The Real Trap of Consumerism
Summary
TLDRThe video critiques consumerism in capitalist societies, particularly the United States, arguing that it's a symptom of capitalism's relentless push for profit. It highlights how corporations manufacture false needs through advertising to drive consumption, leading to environmental degradation and social inequalities. The video suggests that true change requires collective action and systemic reforms rather than individual consumer choices. The creator also discusses the financial challenges of running the channel and appeals for support through Patreon to maintain their work.
Takeaways
- 🛍️ Consumerism is deeply ingrained in imperialist societies, like the United States, where shopping is often seen as a solution to boredom, a means to feel good, or even a way to be ethical by choosing 'right' brands.
- 🌏 The script argues that consumerism is not the root problem but a symptom of a larger issue within capitalism, which drives overconsumption and environmental issues.
- 📈 Overconsumption is evident in the US with retail sales more than doubling since 2013, an increase in households with multiple cars, and the expansion of home sizes, leading to a booming self-storage industry.
- 🌱 Despite high consumption rates, the US has a significant environmental impact, consuming a disproportionate amount of the world's fossil fuel energy and contributing to food waste and high carbon emissions.
- 😔 The paradox of consumerism is that despite material abundance, happiness levels in the US have not improved, with only 25% of Americans reporting satisfaction with their lives.
- 💔 The script highlights the stark inequalities within the US, where some individuals accumulate excessive amounts of goods while others struggle with poverty and homelessness.
- 🏭 The real issue behind consumerism, according to the script, is overproduction driven by the capitalist need for constant capital accumulation and expansion.
- 📊 The script suggests that consumer demand is often manufactured by corporations through advertising and marketing strategies, creating 'false needs' that drive consumption.
- 🎭 Advertising is portrayed as a manipulative tool used by capitalists to assign emotional value to products, making consumers believe they need the latest trends for happiness or to save the planet.
- 👥 The script calls for a collective approach to combat consumerism, suggesting that individual choices are less effective than systemic changes, such as worker control of companies and democratic planning.
- 🔄 To escape the trap of consumerism, the script advocates for a shift away from a focus on profit-driven production towards meeting actual needs of people and the planet, potentially through a socialist economy.
Q & A
What is the main argument presented in the video script regarding consumerism?
-The main argument is that consumerism is not the root problem but rather a symptom of a larger issue, which is the capitalist system that drives overproduction and creates false needs and desires for consumers to fulfill.
How does the script suggest consumerism is related to the current environmental problems?
-The script suggests that consumerism, driven by capitalist overproduction, leads to excessive waste, accumulation of stuff, and high levels of resource consumption, which are unsustainable and harmful to the environment.
What is the 'Easterlin paradox' mentioned in the script?
-The 'Easterlin paradox' is a concept that posits that after basic needs are met, economic growth and higher incomes do not necessarily lead to greater happiness.
How has the script described the role of advertising in the context of consumerism?
-The script describes advertising as a tool used by capitalists to create and promote false needs, giving products emotional value and meaning to entice consumers to buy, thereby driving the cycle of consumption.
What is the M-C-M’ process referred to in the script?
-The M-C-M’ process stands for 'Money-Commodity-More Money' and represents the capitalist cycle where money is invested into commodities, which are then sold for even more money to accumulate capital.
How does the script link the concept of 'false needs' to consumerism?
-The script links 'false needs' to consumerism by explaining that capitalists manufacture desires for products that are not essential, using advertising and marketing to convince consumers that they need these products for happiness or to fulfill a certain lifestyle.
What historical example is given in the script to illustrate the manipulation of consumer desires?
-The script refers to Henry Ford's strategy in 1919, where he and other capitalists increased workers' wages, bank credit, and leisure time to encourage higher rates of consumption, thereby maintaining the capitalist status quo.
How does the script address the issue of overproduction in the context of capitalism?
-The script addresses overproduction by explaining that capitalists must constantly expand their productive capacities to stay competitive, leading to an excess of commodities that need to be sold to the masses, which in turn drives consumerism.
What is the script's view on the effectiveness of individual consumer choices in combating consumerism?
-The script suggests that individual consumer choices, such as buying ethical or green products, are not enough to solve the crises caused by consumerism, as they do not address the root cause of overproduction and the manufacturing of false needs.
What solutions does the script propose to combat consumerism and its effects?
-The script proposes a systemic change, including mass revolution to upend the capitalist system, worker control of companies, democratic planning, and restricting advertising to reduce the manufacturing of false needs.
How does the script reflect on the role of social media and influencers in promoting consumerism?
-The script reflects on the role of social media and influencers as extensions of the advertising industry, using algorithms and data collection to push products and create a constant pressure to consume, which affects mental health and perpetuates false needs.
What is the script's stance on the idea that consumerism can be solved by simply buying less or choosing different products?
-The script's stance is that solving consumerism by simply buying less or choosing different products is insufficient, as it does not tackle the root cause of capitalist overproduction and the systemic creation of false needs.
How does the script discuss the impact of consumerism on mental health and well-being?
-The script discusses the impact of consumerism on mental health by highlighting how the constant push to fulfill false needs can lead to unhappiness, dissatisfaction, and increased stress, even in the face of high consumption rates.
Outlines
🛍️ The Allure of Consumerism
This paragraph introduces the pervasive influence of consumerism in modern society, particularly in imperialist countries like the United States. It highlights how consumerism is deeply ingrained in daily life, with shopping and purchasing used as means to fill emotional voids, alleviate boredom, or demonstrate ethical consumption. The paragraph challenges the notion that consumerism itself is the root of environmental and social issues, suggesting instead that it is a symptom of a larger issue within capitalism. The speaker acknowledges the financial support from Patreon viewers, emphasizing the impact of declining ad revenue on the sustainability of content creation.
📈 Overconsumption and Its Discontents
The second paragraph delves into the statistics and consequences of overconsumption in the United States. It presents data on the increase in retail sales, household car ownership, and average home size, as well as the growth of the self-storage industry. The environmental impact of this consumption is underscored by the disproportionate use of fossil fuels and food waste in the country. Despite the high levels of consumption, the paragraph notes the paradox of unhappiness among Americans, as indicated by life satisfaction surveys, and the stark inequalities that persist in society.
🏭 The Hidden Engine of Capitalism
This paragraph examines the role of corporate overproduction as the driving force behind perceived consumerism. It explains the capitalist cycle of capital accumulation and the necessity for constant expansion, which leads to overproduction. The narrative challenges the common belief that corporations merely respond to consumer demand, arguing instead that they create and manipulate desires to maintain profitability. The paragraph also discusses how advertising and marketing strategies are used to create a sense of false freedom and choice for consumers, who are ultimately influenced by corporate interests more than their own demands.
🎭 The Manufacture of Desires
The fourth paragraph discusses the concept of 'false needs' as identified by Marxist scholar Herbert Marcuse. It describes how capitalists use advertising to create a sense of necessity around products that are not actually needed, but are made desirable through emotional and social appeals. The role of advertising in obscuring exploitative production practices and justifying higher prices is highlighted. The paragraph also touches on the psychological impact of social media and data-driven marketing on consumer behavior, suggesting that these tactics contribute to mental health issues and a distorted perception of happiness and fulfillment.
🔄 Escaping the Consumerist Trap
The final paragraph addresses the question of how to combat consumerism by looking at its root causes. It suggests that the current system is capable of meeting global basic needs but is instead focused on wasteful practices and advertising. The speaker acknowledges their complicity in the system as a content creator and the challenges of operating within capitalism. The paragraph calls for collective action and制度改革, advocating for worker control and democratic planning in production to meet actual needs rather than manufactured desires. It concludes with a call to action for viewers to support the channel on Patreon, emphasizing the importance of community in sustaining independent media.
Mindmap
Keywords
💡Consumerism
💡Capitalism
💡Overproduction
💡False needs
💡Environmental degradation
💡Advertising
💡Inequality
💡Carbon footprint
💡Happiness
💡Collective organizing
Highlights
Consumerism is a pervasive aspect of life in imperialist countries like the United States, influencing emotions and behaviors.
The cycle of working and spending to fill a void is a characteristic of consumerist societies.
Consumerism is not the root problem but a symptom of the larger issue of capitalism.
Overconsumption is often blamed for environmental issues, but it's the capitalist system that drives it.
The video discusses the impact of consumerism on environmental sustainability and social well-being.
The speaker's Patreon support is crucial for the continuation of their content creation.
Rising consumerism in the US is reflected in the doubling of retail sales since 2013.
The increase in household possessions and cars has not led to increased happiness among Americans.
The US, with 5% of the world's population, consumes a disproportionate amount of global resources.
The paradox of increased consumption not leading to greater happiness is highlighted by the Easterlin paradox.
The capitalist system's drive for profit leads to overproduction and the creation of false consumer needs.
Corporations manipulate consumer desires through advertising to maintain profitability.
Advertising assigns emotional value to products, often obscuring their true production costs and labor practices.
Social media and influencer culture contribute to the pressure to consume and the creation of false needs.
The speaker acknowledges their complicity in the system they critique, as their channel also relies on consumer support.
The solution to consumerism involves collective action and restructuring the system, not individual choices.
The video calls for a shift away from consumerism towards a system that prioritizes needs over profits.
Transcripts
With every passing moment, a chance to buy something is at your fingertips. That new pair
of pants you just saw on Instagram, the latest gaming PC that your favorite streamer uses,
or the newest line of Teslas to make you feel like you're saving the planet all bombard you
with visions of what could be. In the imperial core, buying things has become the stuff of
life. To feel good, you shop. If you’re bored you browse things to buy. If you want to be ethical,
you don't stop buying, you just need to find the "right" brand to buy from. Seemingly our
whole lives are wrapped up in the vicious cycle of working all day and then spending to fill the
void in our lives. Consumerism is a problem that runs rampant in imperialist countries like the
United States. It’s right up in our faces at every moment. It’s easy to see this conspicuous spending
and claim that overconsumption is the source of many of our environmental problems. Consumers are,
after all, the ones making the choices at the checkout counter. They’re the ones voting with
their dollars. But today, we’re going to dive into this mistaken worldview. Consumerism is
not the problem, it’s a trap. It’s a symptom of a much larger and more insidious problem
of capitalism that lurks in the shadows. Today we look at the real problem with consumerism,
and how we really combat the out-of-control waste and accumulation of stuff.
This video is made possible by my amazing viewers who support me on Patreon. Over the last two
years, my revenue from ads and sponsorship have dropped substantially. So much so, that if this
trend continues, making videos like these will become less and less financially viable. Which
is why I need you. Our Changing Climate will always be free for everyone regardless of how much
I make, but OCC is a one-person operation and it would be nice to earn enough to pay for rent and
my health insurance, both of which seem to grow yearly. So, if you’ve been a long-time viewer,
or just stumbled across the channel, thank you for watching, and please consider supporting
Our Changing Climate on Patreon with the link in the description. Just one dollar a month
from a small portion of my audience would be huge for the channel and to be honest, me.
Overconsumption is everywhere? Spend enough time on the internet and you’re
bound to buy something. How could you not when Amazon offers free shipping and an option to click
just one button to speed you through the checkout process? Or when the new online marketplace, Temu,
offers rock-bottom prices for basically any good you could want. Consumerism in the US has risen
precipitously, with total retail sales in the US more than doubling since 2013. Indeed, the
percentage of households with two or more cars has increased dramatically from 22% in 1960 to 59% in
2020, while the average home size expanded by 149% from 1,595 square feet in 1980 to 2,383 in 2022
according to the Census Bureau. And when families run out of space to put all of their stuff,
they’ve turned to storage units. In the United States, an estimated 14.6 million households
rent additional storage to keep all of their stuff generating the self-storage industry $29 billion
in revenue every year. All of this growth hasn’t been to accommodate larger families, because the
average family size has actually decreased by 16% from 1980. This expansion of consumption has had
disastrous effects on the environment. Despite being home to just 5% of the world’s population,
the United States consumes 15.7% of the world’s total fossil fuel energy. In the United States,
between 30-40% of food gets wasted through a combination of on-farm loss, transportation,
store overstocking, and lack of at-home planning. The average American emits 14.9 metric tons of
carbon dioxide equivalent, which is more than triple that of the global average of 4.7.
Yet, despite unprecedented consumption rates and a glut of almost every gadget
and appliance imaginable flooding the market, people in the United States aren’t that happy.
According to the General Social Survey, only 25% of Americans are satisfied with their life.
A percentage that’s slowly declined since the 1970s and plummeted during the pandemic. In part,
this is due to the vast inequalities that cleave the United States. As some fill up
their oversized homes and shipping containers with stuff, many struggle to survive. Over 42
million rely on food stamps to put food on the table, while more than 650,000 people
experience homelessness across the country. As the economist William Gibson observes:
“The future is already here – it's just not evenly distributed.” Even for those who do
enjoy excessive and conspicuous consumption of the newest Tesla or Apple’s $3,500 Vision Pro,
more consumption and more income don’t necessarily lead to more happiness. A phenomenon that has
been deemed the Easterlin paradox. A concept that claims that after basic needs are met,
economic growth and higher incomes don’t necessarily lead to greater happiness.
With all this in mind, it’s clear that the capitalist hub of the world is on a
dangerous path. A path that is not only leaving us overworked, in debt, and unhappy but is also
driving us headlong toward a ruinous collision point. Paraphrasing scholar Timothy Jackson,
Diana Stuart and fellow researchers write in a paper that considering the biophysical limitations
of the Earth, extreme resource and material consumption on a finite planet means “ ” In short,
the imperial core is consuming far more than is sustainable for human well-being and the
planet. But is consumerism really the problem? Are the consumption habits of the masses really
the driving force between our environmental and social ails? These are the crucial questions,
ones that hand us the keys to what Karl Marx calls “the hidden abode of production.”
What’s really causing these problems? Behind every dollar spent on that butter melter
you saw on TikTok, or that automatic pot stirrer, lies a corporation. A company eager to offload its
product into your hands to generate profit. The core engine of capitalism is its constant demand
for capital accumulation. Capitalists must constantly expand their productive capacities
through new technologies and decreasing labor costs to create the most commodities for the
lowest prices. If it fails to do so, it gets eaten alive by other, more capable owners who’ve managed
to create more products at cheaper prices. This process of constant accumulation and expansion
creates increased overproduction. Production that generates piles of commodities must be sold
to the masses to continue the cycle of capital accumulation. Exchanging products for even more
money is essential to complete the last leg of the money invested into commodities and sold for even
more money also known as M-C-M’. In a sense, consumption is a release valve of production,
it expands and contracts, but never creates the flow of goods. As scholar Allan Schnaiberg notes,
“Consumption cannot be the leading factor in the expansion of production. Increased consumption
may permit expanded production, but it does not generally cause it.” Unrestrained capitalist
production, then, is the root cause of what we see as the ails of consumerism. According to the
average person living in the capitalist stronghold of the United States and indeed, most economists,
however, corporations are merely responding to consumer demand. This is a skewed view of
reality. The true culprit of all the stuff in our houses, in our landfills, and in our
atmosphere is overproduction. Companies like Best Buy, for example, supply a false freedom when you
walk through their stores. The range of brands and products on the shelves might make you feel
like you have freedom of choice but in reality, you are only served cameras, laptops, or phones
that generate profit or allow corporations to stay competitive. Factors that are often determined by
labor costs, raw materials, and transportation logistics much more than consumer demand. In the
housing market, for example, most people want affordable, comfortable living spaces. Yet,
the buildings developers construct are often luxury condos or turnkey mansions– dwellings
that are unaffordable for the majority, but rake in extensive profit for real estate companies. So,
capitalists produce goods based on factors outside of the realm of consumerism. That being said,
they still need people to buy their stuff. To complete the cycle of Money-Commodity-More Money,
capitalists must sell their products on the market to the masses, regardless of whether
their products have any use. So, instead of focusing on producing only things that are
useful and necessary, capitalism has built a massive apparatus that manufactures false
needs and desires. Here lies the true trap of consumerism. To assure the continued success of
their businesses, capitalists manufacture desires and needs. We believe that it is wholly inherent
wants, needs, and desires that are driving our consumption, that it is human nature, when,
in fact, the forces of corporations are constantly whispering in our ear: consume, consume, consume.
The Trap of Consumerism: In 1919, Henry Ford and his fellow
capitalists were scared. A rising insurgence of anarchist and socialist movements seized
the hearts and minds of Americans across the country. Labor strikes, walkouts, and protests
seeking a better workplace threatened to disrupt the profit-making machines of Ford’s car-making
factories. Then Ford had an idea. A double-edged sword wielded against the worker to maintain the
status quo. Ford and his fellow industry leaders, as one paper describers, “decided to reduce the
chances of a worker rebellion by giving workers increased wages, bank credit, and more leisure
time—all for the purpose of encouraging increased rates of consumption.” As we’ve already seen,
producers require the endless consumption of their commodities to stay competitive and
profitable within a capitalist market system. Capitalists must keep consumers on an endless
treadmill of consumption to reap maximum profit and continue accumulating capital. This leads to
the real trap of consumerism. The manufacturing of what Marxist scholar Herbert Marcuse deemed
“false needs.” To offload all of the useless gadgets, new iterations of the same tech,
and just general junk onto the masses, capitalists need to make us believe that we actually need the
latest iPhone or the Slapchop, or that latest TikTok trend, rather than just want it. This
is where the vast apparatus of advertising comes into play. With ads like this: [XX] and this [XX],
companies assign emotional value and meaning to objects whose actual value stems from the
labor and costs needed to make that product. This process not only obscures exploitative
practices employed during production but also allows companies to set higher prices because
the commodity is now imbued with certain politics and values. Tesla has been extremely effective at
this task. Its brand imbues its cars with ideals of luxury, clean, and sustainable futurism. These
values, in turn, mask the exploitative practices throughout Tesla’s supply chain. Fellow YouTuber,
Yougopnik, cheekily describes this process of value formation through a chocolate bar:
[“Advertisers consciously understand that purchasing patterns directly correlate
to personal values, therefore, the chocolate bar becomes a locally grown eco-friendly saw
infused chocolate bar with a hipster biodegradable wrapper and from whose every purchase two cents
go to starving Sri Lankan children. Now what's the actual difference between this world-saving
chocolate bar and just a chocolate bar? Almost none. They’re made in the same Factory with
the same ingredients and for the same profit motive.”] In short, the advertising industry
works tirelessly to wrap products in values like happiness, power, connection, or sustainability,
because they know that it’s much easier to sell a product to someone based on appeals to their
principles rather than describing the utility of the commodity. This value generation apparatus,
otherwise known as the advertising industry, has become an essential lever in the capitalist
machine. Indeed, advertising revenue has nearly doubled since 2012. With spending
on digital display advertising in just the US alone reaching $63.5 billion in 2022
But in the age of social media, it’s not just advertisements directly from companies that are
pushing us to buy to boost our happiness or save the planet. Your favorite streamer or Instagram
star is constantly influencing you to buy stuff, regardless of whether they’re paid to or not. Even
I support myself through the ad revenue, which I’ll get into later on in the video. This has
disastrous consequences on our mental health as we constantly strive to fulfill those false needs
generated for us. Especially as corporations wield algorithms and data collection to hone
in on what product will best seduce you into buying. In essence, every day, a social media
advertisement is placed in front of you with a product that you never even thought about buying,
but because of data tracking and algorithmic decisions, that product now wiggles its way
into your head like an earworm, and you can’t stop thinking about how your life would be better with
those slippers or that new watch. As a result, the “good life” becomes synonymous with consuming
things. Happiness is equated with shopping. Even streaming services keep you hooked and numb with
features like the autoplay button. It allows us to constantly consume content and search
for that next dopamine hit. But in the process, we stay up way too late, leaving us tired, and
burnt out. In 2017, Netflix’s CEO, very bluntly claimed that their biggest competitor was sleep.
Yet, all of this advertising leads us to believe that the current system we live in
actually benefits us. That keeping up with the Joneses, going deep into debt to buy a new car,
or going on a shopping spree is the answer to our loneliness, alienation, and disconnection from the
people and places around us. As Diana Stuart and her co-authors write, “The ruling class,
benefiting from the labor of others, perpetuates ideas that mystify, elude, and deceive workers
into falsely believing that they benefit from the current system, can move up in the system,
and have freedom in the system, as well as that no other system is possible.” And many of us
have become so distant from the cogs of capitalist production that often political activism has been
boiled down to “voting with your dollars.” This narrative is exactly what the fossil fuel industry
has been hard at work creating for over 40 years through its popularization of carbon footprints,
recycling, and individualizing action. When we as worker-consumers are placated into believing
that the most effective means of change is to transfer our money from one capitalist to another,
the owners of production have won. They’ve distracted us from what’s actually a threat
to them: collective organizing, labor agitation, union power, walkouts, and strikes. Activities
that directly disrupt that cycle of capital accumulation. As scholar Douglas Kellner writes,
capitalists wield “image and spectacle to manipulate people into social conformity and into
behaving in ways functional for the reproduction of capitalism.” In essence, consuming not only
perpetuates the endless cycle of production and capital accumulation, but it also pacifies the
masses by narrowing the possibilities of a “good life” to the purchasing, having, and
watching of more stuff. So, if we know the root causes of consumerism, how then do we escape it?
How we combat consumerism: We already have the means and capacity
to fulfill everyone's basic needs worldwide. Let that sink in. We already produce enough food to
feed everyone globally, but we’re wasting nearly a third of it. We have the technology to create
renewable energy for everyone on the planet, but we’re nowhere near that level. We can build
a world where everyone lives a good, meaningful, and environmentally ethical life, but that world
will mean an end to only shopping at Temu or Shein. It means no Amazon one-click purchases.
It means an end to incessant advertising. And here is where I struggle. I am complicit in that
manufacturing of consumer desire. My channel is run on manufacturing false needs for people. My
livelihood is based on getting you to become a Nebula member or sign up for Ground News. Does it
make it better if I actually like those services and use them? Or that Nebula is ad-free and based
on membership revenue? I tell myself “yes” because I still live under this massive apparatus that
is capitalism. Perhaps I could end YouTube ads if there was more Patreon support, but at the moment
it’s not feasible. At the end of the day, I have no good answer to how to live under capitalism
while also struggling against it. In a sense, this is capitalism at work. It insidiously corrupts the
very messages of those working to dismantle it. Blaming those who must live within it for living
within it. But even if I did cancel all ads, it would only be like spooning a small drop of water
out of a vast ocean. This is why we need more than just an individual, vote-with-your-money approach.
Ideally, a mass revolution would upend our current capitalist system, and the adoption of full worker
control of all companies and production would take root. Democratic planning through worker,
consumer, and community councils would mean an emphasis on producing for actual planetary
and personal needs rather than manufacturing false needs for profit. Of course, this kind
of worker-led socialist economy could be a ways off in the future. We’ll need to build mass power
globally if we are to see it come to fruition. This is why we need to employ non-reformist
reforms like restricting and regulating advertising on the road to building that power.
To beat back the manufacturing of false needs we need to restrict the reach of corporations
in our everyday lives. This could start as simply as reinstating child advertising laws that were
stripped away under the Reagan administration or tamping down social media and influencer
marketing. We cannot simply hope that encouraging everyone to buy ethical, green, or just less stuff
will somehow work to solve the multiple crises in front of us. Especially as mass marketing
and overproduction peck at individual consumers incessantly to “buy buy buy.” To truly escape the
trap of consumerism we must approach the problem from the root. We must dismantle and reimagine
the factories and offices of production that manufacture our desires. And on their rubble build
a world based on useful goods. A world where the stuff we make facilitates, rather than alienates,
our connection to people and the planet. In an effort to depend less and less on
YouTube ads and in-video sponsorships, I need your help. Recently, my revenue
has been slipping because of a combination of demonetization and fewer sponsorships
conversions. My wonderful Patreon supporters, however, have been keeping this channel and
myself afloat. My Patreon supporters have given me financial consistency over the last seven
years so I can pay my rent and ever-increasing healthcare premiums. So, I’m turning to you,
the wonderful people who watch my videos month in and month out. If you have the means,
please consider supporting the channel on Patreon using the link in the description. Just pledging a
dollar a month is huge for the channel, and when you become a Patreon supporter you’ll get early
access to my videos ad-free, bonus content like a guided meditation to calm your climate anxiety,
or even the occasional full-length interview with authors or scholars. But if you aren’t
able to become a channel patron, please don’t worry, just by watching this video to the end,
you’ve done your part. Thank you, and thank you so much to those who already support me on Patreon,
you’re the reason I’m able to make videos like this. Thanks again, and I’ll see you next month.
Weitere ähnliche Videos ansehen
Does "Every Little Thing" REALLY Stop Climate Change?
Can Capitalism Solve World Hunger?
4/8 Elgard - Grand Final of Indonesia Open 2023
James Cameron and Elvis Mitchell discuss the environmental message of Avatar (part 2)
Are Human Beings Inherently Selfish?
How You Are Manipulated To Mindlessly Consume
5.0 / 5 (0 votes)