opposite sides of Dio, the son of Dio (Jotaro) and his best friend (Pucci), and the comparison of their powers, Requiem and Heaven, which are considered by many to achieve Dio's heaven in some form.

What is Made in Heaven's primary ability?

Made in Heaven's primary ability is time acceleration. It can manipulate the entire universe's gravity to make time progress faster, eventually leading to the end of the universe and its reset.

How does Made in Heaven's time acceleration affect other Stand abilities?

Made in Heaven's time acceleration is so powerful that it can shorten Jotaro's time stop ability by a few seconds due to the speeding up of time.

What is Gold Experience Requiem's Return to Zero ability?

Return to Zero is a semi-passive ability of Gold Experience Requiem that allows the user to redirect any cause to any effect and undo anything, effectively returning an action or will to zero.

How does Gold Experience Requiem's Return to Zero ability compare to other Stand abilities?

Return to Zero is considered one of the strongest abilities in the series as it can revert any attack or action back to zero, making it superior to many other Stand abilities.

What is the significance of the Requiem energy mentioned in the video?

The Requiem energy is significant because it is said to dominate living souls and is associated with a power that goes beyond typical Stand abilities, suggesting a level of control over life itself.

What are the different win scenarios presented in the video?

The video presents multiple win scenarios, including Gold Experience Requiem being the ultimate Stand, the Requiem power dominating Made in Heaven, Pucci not having the will to fight against Gold Experience Requiem, a time limit on Gold Experience Requiem's power, and the narrative implications of the Requiem power versus Made in Heaven's purpose.

What is the author's personal opinion on the debate?

The author leans towards scenario two and five, where the Requiem power and its narrative purpose give Gold Experience Requiem an advantage over Made in Heaven, but acknowledges that if certain facts about Gold Experience Requiem are disproven, Made in Heaven could potentially win.

How does the video address the translation and interpretation of Stand abilities?

The video acknowledges that the translation from Japanese to English can lead to subjective interpretations of what constitutes the 'ultimate Stand' and that these interpretations can vary based on the Stand stats and guidebook statements.

What is the importance of the narrative purpose of the Stands in determining the outcome of the debate?

The narrative purpose of the Stands is crucial in determining the outcome because it sets the overall theme and goal of their powers. Gold Experience Requiem's narrative is to fight or achieve godlike power, while Made in Heaven aims for universal happiness, which influences how their abilities are perceived in the context of the debate.