最強掃地機器人 PK (2) 小米 X10 Plus + 科沃斯 X1 OMNI + 石頭 S7 Max Ultra 用後心得老實說

3C 達人廖阿輝

12 Dec 202212:41

Summary

TLDRIn this video, Ah Hui introduces the Xiaomi X10 Plus, Taiwan's third all-in-one floor cleaning robot, comparing it with the Roborock S7 Ultra and Ecovacs X1. After a month of use, he shares insights on choosing between the three, highlighting features like automatic mopping, LDS and dTof sensors, and voice control. He emphasizes the importance of a cleaning station for washing mops and the convenience of a dust bag. The video concludes with a detailed comparison of specs, performance, and pricing, favoring Xiaomi for its cost-effectiveness and functionality.

Takeaways

🤖 Introduction of Xiaomi's X10 Plus as the third all-in-one sweeping robot in Taiwan, following the Stone S7 Ultra and Ecovacs X1.
🛠️ Recommendation for purchasing robots with LDS (Laser Distance Sensor) and radar sensors for advanced navigation and object recognition.
🧹 Evolution of sweeping robots from simple vacuuming to mopping with auto-washable mops and stations, enhancing cleaning efficiency.
💡 Suggestion to opt for robots with a base station for auto-washable mops to avoid continuous use of a dirty mop, akin to manual cleaning practices.
🔄 Description of the auto-washable mop system in the Xiaomi X10 Plus, which rotates at 180 rpm and returns to the base for cleaning, similar to Ecovacs' design.
🔊 Mention of a quiet mode in the Xiaomi X10 Plus for less noise during cleaning, suitable for use while sleeping or in quiet environments.
🚫 Highlight of the robot's ability to detect and avoid obstacles like carpets and mats by lifting the mop, preventing secondary contamination.
📈 Comparison of the three robots' suction power, with the Stone robot having the highest at 5200Pa, and the importance of brush design over raw suction power.
💧 Discussion on the water tank capacities and the frequency of maintenance required for the robots, with Xiaomi having a slightly smaller capacity than Ecovacs.
🏠 Note on the height difference between the robots, affecting their ability to clean under furniture, with Ecovacs being slightly taller.
📱 Comparison of the app and voice control features, with Ecovacs offering direct voice commands without the need for a smartphone or smart speaker.

Q & A

What are the three all-in-one robotic vacuum cleaners mentioned in the script?
-The three all-in-one robotic vacuum cleaners mentioned are Roborock S7 Ultra, Ecovacs Deebot X1, and Xiaomi Mijia Sweeping and Mopping Robot X10 Plus.
What are the key features that Ah Hui suggests looking for in a robotic vacuum cleaner?
-Ah Hui suggests looking for features such as LDS (Laser Distance Sensor), radar sensors, front vision for object recognition, and the ability to automatically return and wash the mop cloth.
How does the Xiaomi X10 Plus differ from the Roborock S7 Ultra and Ecovacs Deebot X1 in terms of mop cloth design?
-The Xiaomi X10 Plus has a dual-rotating mop cloth design similar to the Ecovacs Deebot X1, which is an improvement over the initial single cloth designs and offers a more effective cleaning method.
What is the significance of the auto-wash feature for the mop cloth in robotic vacuum cleaners?
-The auto-wash feature for the mop cloth is significant as it prevents the robot from spreading dirt around the house by washing the mop cloth during the cleaning process, similar to how one would wash a mop or cloth while cleaning manually.
What is the advantage of having a robotic vacuum cleaner with a dustbin bag in the base station?
-A robotic vacuum cleaner with a dustbin bag in the base station allows for less frequent emptying of the dustbin, as the bag can be replaced every 2 to 3 months, depending on the household's dirt situation.
How does the Xiaomi X10 Plus handle different floor types, such as carpets?
-The Xiaomi X10 Plus can raise its mop cloth by 7mm to avoid getting it dirty on carpets or other surfaces that should not be mopped, and it can also navigate around these areas or focus on vacuuming without mopping.
What are the differences in the suction power among the Xiaomi X10 Plus, Roborock S7 Ultra, and Ecovacs Deebot X1?
-The Roborock S7 Ultra has the highest suction power at 5000Pa, followed by the Roborock S5 Max at 5200Pa, and the Xiaomi X10 Plus at 4000Pa. However, Ah Hui suggests that suction power is not as critical for robotic vacuum cleaners as the brush's ability to lift dust and dirt.
How does the Xiaomi X10 Plus compare to the Roborock S7 Ultra and Ecovacs Deebot X1 in terms of price?
-The Xiaomi X10 Plus is the most affordable among the three, with a price difference of approximately 3000 units of currency compared to the other two models.
What are the cleaning capabilities of the base station for the Xiaomi X10 Plus and Ecovacs Deebot X1?
-Both the Xiaomi X10 Plus and Ecovacs Deebot X1 have base stations that can clean the mop cloth, with the Xiaomi X10 Plus having a removable cleaning tray for easier maintenance, while the Ecovacs Deebot X1 has a self-cleaning function that requires manual intervention for optimal results.
What additional features does the Ecovacs Deebot X1 have that the Xiaomi X10 Plus might lack?
-The Ecovacs Deebot X1 has a dTof sensor for more accurate and faster map building, a higher machine height that might limit its access under certain furniture, and direct voice control with 'OK YIKO' for commands without needing a smartphone or smart speaker.

Outlines

00:00

🤖 Introduction to the Xiaomi X10 Plus Robot Vacuum

In this paragraph, the host, Ah Hui, introduces the Xiaomi X10 Plus, the latest addition to the all-in-one robot vacuum market in Taiwan. After using the device for a month, Ah Hui shares his hands-on experience and insights on how it compares to the Roborock S7 Ultra and Ecovacs Deebot X1. He emphasizes the importance of having a robot vacuum with LDS (Laser Distance Sensor) and advanced features like automatic mop cleaning. The Xiaomi X10 Plus is highlighted for its dual-rotating mop plate that mimics the cleaning motion of manually scrubbing floors and its ability to return to the base for washing, a feature that significantly improves cleaning efficiency over traditional single-cloth designs.

05:00

🔍 Detailed Comparison of Robot Vacuum Features

Ah Hui delves into a detailed comparison of the Xiaomi X10 Plus with its competitors, discussing various features such as suction power, side brush design, and mopping capabilities. He notes that while the Xiaomi has slightly less suction power, it is not a significant drawback due to the effectiveness of its brush system. The single side brush on the Xiaomi is contrasted with the dual brushes on the Roborock, but Ah Hui suggests that with good algorithm design, the difference in performance is minimal. The paragraph also touches on the mopping feature, with the Xiaomi's ability to lift its mop by 7mm to avoid carpets and mats, which is a notable advantage over the Roborock's design. Additionally, the discussion includes the base design, with Xiaomi's offering a more compact and space-efficient option, and the differences in water tank capacities between the models.

10:01

🏠 Practical Considerations and Final Verdict on Robot Vacuums

In the final paragraph, Ah Hui wraps up the comparison by addressing practical considerations such as the height of the vacuums, which affects their ability to clean under furniture, and the ease of maintenance and cleaning of the vacuum bases. He points out that the Roborock X1 has a slightly higher height, which may limit its ability to clean under lower furniture. The host also compares the self-cleaning features of the bases, noting that while both have their pros and cons, neither is entirely hands-off. Ah Hui concludes by expressing his personal preference for the Xiaomi X10 Plus due to its competitive price and feature set, which he believes offers 70-80% of the functionality of more expensive models. He acknowledges the appeal of the Roborock X1's advanced features, such as its ability to navigate carpets and its independent voice control, but suggests that for new buyers, the Xiaomi X10 Plus represents a great value.

Mindmap

Keywords

💡Robotic Vacuum Cleaner

A robotic vacuum cleaner is an automated machine that cleans floors and carpets without the need for human intervention. In the video's context, the theme revolves around the introduction and comparison of different models of robotic vacuum cleaners available in Taiwan, highlighting their advancements and features.

💡LDS (Laser Distance Sensor)

LDS is a technology used in robotic vacuum cleaners for navigation and mapping of the cleaning area. It emits a laser beam that reflects off surfaces and returns to the sensor, allowing the robot to understand its surroundings. In the script, it is mentioned as an essential feature for modern robotic vacuum cleaners.

💡Visual AI Recognition

Visual AI Recognition refers to the use of artificial intelligence and cameras in robotic vacuum cleaners to identify and make decisions about objects in the environment. The script mentions this feature as a way for the robots to avoid obstacles like cords and shoes more effectively.

💡Mopping Function

The mopping function is a feature that allows robotic vacuum cleaners to clean floors by not only vacuuming but also mopping, simulating the action of wiping the floor with a cloth. The script discusses the evolution from a simple cloth to automatic wash-and-dry mopping systems.

💡Auto-Emptying Base

An auto-emptying base is a station where the robotic vacuum cleaner returns to empty its dustbin and clean its mop after use. The script emphasizes the convenience of this feature, reducing the need for frequent manual cleaning of the robot.

💡Dust Bag

A dust bag is a disposable container within the vacuum cleaner that collects the dirt and dust. The script mentions that some models have a dust bag design, which simplifies the maintenance by allowing the user to replace the bag every few months instead of cleaning the dustbin regularly.

💡Quiet Mode

Quiet mode is a setting on some robotic vacuum cleaners that operates the machine at a lower noise level, typically by using a single brush roll for cleaning. The script suggests that this feature is suitable for cleaning during sleep hours to minimize disturbance.

💡Height Adjustment

Height adjustment is a feature that allows the robotic vacuum cleaner to raise its mop or brushes to avoid cleaning certain areas like carpets or mats. The script uses this term to describe how certain models can adapt to different floor types and obstacles.

💡dTof (Direct Time of Flight)

dTof is a technology that uses the time it takes for a light signal to bounce back from an object to measure distance. In the context of the video, it is used for more accurate mapping and navigation, but it may increase the height of the vacuum cleaner, affecting its ability to clean under low furniture.

💡Price Comparison

The script discusses the price differences between the various robotic vacuum cleaner models, noting that while they have similar features, the price can be a determining factor for consumers. It mentions a price gap of approximately 3000 units of currency between the models.

💡Cleaning Performance

Cleaning performance refers to the effectiveness of the robotic vacuum cleaner in cleaning various surfaces. The script compares the suction power, brush design, and mopping capabilities of different models, indicating that while suction power is important, the overall cleaning ability is influenced by multiple factors.

Highlights

Introduction to the new Xiaomi X10 Plus robot vacuum, highlighting its one-month use experience.

Recommendation to buy robot vacuums with LDS radar sensors for better performance and object detection.

Importance of choosing a robot vacuum with a base station that can clean its mopping cloth automatically.

Xiaomi X10 Plus features a rotating mop design that cleans itself automatically at the base station.

Comparison of the Xiaomi X10 Plus with other models like the Roborock S7 Ultra and Ecovacs X1.

Detailed analysis of suction power, with Xiaomi X10 Plus offering 4000Pa, compared to other models.

Discussion on the design and effectiveness of single vs. dual side brushes in robot vacuums.

Highlighting the advantages of mop height adjustment, particularly for avoiding carpets and mats.

Comparison of the base station designs, with Xiaomi offering a more compact and minimalist style.

Xiaomi X10 Plus' unique feature of detachable cleaning components for easier maintenance.

Assessment of the robot's noise levels, especially with the single mop mode for quieter operation during sleep.

Recommendation of Xiaomi X10 Plus for users without carpets due to its mop height adjustment.

Comparison of the mapping technologies, with dToF offering faster and more accurate mapping but with a slight height increase.

Final verdict: Xiaomi X10 Plus offers a good balance between price and functionality, especially for new buyers.

Reminder to clean the area before using any robot vacuum to avoid potential obstructions or damage.