FISICULTURISMO: Esporte ou Concurso de Beleza?! (TODA A VERDADE..)

Jeff Medeiros

21 Jun 202317:53

Summary

TLDRThis video explores the debate on whether bodybuilding should be considered a sport or an art form. It compares bodybuilding to both sports and beauty pageants, highlighting the physical training and subjective judging involved. The script discusses the criteria for sports recognition and the challenges bodybuilding faces, such as the use of steroids and the subjective nature of judging. It also touches on the artistic aspect of bodybuilding, suggesting it can be seen as a form of popular art that elicits emotional responses, similar to other art forms. The video concludes with a quote from Sergio Nobre, emphasizing bodybuilding as an art form, where the body is transformed into a work of art.

Takeaways

🏋️‍♂️ Powerlifting achievements like John Hack's bench press record are objectively measurable and undisputed in strength sports.
🤔 In contrast, bodybuilding success can be subjective and open to interpretation, unlike the clear-cut records in powerlifting.
🏆 The decision of the main bodybuilder in the 2022 Mr. Olympia competition was agreed upon by judges, but spectators might have differing opinions.
🎭 Beauty pageants and bodybuilding both involve evaluating physical appearance, but beauty pageants also consider intelligence, communication skills, and social engagement.
💪 Bodybuilding focuses on achieving a balanced, well-developed physique with low body fat, showcasing through choreographed poses.
🏅 Bodybuilding competitions, like Mr. Olympia, are hierarchical and occur at various levels, from local to international.
🚫 The International Olympic Committee (IOC) has not recognized bodybuilding as an Olympic sport due to the use of anabolic steroids, lack of athletic elements, and subjective judging.
🎨 The script discusses the categorization of art into high, medium, and low, suggesting that bodybuilding might be considered a form of popular or low art due to its broad accessibility.
🗽 The script references Arnold Schwarzenegger's exhibition at the Museum of Modern Art in New York, highlighting the artistic aspect of bodybuilding.
📸 Photos of Schwarzenegger by artist Andy Warhol are valued similarly to recognized art pieces, indicating the artistic value of bodybuilding physiques.
🤝 Renowned bodybuilder Sergio Nobre suggests that bodybuilding is not just a sport but primarily an art form, where the body is transformed into a work of art.

Q & A

What is the main difference between powerlifting and bodybuilding in terms of competition recognition?
-In powerlifting, records are established based on concrete and verifiable measures, whereas in bodybuilding, becoming a champion can depend on subjective opinions that are constantly changing.
How does the judging system in bodybuilding competitions work?
-Bodybuilding competitions use a scoring system by a panel of experts to distinguish the best based on criteria such as muscularity, symmetry, and definition. However, the sport is still fundamentally subjective as any viewer might disagree with the panel's assessment.
What are the main components evaluated in a beauty pageant?
-In beauty pageants, participants are evaluated based on their physical appearance, elegance, posture, personality, and specific talents. The purpose is to highlight beauty, confidence, and charisma, as well as to promote values like empowerment, diversity, and social responsibility.
How are bodybuilding competitions structured in terms of categories?
-Bodybuilding competitions are divided into different weight categories and genders, grouping competitors into similar categories. They are judged by a panel of specialists who assign scores and determine the winner in each category.
What is the primary goal of bodybuilding?
-The primary goal of bodybuilding is to achieve a balanced, well-developed muscular body with a low body fat percentage.
Why has bodybuilding not been recognized as an Olympic sport?
-Bodybuilding has not been recognized as an Olympic sport due to the use of anabolic steroids, the lack of athletic elements according to the International Olympic Committee (IOC), and the high subjectivity in evaluating bodybuilding performances.
How does the script categorize different forms of art?
-The script categorizes art into high, medium, and low (popular) art based on the public's ability to understand and appreciate the art form. High art is considered inaccessible to the general public, medium art is accessible and can be appreciated by most, and low art is widely understood and easily appreciated.
What is the significance of Arnold Schwarzenegger's participation in a live art exhibition at the Museum of Modern Art in New York?
-Arnold Schwarzenegger's participation as a live exhibit at the Museum of Modern Art in New York signifies the artistic aspect of bodybuilding, aiming to provoke emotional responses similar to how art does.
How does the script suggest that bodybuilding can be considered a form of popular art?
-The script suggests that bodybuilding can be considered a form of popular art because it is widely understood and easily appreciated by the general public, similar to other forms of popular art like music, television shows, and graffiti.
What is the value of the Polaroid photographs of Arnold Schwarzenegger taken by Andy Warhol, as mentioned in the script?
-The Polaroid photographs of Arnold Schwarzenegger taken by Andy Warhol, mentioned in the script, currently have a value between $8,000 and $12,000 on auction sites.
What is the final opinion expressed by Sérgio Nobre in the script regarding bodybuilding?
-Sérgio Nobre, a renowned bodybuilder from the Golden Era, expresses the opinion that bodybuilding is not just a sport but, first and foremost, a form of art.

Outlines

00:00

🏋️‍♂️ The Subjectivity of Bodybuilding as a Sport

This paragraph introduces the debate over whether bodybuilding should be considered a sport. It contrasts powerlifting, where achievements are empirical and measurable, with bodybuilding, which is more subjective and relies on judges' opinions. The paragraph highlights the 2022 Mr. Olympia competition as an example where the winner is chosen by a panel of judges, but the decision could be subjectively disagreed with by spectators. It questions the legitimacy of bodybuilding as a competitive sport due to its reliance on subjective criteria rather than empirical results.

05:03

🤔 The Criteria for Sports and Bodybuilding's Place in Them

The second paragraph delves into the characteristics that define a sport and whether bodybuilding meets these criteria. It outlines that sports are physical activities with established rules, often requiring physical and mental skills, and can be competitive or recreational. Bodybuilding is compared to other sports, with the argument that it lacks the objective measures found in most sports, as its evaluation is based on subjective judgments of appearance. The paragraph also discusses the historical context of bodybuilding's attempt to be recognized as an Olympic sport and the reasons it has not been included, such as the use of anabolic steroids and the lack of athletic elements beyond physical appearance.

10:04

🎨 The Artistic Spectrum: Where Does Bodybuilding Fit?

Paragraph three explores the concept of bodybuilding as an art form, discussing the categorization of art into high, medium, and low (popular) art. It uses examples to illustrate how bodybuilding could be seen as a form of popular art, accessible and understandable to a wide audience, much like graffiti or popular music. The paragraph draws parallels between the emotional responses evoked by bodybuilding and those from other art forms, suggesting that bodybuilding's ability to inspire and elicit emotional reactions positions it within the realm of artistic expression.

15:05

💪 The Timeless Value of Bodybuilding as Art

The final paragraph emphasizes the enduring value of bodybuilding as an art form, using the example of Arnold Schwarzenegger's Polaroid photos taken by artist Andy Warhol. It discusses how these images, like other recognized art pieces, have increased in value over time, highlighting the artistic appeal and originality of a bodybuilder's physique. The paragraph concludes by suggesting that bodybuilding is a form of expression that provokes emotional responses, similar to other art forms, and that it has the potential to inspire and motivate, thus solidifying its place as an art.

Mindmap

Keywords

💡Powerlifting

Powerlifting is a competitive strength sport that involves three attempts at maximal weight single-lift of three lifts: squat, bench press, and deadlift. It is mentioned in the script to contrast with bodybuilding, emphasizing the objective nature of powerlifting records versus the subjective evaluation in bodybuilding competitions.

💡Bodybuilding

Bodybuilding is a sport that promotes the development of one's musculature and aesthetically pleasing physique. The script discusses how bodybuilding, unlike powerlifting, involves subjective judgments based on the appearance and symmetry of the competitors' bodies, rather than objective measures.

💡Mr. Olympia

Mr. Olympia is an annual bodybuilding contest, which is one of the most prestigious competitions in the sport. The script refers to it as an example of a major event in the world of bodybuilding where the subjective nature of judging is highlighted.

💡Subjectivity

Subjectivity pertains to the quality of being influenced by personal feelings, tastes, or opinions. The script explores how subjectivity plays a significant role in bodybuilding judging, where opinions on the 'best' physique can vary widely among spectators and judges.

💡Aesthetics

Aesthetics in the context of the script refers to the appreciation of beauty and the principles that underlie this appreciation. It is central to both beauty pageants and bodybuilding, where the appearance and presentation of the physique are key to the evaluation process.

💡Beauty Pageants

Beauty pageants are competitive events where contestants are judged on their physical appearance, elegance, and personality. The script compares these to bodybuilding in terms of the criteria used for judging, highlighting the subjective nature of beauty and the importance of appearance.

💡Steroid Use

The use of anabolic steroids is a controversial topic in bodybuilding, as it enhances muscle growth but can have health risks. The script mentions that the prevalence of steroid use in bodybuilding is one of the reasons why it is not recognized as an Olympic sport.

💡Olympic Sports

Olympic sports are sports that are part of the Olympic Games and are recognized for their athletic and competitive nature. The script discusses the criteria for Olympic sports and why bodybuilding, due to its subjective judging and steroid use, does not meet these criteria.

💡Art

Art in the script is discussed as a form of creative expression that can be appreciated for its beauty and emotional impact. It draws a parallel between bodybuilding and art, suggesting that the physique of a bodybuilder can be seen as an artistic creation that elicits emotional responses.

💡Arnold Schwarzenegger

Arnold Schwarzenegger is a former professional bodybuilder, actor, and politician. The script references him as an iconic figure in bodybuilding who has transcended the sport to become a symbol of the art and discipline involved in bodybuilding.

💡High Art, Middlebrow Art, Low Art

These terms categorize art based on its accessibility and the level of cultural sophistication required to appreciate it. The script uses these categories to discuss where bodybuilding might fit within the hierarchy of art forms, suggesting that bodybuilding could be considered a form of 'low art' due to its broad appeal and accessibility.

Highlights

John Hack's world record in the 100 kg bench press category in powerlifting is indisputably recognized in strength sports.

In contrast, bodybuilding achievements can be subjective and may not appear as a matter of merit.

The decision of the main bodybuilder at the 2022 Mr. Olympia competition was agreed upon by the FPB judges, but spectators could disagree with the panel's evaluation.

Bodybuilding is fundamentally subjective, unlike powerlifting where records are based on concrete and verifiable measures.

Some argue that bodybuilding should not be considered a competitive sport due to its reliance on subjective opinions and emotions.

Bodybuilding and beauty pageants share similarities as both involve judging based on physical appearance and other criteria.

Beauty pageants assess contestants on appearance, elegance, posture, personality, and specific skills.

Bodybuilding competitions focus on muscular symmetry and definition, with competitors displaying their physique in choreographed poses.

Bodybuilders prepare intensively for competitions with rigorous training, diet, and physical preparation routines.

Bodybuilding competitions are organized at various levels, from local to international events like Mr. Olympia and the Arnold Classic.

The International Olympic Committee (IOC) has not recognized bodybuilding as an Olympic sport due to the use of anabolic steroids.

The IOC also argues that bodybuilding lacks athletic elements and is based solely on physical appearance, not athletic performance.

The subjective nature of bodybuilding evaluations makes it difficult to include as an Olympic event, according to the IOC.

Art is a creative expression that can vary widely and is not necessarily linked to physical effort or sports.

Bodybuilding can be seen as a form of popular art, similar to graffiti, anime, or TV shows, which are widely accessible and understandable.

Arnold Schwarzenegger's participation in a live statue exhibit at the Museum of Modern Art in New York highlights the artistic aspect of bodybuilding.

Bodybuilders, like artists, create something to be observed and elicit emotional responses, which can be seen as a form of artistic expression.

The emotional impact of bodybuilding can be compared to that of art, with reactions serving as inspiration and motivation for others.

Renowned bodybuilder Sergio Nobre suggests that bodybuilding is not just a sport but primarily an art form, with the body as the canvas.