What is Metaphysics?

PHILO-notes

16 Dec 202003:22

Summary

TLDRMetaphysics, the branch of philosophy exploring the nature of existence, space, time, and the divine, has faced scrutiny in the 20th century. Traditionally seen as foundational to understanding the world, it has been challenged by scientific advancements and philosophical movements like logical positivism and deconstruction, which view metaphysical inquiries as linguistic ambiguities or a manifestation of logocentrism.

Takeaways

📚 Metaphysics is a branch of philosophy that deals with the most general and abstract questions, such as the nature of existence, space, time, God, and the human soul.
🔍 It aims to provide a comprehensive account of the world that is not affected by the uncertainties of experience, offering a systematic understanding beyond empirical knowledge.
📜 The term 'metaphysics' is derived from 'ta metatar physica', meaning 'the work after the physics', and was catalogued after Aristotle's 'Physics'.
👶 Aristotle's 'Metaphysics', also known as 'first philosophy', is one of the earliest and most influential works on the subject in Western philosophy.
🔄 Metaphysics is considered to be the study that comes after physics, offering a systematic account of the categories used by physics, the study of nature.
🤔 Central to the subject are three fundamental questions: the nature of existence, the persistence of things through change, and the overall understanding of the world.
🛑 In the 20th century, metaphysics faced criticism and its existence was questioned, with some viewing it as outdated or unnecessary in light of scientific advancements.
🧑‍🔬 The natural sciences, particularly mathematics and theoretical physics, have taken over questions that were once the domain of metaphysics, such as those about space and time.
🗣️ The 'linguistic turn' in philosophy led to the view that traditional metaphysical concerns are often rooted in linguistic misuse and ambiguities.
🔍 For logical positivists and analytic philosophers, metaphysics is seen as speculative and unverifiable, with problems arising from language misuse.
📚 Deconstructionists, like Jacques Derrida, use 'metaphysics' or 'Western metaphysics' as a synonym for philosophy itself, critiquing its inherent logocentric tendencies.
🔄 The task for philosophers, according to some traditions, is to clarify concepts and language to eliminate metaphysical pseudo-problems.

Q & A

What is the traditional definition of metaphysics?
-Metaphysics is traditionally defined as the branch of philosophy that deals with the most general and abstract questions, such as those pertaining to the nature of existence, the categories of space and time, the existence of God, or the immortality of the human soul.
What does metaphysics aim to provide?
-Metaphysics aims to provide a comprehensive account of the world that is proof against the uncertainties of experience.
What is the origin of the term 'metaphysics'?
-The term 'metaphysics' is supposedly derived from the Greek words 'ta metatar physica', which means 'the work after the physics', referring to the treatise by Aristotle that was catalogued after his 'Physics'.
What is the significance of Aristotle's 'Metaphysics' in the history of philosophy?
-Aristotle's 'Metaphysics', which he himself called 'first philosophy', is one of the earliest treatises on the subject and has had immense influence on the entire history of Western philosophy.
In what way is metaphysics related to physics?
-Metaphysics is to physics as meta-language is to language, offering a systematic account of the categories employed by physics, which is defined as the study of nature.
What are the three central questions at the heart of Aristotle's 'Metaphysics'?
-The three central questions are: 1. What is existence and what sorts of things exist in the world? 2. How can things continue to exist and yet undergo the change we see about us in the natural world? 3. How can this world be understood?
Why has metaphysics come under attack in the 20th century?
-Metaphysics has come under attack due to developments in the natural sciences, which have made questions pertaining to space and time a matter for mathematicians and theoretical physicists, and the so-called 'linguistic turn' in philosophy, which views traditional concerns of metaphysics as problems arising from the misuse of language.
What is the view of the logical positivists of the Vienna Circle on metaphysics?
-For the logical positivists of the Vienna Circle, metaphysics is viewed as a derogatory term to be applied to speculative or unverifiable statements, such as 'God exists'.
How do philosophers associated with analytic philosophy and ordinary language philosophy view metaphysical problems?
-For these philosophers, metaphysical problems are simply a product of the ambiguities of language, and the task of philosophy is to arrive at a better understanding of concepts through a better understanding of language.
What is the perspective of Jack Derrida and practitioners of deconstruction on metaphysics?
-Jack Derrida and practitioners of deconstruction tend to use the term 'metaphysics' or 'Western metaphysics' as a synonym for philosophy itself and hold that it is the most dangerous manifestation of logocentrism.

Outlines

00:00

📚 Introduction to Metaphysics

Metaphysics is explored as a branch of philosophy that delves into the most fundamental and abstract questions about existence, space, time, and the nature of reality. It aims to provide a comprehensive understanding of the world beyond the uncertainties of experience. The term is derived from 'ta metatar physica,' meaning 'the work after the physics,' which refers to Aristotle's treatise that followed his work on physics. Aristotle's 'Metaphysics,' also known as 'first philosophy,' has significantly influenced Western philosophy. The core of the book revolves around three key questions: the nature of existence, the continuity of existence amidst change, and the understanding of the world. Despite its historical significance, metaphysics faced criticism in the 20th century, particularly from natural sciences and philosophers who view its concerns as arising from the misuse of language.

Mindmap

Keywords

💡Metaphysics

Metaphysics is traditionally defined as the branch of philosophy that deals with the most general and abstract questions, such as the nature of existence, the categories of space and time, and the existence of God. It seeks to provide a comprehensive account of the world that is proof against the uncertainties of experience. In the script, metaphysics is presented as a foundational aspect of philosophy, with a history that can be traced back to Aristotle's 'First Philosophy,' which has had a significant influence on Western philosophy.

💡Existence

Existence, as a concept in metaphysics, pertains to the state of being real or having actual being. The script raises the question of 'what is existence' and explores the types of things that exist in the world. It is central to the philosophical inquiry of metaphysics, as it delves into the nature of reality and what constitutes being.

💡Space and Time

Space and time are fundamental categories in metaphysics, referring to the dimensions in which events occur and objects exist. The script mentions that questions pertaining to space and time have historically been within the domain of metaphysics but are now often addressed by mathematicians and theoretical physicists, indicating a shift in how these concepts are studied.

💡God

The existence of God is a classic topic in metaphysics, often explored in relation to the nature of existence and the ultimate cause or reason for the universe. The script touches on this by discussing how metaphysics has been criticized for dealing with unverifiable statements such as 'God exists,' highlighting the contentious nature of metaphysical claims.

💡Immortality

Immortality is the concept of living forever, often associated with the human soul's continued existence after death. The script mentions the immortality of the human soul as one of the abstract questions that metaphysics seeks to address, reflecting the philosophical interest in the nature of life and death.

💡Aristotle

Aristotle, a prominent Greek philosopher, is known for his work 'Metaphysics,' which the script refers to as one of the earliest treatises on the subject. His 'First Philosophy' has had a profound impact on the development of Western philosophy, setting the stage for many subsequent metaphysical inquiries.

💡Linguistic Turn

The 'linguistic turn' refers to a shift in philosophy that emphasizes the role of language in shaping thought and understanding. The script mentions this development as a reason why traditional metaphysical concerns are often viewed as arising from the misuse of language, suggesting a critique of metaphysics from a linguistic perspective.

💡Logical Positivism

Logical positivism is a philosophical movement that emphasizes empirical verifiability as the standard for meaning. The script describes how, for the logical positivists of the Vienna Circle, metaphysics is seen as speculative and unverifiable, thus deeming it as pseudo-problems arising from language ambiguities.

💡Deconstruction

Deconstruction, a critical theory developed by Jacques Derrida, challenges traditional philosophical concepts by examining the inherent instability of meaning within language. The script notes that deconstructionists use the term 'metaphysics' to critique the foundational assumptions of Western philosophy, viewing it as a manifestation of 'logocentrism.'

💡Continuity and Change

The script raises the metaphysical question of how things can continue to exist while undergoing change, which is a central issue in understanding the nature of reality. This concept is related to the philosophical problem of identity over time and the persistence of objects through change.

💡Conceptual Understanding

Conceptual understanding, as discussed in the script in relation to the task of philosophy, involves gaining clarity on concepts through a better understanding of language. This is particularly emphasized in the context of analytic philosophy and ordinary language philosophy, where metaphysical problems are seen as arising from linguistic ambiguities.

Highlights

Metaphysics is traditionally defined as the branch of philosophy that deals with the most general and abstract questions.

It pertains to the nature of existence, categories of space and time, the existence of God, and the immortality of the human soul.

Metaphysics seeks to provide a comprehensive account of the world that is proof against the uncertainties of experience.

The term 'metaphysics' is derived from the Greek words 'ta metatar physica', meaning 'the work after the physics'.

Aristotle's 'Metaphysics', also known as 'first philosophy', is one of the earliest treatises on the subject.

Aristotle's work has had immense influence on the entire history of Western philosophy.

Metaphysics is considered to come after physics in offering a systematic account of the categories employed by physics.

Metaphysics is to physics as meta language is to language.

The core of the book revolves around three questions: existence, continuity of existence, and understanding the world.

Metaphysics has been under attack in the 20th century, with its very existence being called into question.

Developments in natural sciences have made questions about space and time more a matter for mathematicians and theoretical physicists.

The linguistic turn in philosophy views traditional metaphysical concerns as problems arising from the misuse of language.

Logical positivists view metaphysics as speculative or unverifiable statements, often derogatory.

Analytic philosophy and ordinary language philosophy see metaphysical problems as a product of language ambiguities.

For philosophers of these traditions, philosophy's task is to understand concepts better through a better understanding of language.

Jack Derrida and deconstructionists use the term 'metaphysics' or 'Western metaphysics' as a synonym for philosophy itself.

Derrida holds that metaphysics is the most dangerous manifestation of logocentrism.