Futbol sahiden afyon mu? (Mario Vargas Llosa, II. Abdülhamit, Ümit Yaşar Oğuzcan ve Goal 3)
Summary
TLDRThe video explores the widespread popularity of football, discussing how it transcends social and economic boundaries. It references Nobel laureate Mario Vargas Llosa's views on football as a representation of legality, equality, and freedom. However, it also critiques the commercialization of the sport, which has compromised its ideals. The script examines how industrial football creates inequality and offers a false sense of freedom. The conclusion suggests that while football can foster community and personal growth, it should not consume one's life, emphasizing moderation and awareness of the sport's broader social impact.
Takeaways
- ⚽ Football's popularity is rooted in its ability to satisfy human desires for legality, equality, and freedom, as per Nobel laureate Mario Vargas Llosa.
- 📜 The yellow and red cards in football symbolize legal regulations, similar to real-life consequences like imprisonment for theft, providing a sense of justice to the audience.
- ⚖️ Football is theoretically a non-discriminatory sport, treating both teams equally regardless of their jerseys or status, fostering a sense of fairness.
- 🚪 Football provides a form of freedom where fans can express themselves freely, chanting and behaving in ways they wouldn't in normal life, offering an outlet for primal emotions.
- 🎭 The perception of football as an ideal society is challenged by the realities of industrialized sports, where wealth and corruption often undermine the sense of justice and fairness.
- 💰 The commercialization of football has eroded its spirit of equality, turning players into products and fans into customers, with access to games increasingly limited by financial barriers.
- 🔒 Paid subscriptions for major leagues like the Super Lig, Ligue 1, Serie A, and Champions League create economic inequality, making it difficult for many fans to watch their favorite teams.
- 🧠 According to the Frankfurt School, football creates a false sense of rebellion and submission, pacifying fans and diminishing their revolutionary potential.
- 📚 The script contrasts a football fan with a person who reads Marx, questioning which type of individual poses more of a threat to those in power, hinting at football's role in distracting the masses.
- 🤝 Despite its flaws, football can still be a positive force, fostering social connections and shared experiences, as long as it doesn't dominate one's life.
Q & A
What are the main reasons Mario Vargas Llosa believes football is popular?
-According to Mario Vargas Llosa, football is popular due to its connection to legality, equality, and freedom. These aspects reflect societal ideals that people desire and find satisfaction in through football.
How does football represent legality according to the script?
-Football represents legality through its rules, such as yellow and red cards. These function like laws in real life, where punishment is given to offenders, mirroring justice systems like a thief going to prison.
What does the script say about football's connection to equality?
-The script suggests that football, in theory, promotes equality since its rules apply equally to all players regardless of background. However, in practice, the industrialization of football has eroded this equality.
How does football provide a sense of freedom, according to Mario Vargas Llosa?
-Football allows fans to express themselves freely, letting out emotions like shouting, chanting, or even cursing without societal constraints, giving a sense of liberation during the game.
Why does the script argue that football's connection to justice is flawed in some societies?
-In societies with complicated justice systems, like Turkey, football is seen as failing to deliver true justice. Issues like match-fixing and corruption in football undermine its ability to reflect fairness.
What role does industrialization play in the decline of equality in football?
-The industrialization of football has turned players into products and fans into consumers. This commercialization has damaged the sense of equality, making the sport more about wealth and less about fair competition.
How does the script criticize football's portrayal of freedom?
-The script argues that the sense of freedom in football is an illusion. Sociologists from the Frankfurt School believe that football creates false rebellion, allowing fans to release tension without challenging societal structures.
What is the link between football and capitalism according to the script?
-Football provides a temporary escape from the pressures of capitalism, but this relief is superficial. Fans feel satisfied after matches, but this satisfaction dulls their revolutionary potential and keeps them complacent.
Why does the script reference the Portuguese dictator Salazar in the context of football?
-The script mentions Salazar's belief that without football, he couldn't have governed Portugal. This suggests that football pacified the population, preventing rebellion by giving them an outlet for their frustrations.
What advice does the script give to football fans about their engagement with the sport?
-The script advises fans not to let football dominate their lives but to enjoy it moderately. Fans can still have meaningful experiences, like traveling and meeting new people, without becoming obsessed with the sport.
Outlines
⚽ The Universal Appeal of Football
This paragraph introduces football as a sport enjoyed by people from all walks of life, across all social strata. Unlike golf, which is viewed as a pastime for the elite, football transcends barriers of age, race, and class. The paragraph highlights the economic and cultural power of football, noting how it has grown into a massive industry capable of generating significant revenue. The text poses the question of why football has become so popular and powerful, prompting the reader to delve into the reasons behind its widespread appeal. Citing Nobel Prize-winning author Mario Vargas Llosa, the paragraph outlines three key reasons for football's popularity: legality, equality, and freedom, which are explored in more depth later on.
📜 Football as a Model of Society
Mario Vargas Llosa’s thoughts on football are further explored in this section, focusing on how football reflects societal ideals of legality, equality, and freedom. Legality is represented by yellow and red cards, which mimic legal systems by punishing rule-breakers. This is compared to real-world legal consequences, like a thief being sent to jail. Equality is addressed through football’s theoretically non-discriminatory nature; despite differing team colors or uniforms, the rules apply equally to both sides. Lastly, football offers a form of liberation where both players and fans can express primal emotions freely, chanting and acting in ways they might suppress in daily life. The stadium, in this sense, becomes an arena for releasing built-up tensions, similar to ancient Roman gladiatorial spectacles.
🔍 The Illusion of Justice and Equality in Football
This paragraph critiques Llosa’s idealized view of football, especially within countries like Turkey where justice is often seen as a complex and contentious issue. It discusses how football fails to offer true justice to its fans due to corruption and scandals, like match-fixing and betting fraud, which taint the sport. The industrialization of football has led to a system where money dictates success, undermining any notion of fairness. Wealthier teams have a distinct advantage, and referees are often viewed with suspicion, reducing trust in the game’s fairness. Though football once held the potential to foster equality, its commercialization has distorted that ideal.
💰 The Impact of Commercialization on Football’s Equality
The text continues to explore how football's commercialization has eroded its spirit of equality. The growth of pay-per-view broadcasting has created divisions within society, as only those who can afford these services can follow their favorite teams. As a result, many fans, particularly those from less affluent backgrounds, are left to rely on match summaries or newspaper articles to stay informed. Football’s industrialization has turned players into commodities and fans into consumers, solidifying the sport’s capitalist foundations. The ideal of football as a sport for all has been undermined by these economic barriers.
🕊️ Football and the False Sense of Freedom
This section challenges the notion that football offers freedom, suggesting that the experience of attending matches and expressing emotions during games is merely an illusion of liberation. Drawing on the ideas of the Frankfurt School, the paragraph argues that football creates a false sense of rebellion and submission. Fans may release their frustrations in the stadium, but this temporary catharsis only helps them cope with the pressures of capitalism, rather than inspiring genuine social change. The example of Portuguese dictator Salazar’s comment about ruling the country through football is used to support this argument, suggesting that football pacifies the masses rather than empowering them.
📚 Football’s Role in Society and Its Limits
This final paragraph reflects on football’s place in society, emphasizing that while the sport creates a feeling of freedom, it doesn’t promote true social awareness or change. The text argues that if football truly raised consciousness around issues of legality, equality, or freedom, it would likely have been banned, much like it was in early England and during the reign of Ottoman Sultan Abdul Hamid II. Football is permitted today precisely because it doesn't threaten the existing power structures. The paragraph closes by encouraging a balanced approach to football, advocating for the sport to be enjoyed in moderation, while not allowing it to consume one's life entirely.
👑 A Poetic End: Football as the Last Kingdom
The script concludes with a poetic reflection from Turkish poet Ümit Yaşar Oğuzcan, suggesting that in time, all forms of monarchy will fade, leaving football as the sole remaining kingdom. This sentiment reinforces the idea that football holds a unique and enduring place in global culture, transcending other societal structures. The final phrase, ‘Hail to the king, long live football,’ underscores the sport’s continued dominance and lasting appeal, rounding out the discussion with a nod to both its power and popularity.
Mindmap
Keywords
💡Football (Soccer)
💡Industrialization of Football
💡Mario Vargas Llosa's Perspective
💡Legality
💡Equality
💡Freedom
💡Frankfurt School’s Critique
💡Commercialization and Media Rights
💡False Sense of Justice
💡Dictatorship and Football
Highlights
Golf is not an exclusive sport for the elite but can be enjoyed by all ages, races, and social statuses.
Football is popular due to its legality, equality, and freedom according to Nobel Prize-winning writer Mario Vargas Llosa.
Yellow and red cards in football represent real-life legal systems, similar to how punishments in society deter bad behavior.
Football theoretically promotes equality by enforcing rules equally for both teams, regardless of their background.
Football allows fans to express emotions freely, including singing, shouting, and cursing during matches.
Vargas Llosa compares football stadiums to ancient Roman arenas where primal instincts are satisfied.
The idea of justice in football is often questioned in countries with complex legal systems, like Turkey.
The industrialization of football has undermined its spirit of equality, turning players into products and fans into customers.
The commercialization of football, including paid broadcasts, creates inequality, making it inaccessible for many fans.
The freedom football provides is viewed by some, like the Frankfurt School, as a false sense of rebellion and submission.
Portuguese dictator Salazar once remarked that he couldn't govern without football, indicating its role in social control.
Football provides a temporary sense of freedom and relief from the pressures of capitalism but doesn't foster real consciousness.
Historically, football was banned in places like England and the Ottoman Empire but was eventually allowed after being deemed harmless.
Football doesn’t contribute to intellectual awakening; governments prefer citizens who watch football over those who read Marx.
The conclusion quotes Ümit Yaşar Oğuzcan: 'Over time, all kingdoms will become republics, and the only kingdom left will be the kingdom of goals.'
Transcripts
bu kahvehanelerin tahta sandalyelerinde
de parlamentonun Ceylan Deli
koltuklarında da aynı muhabbet yapılıyor
her yaştan ırktan sosyal statüden
insanın haz duyabildiği bir spor Golf
gibi bir avuç burcunun eğlencesi değil
Toplumun tüm tabakalarında kucaklayan
bir spor Evet futbol neden böylesine
popüler neden bir ülkenin cari açığı
kapatabilecek kadar paralar top peşinde
koşan adamlar ödeniyor topun etrafında
kurulmuş bir endüstri nasıl bu kadar
gelişebiliyor Hazırsanız başlayalım
[Müzik]
[Alkış]
Nobel ödüllü yazar Mario vargas llosa ya
göre futbol üç nedenden ötürü popülerdir
yasallığı a eşitliği ve özgürlüğü
duyulan dua liste yazara göre İnsanlar
son derece Doğal olan bu isteklerine
futbola tatmin ederler Dolayısıyla
futbol dünyasında ideal bir toplum
modeli Barındırır Dilerseniz yazarın
görüşlerini biraz daha detaylandır alım
yasal
Bu elbette ki sarı ve Kırmızı kartlar
dır sarı ve Kırmızı kartlar reel hayatın
hukuki düzenlemelerini temsil eder
hırsızlık yapan bir şahsın hapse
girmesiyle rakibine tekme atan bir
futbolcunun oyundan atılması aynı
mantıktır Tıpkı pedagojide olduğu gibi
futbolda da Verilen her cezanın bir
caydırıcılığı vardır rakip takıma
gösterilen her kart taraftarın gerçek
hayatta bulamadığı Adalet duygusunu
perçinler eşitlikten kasıp ise futbolun
teorik olarak ayrımcılığa İzin vermeyen
bir spor olmasıdır Sağdaki formalarının
renkleri ne onu susun kurallar her iki
tarafa da eşit işlemektedir son olarak
futbol özgürlüğe açılan bir kapıdır
yazara göre sürümüne çıkan her tarafta
normal hayatta utana bileceği
davranışları kayıtsızca sergilemeye
başlar mesela 90 dakika boyunca
dilediğin Marşı söyleyebilir anlamsızca
bağırıp çağırabilir veya Ağız dolusu
küfür edebilir Dolayısıyla hem oyuncular
hem de seyirciler stadyuma girdikleri
anda birtakım ilkel duygularını tatmin
ederler Tıpkı arenalar dakika
Bu maddeleri büyük bir ihtirasla izleyen
Romalılar gibi Mario vargas llosa nın bu
düşünceleri Elbette tartışmaya açıktır
Öncelikle adaletin çok alengirli bir
kavram olduğu ülkelerde mesela
Türkiye'de futbola kimleri de yoğun
şekilde tartışılmaktadır insanlara ya
hayatta bulamadıkları Adalet duygusuna
çoğu zaman yeşil sahada Nail olamazlar
Çünkü endüstriyel futbol pazarı zengin
olanın borusunun öttüğü şike bayısın
Kanık sandığı bir ortam yaratmıştır
paranın kirlettiği futbol Hakemleri olan
güveni zedelediği için bu sporun
popüleritesini yarattığı suni Adalet
duygusuyla açıklayamayız futbolun eşit
az verme potansiyeli olduğu ise kısmen
Doğrudur proleterya ya da burjuvazi
Hristiyan ya da Müslüman herkes futbolla
ilgili benzer hisler taşır Ancak bugün
baktığımızda tablonun değiştiğini
görmekteyiz futbolun endüstriyelleşme si
eşitlik ruhunu tamamen zedelemiştir
futbolcular birer ürüne taraftarlar ise
müşteriye dönüştürülerek kapitalist
fabrikanın temelleri atılmıştır
sözgelimi
o Süper Lig'i Fransa ligi İtalya ligi
Şampiyonlar Ligi ve Avrupa Ligi
maçlarının tamamı şifreli
yayınlanmaktadır maddi bir külfet olan
bu şifreli yayınlar toplum içinde
eşitsizlik yaratmaktadır ve milyonlarca
yoksul kişi sevdiği takımı ancak maç
özetleri nden veya gazete yorumlarından
takip edebilmektedir son olarak futbolun
özgürlük getirdiği düşüncesi tamamen
yanılsama mıdır Sosyolojinin köklü
kurumlarından Frankfurt Okulu'nda
futbolun sahte bir isyankarlık ve
teslimiyetçilik yarattığı söylenir örnek
verelim stadyuma giderek heyecanlanan
bağırıp çağıran bedensel ve duygusal
Efor harcayan bir tarafta rahatlamış
şekilde evine dönecek Kapitalizm
baskısını bir nebze unutacak tır başka
bir değişle futbol müsabakasından çıkan
birey kendini ifade etmenin fırsatını
bulduğu için gevşe Jack devrimci
potansiyelini törpüle jactir bu görüşe
destek olarak portekiz'e diktatör Sen
Hızır'ın futbol olmasaydı Portekiz
yönetemez dim sözünü örnek verebiliriz
özetle futbol bir özgürlük hissi yaratır
Allah bilir ama bu hiç tamamen
yanılsamadan ibarettir Eğer futbol
yasallık eşitlik ve özgürlük konularında
bizleri bilinçlendiriyor olsaydı çoktan
yasaklanmış olurdu kaldı ki bu spor
İngiltere'de fil izlendiğinde ne idüğü
belirsiz olduğu için defalarca
yasaklanmış ancak zararsız olduğundan
emin olunduktan sonra serbest
bırakılmıştır benzer şekilde ikinci
Abdülhamid de futbolu yasakladığı için
osmanlıdaki ilk müsabakalar azınlıklar
arasında oynanmıştır futbol bugün
tamamıyla serbestler ve teşvik
edilmektedir Çünkü insanların
bilinçlenmesini hiçbir katkı yapmaz
gözünüzün önüne iki insan getirin birisi
tüm Boş zamanlarında futbol maçı izliyor
kendi diğeri Max okuyor Siz iktidar
olsaydınız hangisini yerler Deniz
Elbette kendimize futbola tamamen
kapatmayalım bu işi abartmadan değerli
vaktimizin tamamını harcamadan Pekala
futbolsever olabiliriz deplasmanlara
giderek yeni insanlarla Tanışabilir
onlarla kamusal alanlar oluşturabilir ve
yepyeni deneyimlerle kendimizi
geliştirebiliriz burada önemli olan
amatör
bu etmemek Öyleyse videoyu Ümit Yaşar
Oğuzcan'ın nefis bir cümlesiyle
sonlandıralım zamanla bütün krallıklar
Cumhuriyet olacak kala kala bir gol
krallığı kalacak dünyada krala Selam
futbola devam
[Müzik]
5.0 / 5 (0 votes)