The Psychology of Career Decisions | Sharon Belden Castonguay | TEDxWesleyanU

Summary

The speaker shares a personal journey of losing their runner identity due to a knee injury and explores the impact of personal identities on professional paths. They discuss the evolution of career counseling, the limitations of passion as a guiding force, and the challenges posed by the fourth Industrial Revolution. The talk emphasizes the importance of self-awareness, questioning our life narratives, and embracing the messiness of career decision-making in a constantly changing world.

Takeaways

• 🏥 The speaker had to adopt an alternate identity due to a knee injury, which has been more painful than the injury itself.
• 🏃‍♀️ Running has become a significant part of the speaker's identity, and the inability to run post-injury is a major setback.
• 🌟 Personal identities can significantly influence and shape professional identities, affecting work engagement.
• 📉 According to Gallup, 87% of employees worldwide are not engaged in their work, which impacts the bottom line.
• 🔍 Career counselors focus on internal reasons for work engagement, such as personal interests and motivations.
• 🏭 Historically, career choices were often dictated by family, gender, and social class, but this changed with industrial revolutions.
• 🔬 The military's interest in career counseling during World Wars led to the development of psychological tests for job placement.
• 💼 The late 90s saw a shift in career counseling towards encouraging clients to follow their passions, despite practical considerations.
• 🤖 The fear of the fourth Industrial Revolution and AI replacing jobs has led to a reevaluation of the 'follow your passion' career advice.
• 🧠 Humans are not as rational as thought when making career decisions, often influenced by unconscious biases and social surroundings.
• 🔄 The design thinking process is suggested as a potential framework for career decision-making in the face of rapid change and uncertainty.

Q & A

What was the speaker's initial reaction to the news that they would no longer be able to run?

The speaker found giving up their running identity more painful than the knee injury itself, as running had become a significant part of their identity.

According to the speaker, how do personal identities influence professional choices?

Personal identities can affect and create professional identities, as people's backgrounds, skills, interests, and societal influences shape the line of work they choose and their engagement in it.

What percentage of employees worldwide are not engaged in their work according to Gallup?

Gallup reports that 87% of employees worldwide are not engaged in their work.

Career counseling evolved from helping people choose a line of work based on their background and skills to focusing on passions and personal interests, and more recently to considering the iterative nature of career decisions in the face of rapid technological changes.

null

What is the speaker's perspective on the advice to 'follow your passion' for career choices?

The speaker suggests that the advice to follow one's passion may not be practical for everyone, as many people are not sure what their passions are and may have other immediate concerns like financial stability.

How does the speaker describe the impact of the fourth Industrial Revolution on career decisions?

The speaker highlights the fear and uncertainty that the fourth Industrial Revolution brings, as it may lead to job displacement due to advancements in artificial intelligence, making traditional career advice less relevant.

What is the speaker's view on the role of self-awareness in career decision-making?

The speaker believes that self-awareness is crucial for individuals to understand their personal biases and societal influences, which can help them make more informed career decisions and avoid internalizing limiting beliefs.

How does the speaker describe the process of career identity formation?

The speaker describes career identity as a sum of all possible identities, influencing individuals in different ways at different times, often unconsciously, and suggests that it is a deeply personal life and career narrative.

What advice does the speaker give regarding one's career narrative?

The speaker encourages individuals to embrace the messiness of their career narrative, own their story, and not let others write it for them, acknowledging that the process is iterative and complex.

What quote does the speaker use to conclude their presentation?

The speaker concludes with a quote from Cicero, emphasizing that understanding oneself and making career decisions has always been a challenging and complex process.