12 Angry Men (3/10) Movie CLIP - Who Changed Their Vote? (1957) HD

Summary

In a tense jury room, a lone juror stands against the majority, casting doubt on a defendant's guilt. As tempers flare and secrets are threatened, the juror's insistence on reasonable doubt sparks heated debate. The script explores themes of justice, prejudice, and the weight of individual responsibility within a group dynamic.

Takeaways

• 🗣️ A juror is adamant about the defendant's guilt, repeatedly voting 'guilty'.
• 🤔 Another juror changes their vote from 'guilty' to 'not guilty', causing tension.
• 🤫 The secrecy of the jury room is emphasized, but one juror claims to know who changed their vote.
• 😠 There is a heated exchange between jurors, with one being accused of changing their vote due to emotional manipulation.
• 😤 One juror is described as 'excitable', indicating strong emotions and a passionate stance.
• 👨‍⚖️ A 'fatherly' figure tries to maintain order and insists on hearing the reasons behind the vote change.
• 🤝 The juror who changed his vote is supported by another, who respects his motives despite believing the defendant is likely guilty.
• 🧐 The juror who changed his vote is not claiming the defendant's innocence but expressing uncertainty.
• 💭 The script suggests that standing alone against a group can be difficult and may lead to ridicule.
• 📅 A specific date is mentioned, 'August 10 to 2', which could be significant to the case or the deliberation process.

Q & A

What is the main conflict in the jury room?

The main conflict is the disagreement over the guilt of the defendant, with one juror initially voting 'not guilty' and the rest voting 'guilty'.

Why does the juror who votes 'not guilty' change his vote?

The juror who initially votes 'not guilty' does not change his vote. Another juror changes his vote to 'not guilty' after hearing the first 'not guilty' juror's arguments.

What is the significance of the secret ballot?

The secret ballot is significant because it allows jurors to vote without influence from others, ensuring that their decision is based solely on the evidence.

Why does the juror who wants to keep the vote secret become upset?

The juror becomes upset because the secret ballot was agreed upon to protect the integrity of the voting process, and someone revealing their vote breaks that agreement.

What does the phrase 'some golden voice preaches thoughts' imply?

This phrase implies that the juror who votes 'not guilty' is persuasive and is able to sway others with his arguments and thoughts about the case.

What is the juror's attitude towards the defendant?

The juror's attitude is initially one of doubt and a desire for further discussion, rather than a definitive stance on the defendant's guilt.

Why does the juror who changes his vote to 'not guilty' do so?

The juror changes his vote because he respects the motives of the first 'not guilty' juror and wants to hear more evidence and arguments before making a final decision.

What does the 'excitable' juror represent in the script?

The 'excitable' juror represents the passion and emotional response to the case, which contrasts with the more rational and evidence-based approach of the first 'not guilty' juror.

What is the significance of the date mentioned, 'August 10 to 2'?

The date 'August 10 to 2' is likely referring to a timeline or a specific event related to the case, although the script does not provide enough context to determine its exact significance.

What is the role of the 'father' figure in the script?

The 'father' figure is likely a respected member of the jury who is trying to maintain order and ensure that everyone's opinions are heard.

Why does the juror say 'let's sit down' at the end?

The juror says 'let's sit down' to suggest that the group should calm down and listen to the arguments being presented, rather than getting agitated and confrontational.