The case of people hating Geoff Johns

Summary

In this video, Birch discusses the mixed reception of his content and addresses the controversy surrounding comic book writer Jeff Johns. He argues that while Johns has his critics, much of the hatred is unfounded and stems from a misunderstanding of his work. Birch also touches on the impact of fan bases, particularly Snyder fans, on creators' careers and the importance of respecting the past in comic book storytelling.

Takeaways

• 🎥 The speaker addresses criticism about the focus and content of their videos, acknowledging both the desire for more focused content and the appreciation for diverse topics.
• 📽️ The speaker discusses the dilemma of outdated video content, questioning whether to post videos recorded months prior due to their relevance.
• 💭 There's a mention of the polarizing figure Jeff Johns, who receives both praise and criticism, with the speaker suggesting that Johns has written more good content than bad.
• 🤔 The speaker questions the impact of fan backlash, particularly from Snyder fans, on Jeff Johns' career, suggesting that such mob mentality might not be as influential as believed.
• 🗣️ It's highlighted that Jeff Johns doesn't often speak out publicly, which contrasts with the frequent trending of his name by fans, both positively and negatively.
• 👎 The speaker argues against the notion that Jeff Johns is solely responsible for negative trends in comics, suggesting that other factors and individuals contribute to these issues.
• 📚 There's a critique of the comic industry's practices, particularly regarding the treatment of writers and the focus on meeting deadlines rather than sales performance.
• 📉 The speaker touches on the career implications for creators who might face public criticism and how it contrasts with those who remain silent.
• 🎬 Commentary on Zack Snyder's future with DC movies is provided, with the speaker suggesting that Snyder should move on to other projects, such as a Netflix series, for career growth.
• 🛑 The speaker concludes by urging Snyder fans to stop chasing after more DC movies and to embrace new opportunities for the director, indicating that clinging to the past may not be beneficial.

Q & A

What are some of the complaints the speaker receives about the format of the videos?

Some viewers complain that the videos are too nerdy and focus too much on one topic without straying, while others say the videos wander around and talk about unrelated things like muffler noises and RVs.

How does the speaker view Jeff Johns' writing overall?

The speaker believes that Jeff Johns has written both good and mediocre work but emphasizes that he has written more good than bad material. The speaker thinks Johns is a good writer but not the greatest.

What are some of the criticisms Jeff Johns faces, according to the speaker?

Jeff Johns is often criticized by Snyder fans and others for various reasons, including accusations of sexism, misogyny, and racism. Additionally, he is accused of being one of the 'baddies' at Warner Media responsible for causing chaos.

Why does the speaker think Snyder fans shouldn't hate Jeff Johns?

The speaker believes that if Snyder fans truly understood Jeff Johns, they would not hate him because Johns likely benefited the cause Snyder fans support more than they realize.

What is the speaker's opinion on the impact of Twitter mobs like Snyder fans on Jeff Johns' career?

The speaker believes that despite the noise created by Twitter mobs like Snyder fans, they probably do not have a significant impact on Jeff Johns' career.

Why does the speaker think Jeff Johns has gained a negative reputation recently?

The speaker thinks Jeff Johns' negative reputation is mostly rooted in the Ray Fisher situation and his association with being one of the 'baddies' at Warner Media. It is also linked to the perception that Johns represents the 'old institution of comics' in opposition to more progressive creators.

How does the speaker compare Jeff Johns' reputation to that of other comic creators?

The speaker suggests that Jeff Johns has been wrongly grouped with creators like Jim Shooter, who are perceived as wanting to cut 'woke' content and return to a more traditional style. This, according to the speaker, is a misconception.

What does the speaker think Zack Snyder should focus on instead of DC movies?

The speaker thinks Zack Snyder should focus on making a successful career at Netflix, suggesting he should produce a Netflix series rather than stay tethered to the DC Universe, which the speaker views as baggage for Snyder at this point.

What does the speaker mean when discussing Teeny Howard's reputation in comics?

The speaker notes that Teeny Howard has a reputation for consistently delivering her work on time, which editors appreciate. The speaker clarifies that it's not just about not hurting the brand but also about being reliable and getting work done without drama.

How does the speaker describe the broader cultural divide affecting creators like Jeff Johns?

The speaker believes that Jeff Johns has been unfairly dragged into a cultural divide, where some see him as a representative of traditional, conservative values in comics, while others believe in subverting expectations and 'killing the past,' much like what was seen in recent Star Wars films.