Sorry, We Need To Talk About Fabrizio Romano

HITC Sevens
20 Aug 202429:25

Summary

TLDRThe video script discusses the rise of Fabrizio Romano, a prominent football journalist known for his transfer news coverage. It delves into Romano's journey from a teenage blogger to a social media sensation with millions of followers. However, the script also criticizes Romano's one-sided reporting on Mason Greenwood, a player accused of serious allegations, suggesting a potential lack of journalistic integrity and raising questions about the influence of public interest and personal motives in football journalism.

Takeaways

  • 😀 Fabrizio Romano is a well-known and trusted football journalist, particularly for his transfer news coverage.
  • 👑 Known as 'the king of the transfer window,' Romano has a massive following on social media, exceeding many football clubs and players.
  • 📢 Romano's career took off when he started his blog at 18 and later scored significant scoops, including player transfers, which boosted his reputation.
  • 🔍 Romano has been criticized for his extensive and one-sided coverage of Mason Greenwood, especially considering the player's controversial background.
  • 🤔 The video raises questions about Romano's journalistic integrity, suggesting a possible lack of critical commentary on certain players.
  • 💬 Romano has been accused of not crediting other journalists for their work, capitalizing on their stories to gain engagement on social media.
  • 💰 The script discusses the influence of the 'attention economy' on Romano's rise to fame and the role of brand deals in his career.
  • 📝 The video script implies that Romano's early success was partly due to a quid pro quo relationship with an agent, setting a precedent for his modus operandi.
  • 🤝 Romano's growth is attributed to his ability to understand and adapt to the public's appetite for transfer news and social media trends.
  • 📉 Some critics argue that transfer journalists like Romano have taken some of the excitement out of the transfer market by over-reporting on deals.
  • 🎯 The video concludes by emphasizing the murky nature of football journalism and the potential for conflicts of interest in the industry.

Q & A

  • Who is Fabrizio Romano and what is his significance in the world of football journalism?

    -Fabrizio Romano is a renowned football journalist known as the 'king of the transfer window.' He has gained a massive following and is considered one of the most trusted sources for transfer news, starting his career at the age of 18 with his own blog and eventually breaking significant transfer news stories.

  • What was the first significant news story Fabrizio Romano broke?

    -Romano's first significant news story was about the transfer of Maro Accardi to Sdor, which was a relatively minor story at the time, but it marked the beginning of his career in breaking transfer news.

  • How did Romano's career take off after his initial break?

    -Romano's career took off when he landed a job at Sky Sports Italia and was mentored by veteran transfer journalist Jan Luca deao. He worked tirelessly to build contacts and eventually broke the news of Accardi's move to Inter Milan, which was a much bigger story.

  • What role did social media play in Fabrizio Romano's rise to fame?

    -Social media played a crucial role in Romano's rise to fame. With nearly 90 million followers across platforms, his coverage of high-profile transfers, such as Paul Pogba's return to Manchester United and Bruno Fernandez's signing, elevated him to a level of stardom online, exceeding any football journalist before him.

  • What is Fabrizio Romano's catchphrase, and how has it become iconic in world football?

    -Fabrizio Romano's catchphrase is 'Here we go,' which has become iconic in world football. It is frequently invoked by clubs, players, and fans alike to announce that an exciting deal has been completed.

  • What controversy surrounds Fabrizio Romano's coverage of Mason Greenwood's transfer to Marseilles?

    -The controversy lies in Romano's one-sided and highly editorialized coverage of Greenwood's transfer, without mentioning the player's past accusations and the subsequent dropping of charges due to the withdrawal of a key witness, which some argue should be part of the public interest when reporting on such a controversial figure.

  • Why has Fabrizio Romano been criticized for his coverage of Mason Greenwood?

    -Romano has been criticized for his uncritical and disproportionate coverage of Greenwood, including tweeting about him frequently and quoting sources praising the player without providing any context regarding the controversy surrounding him.

  • What is the significance of the Danish journalist's allegations about Fabrizio Romano's company offering publicity for payment?

    -The allegations suggest that clubs can buy publicity from Romano's company by paying a fee, which raises questions about the integrity and objectivity of the coverage provided by Romano to his large following on social media.

  • How does the video script suggest the relationship between football agents and journalists like Fabrizio Romano?

    -The script suggests that there can be a quid pro quo relationship between football agents and journalists, where agents provide exclusive information to journalists in exchange for favorable coverage of their clients.

  • What criticism do some other journalists have against Fabrizio Romano?

    -Some journalists accuse Romano of not properly crediting their work, suggesting that he takes stories they have covered and presents them as his own, benefiting from his larger following.

  • How has Fabrizio Romano's approach to social media contributed to his success?

    -Romano's success can be attributed to his ability to read the public mood and adapt to it. He shifted from personal Instagram posts to transfer news and expanded his reach beyond Italian football by writing and speaking in English, capitalizing on the explosion of social media and the attention economy.

Outlines

00:00

📰 Fabrizio Romano's Rise to Fame

Fabrizio Romano, at 31, has become a trusted and influential figure in football journalism. Starting as a blogger at 18, Romano broke into the scene with exclusives on player transfers, notably involving Gerard Deulofeu and Marco Accardi. His work at Sky Sports Italia under the mentorship of Jan Luca deago expanded his network. Romano's global recognition grew with his freelance work for The Guardian, particularly his coverage of Paul Pogba's return to Manchester United and Bruno Fernandez's signing. With nearly 90 million followers, Romano's catchphrase 'Here we go' has become iconic in football, often used to confirm deal completions.

05:01

🤔 Questioning Romano's Coverage of Mason Greenwood

The script discusses concerns about Romano's extensive coverage of Mason Greenwood, especially given the player's controversial background involving assault allegations. Romano has tweeted about Greenwood frequently, often without critical commentary, which raises questions about editorial bias or the influence of public interest. The video script suggests that Romano's focus on Greenwood may be driven by audience engagement rather than a balanced journalistic approach.

10:01

🔊 The Impact of Romano's One-Sided Reporting

This paragraph delves into the implications of Romano's one-sided coverage of Greenwood, highlighting the lack of context regarding the player's past legal issues. It criticizes Romano for amplifying positive comments about Greenwood from figures like Marseille's coach Roberto de Zerbi, without addressing the controversy surrounding the player's signing. The script suggests that Romano's reporting may be more about generating engagement than providing comprehensive news.

15:02

🤝 The Murky World of Football Journalism

The script explores the unspoken rules of football journalism, where relationships between journalists, agents, and clubs can influence coverage. It suggests that Romano's initial break in the industry was through a mutually beneficial relationship with an agent. The paragraph implies that such relationships might continue to play a role in Romano's work, hinting at the possibility of undisclosed agreements for favorable coverage.

20:02

📉 The Changing Landscape of Football News

This paragraph discusses the evolution of football journalism, with a focus on the role of social media and the 'attention economy.' It acknowledges Romano's ability to adapt to these changes and capitalize on the public's appetite for real-time updates. The script also addresses criticisms that Romano may not always credit the original sources of stories, instead presenting them as his own scoops to his large following.

25:02

🎥 Romano's Brand Deals and Public Perception

The final paragraph touches on Romano's involvement in brand deals and advertising, suggesting a potential conflict of interest with his journalistic integrity. It also addresses the public's perception of Romano, particularly in light of his coverage of controversial figures like Mason Greenwood. The script concludes by reiterating the concerns about Romano's reporting methods and their implications for the integrity of football journalism.

Mindmap

Keywords

💡Fabrizio Romano

Fabrizio Romano is an Italian sports journalist who specializes in transfer news, particularly in football. He is known for his extensive following and trusted reputation within the football community. In the video, Romano's journey from a young blogger to a globally recognized figure in sports journalism is highlighted, emphasizing his influence and the controversies surrounding his reporting style.

💡Transfer Window

The transfer window is a period during which football clubs can transfer players into and out of their squads. Romano is dubbed 'the king of the transfer window' due to his expertise and prominence in reporting on player transfers. The video discusses Romano's significant role and impact during these periods, especially on social media.

💡Scalability

Scalability refers to the ability of a system, process, or entity to handle a growing amount of work. In the context of the video, Romano's work scalability is mentioned when discussing how covering stories beyond Italian football expanded his audience and influence, leading to a significant increase in his social media following.

💡Catchphrase

A catchphrase is a popular phrase or expression that is associated with a particular person or entity. Romano's catchphrase 'Here we go' has become iconic in world football, signaling the confirmation of a transfer deal. The video explains how this phrase has contributed to his brand and is frequently used by clubs, players, and fans.

💡Social Media

Social media platforms are used by Romano to disseminate transfer news and engage with his followers. The video emphasizes Romano's massive following on various social media platforms, which is a testament to his popularity and the effectiveness of his reporting strategy.

💡Mason Greenwood

Mason Greenwood is a professional football player who has been the subject of controversy due to off-field incidents. The video script discusses Romano's coverage of Greenwood, particularly focusing on his transfer to Marseille and subsequent debut, which has been criticized for lacking context and critique regarding the player's past.

💡Controversy

Controversy in this video refers to the disagreement or dispute surrounding certain topics, in this case, Romano's reporting style and the player Mason Greenwood. The video critiques Romano for his one-sided coverage and lack of critical commentary on the controversies related to Greenwood's past allegations.

💡Debate

Debate is a formal discussion on a particular topic in which different arguments are put forward for and against. The video mentions a debate within the football community regarding the signing of Greenwood by Marseille, highlighting the differing opinions and the public interest in the controversy.

💡Public Interest

Public interest refers to matters that affect the public as a whole and are of general concern. The video discusses whether Romano's coverage of Greenwood serves the public interest, questioning the balance between providing updates and offering critical context to the audience.

💡Transfer Rumors

Transfer rumors are speculative reports about potential player transfers between football clubs. Romano started his career by covering such rumors, and the video reflects on how this initial focus has evolved into a larger role in the football journalism landscape.

💡Journalistic Integrity

Journalistic integrity involves maintaining a standard of honesty, accuracy, and fairness in reporting. The video questions Romano's integrity by suggesting that his coverage of certain players, particularly Greenwood, may be influenced by factors other than objective reporting.

Highlights

Fabrizio Romano is known as the king of the transfer window and is one of the most followed and trusted football journalists globally.

Romano started his career at 18 by founding a blog covering transfer rumors.

He gained prominence by breaking the news of Maro Accardi's move to Sdor.

Romano's work was boosted by his mentor Jan Luca deao at Sky Sports Italia.

He expanded his reach by covering stories in English on the Guardian's platform.

Romano's coverage of Paul Pogba's return to Manchester United increased his visibility.

He has a massive social media following, exceeding any football journalist before him.

Romano's catchphrase 'Here we go' has become iconic in world football.

Despite his popularity, there are criticisms of Romano's one-sided coverage of certain players.

Romano's frequent tweets about Mason Greenwood have raised questions about his editorial stance.

There are allegations that Romano's company has offered clubs publicity for a fee.

Romano's growth is attributed to his understanding of the public mood and the social media landscape.

Some journalists accuse Romano of taking credit for their work by promoting it to his large following.

Romano has been involved in various brand deals, reflecting his growing audience and profile.

Critics argue that Romano's coverage takes some of the fun out of the transfer market by revealing deals too early.

The video discusses the ethical implications of Romano's coverage of players accused of serious crimes.

Transcripts

play00:00

Fabrizio Romano is a phenomenon dubbed

play00:03

the king of the transfer window at the

play00:05

age of 31 Romano is one of the most

play00:08

followed and trusted journalists in the

play00:10

world it all started when Romano was

play00:12

just 18 years old and he founded his own

play00:14

blog covering transfer rumors his first

play00:17

big scoop if you can call it that came

play00:20

when an aspiring agent at Barcelona's

play00:22

laazer Academy reached out to him and

play00:24

asked him to write profiles about two

play00:26

players that he hoped to represent

play00:28

namely Gerard de F and Maro Accardi

play00:32

Romano obliged and subsequently broke

play00:34

the news of a Cardi's move to sdor it

play00:37

wasn't exactly headline breaking news

play00:40

aardi like Romano was just 18 years old

play00:43

and was a youth team player who had

play00:45

never played for Barcelona joining a

play00:47

second tier team in Italy as a thank you

play00:49

for Romano's contribution to his own

play00:51

career though the same agent gave him

play00:53

another scoop two years later which

play00:56

allowed Romano to break the news of a

play00:58

Cardi's move to Inter Milan this was a

play01:00

much bigger story and for a young Romano

play01:03

the touch paper had well and truly been

play01:05

lit during the intervening period Romano

play01:08

had landed a job at Sky Sports Italia

play01:10

where veteran transfer journalist Jan

play01:12

Luca deao had taken him under his wing

play01:15

and become his mentor Romano worked

play01:17

tirelessly to build up contacts at clubs

play01:20

with agents and even with restaurants

play01:22

and hotels that he knew were often

play01:24

frequented by players and prospective

play01:26

new signings but his explosion onto the

play01:28

world stage was a combination of

play01:30

accident and opportunism in 2015 Romano

play01:34

landed a freelance role with the

play01:36

guardian and began covering stories in

play01:38

English on a consistent basis it was the

play01:41

frequent updates on Paul pogba's return

play01:43

to Manchester United in 2016 for a world

play01:46

record fee that open Romano's eyes to

play01:48

the scalability of his work if he

play01:50

broadened his Horizons Beyond Italian

play01:52

football and it was his coverage of

play01:54

another Manchester United signing Bruno

play01:56

Fernandez that elevated Romano to a

play01:58

level of stardom online profile

play02:01

exceeding any football journalist before

play02:03

him at the time Romano was still only 26

play02:07

years old Romano now has close to 90

play02:10

million followers on social media and

play02:12

probably more by the time that you're

play02:13

watching this joing one of the B anual

play02:16

periods of immense growth for brand

play02:18

Romano otherwise known as a transfer

play02:21

window Romano has more followers on

play02:23

Twitter than Bayern Munich or Muhammad

play02:25

Salah more followers on Instagram than

play02:27

AC Milan or Kevin De bruyne more

play02:29

followers on Facebook than Ajax

play02:31

Newcastle United and Baio saaka combined

play02:35

more followers on Tik Tok than either

play02:36

Arsenal or Robert levendowski and most

play02:39

incredibly of all he has more

play02:41

subscribers right here on YouTube than

play02:43

yours truly the hitc SS and Alfie pots

play02:47

armmer YouTube channels combined I know

play02:51

I can't believe it either all the while

play02:53

Romano has managed to turn his

play02:54

catchphrase here we go into one of the

play02:57

most iconic in World football frequently

play02:59

invoked by clubs players and fans alike

play03:02

when an exciting deal has been done it

play03:05

is a remarkable Journey from aspiring

play03:07

teenage blogger to Global Sensation that

play03:10

has made Romano a source of a and

play03:12

inspiration you'd have to be a real rter

play03:15

to have a bad word to say about him then

play03:17

wouldn't

play03:19

you I mean really what kind of person

play03:22

would do something like that oh oh yeah

play03:27

that's right here we go

play03:30

a week or so ago I made a video about

play03:32

why the 2024 summer transfer window has

play03:35

felt so boring in which I made a

play03:37

fleeting remark about not being very

play03:39

fond of fabito Romano well I shouldn't

play03:43

sugarcoat it what I actually described

play03:45

him as is a repugnant and aoral ghoul

play03:48

that's it Al don't sit on the fence tell

play03:50

us what you really think to my surprise

play03:53

what seemed like about half of the

play03:55

comments on that 34 Minute long video

play03:58

were just people asking why I'm not a

play04:00

fan of fabito Romano I probably

play04:02

shouldn't have been so surprised as I

play04:04

outlined in the introduction Romano is

play04:07

immensely popular both in terms of the

play04:09

sheer size of his following but also in

play04:11

terms of people being fond of him

play04:12

himself he is a likable and personable

play04:15

character he's got a good camera

play04:17

presence and uh well he provides

play04:19

reliable information about transfers

play04:21

which for good or bad is highly valued

play04:24

and much appreciated by a lot of

play04:26

especially very online football fans he

play04:29

was consider Ed not by me but he was

play04:31

considered to be witty articulate

play04:34

knowledgeable and so on and much

play04:37

respected again not by me but I'm giving

play04:40

the general impression anyway I thought

play04:43

nothing of it I burn Bridges like a

play04:45

retreating Army implementing a scorched

play04:47

Earth policy on this channel but then

play04:49

over the weekend Romano tweeted not once

play04:53

not twice but three times about Mason

play04:55

Greenwood's debut for Marseilles and I

play04:58

thought nah sorry this bl's getting a

play05:00

video it's not the first time it should

play05:02

be said that Romano has tweeted about

play05:05

Greenwood oh no far from it in fact

play05:08

since the 8th of July

play05:10

2024 so what in the last 6 weeks Romano

play05:14

has tweeted about Greenwood brace

play05:16

yourselves 25 times which you know is

play05:21

quite a lot Elon Musk doesn't even tweet

play05:23

the word concerning in response to a

play05:25

post by a white supremacist that often

play05:28

now I know what some of you will

play05:30

probably be thinking and I want to be as

play05:33

fair to Romano as possible his job is

play05:35

covering transfers Mason Greenwood move

play05:38

from Manchester United to Mars during

play05:39

that time of course he's going to report

play05:42

on it so what if he seem to report on

play05:44

Greenwood's transfer Saga more than most

play05:47

if you look up most notably and I

play05:50

actually did this it took forever Joel

play05:52

Felix and Victor osam men specifically

play05:55

Romano has also tweeted about them an

play05:57

awful lot over the last six or so weeks

play06:00

so what's the problem well firstly

play06:03

Romano doesn't just tweet about

play06:04

Greenwood in relation to potential

play06:06

transfers as was the case over the

play06:08

weekend when he made his debut for

play06:10

Marseilles secondly he actually quoted

play06:12

Greenwood uncritically with zero

play06:15

commentary when he wrongly claimed to

play06:17

have been cleared of all charges when in

play06:19

actual fact the case against him was

play06:21

dropped due to the main witness

play06:22

withdrawing her testimony and the crown

play06:24

prosecution service being unable to

play06:26

prosecute a case without that witness

play06:28

which is a fairly significant

play06:30

distinction and thirdly and most

play06:33

conspicuously of all Romano's coverage

play06:35

of Greenwood and others but we will just

play06:38

stick with Greenwood for now is often

play06:40

highly editorialized allow me to give

play06:43

you some examples for a start there are

play06:46

at least 10 examples of Romano tweeting

play06:48

about Greenwood which has little or

play06:50

nothing to do with transfers take this

play06:53

tweet from September

play06:54

2023 when Romano shared a video

play06:57

captioned GFE fans welcoming Greenwood

play07:00

now I had a little look and uh again

play07:03

brace yourselves for this because you're

play07:05

in for a shock I couldn't find Romano

play07:07

ever having shared a video of any other

play07:09

GFE players being unveiled in fact

play07:13

outside of transfer news and managerial

play07:15

or executive incomings and outgoings I

play07:17

couldn't find a single tweet by Romano

play07:20

about GFE that wasn't about Mason

play07:23

Greenwood strange H there is a perfectly

play07:26

innocent explanation for all of this of

play07:29

of course Mason Greenwood is a former

play07:32

England International who has been in

play07:34

the news a lot in recent years and he

play07:36

was on loan at GF from Manchester United

play07:39

one of the biggest clubs with one of the

play07:41

biggest fan bases and therefore among

play07:43

the most interest in their players of

play07:46

any club in the world it is just basic

play07:48

supply and demand people want Greenwood

play07:51

updates Romano is just the vehicle

play07:53

through which they receive them he only

play07:55

talks about Greenwood so often because

play07:57

it is in the public interest seems

play08:00

innocuous enough right except if Romano

play08:03

is indeed providing a public service

play08:05

which would seem to be the only

play08:07

justification for giving Greenwood such

play08:09

disproportionate coverage in airtime

play08:11

surely it would also be in the public

play08:13

interest for that coverage to come with

play08:15

some context and critique I mean it's

play08:18

one thing to site Greenwood having been

play08:20

in the news a lot in recent years as a

play08:22

justification for giving him

play08:24

disproportionate coverage but why he has

play08:26

been in the news so much in recent Years

play08:28

also seems somewhat relevant here no for

play08:32

any of you who are completely baffled by

play08:34

what I'm talking about and have been

play08:36

living under a rock for the last few

play08:37

years with this being the first piece of

play08:39

media that you have consumed since the

play08:41

dawn of covid-19 in January 2022

play08:45

Greenwood was accused of assault on

play08:47

social media by his girlfriend these

play08:49

accusations were accompanied with images

play08:51

of Greenwood's girlfriend appearing

play08:53

battered bruised and bleeding and audio

play08:55

of her telling a man that she calls

play08:57

Mason that she doesn't want to engage in

play08:59

an intimate act with him and him telling

play09:01

her that he doesn't care before

play09:03

threatening her I am saying appears to

play09:05

show and a man she calls Mason because

play09:08

12 months after Greenwood was arrested

play09:10

on suspicion of rape assault sexual

play09:13

assaults and threats to kill the crown

play09:15

prosecution service dropped all charges

play09:17

against him citing the withdrawal of key

play09:19

Witnesses for what it's worth as far as

play09:22

I can tell at least neither Greenwood

play09:24

nor his Representatives nor any of his

play09:27

clubs have ever denied that the voice on

play09:28

the audience was him I'm obviously not

play09:31

going to share them here but I would

play09:33

imagine most people are familiar with

play09:35

them and my personal view is that it is

play09:37

terrifying that anyone would look to

play09:39

defend or make apologies for someone

play09:41

having seen and heard them to be clear I

play09:44

think there is absolutely nothing wrong

play09:46

with a football journalist covering

play09:48

Mason Greenwood's move to Marseilles

play09:50

heck I've talked about it on this very

play09:52

channel so that would be pretty

play09:54

hypocritical of me and I think there are

play09:56

plenty of interesting dignified and

play09:58

worth ways in which to cover it that

play10:01

actually are in the public interest for

play10:03

example Greenwood's move to Marseilles

play10:05

has unsurprisingly proven to be

play10:08

extremely controversial in Marseilles

play10:10

with many supporters having voiced their

play10:12

disgusted his arrival along with the

play10:14

mayor of Mars benoir payan a lifelong

play10:17

Mars fan who made headlines when he

play10:19

called on Marse president Pablo Longoria

play10:22

not to sign Greenwood branding Greenwood

play10:25

and I quote a disgrace that conflict

play10:28

between those who consider Greenwood to

play10:30

be beyond the pale and signing him a

play10:32

moral Abomination and those who don't

play10:34

care about his character any past

play10:36

indiscretions what he's been accused of

play10:38

and the evidence against him only

play10:40

whether he can score goals and make

play10:42

money for Marse that is genuinely in the

play10:45

public interest I'm not expecting fabito

play10:48

Romano to do any groundbreaking work or

play10:50

investigative journalism on the ground

play10:52

getting quotes from Mars sponsors fan

play10:55

groups directors Ultras and owners on

play10:57

what side they fall down on that's not

play10:59

what he does but straightforwardly

play11:01

reporting on something like payan's

play11:03

opposition that was already within the

play11:05

public domain or indeed just any

play11:08

opposition the fact that the move may

play11:10

have been remotely controversial or

play11:11

unpopular with some people you know like

play11:14

uh domestic violence Charities I hardly

play11:17

think that that is too big of an ask

play11:19

what is particularly strange about all

play11:21

of this is the fact that even if you

play11:23

consider Fabrizio Romano to be an aoral

play11:26

pit of vity totally uninterested in the

play11:29

concepts of right wrong or any semblance

play11:31

of decency whatsoever which I do and you

play11:34

think his primary concern is solely

play11:36

likes shares and ultimately money which

play11:39

uh I also do that wouldn't explain his

play11:42

one-sided coverage of Greenwood a tweet

play11:45

about the opposition to Greenwood

play11:46

signing for Marseilles especially from a

play11:48

figure as prominent as the mayor of the

play11:51

second largest city in France I am

play11:53

almost certain would gain a fair amount

play11:55

of traction greater traction I would

play11:58

imagine then a video of Greenwood

play12:00

walking from the airport to his private

play12:02

transport in Marseilles captioned by

play12:04

Romano Mason Greenwood has just landed

play12:07

in Marseilles plan confirmed I mean I

play12:11

can't be sure of course but that would

play12:13

be my suspicion or how about Romano

play12:15

tweeting not once not twice but three

play12:18

times about Greenwood's debut away at

play12:20

breast a game which commanded

play12:22

International attention of course

play12:24

speaking about him in glowing terms

play12:26

Romano's first tweet read quote first

play12:29

goal as Olympic marsel player just 3

play12:32

minutes into the game for Mason

play12:34

Greenwood accompanied by a photograph

play12:36

seemingly of Greenwood in training his

play12:38

second tweet red quote Mason Greenwood

play12:41

makes it two in 30 minutes excellent

play12:43

debut as olyp Marse new player end quote

play12:47

and his third in which he quoted marse's

play12:50

head coach Roberto daeri read quote

play12:53

deseri Mason Greenwood is just

play12:56

exceptional he's an excellent player and

play12:58

you can see that I'm happy to see him

play13:01

scoring so it will all the controversy

play13:03

in the media end quote right uh let's

play13:07

just unpack all of that shall we firstly

play13:10

Greenwood scored a goal nothing to do

play13:12

with transfers Romano tweeted about it

play13:14

bit odd but he does do that very

play13:17

occasionally he tweeted that amadu Anana

play13:19

had scored on his Aston Villa debut

play13:21

which you know anano has never been

play13:23

credibly accused of heinous crime so

play13:25

slightly different but for the sake of

play13:27

steelmanning Romano we just let that

play13:29

first one slide his second tweet and he

play13:32

didn't tweet twice let alone three times

play13:34

about anyone else's debut on Saturday

play13:36

afternoon not even one mention of Center

play13:39

back voldman Anton scoring and keeping a

play13:42

clean sheet on his debut for brucia

play13:44

Dortmund oddly enough his second tweet

play13:46

added some editorializing heaping Praise

play13:49

on Greenwood and describing it as a

play13:51

quote excellent debut how very kind and

play13:55

last but not least there is the dii

play13:57

quote to be clear

play13:59

this isn't the first time that Romano

play14:01

has just uncritically quoted deser on

play14:04

Greenwood back in July he Amplified

play14:06

these incredibly dignified comments by

play14:08

the Zerby which read quote for sure

play14:11

Mason's a worldclass player I don't know

play14:13

his background no matter the player once

play14:16

they sign here they become like my

play14:18

children I protect them always end

play14:22

quote Stay classy Roberto at least that

play14:26

time the quote made grammatical and

play14:28

syntactical if not moral sense this time

play14:31

Romano again very happily and

play14:34

uncritically quotes deeri as saying

play14:37

quote Mason Greenwood is just

play14:39

exceptional he's an excellent player and

play14:42

you can see that I'm happy to see him

play14:44

scoring so it will all the controversy

play14:46

in the media end quote huh so it will

play14:51

all the controversy in the media it will

play14:53

what Roberto make people forget the

play14:55

video and audio that they saw with their

play14:57

own lying eyes and ears make people

play14:59

Overlook that three of Mars's front 4

play15:01

have either been convicted for their

play15:03

role in a deadly driving accident

play15:05

accused of rape or accused of beating

play15:07

women and pressuring secondary school

play15:09

girls to perform lud acts in front of

play15:11

them or just make people forget that

play15:13

you're a gutless and Shameless coward be

play15:16

clear Roberto we don't know what you

play15:18

mean otherwise how are fabrizio's 87

play15:22

million followers going to know what

play15:24

you're talking about at least we've

play15:26

established I suppose that Fabrizio is

play15:28

capable of uncritically quoting someone

play15:30

without any commentary just in case you

play15:33

thought me suggesting that he could have

play15:34

done the same with the mayor of

play15:35

Marsailles in relation to Greenwood's

play15:37

transfer was beyond his capabilities so

play15:41

uh it's all a little bit strange I think

play15:44

Romano's primary motive is engagement

play15:46

and the revenue that a company's

play15:48

engagement but it seems as though with

play15:50

some players as in the case of Greenwood

play15:53

it goes a little bit beyond that now

play15:56

just to be absolutely clear because I

play15:59

wouldn't want there to be any ambiguity

play16:01

surrounding this whatsoever I am not

play16:03

suggesting that Romano has ever received

play16:06

any payment in exchange for anything

play16:08

that he has written or talked about on

play16:10

social media I am not claiming or even

play16:14

remotely suggesting that Denmark's

play16:16

oldest football magazine tips bladet are

play16:19

and claim to have been shown

play16:20

documentation proving it but I am

play16:22

absolutely not no I have no evidence to

play16:26

suggest that is the case but what I will

play16:28

do and I'm sure fabito would approve of

play16:30

me doing it because it is one of his

play16:32

favorite pastimes is just uncritically

play16:34

quote someone else according to the

play16:37

Danish journalist throlls B enson

play16:39

writing in tips blad it and translated

play16:41

into English quote clubs can buy

play16:44

publicity tips bladet has seen

play16:46

documentation of how the company behind

play16:49

for Brito Romano has contacted clubs

play16:51

also Danish with an offer that they can

play16:53

buy mention on the Italian social media

play16:56

the clubs can pay a shilling and then

play16:58

Fabrizio Romano provides publicity for

play17:01

the club and player to his more than 20

play17:03

million followers on X and 27 million

play17:06

followers on Instagram end quote not my

play17:09

words ladies and gentlemen the words of

play17:11

throlls B enson what do I make of it all

play17:15

well farbe it from me to say really I'm

play17:17

just sharing it with you all hey as my

play17:19

old mate fabito always says don't shoot

play17:22

the messenger just because I'm sharing

play17:25

something with you quoted directly and

play17:27

have added zero cont text or criticism

play17:30

does not mean that I support it or

play17:32

endorse it in any way shape or form

play17:35

isn't that right for Brito in all

play17:37

seriousness I genuinely don't know

play17:39

whether those allegations are true but

play17:41

what I do know is that football is a

play17:43

murky business and much as we might like

play17:45

to think of it as being one of the

play17:47

world's last great meritocracies and in

play17:49

some ways it is in the sense that talent

play17:51

and hard work are key determinants of

play17:54

success you can't just Wing your way to

play17:56

winning a Balon door in other ways much

play17:59

like in other Industries sometimes it's

play18:01

not just about what you know but who you

play18:03

know Romano's first breakthrough was

play18:05

writing a profile about two youth team

play18:07

players on behalf of an aspiring agent

play18:10

in exchange for a scoop and subsequently

play18:13

a much bigger scoop two years later in

play18:15

other words it was a titp fortat

play18:18

relationship of the kind that are almost

play18:20

ubiquitous in football journalism and in

play18:22

the media as a whole just as in politics

play18:25

politicians will leak information and

play18:27

gossip to the media particularly to

play18:29

Lobby journalists here in the United

play18:31

Kingdom in exchange for more favorable

play18:33

coverage about themselves their party or

play18:35

more negative coverage of their

play18:37

political opponents footballers and

play18:39

particularly football agents are really

play18:42

no different agents feed their allies in

play18:44

the Press leaks gossip and exclusive or

play18:47

early information and in exchange they

play18:50

might expect let's just say some

play18:52

favorable coverage of one or more of

play18:55

their clients so I'm Dave bottom FEI an

play18:59

agent who works on behalf of the total

play19:01

mercenaries and unashamed greed

play19:03

Incorporated talent agency and I want it

play19:05

to be out in the press that my

play19:06

18-year-old client Bobby wvic is looking

play19:10

to leave porchester athletic and sign

play19:12

for oil Rich dictatorship FC so I feed

play19:15

my friend Mark MC scumbag who works as a

play19:18

journalist for the racism and

play19:19

transphobia times and has lots of

play19:21

followers on social media a story about

play19:24

a training ground bust up some manager

play19:26

losing the dressing room or Danny MC

play19:28

wats his face being left out of the

play19:30

squad at the weekend and in return he

play19:32

writes about how Bobby want out ofic is

play19:34

the best thing since slice bread the

play19:36

rich s are all desperate to sign him and

play19:38

he is actively exploring his options

play19:41

away from Forester pushing it out to his

play19:43

millions of readers and followers all of

play19:46

a sudden every Rich seven clubs fans are

play19:49

desperate for their team to sign Bobby

play19:51

if they don't it shows a frightening

play19:53

lack of ambition quite frankly and the

play19:55

board has to go have have I watched him

play19:59

yeah of course I've watched him he

play20:01

completed three successful jewels on

play20:03

Tuesday night in an under 21 behind

play20:05

closed doors friendly against Damo never

play20:07

heard of them again just to be clear I'm

play20:11

not suggesting that Fabrizio Romano is

play20:13

Mark M scumbag in this analogy Mark

play20:16

mumbach is his own man with his own

play20:18

sources and is not to be confused with

play20:21

anyone else put some respect on Mark's

play20:23

name please for crying out loud honestly

play20:26

if he just picked a better catchphrase

play20:27

back in 201 16 then here we commence

play20:30

he'd be the one with 90 million

play20:32

followers by now no I'm not suggesting

play20:35

that Romano does anything like this I

play20:38

have no idea but even if he did it would

play20:41

be by no means exclusive to him but as

play20:43

someone who is hyper reliant on contacts

play20:46

leaks and early info more so than just

play20:48

about anyone else in the business as

play20:50

well as having the largest social media

play20:52

presence among his peers it would be

play20:54

surprising if he wasn't especially

play20:56

impacted by such quidd Pro oo

play20:59

Relationships by his own admission that

play21:01

is how Romano got started in covering

play21:03

transfers so it would seem odd if he had

play21:06

stopped there I spoke in that previous

play21:08

video about how not just Romano even if

play21:10

he is the most prominent example but

play21:12

transfer journalists as a whole are

play21:15

often perceived as having taken some of

play21:16

the fun out of the transfer market by

play21:19

providing constant commentary on every

play21:21

deal meaning that by the time they are

play21:23

officially announced everyone is either

play21:25

already well aware of them if not

play21:27

actively Bor of caring about it gone of

play21:30

the days by and large of Arsenal calling

play21:32

a press conference and sending the world

play21:34

of football into a meltdown when they

play21:36

unveiled S Campbell signed on a free

play21:38

transfer from their bitter Rivals

play21:39

Tottenham when the entire press pack had

play21:42

just been expecting them to announce the

play21:44

signing of goalkeeper Richard Wright I

play21:47

agree with that criticism but as I said

play21:49

at the time I don't blame journalists

play21:51

like Fabrizio Romano or his PE I blame

play21:54

the insatiable appetite of chronically

play21:56

online football fans myself included

play21:58

when I was a bit younger at least for

play22:00

the newest updates every second of every

play22:03

minute of every hour of every day

play22:05

throughout the entire transfer window

play22:07

and Beyond in that sense Romano is just

play22:10

serving a very real public appetite as a

play22:13

big fish within a broader ecosystem for

play22:16

which I don't really think you can hold

play22:18

him personally responsible if anything

play22:21

Romano's greatest strength has just been

play22:23

to read the public mood and then shift

play22:25

with it he has said himself it was when

play22:28

people started commenting on his

play22:29

personal Instagram photographs that he

play22:31

quit sharing photographs about himself

play22:34

and started using it as a platform to

play22:36

talk about transfers it was when he saw

play22:38

a rise in traffic covering English clubs

play22:41

that he realized that there was a bigger

play22:42

market for him if he expanded his reach

play22:44

Beyond Italian football and wrote and

play22:46

spoke in English instead and it is the

play22:49

explosion in social media and the

play22:51

attention economy that has turned him

play22:53

into a superstar with Romano just

play22:55

getting swept up in the wave by becoming

play22:57

very good at understanding how it works

play23:00

there are other journalists and this

play23:02

isn't private information I am referring

play23:05

solely to those who have publicly add

play23:06

their grievances online who have accused

play23:08

Romano of not properly crediting other

play23:10

journalists for their work and therefore

play23:13

basically taking the glory with his much

play23:15

larger following for other people's hard

play23:17

work you may even have seen Romano

play23:20

sometimes be described as a tapin

play23:21

merchant owing to the perception that he

play23:24

takes stories that have already been

play23:25

covered by other lesser known

play23:27

journalists and boost them at the 11th

play23:29

Hour as his own taking all of the credit

play23:32

I have seen examples where I think this

play23:34

is a fair assessment of what Romano was

play23:36

done but also others where I think it's

play23:38

probably a little bit harsh and

play23:40

sometimes he does credit other

play23:42

journalists I think it's pretty evident

play23:44

that Romano works very hard does have

play23:46

lots of reliable sources and contacts

play23:49

and does get lots of Scoops which is

play23:51

unsurprising especially now given the

play23:54

size of his following he has also been

play23:56

shrewed throughout his growth in in not

play23:58

boosting stories as soon as he hears a

play24:00

whisper about them from anyone and in

play24:02

generally trying to be more accurate

play24:04

than the kind of gossip and rumor

play24:06

accounts and websites that dominated the

play24:08

field when he started out I know because

play24:11

around the same time when I was only 13

play24:14

I started a transfer rumors and news

play24:16

website of which there were hundreds if

play24:19

not thousands at the time writing

play24:21

largely nonsense transfer rumors that

play24:23

I'd either heard from some Anonymous

play24:25

accounts or just entirely made up are IP

play24:30

www.fo rumors. kk5 dog gone but never

play24:34

forgotten don't bother trying to look

play24:36

that up by the way not only have all

play24:38

traces of it been wiped from the

play24:39

internet I checked but it also now

play24:41

redirects you to some very viruslike

play24:44

looking popup nonsense now if you want

play24:47

to see my other work just follow the

play24:48

Alfie Poots hmer YouTube channel where

play24:51

there are already three out standing and

play24:53

fascinating videos including me visiting

play24:55

the world's biggest football stadium

play24:57

Capac

play24:59

250,000 following Georgia at their first

play25:02

ever tournament Euro 2024 and pretty

play25:05

soon there will be a fourth one of me

play25:08

visiting the German city with the lowest

play25:10

GDP per capita where I also visit a

play25:12

theme park with a friend who's terrified

play25:15

of rides yeah exactly you wouldn't want

play25:18

to miss that would you where was I oh

play25:20

yeah fa Brito Romano look I don't want

play25:24

any of you thinking that I'm just mad

play25:25

because I turned down a brand deal with

play25:27

the Chinese Electronics manufacturer and

play25:30

tournament sponsors high sense at the

play25:31

2022 welcome in Qatar because well you

play25:34

know I don't do brand deals let alone at

play25:37

that tournament only for Guess Who

play25:39

that's right good old Fab to pop up and

play25:41

say here we go buy a new TV please high

play25:45

sense really were only interested in

play25:47

partnering with the biggest names in

play25:49

World football I can only assume that I

play25:51

was Port of Call number one Kaka second

play25:54

and good old Fab third In fairness

play25:57

fauzio is is a veteran Advertiser over

play26:00

the years he's done brand deals with the

play26:02

likes of scrill the Peter Crouch podcast

play26:05

Beats headphones s is it pronounced SRA

play26:08

I think so la Laver that is a Saudi

play26:12

perfume company apparently Google pixel

play26:15

opta Adidas Turkish Airlines and Pepsi

play26:19

that was in order of alt to you by the

play26:20

way with all due respect to the pizza

play26:22

Crouch podcast the move to Google Adidas

play26:25

and Pepsi is probably somewhat

play26:27

representative of how rapidly Romano's

play26:29

audience and profile has grown over a

play26:32

short period of time Romano has also

play26:34

advertised the online gambling company

play26:36

Betson and the Bitcoin and altcoin

play26:38

exchange platform Z crypto I mean of

play26:42

course he has I am earing rumors of the

play26:44

collaps in the value of tcoin wiping out

play26:47

your investment as well as a serious

play26:49

gambling addiction leading to the

play26:51

breakdown of your work life

play26:53

relationships and mental health here we

play26:56

go that isn't real how he advertised

play26:59

them it's a shame that I don't do

play27:00

brandels to be honest I think I'd be

play27:02

great at them nor am I annoyed it must

play27:04

be said about him flagrantly trying to

play27:06

steal my list of seven format back in

play27:09

2021 nice try for barzio but there's

play27:12

only room for one seven Bas listicle

play27:14

content creator in this town no all of

play27:17

that is water under the bridge I just

play27:19

think that anyone sing over a guy who is

play27:21

very credibly accused of doing truly

play27:24

horrific things and basically whatever

play27:26

the motive doing PR for them without any

play27:30

mention whatsoever of the jet sized

play27:32

elephant in the room is well at best

play27:35

rather sus I tweeted this before making

play27:38

this video and some people replied

play27:40

saying that Romano couldn't possibly say

play27:43

anything about the accusations against

play27:45

Greenwood because he would get sued

play27:48

firstly even if that were true it

play27:50

wouldn't mandate him to be gushing in

play27:52

his praise of him and secondly it isn't

play27:54

true you can't say that Mason Greenwood

play27:56

is X or did one as a matter of fact well

play28:00

you can but you would be potentially

play28:02

liable to some defamation or liable

play28:04

claims because he hasn't been convicted

play28:06

of anything I mean I highly doubt he

play28:08

would sue because of the Optics and the

play28:10

stries and effects public opinion etc

play28:13

etc but you could theoretically which is

play28:16

why I don't but you can say what

play28:18

Greenwood was accused of what the

play28:20

evidence that was widely publicized on

play28:22

social media was and why the crown

play28:24

prosecution service in their own words

play28:27

dropped the case against against him I

play28:29

mean I literally did it in this video

play28:32

lots of people have done it it's not

play28:34

very hard so uh yeah that's why I called

play28:38

Fazio Romano a repugnant and aoral ghou

play28:42

I am uh I'm happy to clear that up

play28:45

cheers thank you all as for watching hit

play28:48

the like button if you enjoyed today's

play28:50

video let me know your thoughts Down

play28:52

Below in the comments and of course it

play28:54

goes without saying make sure that

play28:55

you're subscribed and have notifications

play28:57

turned on not just for this channel HCC

play29:00

7s but as I mentioned earlier on also my

play29:03

second Channel Alfie Poots Arma uh both

play29:05

of which should be about to appear on

play29:07

your screens now along with a couple of

play29:09

videos that you might fancy watching

play29:10

after this one you can also find me on

play29:12

Twitter threads and Instagram via the

play29:15

username at h7s on all three should you

play29:17

wish to do so and all of those links

play29:20

plus a whole lot more should be down in

play29:21

the video description below cheers

Rate This

5.0 / 5 (0 votes)

Etiquetas Relacionadas
Fabrizio RomanoFootball JournalismTransfer NewsSocial MediaControversyMason GreenwoodMedia InfluenceJournalistic EthicsSports CoverageOnline EngagementIndustry Critique
¿Necesitas un resumen en inglés?