30€ Smart Ring vs 449€ Samsung Galaxy Ring: Ist billiger sogar besser?

Summary

The video compares two smart rings: the premium Samsung Galaxy Ring and the budget-friendly M1 Smart Ring. The Samsung Galaxy Ring, priced at €449, offers superior build quality, more advanced health tracking features, and a stylish design. It excels in heart rate, sleep, and SpO2 monitoring, and includes a sleek charging case. In contrast, the M1 Smart Ring, costing only €30, is bulkier and less accurate in tracking but still provides basic features like step counting, sleep tracking, and pulse monitoring. The video emphasizes the difference in quality and functionality, ultimately recommending the more affordable M1 ring for those on a budget.

Takeaways

• 😀 The Samsung Galaxy Ring is priced at €449 and is significantly more expensive than the M1 Smart Ring, which costs around €30-40.
• 😀 The Samsung Galaxy Ring offers a more premium design with three color options: black, silver, and gold, while the M1 Smart Ring has a less aesthetic design and only comes in one color.
• 😀 The Samsung Galaxy Ring is made with high-quality materials, including a titanium protective coating and is resistant to water and dust with an IP68 rating.
• 😀 The M1 Smart Ring is more affordable but uses a cheaper plastic material, resulting in visible scratches and lower durability.
• 😀 The Galaxy Ring includes advanced fitness tracking features like heart rate, blood oxygen saturation, sleep monitoring, and HRV measurement, making it more sophisticated compared to the M1 Smart Ring.
• 😀 Both rings offer sleep tracking, but the Galaxy Ring is more accurate, providing detailed phases of sleep, while the M1 Smart Ring shows less precise data.
• 😀 Step tracking accuracy is unreliable on both devices, with the Galaxy Ring sometimes overestimating steps and the M1 Smart Ring underestimating them.
• 😀 The Samsung Galaxy Ring offers continuous heart rate and blood oxygen level monitoring, while the M1 Smart Ring has manual measurement features that aren't always reliable.
• 😀 The Galaxy Ring provides a more robust app experience with features like fitness tracking insights, stress assessments, and advanced sleep analysis, while the M1 Smart Ring app is simpler and more basic.
• 😀 The Samsung Galaxy Ring has a more convenient charging system, using a transparent case with a USB-C port, whereas the M1 Smart Ring requires a magnetic charging cable that is less user-friendly.
• 😀 While the Samsung Galaxy Ring is a more expensive investment, it offers superior functionality, build quality, and app integration, whereas the M1 Smart Ring, while cheaper, compromises on accuracy and features.

Q & A

What are the key differences in design between the Samsung Galaxy Ring and the M1 Smart Ring?

The Samsung Galaxy Ring has a sleek, minimalistic design with a slim, titanium-coated exterior, available in three colors (black, silver, and gold). It is thinner and lighter, weighing between 2.3 and 3 grams, with a 7mm width. On the other hand, the M1 Smart Ring is bulkier, has a single color option (black with a silver rim), and weighs slightly more at 3.5 grams. It also features a less refined, plastic build and a more obvious smart ring design.

How does the durability of the Samsung Galaxy Ring compare to the M1 Smart Ring?

The Samsung Galaxy Ring is highly durable, featuring a titanium layer that offers resistance against scratches and daily wear. It has an IP68 rating for water and dust resistance. The M1 Smart Ring, in contrast, is made from cheaper plastic, which is prone to scratches, and does not offer the same level of durability. Its water protection is only rated at IP5.

What health metrics do the Samsung Galaxy Ring and M1 Smart Ring track?

Both rings track essential health metrics like heart rate, sleep, and blood oxygen levels (SpO2). The Samsung Galaxy Ring additionally tracks respiratory rate, heart rate variability, and offers automatic workout recognition. The M1 Smart Ring tracks heart rate, sleep, steps, and SpO2 but lacks heart rate variability tracking and automatic workout recognition.

How reliable are the sleep tracking results for both rings?

The Samsung Galaxy Ring provides accurate sleep tracking, showing sleep stages with minimal deviation from reference devices like the Apple Watch Series 8. In comparison, the M1 Smart Ring's sleep data is less reliable, with frequent discrepancies and data gaps, potentially due to the ring’s battery running out during sleep.

Which ring offers better accuracy for step counting?

The Samsung Galaxy Ring's step counting is more reliable, although still slightly off compared to the Apple Watch. The M1 Smart Ring, however, consistently underperforms, showing roughly half the steps counted by the Apple Watch, making it less reliable for tracking daily movement.

What is the difference in battery life between the two smart rings?

The Samsung Galaxy Ring offers a longer battery life, lasting up to 7 days depending on the size of the ring. Smaller sizes have slightly shorter battery life. The M1 Smart Ring has a much shorter battery life, lasting 3 to 5 days, but is more likely to run out of battery without notifying the user.

What are the app experiences like for both rings?

The Samsung Galaxy Ring uses the Samsung Wearable App for setup and the Samsung Health App for fitness and health tracking, providing a comprehensive, user-friendly experience. The M1 Smart Ring relies on a simpler, less polished app, with limited functionality and often inaccurate or missing data.

Does the Samsung Galaxy Ring have any additional smart features?

Yes, the Samsung Galaxy Ring offers extra features such as a camera trigger function, allowing users to take photos with a gesture, and a ring locator that uses a blinking LED light to help find it. However, it lacks sound alerts for locating the ring and ultra-wideband technology for precise tracking.

How does the price compare to the features offered by both rings?

The Samsung Galaxy Ring is significantly more expensive at €449, offering superior build quality, a wider range of health metrics, better app integration, and a unique charging case. The M1 Smart Ring, priced at €30 to €40, provides basic tracking features but lacks the quality and functionality of the Galaxy Ring.

Would you recommend the Samsung Galaxy Ring or the M1 Smart Ring for someone on a budget?

For someone on a budget, the M1 Smart Ring is a more cost-effective option, offering basic fitness tracking at a fraction of the price of the Samsung Galaxy Ring. However, for those seeking more accurate data, better durability, and additional smart features, the Samsung Galaxy Ring is a better choice, despite its higher price.