燕郊爆炸现场记者被阻拦,记协为何要为央视记者站台?|燕郊|爆燃|央视记者|新闻|维稳|王局拍案20240314
Summary
TLDR本视频报道了发生在河北省三河市燕郊镇的一起严重的煤气爆炸事故,时间为3月13日早晨。爆炸地点位于一家炸鸡店,造成7人死亡,27人受伤。事故引发了广泛关注,许多市民用手机和行车记录仪记录了爆炸过程。报道还涉及了对事故现场的描述,包括建筑物被摧毁和玻璃被炸碎的情况。报道指出,煤气爆炸的巨大冲击力引起了人们对煤气安全管理的关注。同时,视频还报道了中央电视台记者在现场报道时遭到当地政府干扰的情况,以及中国记者协会对此事的反应和要求,最终燕郊对此事件发表了道歉声明。该报道不仅反映了事故的严重性,还突出了媒体报道权利和公共安全管理的重要性。
Takeaways
- 💥 爆炸发生在河北省三河市燕郊镇的一家炸鸡店,造成了严重的破坏和火焰冲天。
- 🕗 时间定在早上7:54,现场有许多人,并且很多市民用手机和行车记录仪记录了整个爆炸过程。
- 🚒 爆炸被认为是气瓶泄漏导致的爆轰,这种现象在餐饮业使用的大型气瓶中更为常见。
- 🔍 初步分析认为,泄漏的气体与空气混合后遇到明火引发了爆轰,导致了巨大的爆炸影响。
- 🏢 爆炸导致整栋建筑倒塌,附近的建筑也受到严重影响,街对面的商业街建筑玻璃被震碎。
- 🚑 报告提到此次事故导致7人死亡,27人受伤,反映了基层社会管理和火灾安全管理的重大疏漏。
- 📺 事故发生后,央视记者迅速到达现场进行报道,但遭到了当地政府的阻挠。
- 🔥 中国记者协会发表文章,质疑当地对媒体报道的阻碍,强调媒体在紧急灾难报道中的必要性和权利。
- 📢 该事件在网络上引起了广泛关注和公众愤怒,批评了燕郊的做法,并强调了新闻自由和透明度的重要性。
- 🏥 随后,燕郊发布了道歉声明,解释了阻碍记者报道的情况,并对此表示歉意。
Q & A
爆炸发生的具体时间和地点是什么?
-爆炸发生在2024年3月13日早上7点54分,地点位于河北省三河市燕郊镇的一家炸鸡店。
爆炸发生时有多少人在现场?
-爆炸发生时有很多人在现场,包括顾客和路过的车辆中的人员。
爆炸的影响有多大?
-爆炸的影响非常大,火焰直冲天际,整个建筑被摧毁,对面街道的建筑物所有玻璃也被震碎,一楼的门基本被炸飞。
Outlines
💥河北燃气爆炸事故现场
3月13日早晨7:54,河北省三河市燕郊镇发生了一起爆炸事故,事发地点为一家炸鸡店,现场火光冲天,人群慌乱逃窜。此次爆炸被认为是由燃气泄漏引起的爆炸,涉及到的燃气罐与家用燃气罐不同,体积较大,管理不善容易导致严重后果。此类爆炸事故近年来频发,引起了广泛的社会关注。
🚫新闻报道受阻
在燕郊爆炸事故发生后,到场报道的央视记者遭遇当地工作人员的阻挠,导致直播中断。这一事件引发了公众的强烈不满,并被视为对中央政府的不尊重。中国记者协会随后发文质问燕郊的做法,强调媒体在灾难报道中的必要性及其对防止谣言传播的重要作用,此举在社会上引起了正面的反响。
🔍事故现场报道分析
经过仔细分析央视记者在燕郊爆炸事故现场的报道,可以看出记者们并未遭到系统性的阻挠。他们的报道侧重于积极的救援努力和事故现场的情况,这与央视报道紧急事件的常规方式相符。尽管存在一定的干扰,但并未严重影响报道的进行。这次事件中,记者的权利受到限制是一种客观现实,引发了对记者报道权利的广泛关注。
✊媒体与权力的较量
燕郊爆炸事件中的媒体阻挠现象反映出媒体在中国社会运作中面临的困难。尽管中国记者协会发声支持记者权利,但实际上媒体的独立报道空间十分有限。中国缺乏一个保障媒体权利的制度环境,导致媒体难以成为社会的第四权力。燕郊事件揭示了中国媒体职业的现状,以及记者在报道真相时面临的挑战。
Mindmap
Keywords
💡爆炸
💡气瓶泄漏
💡灭火
Highlights
河北三河市燕郊镇发生爆炸,现场情况惨烈,火焰冲天。
爆炸发生在一家炸鸡店,事发时店内有很多人。
许多市民用手机和行车记录仪记录了整个爆炸过程。
爆炸后,现场民众慌乱逃离,路过的车辆也紧急停车逃离。
爆炸视频上传网络后,引起了广泛关注。
爆炸看似由煤气罐泄漏引发,但实际影响巨大,如同战争现场。
Transcripts
The footage you are now seeing is from yesterday, that is, March 13th.
It's the scene of an explosion that occurred in Yanjiao Town, Sanhe City, Hebei Province.
This explosion happened at 7:54 in the morning.
The location was a fried chicken shop, where many people were present.
Many citizens recorded the entire explosion process with their mobile phones and dashcams.
You can see the explosion site was truly a horrific sight, with flames reaching the sky.
Then, many people at the scene fled in a disheveled manner.
And there were people passing by in their cars,
who quickly jumped out of their cars to escape the scene.
At the time the accident just happened, I didn't pay much attention to it,
because I thought that these kinds of domestic explosions have been too frequent in recent years.
An explosion of a gas cylinder
wouldn't have too severe consequences, right?
But a few hours later, this video was uploaded online,
and I was indeed shocked when I saw it.
You see, from that aerial angle,
it simply doesn't look like the result of a gas cylinder explosion.
It's like a war just happened,
leaving behind ruins caused by an aerial bomb.
So, why would a gas explosion produce such a huge impact?
I'm here to share a piece of common knowledge with everyone,
that is, this gas explosion, or say, a gas fire,
it's a deflagration process.
That is, initially, the gas cylinder might have leaked,
and after leaking, the gas leaked out from the cylinder.
After leaking out,
since there was no open flame, it actually diffused into the air continuously.
During the diffusion process,
the gas and the oxygen in the air were actually fully mixed.
That is, within a quite large area of the leak, a large air range,
the gas and air were fully mixing.
At this time, if there's a slight open flame, it would suddenly cause a deflagration.
So-called deflagration is not a simple combustion,
it's explosive, so the scene is actually an explosion site.
So you can see, can't you, an entire building was blown down.
Not only was this building blown down,
you can see, the building across the street, also a commercial street, also a building,
all the glass in that building was also shattered.
The doors on the first floor were basically all blown down.
The effect of the explosion is truly shocking.
Actually, why did this leak happen?
There's also a background to it,
that is, most gas cylinders used in the domestic catering industry
are different from the gas cylinders we use at home.
They are very, very large, looking like an aerial bomb.
So, if these gas cylinders are poorly managed and leak,
it would cause a deflagration.
You can look at the domestic news in recent years,
Such deflagration incidents, we have seen quite a few of them within this year.
Not just in Beijing.
All because of the so-called management and use of gas cylinders.
For example, coil aging.
For example, those in the catering industry not tightening them after cooking at night leading to incidents.
So, these tragedies occur.
As you can see, we get to witness.
The domestic government departments' management of fire safety.
Still has significant oversights.
You can imagine.
Yanjiao is just a stone's throw away from Beijing, though it's in Hebei Province.
In fact, most residents here work in Beijing.
But they live here because they can't afford a house in Beijing with their not-so-high income.
In fact, the distance to Beijing is very close.
The explosion site is only 9 kilometers from Beijing's administrative center.
Think about it, Yanjiao Town in Hebei Province, only 9 kilometers from Beijing.
Its management level and the fire safety hazards are so significant.
A gas cylinder explosion caused 7 deaths and 27 injuries.
Think about it, this is China today.
A true reflection of the government's grassroots social management level.
But, I don't really want to delve too much into the disaster aspect of this news today.
Because the reason this news became a hot topic online.
Is not because it was a death and injury incident caused by a gas deflagration accident.
Because, as I just mentioned.
News like this has happened too many times online in recent years.
This news has garnered a lot of attention on the domestic internet.
Because after the accident happened.
A CCTV reporter quickly arrived at the scene to report.
During the reporting process, two groups of reporters were obstructed by the local government.
Traffic congestion will occur.
Because after this incident.
The first group, CCTV Channel 2's reporters.
Their live broadcast was interrupted by local staff coming over to block them.
Blocking the camera, resulting in the interruption of the live broadcast.
Forces from fire and public security are also intervening.
Too dangerous, too dangerous, stop recording.
Retreat, retreat.
Okay, Hailing, please also pay attention to safety.
Another one is a reporter from CCTV News Center.
To my knowledge, this reporter from the News Center is actually based in Beijing.
He arrived at the scene first.
Then, he posted a video online.
He was completely pushed away from the scene by a dozen local security guards or police.
Just completely pushed out from the scene.
See, we three reporters were surrounded and pushed by a dozen people.
Look, come and see, this is Hebei, look at the TV.
These two videos have been fermenting online since yesterday.
Many people are very angry.
You think, what does a CCTV reporter represent? They represent the central government.
You, little Yanjiao, what is Yanjiao?
Sanhe city, don't be misled by its name being a city, it's a county-level city.
Below the county-level city is Yanjiao Town, and Yanjiao Town is a division-level unit.
A fire occurred in such a division-level place.
CCTV reporters went there to report.
Then, the live broadcast was rudely interrupted, and they were directly asked to leave the scene.
This immediately caused a lot of people's anger.
In recent years, media coverage of such disasters.
Has faced various obstacles and barriers.
But for a district like Yanjiao.
To directly use such pushing and shoving against CCTV reporters.
Isn't that completely disregarding the central government?
So, everyone is criticizing online.
Yanjiao really did go too far.
The news fermented on this basis.
Last night, the China Journalists Association spoke out.
The China Journalists Association published an article on its official account.
Asking three questions to Yanjiao, which three?
They asked whether media should be present at the scene during the reporting process of such emergencies and disasters.
In the midst of such disastrous processes, is the presence of media necessary?
First question, they say it's necessary.
Because having media on the scene to report would prevent the spread of rumors, right?
That's the first point.
The second point says
Is media presence at the scene adding chaos? No, why?
Because the media uses their professional cameras
To present the entire rescue process
This is an essential aspect to satisfy the public's right to know
The third aspect they mentioned is about these so-called emergencies
Are the press releases issued by local governments enough? They say no
Because ordinary people getting to know such a news event
On one hand, will look at the local government's press release
On the other hand, they will check internet news
If the internet news is inaccurate
People might believe the latter
If at this time, the media can report authoritatively on their own
Then, actually, beyond the local government's press release
It can form a very authoritative channel
To prevent the spread of rumors
These are the 3 questions mainly raised by the China Journalists Association
Directly targeting Yanjiao Town in Sanhe City, Hebei Province
Many people applauded the Journalists Association
Here, let me add, what exactly is the China Journalists Association
I had dealings with the China Journalists Association in the past years
It's actually a management organization for journalists under the Central Propaganda Department
Of course, it's a government-operated association
Usually not doing much, its main function is to select the China News Award
At the same time, it's involved in the journalist certification process through organizing exams
Actually, it doesn't play a big role
But inside the association, there are many vice-chairmen
Who are leaders from the media
So they actually have a bit of a consciousness to fight for journalists' rights
That kind of awareness
Moreover, why I think the Yanjiao incident caused such a big backlash
Is because, Yanjiao, a small place
Could use such a method against CCTV journalists?
So the China Journalists Association couldn't stand it
And directly issued these three questions
After all, the China Journalists Association is a deputy-ministerial level unit
So after the China Journalists Association released this message
It put a lot of pressure on Yanjiao
On March 14, Yanjiao specifically issued an apology statement
What does the apology statement say?
It says that after the CCTV reporters arrived at the scene
Our interaction was very good, and we provided a lot of help for their reporting
Then, it was suddenly discovered that there might be a secondary explosion at the scene
For safety reasons, we moved them out
Of course, some staff on the scene spoke quite rudely
We indeed didn't work delicately and apologize to CCTV reporters and the society
After all, it's Yanjiao, a county-level area
So the attitude was relatively humble
But many netizens did not accept this apology statement
Some people said at the scene
They said you see the female reporter said it was dangerous at the scene
But behind her, a group of people looked like leaders
Wearing white masks as if nothing was wrong, why didn't they evacuate?
It shows that saying the scene was very dangerous is deceiving
Just wanted to send the reporters away
All this shows they actually wanted to restrict the reporters' reporting
Such a sinister motive
Not really for the so-called safety of reporters
I took the two videos of the reporters being obstructed and looked at them carefully
I also took the CCTV reporter's live broadcast at the scene
That day, which lasted three and a half hours, and watched it carefully
Let me share my thoughts on this matter
Firstly
The Channel 2 reporter's live broadcast was interrupted at the scene
If you look closely, indeed, something happened on the scene
Indeed, they might not have intended to obstruct the CCTV reporter from reporting there
Here, let me share a common knowledge
CCTV reporters' live broadcast process involves linking up with the studio
It's not just rushing over and then live broadcasting
They generally need to be on the scene 20 minutes to half an hour in advance
To set up the equipment, connect signals, and conduct tests
So, actually, when you watch the live broadcast
In fact, that female reporter named Yang Hailing
She had already been standing there for at least 20 minutes
If those people at that time didn't allow her to broadcast live
She wouldn't have been able to be in that area
Then, you can see at the beginning of her live broadcast
People in front and behind were saying, "Hey, glass is falling, glass is falling"
Glass falling is dangerous
At this scene
We can see
Glass falling, glass falling
So at this time, someone blocked her camera and told her to leave
I believe Yang Hailing's live broadcast
Actually didn't mean to stop her from reporting
That is, if they really didn't want her to report
She wouldn't have been able to stand in that position
And indeed, an incident occurred on-site
And the other reporter
Named Xu Mengzhe
Xu Mengzhe was indeed pushed out of the scene
But without the exact time and location, we can't judge
However, I pulled up the CCTV News
The live broadcast of the new media at that time
This female reporter on March 13th
Did a live broadcast for three and a half hours on-site
I watched this three and a half hours of broadcast
Indeed, there wasn't much interference from the locals
Because I have also been to the scene of such emergencies
Basically, it's divided into three zones
The first zone is called the hot zone
The so-called hot zone is inside the ruins
Where the firefighters are rescuing
a zone where only they can enter
The second area is called the warm zone.
So, the warm zone is outside the building,
extending to the outermost crossroads.
This area includes doctors, staff, and auxiliary rescue personnel.
The third area is called the cool zone, which is an absolutely safe area.
Actually, reporter Xu Mengzhe was mainly active in the warm zone that day.
She wasn't much affected.
The closest she got, I saw, was just a few dozen meters from the scene,
and she kept doing live broadcasts.
"I am Xu Mengzhe, a reporter from the headquarters in Beijing.
Now, my current location is
just the core site of the explosion that occurred at 8 o'clock this morning,
which is a place in Yanjiao Town, Sanhe City, Hebei Province.
Now, as you can see,
the building behind me is where the explosion occurred today.
You can see that all the main structures of that place have been basically destroyed,
only a bit of the scaffolding is left.
Let's go over there and take a look, come on.
These are some of the utensils from the restaurant that were cleared out just now.
This seems to be a small steamer.
Hello, did you find anything just now?
Just now, the dog...
Let our team leader, leader,
Which one can, uh,
Will I affect him if I go now? I dare not get too close.
Then, including some details she discovered on-site,
also including her visit to the building across the street to view the scene,
completely unaffected.
It should be said that as a CCTV reporter, she has some privileges.
Of course, there were no other media reporters on-site,
for example, reporters from local stations, like Hebei station, don't even think about it,
only CCTV reporters could possibly enter the scene.
But when I was on-site,
Xu Mengzhe seemed quite cooperative with the local rescue efforts,
for example, she repeatedly mentioned that they need to listen to the rescuers on-site,
can't just wander around on their own, because the site is dangerous.
Okay, okay, okay, I'm leaving right away, leaving right away.
Just now, the firefighter reminded us
that this area is where all the heavy machinery will be entering.
If we were in that position, it could potentially be dangerous,
so they asked us to leave.
Come on, come on, let's back out, back out.
There's a detail,
at one point, the local firefighters said they needed to use a life detection device
to search for any survivors in the rubble.
They needed to use that instrument, and at that moment, all construction machinery stopped.
They were using the life detection device to search for survivors on-site.
At this time, Xu Mengzhe also said,
"Let's quickly lower our voices, quiet down,
not to disturb the people on-site."
"Today, our main task is to extinguish the fire and maintain stability."
"Now, we can see a large number of medical personnel already waiting on-site."
"Just before the live broadcast, the firefighters told us
they are now going inside the building to conduct life detection."
"They are confirming whether there are any trapped individuals inside the building."
So, there was a detail,
you can see now the sound is very noisy,
because the site operations have resumed,
we are going to clear the crossroads,
including using some large equipment for spraying, including doing some water supply.
The sound is very loud, but before that, the site was almost completely silent,
we all spoke softly,
because the firefighters were conducting life detection work.
"We tried to leave a silent space for the sonar."
Overall, the cooperation between the reporter and the rescuers was good.
And her overall tone of reporting on the scene was very familiar to me,
which is basically how CCTV reports such emergencies:
Firstly, focus on reporting the rescue effort,
when the rescuers arrived, how they are conducting the rescue,
another team of doctors arrived, another team of firefighters,
in summary, focusing on positive rescue reporting.
Secondly, while reporting positively on the rescue, showing the disaster situation,
This is CCTV's overall method of reporting such emergencies.
Basically, the reporting that day followed this approach.
So, it didn't violate the overall tone of propaganda and reporting.
So, in my view
Even though these two reporters faced some so-called obstructions that day,
the locals didn't really make it difficult for their reporting.
Because she had a three-and-a-half-hour live broadcast,
if they really wanted to make it difficult,
how could she have conducted a three-and-a-half-hour live broadcast?
But why are netizens very angry about this?
Frankly, I think there are some reasons for this.
Firstly, CCTV might not have faced much trouble in Yanjiao this time,
but over the years, at other news scenes or sudden news events,
there have been many difficulties.
People can really feel
that the rights of reporters and media to report have been highly restricted.
This is an objective reality.
It's just that this time it was Yanjiao, which maybe didn't have the power to make it difficult,
but, for example, during the Eastern Airlines incident,
could the media enter the scene? No, they couldn't.
Even CCTV didn't do a live broadcast then, right?
Or during the explosion at the hazardous material warehouse at Tianjin Port,
could you enter? No, you couldn't.
And the big fire in Tianjin the year before last,
when Li Hongzhong was the Party Secretary of Tianjin,
over 100 people were burned to death instantly.
Could the media report on it? No, they couldn't.
Even CCTV couldn't enter, right?
So, for these departments, these areas, because of their high administrative level,
CCTV also has been powerless over the years.
Even this time, you can see CCTV itself did not share
those so-called scenes of reporters being obstructed.
Indeed, the power of the media has been restricted like this.
This is a reality, so media professionals are dissatisfied, including the Journalists Association.
The second factor is that Yanjiao is easy to deal with because of its low administrative level.
It's just a department at the regular departmental level. If even such a department
doesn't show enough respect to CCTV,
everyone takes Yanjiao out as a scapegoat,
as a fictional enemy to deal with.
When Li Hongzhong was the Party Secretary of Tianjin,
would the Chinese Journalists Association dare to write such an article?
Three questions for Tianjin City, three questions for Li Hongzhong?
Dare they? Definitely not.
But Yanjiao, because it has no background,
is like a soft persimmon that anyone can squeeze.
So, it became a fictional enemy in the process of defending journalists' rights.
This is the most interesting phenomenon I see in the interaction between the media and the locals during the Yanjiao explosion incident.
Because without such a fictional enemy, the Chinese Journalists Association wouldn't dare to speak out,
since it also wouldn't dare to confront those government departments that truly have power.
They can only support the power of reporters' reporting
when facing such a safe opponent.
They can only act against such a safe opponent,
to support the force of reporters' reporting.
Even Hu Xijin knew, Hu Xijin came out again,
saying this is completely in line with the current propaganda guidelines and needs.
They also took action to obstruct CCTV reporters in such a manner
because Yanjiao as an opponent is a soft persimmon.
I think this is very important.
But even so, I believe this incident is still valuable
because it highlights the difficulties
media currently face in the operation of Chinese society.
I've said it many times,
journalism as a profession in China is truly dead, really dead.
Think about the Yanjiao incident,
was the live broadcast done by CCTV really news reporting?
From a purely journalistic perspective, it falls far short.
Why? Because, as I mentioned earlier, you only cover the rescue,
the rescue process with a slight mention of the disaster situation.
What about the 7 deceased? Their injuries, their family backgrounds,
why they were working there, where they were that day,
including the injured?
Is there such information? That's real investigation.
Including why the deflagration happened,
whether the restaurant used piped gas or gas cylinders.
Then, why would deflagration occur with these gas cylinders during the process?
Such so-called genuine investigative reporting
is also not seen in CCTV's live broadcast.
The latest news I know is that Xinhua News Agency reporters were also driven away.
Why? Because they wanted to visit the ICU in the hospital to contact the victims and their families,
and then they were driven away by the local security.
What about Xinhua News Agency, and what about CCTV?
If you really want to do an investigation, it's not allowed.
You might be allowed to cover the disaster or rescue to a limited extent.
Or to a limited extent, it's possible.
So, as I said, the profession of media in China has long been dead.
So this current situation is unbearable even for the Chinese Journalists Association, a subordinate department of the Central Propaganda Department.
就是连这样的一个最基本的知情权普通的老百姓都难以获得
As a media, it's hard to defend
After Hu Xijin's apologist draft came out
Someone once said, Hu Xijin, what you said is wrong, it's not about the approach to propaganda reporting
You must know that the approach to propaganda reporting does not have an objective standard
If you say you need it, then the media's reporting can be on the spot
If you say you don't need it, then you don't need it, so you must leave
What really should uphold the rights of journalists is the law
So some say, what if China had a press law
Actually, in my view, this statement is also incorrect, why
Do you think the rights of Chinese journalists can be protected just because China has a press law?
How many laws does China have
Aren't there laws like the Compulsory Education Law, the Teachers' Law, the Anti-Corruption and Waste Law
Did they solve the problem?
The NPC is still the supreme organ of state power, isn't it
Do you really think it's the highest authority in China? You're naive
China doesn't lack laws, it lacks the systemic environment to implement the law
Actually, for the media to become the true fourth estate in society
There's a prerequisite, what is the prerequisite
It is that in this society there is no absolute power
This power itself is restricted
If this power itself is restricted
Only then can the media possibly become the fourth power, a fourth kind of power
If there's a power in this society that is completely unrestrained
When no force can restrain it
How can the media possibly become so-called the fourth power
It's impossible, this is the true social reality of China today
In China, the power of the Communist Party of China is not subject to any rights constraints
Under these circumstances, even if there's a press law
It can't guarantee the rights of the Chinese media
When it needs you, it might let you into the scene
To shoot the disaster, shoot the rescue
When it doesn't need you, you better leave here quickly
As for whether there's so-called shoving or conflicts on the scene
Actually, these are all illusions, all misunderstandings, everyone must not be misled
The core of the issue is what I have just explained
But sadly, this reality, whether it's current domestic media personnel
The general public, or even the Chinese Journalists Association
None can change this social reality
So, scene after scene of journalists being shoved
blocked, troubled, and banned at news scenes
You might continue to see
If one day even this is no longer visible, then this profession is completely dead
Okay, that's all I have to say for today, thank you everyone
Look, we three journalists were chased and shoved by more than a dozen people
Look, come see, this is Hebei
Hello, did you find anything just now
Just now the dog...
Let our captain
If we were in that position, it could have been dangerous
So, that's why we were asked to come out
I'm from the central station, journalist Xu Mengzhe
So, my current location
Is the core scene of the explosion that just happened at 8 o'clock this morning
That is, a location in Yanjiao Town, Sanhe City, Hebei Province
Ver Más Videos Relacionados
【朝日】「俺を誰様だと思ってる、朝日新聞の記者だぞ」橋下徹VS朝日新聞から分かるマスゴミの闇。中国新聞や清志会など文脈を汲み取らない組織は悪ばかり。
INSIDE a REAL Ukrainian ARMS ROOM in 2024!
tagesschau 20:00 Uhr, 11.03.2024
Manish Kashyap Interview : NDA सरकार बनते ही मनीष कश्यप का वीडियो तेजी से हो रहा वायरल | Bihar News
I Investigated the Palestine Protests in NYC
中国陷入瘋狂! 稱為台灣和美國拼了! “航母來一艘打沉一艘” 卻又擔心付出的“代價”是什麼?
5.0 / 5 (0 votes)