Milgram's Obedience Experiment

Summary

In 1963, psychologist Stanley Milgram conducted a groundbreaking experiment at Yale University to explore the conflict between obedience to authority and personal conscience. Participants, believing they were administering electric shocks to a 'learner,' were pressured by an authority figure to continue increasing the voltage despite their discomfort. The study revealed that 65% of participants obeyed orders to administer shocks up to a potentially lethal level. Milgram's findings led to the development of the 'agency theory,' suggesting people enter an 'agentic state' where they obey authority figures, believing the authority will take responsibility for their actions.

Takeaways

• 👨‍🔬 Stanley Milgram conducted an experiment at Yale University to study obedience to authority and personal conscience.
• 🔍 The experiment was a response to the Nuremberg trials where defendants claimed they were 'just following orders'.
• 📢 Participants were recruited through newspaper ads for a 'learning study', not knowing the true nature of the experiment.
• 👨‍🏫 The setup involved a 'teacher' and a 'learner', with the latter being an actor and the former being the actual participant.
• ⚡️ The 'teacher' was instructed to administer electric shocks to the 'learner' for incorrect answers, with shock levels escalating.
• 👨‍🔬 The experimenter, played by an actor, insisted that the 'teacher' continue administering shocks despite objections.
• 📈 65% of participants obeyed the authority figure and administered shocks up to the maximum level of 450 volts.
• 🔁 Milgram conducted 18 variations of the experiment, all yielding similar results about the nature of obedience.
• 🧠 Milgram developed the 'agency theory', suggesting people act autonomously or as agents depending on the presence of authority.
• 🏢 The theory posits that individuals will obey authority figures if they believe those figures will take responsibility for the consequences of their actions.
• 👀 The study raises ethical questions about the limits of scientific research and the power dynamics between authority and individuals.

Q & A

Who conducted the famous obedience study in psychology?

Stanley Milgram, a psychologist at Yale University, conducted the famous obedience study in psychology.

What was the main focus of Milgram's experiment?

The main focus of Milgram's experiment was to examine the conflict between obedience to authority and personal conscience.

What was the historical context that led to Milgram's experiment?

The historical context was the justifications for acts of genocide offered by those accused at the World War II Nuremberg war criminal trials, where the defense was based on obedience to orders from superiors.

How did Milgram select participants for his experiment?

Milgram selected participants for his experiment through newspaper advertising, inviting male participants to take part in a study of learning at Yale University.

What was the role of the learner in Milgram's experiment?

The learner in Milgram's experiment was an actor hired to pretend to be a real participant, and he was taken into a room and had electrodes attached to his arms.

What was the purpose of the electric shock generator in the experiment?

The electric shock generator was used to administer electric shocks to the learner whenever he made a mistake in recalling the list of paired words during the learning test administered by the teacher.

What were the four prods given by the experimenter to encourage the teacher to continue administering shocks?

The four prods given by the experimenter were: 1) Please continue. 2) The experiment requires you to continue. 3) It is absolutely essential that you continue. 4) You have no other choice but to continue.

What was the surprising result of Milgram's study regarding obedience to authority?

The surprising result was that 65% of the participants continued to administer electric shocks up to the highest level of 450 volts when instructed to do so.

How many variations of the study did Milgram conduct, and what were the general outcomes?

Milgram conducted 18 variations of the study, and all of them yielded similar results, indicating that the findings were not a one-off random occurrence.

What is the agency theory developed by Milgram, and how does it explain the behavior of the participants?

The agency theory suggests that people have two states of behavior: autonomous, where they direct their own actions, and agentic, where they allow others to direct their actions and pass off responsibility for the consequences. According to this theory, people obey authority when they believe that authority will take responsibility for the consequences of their actions.

Outlines

00:00

🔬 Stanley Milgram's Obedience Study

The paragraph discusses Stanley Milgram's groundbreaking study on obedience to authority, conducted at Yale University in 1963. Milgram aimed to understand the conflict between obedience to authority and personal conscience, inspired by the justifications of genocide during the Nuremberg trials where defendants claimed they were just following orders. The experiment involved male participants who were led to believe they were administering electric shocks to a 'learner' (an actor) whenever he made a mistake in a memory test. The shocks were fake, but the participants were unaware, and they were urged by an authority figure (another actor) to continue increasing the shock levels despite their discomfort. The study revealed that 65% of participants were willing to administer shocks up to the maximum level of 450 volts, demonstrating a disturbing willingness to obey authority even at the cost of causing harm. Milgram's findings led to the development of the 'agency theory,' which suggests that people enter an 'agentic state' where they allow others to direct their actions and pass off responsibility for the consequences.

05:02

📚 Agency Theory and Obedience

This paragraph delves into the agency theory proposed by Milgram to explain the behavior of participants in his obedience study. According to the theory, individuals will obey an authority figure when they believe that authority will take responsibility for the consequences of their actions. The theory identifies two conditions necessary for a person to enter an 'agentic state': the authority figure must be perceived as legitimate and qualified to direct behavior, and the individual must believe that the authority will accept responsibility for the outcomes. The paragraph concludes with a call to action for viewers to engage with the content by liking the video, subscribing to the channel, and turning on notifications to stay updated with new content.

Keywords

💡Obedience

Obedience refers to the act of complying with or following orders, commands, or requests. In the context of the video, it is central to understanding the psychological experiment conducted by Stanley Milgram, which aimed to explore the conflict between obedience to authority and personal conscience. The video discusses how obedience was used as a defense during the Nuremberg trials, suggesting that individuals were merely following orders, highlighting the complexity of obedience in moral and ethical dilemmas.

💡Stanley Milgram

Stanley Milgram was a psychologist at Yale University who conducted a series of experiments on obedience to authority. His name is synonymous with the study of obedience, as his experiments were groundbreaking in understanding how far individuals would go in obeying orders from an authority figure, even if it involved causing harm to others. The video script details his experiment, emphasizing his role in shaping our understanding of obedience in psychology.

💡Nuremberg Trials

The Nuremberg Trials were a series of military tribunals held after World War II to prosecute prominent members of the political, military, and economic leadership of Nazi Germany. In the video, the trials are mentioned as a historical backdrop to Milgram's experiments, as the defense of the accused often centered on the claim of 'just following orders,' which raised questions about the nature of obedience and personal responsibility.

💡Authority

Authority, in this context, refers to the power or right to give orders, make decisions, and enforce obedience. The video explores the psychological dynamics of obedience to authority figures, as demonstrated in Milgram's experiment where participants were asked to administer electric shocks to a 'learner' upon the instruction of an authority figure, the experimenter.

💡Personal Conscience

Personal conscience is an individual's moral sense of right and wrong, which guides their actions. The video discusses the conflict between obeying authority and following one's personal conscience, a tension that was central to Milgram's experiments. Participants had to grapple with their own moral judgments versus the demands of the authority figure in the study.

💡Experiment

In the video, the term 'experiment' refers to the scientific procedure designed by Milgram to study obedience. It involved a setup where participants believed they were administering electric shocks to a 'learner' under the direction of an experimenter. The experiment is a key element in understanding the video's theme, as it illustrates the behavioral outcomes when individuals are placed in a situation that challenges their moral and ethical boundaries.

💡Actor

In the context of the video, an 'actor' refers to the individuals who were hired to play specific roles in Milgram's experiment, such as the 'learner' who received electric shocks. The use of actors was crucial to the experiment's design, as it allowed for controlled variables and a more accurate study of obedience without actual harm being done.

💡Electric Shock Generator

The electric shock generator was a central道具 in Milgram's experiment, used to simulate the administration of electric shocks to the 'learner.' It was a key element in creating a realistic and high-pressure environment that tested the participants' obedience. The script describes the shock generator as having switches marked with increasing voltage levels, up to a point that was potentially lethal, emphasizing the severity of the situation participants faced.

💡Agency Theory

Agency theory, as developed by Milgram, is a psychological concept introduced in the video to explain the behavior of participants in his experiment. It suggests that individuals can enter an 'agentic state' where they allow others to direct their actions and pass off responsibility for the consequences. This theory helps to understand why participants in the experiment continued to administer shocks, as they perceived the experimenter as a legitimate authority who would take responsibility for their actions.

💡Autonomous State

The autonomous state is a concept mentioned in the video in relation to agency theory. It refers to a state where individuals direct their own actions and take responsibility for the outcomes. The video contrasts this with the agentic state, where individuals obey authority figures and pass off responsibility. Understanding the autonomous state is important for grasping the psychological conflict that participants in Milgram's experiment faced between personal autonomy and obedience to authority.

💡Variations

Variations in the video refer to the different versions of the experiment that Milgram conducted to explore obedience under various conditions. By altering aspects of the experiment, such as the proximity of the 'learner' or the presence of other authority figures, Milgram was able to study how different factors influenced obedience. The video emphasizes that the consistent results across these variations underscore the robustness of the findings on obedience to authority.

Highlights

Stanley Milgram conducted an experiment at Yale University to study obedience to authority versus personal conscience.

The experiment aimed to understand if the Holocaust perpetrators were merely following orders.

Participants were recruited through newspaper ads for a 'learning study' at Yale.

The setup involved a 'teacher' and a 'learner', with the latter being an actor.

The 'learner' was strapped with electrodes, simulating an electric shock generator.

The 'teacher' was instructed to administer shocks for wrong answers, with voltage increasing for each mistake.

The experimenter, played by an actor, pressured the 'teacher' to continue with the shocks.

The shocks were not real, but the 'teacher' was led to believe they were.

65% of participants administered the maximum 450-volt shock.

All participants continued to at least 300 volts.

Milgram conducted 18 variations of the study, with similar results.

The study challenged the notion of Germans being particularly obedient to authority.

Milgram developed the 'agency theory' to explain the participants' behavior.

The theory suggests people enter an 'agentic state' when obeying authority.

Two conditions must be met for obedience: perceived legitimacy of authority and belief in their responsibility for consequences.

People obey when they believe authority will take responsibility for their actions.

The study's findings have significant implications for understanding human behavior under authority.

Transcripts

one of the most famous studies of

obedience in psychology was carried out

by Stanley Milgram a psychologist at

Yale University he conducted an

experiment focusing on the conflict

between obedience to Authority and

personal conscience in 1963 Milgram

examined justifications for acts of

genocide offered by those accused at the

world war two Nuremberg war criminal

trials their defense sovereign was based

on obedience that they were just

following orders from their superiors

Morgan devised the experiment to answer

the question could it be that those who

committed such atrocities in the

Holocaust were just following orders

could we call them all accomplices

mordrem wanted to investigate where the

Germans were particularly obedient to

authority figures as this was a common

explanation for the Nazi killings new

world war ii mordrem selected

participants for his experiment by

newspaper advertising or male

participants to take part in a study of

learning at Yale University the

procedure was that the participant was

paired with another person and they drew

lots to find out who would be the

learner and who would be the teacher the

draw was fixed at the participant was

always the teacher and the learner was

an actor hired pretending to be a real

participant Valona who was an actor

called mr. wallace was taken into a room

and had electrodes attached to his arms

and the teacher and researcher went into

a room next door that had contained an

electric shock generator and a row of

switches marked from 15 volts which is a

slight shock to 375 volts which had a

danger reading of severe shock and up to

450 volts which is enough to kill a

human being continue please

the experiment requires you continue

teacher please continue

what disciplines were comprised of 40

males aged between 20 and 50 whose job

ranged from unskilled to professional

they were paid four and a half dollars

just for turning up to the study at the

beginning of the experiment they were

introduced to the other participants

which was the actor taking on the role

as the learner the experimenter who was

also an actor was dressed in a grey lab

coat played by an actor not morkrum

himself two rooms in the air laboratory

were used one for the learner with an

electric chair and another for the

teacher and the experimenter with an

electric shock generator the learner mr.

Wallace was structured chair by

electrodes after he had learned a list

of ped words given to him to learn the

teacher tests and by naming wood and

then asking the learner to recall its

part now pay from a list of four

possible choices the teacher is told to

administer an electric shock every time

the learner made a mistake the learner

gave mainly wrong answers on purpose and

for each of these the teacher gave him

an electric shock when the teacher

refused to administer shock the

experimenter was to give a series of

orders and products to ensure that they

continued there were four prods and if

one was not obeyed then the experimenter

who was called mr. Williams read out the

next prod and so on the four prods were

firstly please continue secondly the

experiment requires you to continue

three it is absolutely essential

you continue for you have no other

choice but to continue so what were the

results of the study

Morgan Barnett sixty-five percent almost

two-thirds of the participants the

participants who played the role as the

teachers administering the electric

shock continue to the highest levels of

450 volts all the participants continued

to at least 300 volts Morgan did more

than one experiment in fact he carried

out 18 variations of the study

all with similar results so this can't

be taken as once off random and a non

occurring event all he did was alter the

situation to see how this affected

obedience from the results of the study

nor groom developed theory called the

agency theory

Morgan explained the behavior of his

participants by suggesting that people

have two states of behavior when they

are in a social situation the first is

the autonomous state people direct their

own actions and they take responsibility

for the results of those actions then

there is the agentic state people allow

others to direct their actions and then

pass off the responsibility for those

consequences to the person giving the

orders in other words they act as agents

for another person's wool mordrem

suggested that two things must be in

place for a person to enter this Jenica

state firstly the person giving the

orders is perceived as being qualified

to direct other people's behavior that

is they are seen as a legitimate source

of authority secondly the person being

ordered is able to believe that the

authority will accept responsibility for

what happens agency theory stipulates

that people will obey an authority when

they believe that that authority will

take responsibility for the consequences

of their actions and that's all for

today's video I hope you found it

interesting if you did give the video a

like and if you wants more types of

videos like this subscribe to the

channel and remember to turn

notifications on otherwise you will

never know when a new video is posted