What Darwin Never Knew (NOVA) Part 2/8 HD

Summary

This script explores Charles Darwin's revolutionary theory of evolution, focusing on his observations of finches and tortoises in the Galapagos and fossils in South America. It delves into the concept of natural selection, where environmental pressures favor traits that enhance survival, leading to species diversification. The script also touches on embryonic development as evidence of common ancestry and the impact of Darwin's 'tree of life' on our understanding of biodiversity.

Takeaways

• 🌏 The Galapagos finches and tortoises diversified into many kinds with different beak shapes and shells, respectively, depending on the island they inhabited.
• 💡 Darwin challenged the prevailing view that species were unchangeable and perfect as created by God, suggesting that species could evolve and adapt.
• 🦏 Darwin's study of fossils in South America indicated that extinct giant sloths and armadillos were the ancestors of smaller, still-existing species.
• 🐍 Studying embryos revealed that species like snakes and whales had traits in their early stages that disappeared or transformed as they matured, hinting at common ancestry.
• 🎵 The idea that humans have fish in their family tree, supported by embryonic evidence, was a significant departure from the belief in separate creation of species.
• 🌳 Darwin proposed the 'tree of life' concept, suggesting all species are interconnected and evolved from common ancestors over time.
• 🐕 The variety in dog breeds, achieved through selective breeding, inspired Darwin to consider a similar process of natural selection occurring in nature.
• 🏞 Darwin's view of nature as a 'war of nature' where only the best adapted survive, contrasted with the Victorian sentimental view of nature.
• 🐧 The finches' beak shapes on the Galapagos Islands adapted to fit the diet of each island, demonstrating how species can change to suit their environment.
• 🔍 Darwin recognized that variation within species was the starting point for natural selection, as slight differences could determine survival in the wild.
• 📚 In 1859, Darwin published 'On the Origin of Species,' a groundbreaking work that introduced the theory of evolution by natural selection.

Q & A

What was the initial diversity of finches in the Galapagos?

Initially, there was just one type of finch in the Galapagos, but over time it diversified into many kinds with different beak shapes.

How did Darwin's view of the tortoises in the Galapagos differ from the standard view at the time?

Darwin observed that one type of tortoise had diversified into many kinds with different shells depending on the island they lived on, which contradicted the standard view that species were created by God and were unchangeable.

What did Darwin discover about the fossils he collected in South America?

Darwin found fossils of a giant sloth and a huge armadillo-like creature, which were extinct but resembled smaller, still-existing animals in South America, suggesting that species can change over time.

How did Darwin's study of embryos contribute to his theory of evolution?

Darwin discovered that embryos of different species, such as snakes and whales, showed vestiges of structures that were present in their ancestors but not in the adult forms, indicating a common ancestry and evolutionary change.

What evidence did Darwin find in human embryos that supported the idea of a common ancestor with fish?

In human embryos, Darwin observed tiny slits around the neck that were similar to gills in fish, suggesting that humans must be descended from fish.

What was the astonishing conclusion Darwin arrived at regarding the diversity of life?

Darwin concluded that all species were connected in a 'tree of life,' meaning that different species, even those that don't look alike, share a common ancestor.

What process did Darwin call the transformation of one type of creature into another?

Darwin called this process 'descent with modification,' which explains how species can change dramatically over generations.

How did Darwin's observations of dog breeds inspire his theory of natural selection?

Darwin saw that dog breeders could select for individual traits and change breeds, which led him to consider if a similar form of selection could occur in nature without human interference.

What was Darwin's view of nature that contrasted with the Victorian sentimental view?

Darwin viewed nature as a 'savage' battlefield where every creature was in a desperate struggle for survival, which he believed was a creative process leading to the evolution of species.

How did the finches' beak shapes on the Galapagos Islands provide evidence for natural selection?

The finches on different islands had beak shapes that were adapted to the specific diets available on each island, suggesting that these beak shapes had evolved to help the finches survive in their respective environments.

What concept did Darwin identify as the starting point for change in nature?

Darwin identified 'variation' as the starting point for change in nature, where tiny differences among individuals could make a significant difference in survival and reproduction.

What was the significance of Darwin's publication 'On the Origin of Species'?

'On the Origin of Species' was a groundbreaking work that introduced the theory of evolution by natural selection, fundamentally changing our understanding of the diversity and history of life on Earth.

Outlines

00:00

🐦 Evolution and Adaptation in the Galapagos

This paragraph discusses Charles Darwin's observations of the Galapagos finches and tortoises, noting their diversification into various species with distinct physical traits based on their island habitats. Darwin challenged the prevailing belief in divine creation of unchanging species, proposing instead a process of evolution driven by environmental pressures. The paragraph also touches on his examination of fossils, which suggested that extinct creatures like giant sloths and armadillos were the ancestors of living species, further supporting his theory of species change over time.

05:03

🐶 The Role of Artificial Selection and the Concept of Natural Selection

The second paragraph delves into Darwin's insights on the variety within species, exemplified by the wide range of dog breeds developed through artificial selection. He observed that breeders could manipulate traits like size and shape, leading to the creation of new breeds. This inspired Darwin to consider a natural equivalent of this process, natural selection, where environmental factors and competition for resources drive the evolution of species. The paragraph also highlights the Victorian era's romanticized view of nature, which Darwin's experiences and observations contradicted, leading him to see nature as a brutal and relentless struggle for survival.

10:05

🌿 The Mechanism of Natural Selection and the Origin of Species

In the final paragraph, the focus shifts to the mechanism of natural selection and how it contributes to the formation of new species. Darwin's observations of the Galapagos finches with their varied beak shapes, adapted to different food sources on different islands, serve as a prime example of natural selection at work. The paragraph also discusses the concept of variation, where slight differences among individuals can have significant survival implications in the wild. Over generations, these variations accumulate, leading to the emergence of new species. Darwin's groundbreaking work, 'On the Origin of Species,' synthesized these ideas, marking a pivotal shift in the understanding of life's diversity and evolution.

Keywords

💡Finch

Finch refers to a group of small to medium-sized passerine birds, known for their distinctive beaks and song. In the video, finches are highlighted as a prime example of species diversification, having evolved into many kinds with different beak shapes on the Galapagos Islands. This variation in beak shape is crucial to the birds' survival, as it allows them to adapt to different food sources on different islands, illustrating the concept of natural selection.

💡Tortoise

Tortoises, as mentioned in the script, represent another example of species diversification. The Galapagos tortoises are known to have evolved into different kinds with varying shell shapes depending on the island they inhabit. This diversification is a key point in the video's discussion of how species change over time, challenging the prevailing view of species as unchanging creations of a divine entity.

💡Natural Selection

Natural selection is the process by which certain heritable traits become more common in a population because they confer a reproductive advantage to the individuals that possess them. In the video, Darwin's theory of natural selection is central to explaining how species evolve and adapt to their environments. The script uses the example of finches with different beak shapes to demonstrate how natural selection can lead to the emergence of new species.

💡Variation

Variation refers to the differences among individuals within a species. In the video, Darwin's observation of variation among individuals, such as the differences between him and his brother or among his children, is used to illustrate the concept that variation is the starting point for change in nature. It is the basis for natural selection, as it provides the raw material upon which environmental pressures can act.

💡Embryo

An embryo is the early developmental stage of a multicellular organism. The video discusses the study of embryos to illustrate Darwin's insights into the common ancestry of different species. For example, the presence of gill slits in human embryos, which are similar to structures found in fish, supports the idea that humans evolved from aquatic ancestors.

💡Extinction

Extinction is the permanent loss of a species. The script mentions extinct animals like the giant sloth and the armadillo-like creature, whose fossils Darwin found in South America. The existence of their smaller, still-living relatives suggests that species can change or become extinct over time, which was a radical idea at the time.

💡Tree of Life

The tree of life is a metaphorical concept that describes the relationships among all living organisms. In the video, Darwin's tree of life represents his idea that all species are interconnected, sharing a common ancestor. This concept is fundamental to understanding the diversity of life on Earth and the process of evolution.

💡Descent with Modification

Descent with modification is a term used by Darwin to describe the process by which species evolve over time through the accumulation of small changes. In the video, this concept is used to explain how one type of creature can be transformed into something completely different over generations, as seen in the evolution of finches on the Galapagos Islands.

💡Competition

Competition in an ecological context refers to the struggle between organisms for resources such as food, space, or mates. The video describes the Victorian view of nature as sentimental, but Darwin saw it as a battlefield where competition is fierce. This competition, or 'war of nature,' drives natural selection by favoring individuals best adapted to their environment.

💡Adaptation

Adaptation is the process by which an organism becomes better suited to its environment. In the video, the different beak shapes of finches on the Galapagos Islands are examples of adaptations that enable the birds to exploit different food sources. Adaptations are a result of natural selection and are key to understanding how species evolve.

💡On the Origin of Species

On the Origin of Species is the seminal work by Charles Darwin, published in 1859, which introduced the theory of evolution by natural selection. The video emphasizes the significance of this book as it fundamentally changed our understanding of life's diversity and the processes that drive it. The publication of this work marked a major shift in scientific thought and is still considered a foundational text in biology.

Highlights

Darwin observed that finches in the Galapagos Islands diversified into many kinds with different beak shapes, suggesting species change over time.

The prevailing view at the time was that species were created by God and were unchangeable, but Darwin challenged this with evidence from the Galapagos.

Fossils of giant sloths and armadillos in South America indicated to Darwin that species could evolve from ancient ancestors.

Studying embryos revealed evidence of common ancestry among species, such as snake embryos showing the rudiments of legs.

Darwin's observation of whale embryos with teeth suggested that whales descended from creatures with teeth, indicating evolutionary change.

Human embryos showing structures similar to fish gills provided evidence that humans must be descended from fish, a radical idea at the time.

Darwin proposed the tree of life concept, suggesting all species are connected and evolved from common ancestors.

Darwin's theory of descent with modification explained how one type of creature could be transformed into something completely different over time.

Darwin found clues to how species change in the diversity of dog breeds, which were created through selective breeding.

He hypothesized that a similar form of selection could be occurring in nature without human interference, leading to the concept of natural selection.

Darwin's view of nature as a battlefield, where competition and struggle for survival drive the process of evolution.

The finches of the Galapagos Islands provided a clear example of how natural selection could lead to the development of different beak shapes for different diets.

Darwin recognized that variation among individuals within a species is the starting point for change in nature.

The concept of natural selection suggests that tiny variations could accumulate over many generations, leading to the emergence of new species.

Darwin's theory of evolution by natural selection was published in his groundbreaking work 'On the Origin of Species' in 1859.

Darwin's work had a profound impact on the understanding of the diversity of life and the process of evolution.

The idea that species are not fixed but can evolve challenged long-held religious and scientific beliefs about the nature of life.

Transcripts

species

[Music]

change originally there must have been

just one type of Finch in the

galopagos but over time it had

Diversified into many kinds with

different beak

shapes the same for the

tortoises one type of tortoise must have

turned into many kinds

with different shells depending on which

island they lived

on with this great Insight Darwin

entered dangerous new territory the

standard View at the time was that God

had created every species and that what

God had created was perfect and could

not

change but Darwin said no why would the

Creator bother with making slightly

different finches for each of these

different islands that all looked

alike the prevailing view just didn't

make

sense but this was only the beginning of

Darwin's

Revolution he turned his attention to

the fossils he had collected in South

America one was of a giant

sloth

another was of a huge armadillo like

creature these animals were

extinct but little sloths still existed

in South America and so did smaller

armadillos what could this mean it

dawned on him that they resembled each

other so what he had found in the ground

were the buried ancestors of the living

animals of South America so again here

was was more evidence that species

[Music]

changed somehow these Ancient Giants

must have been transformed into the

smaller creatures we see

today but what Darwin would later find

out took this idea of how species change

into a completely new

league in Victorian times scientists

routinely studied life forms at the

embryonic

stage how these tiny forms develop from

just a single cell into an entire

creature has long been seen as one of

the wonders of

nature watching a developing embryo is

truly the most glorious Miracle of

nature I mean you know

Noble what Darwin learned from studying

the embryos amazed him

in snake embryos you could see tiny

bumps the Bony rudiments of

legs but these would never develop in

the adult

snake Darwin wondered where snakes

somehow descended from animals with

legs he learned that whales which have

no teeth as adults had them as

embryos those teeth disappeared before

they were

born to Darwin it had to mean whales

were descended from creatures with

teeth but human embryos provided the

most startling

evidence under the microscope tiny slits

around the neck were clearly visible

exactly the same structures were found

in

fish but in fish they turned into

gills in humans they became the bones of

our inner

[Music]

ear surely this showed that humans must

be descended from

fish it's an astonishing

thought I don't know about your

ancestors but mine included priests and

you know know the the the usual The

Usual Suspects but but the idea that all

of us have have fish in our family tree

I think it's

amazing and so Darwin arrived at an

astonishing conclusion one that would

become Central to his understanding of

the great diversity of Life Darwin had

this amazingly bold idea the tree of

life that all species were

connected and what it meant was if you

go far enough back in our family tree of

humans you'll come to

fish if you go far enough back in the

family tree of birds you'll come to

dinosaurs so that creatures that don't

look anything at all like each other are

actually deeply connected no one came

close to having this idea before

Darwin this seemed to be an explanation

for the vast diversity of animals

beginning with a common ancestor over

time across Generations species could

change

dramatically some might add new body

features others might drop

them ultimately one type of creature

could be transformed into something

utterly

different it's a process Darwin called

descent with

modification but it all begged a

question why what was making cre

creatures

change Darwin needed Clues and he found

them in a very surprising

Place

dogs big small fat

tall the British have long been obsessed

by

[Music]

them it was a full-blown love affair in

Victorian

England

[Music]

even her majesty was dog

crazy that love affair still continues

today especially among scientists like

Heidi Parker at the National Institutes

of Health so one of the most interesting

things about dogs is the kind of

variation that you have and we have dogs

the size of groundhogs versus a dog like

zeppy the Leonberger who can get to be

the size of a mule deer if we had that

kind of size variation in humans we

would have people running around the

size of Barbie

dolls in his day Darwin knew this range

of sizes hadn't come about by

chance through a careful process of

selection dog breeders mix different

dogs with different physical traits to

create new

forms Darwin was intrigued by what he

was seeing breeders doing with a

domestic dog they could select for

individual traits like size or shape and

they could actually change their

breed the whippit for example had been

developed to chase

rabbits it was created by mixing

Greyhounds for Speed with Terriers used

to hunt small

game and then it hit Darwin was there a

similar form of selection going on in

nature but without human

interference could natural selection

explain the great diversity of

life it was

brilliant he took something very

familiar and comfortable for example

animal breeding and explained that the

same sort of thing was going on in

nature uh just at a little bit different

pace and with no uh human

[Music]

[Applause]

guide but what could be carrying out

selection in the wild

it was then that Darwin took a

completely fresh look at

nature the Victorian view of nature was

sentimental Lambs laid down with lions

but Darwin's travels on the Beagle led

him to a different

[Music]

view for Darwin nature was

Savage every creature was locked in a

desperate struggle for

survival ultimately ending in

[Music]

[Applause]

[Music]

death the scale of death in nature is

absolutely

[Music]

horrendous and sometimes it's not just

that there's a lot of death but the it's

very unpleasant

[Music]

death but in all this brutal

chaos Darwin saw a pattern Darwin showed

that nature was a battlefield and that

everything was in competition and this

brutal battle this war of nature as

Darwin described it was actually a

creative process

process the pattern that Darwin saw was

that the creatures that survived were

those best adapted to the specific

environments they lived

in for instance some could handle

extremes of

climate others were brilliantly honed

killing machines perfect for catching

the available

prey still others were perfect to evade

those who might be hunting

them but how did this harsh view of

nature explain the finches on the

galopagos where Darwin observed that the

birds on different Islands had different

beak

shapes somehow those different different

beaks must be helping the finches

[Music]

survive the finches of the galpagos

islands have beaks of many sizes and

shapes and there's a reason for that

they use their beaks as tools now if you

think of the type of tool you would want

to crush a seed that's very tough but

it's the food that you really like you'd

want a beak like this which is the type

of beak the ground finch has

on an island where the only food is

seeds that are hard to

crack a short powerful beak will mean a

finch Will

Survive but on another Island the

available food isn't seeds but

flowers if you wanted to get into narrow

spaces to get pollen and nectar that are

very hard to get at you wouldn't need a

big strong beak you'd need a probing

beak so on a different Island where you

have a different food source you have a

different beak shape and this pattern

was repeated across the

Galapagos it seems that the Finch's

beaks had altered to fit the diet of

each particular

Island and that was how one original

type of Finch had been transformed into

[Applause]

many

[Music]

but how had these changes come

[Music]

about here Darwin had another

clue he could see it in his own

family as every parent knows no two

children are ever exactly the

same Charles looked different from his

brother brother arasmus even though they

shared the same

parents Charles's Children looked a bit

like

him and his wife

Emma but they too looked different from

each other that was something he called

variation he realized that not every

individual was the same Stamped Out like

a toy from a press but there was

[Music]

variation Darwin realized that variation

must be the starting point for change in

nature in any generation the animals in

a litter are never quite the

[Music]

same and in the wild such a tiny

variation might make all the difference

between life and

death two penguins for instance might

differ a tiny bit in the thickness of

their blubber a big factor if you live

in extreme cold

cold in a harsh climate the environment

will select who will live and who will

die and slowly Darwin suggested over

many many generations these tiny

variations would allow the fit to get

fitter and the

unfit would

vanish these variations accumulate and

eventually new species Branch off

this is evolution by natural selection

it is one of the keys to how new species

are

formed and so in 1859 after years of

painstaking research Darwin finally

published his Masterwork On the Origin

of

Species it is still impossible to

overstate its importance it was really a

Quantum ad