JUS INDO #133 : FABRIZIO ROMANO : HERE WE GO, PATRICK KLUIVERT PELATIH TIMNAS INDONESIA

Summary

In this video, the speaker discusses the recent developments surrounding the Indonesian national football team, focusing on the appointment of Patrick Kluivert as the new coach. He addresses the public's disappointment over the dismissal of Shin Tae-yong and the cultural dynamics of hiring a Dutch coach. The speaker encourages viewers to support Kluivert, despite his controversial past and lack of experience, emphasizing that the ultimate goal is World Cup qualification. He also highlights the importance of understanding the internal factors behind the decision and stresses the need for unity in the pursuit of national success.

Takeaways

• 😀 The appointment of Patrick Kluivert as Indonesia's head coach has sparked mixed reactions, but it's important for fans to support him for the sake of the team's success.
• 😀 The decision to replace Shin Tae-Yong with Kluivert was made by PSSI, and while there are concerns, it's essential to respect the choice and focus on supporting the team.
• 😀 The frustration of Indonesian fans regarding the coach change is understandable, but it should not overshadow the ultimate goal: qualifying for the World Cup.
• 😀 Dutch coaches, like Kluivert, have an advantage due to their cultural understanding and footballing background, which can improve communication and performance within the team.
• 😀 While Kluivert's CV might not be stellar, his experience and name recognition in the football world can earn respect from players, both local and foreign.
• 😀 Fans need to remember that everyone makes mistakes, and Kluivert deserves a second chance to prove himself, just as other coaches have had in the past.
• 😀 The media and public criticism of Kluivert may hinder his ability to perform optimally. Support and a positive environment are needed for him to succeed.
• 😀 Erick Thohir's decision to appoint Kluivert was a calculated one, backed by his extensive experience in football management, and should be trusted.
• 😀 Rather than criticize, fans should ask questions about the reasoning behind the decision, as there may be factors that are not publicly disclosed.
• 😀 Despite the criticisms, the speaker emphasizes that the main goal remains: Indonesia's qualification for the World Cup. Fans should support the team with this in mind, rather than dwelling on negativity.

Q & A

Why is the speaker advocating for support of Patrick Kluivert despite initial doubts?

The speaker urges support for Kluivert because, despite not being their first choice and having a coaching CV that isn’t very impressive, the ultimate goal is to qualify for the World Cup. Negative criticism will only hinder the team’s progress, and it is more important to unite behind the coach to give the team the best chance of success.

What does the speaker say about the cultural differences between Indonesian and Dutch football?

The speaker explains that the Dutch football culture is very direct and emphasizes tactical discussions. This could create challenges in communication, but it is essential to understand that these differences in culture are important, especially given the increasing presence of Dutch players in the Indonesian national team.

How does the speaker feel about Shin Tae-yong’s firing?

The speaker acknowledges that Shin Tae-yong’s firing was disappointing for many, including themselves. However, they clarify that their goal was never to criticize him personally, but to advocate for a coach who could give Indonesia a better chance to qualify for the World Cup.

What does the speaker think about the role of social media in the controversy?

The speaker criticizes how social media distorts opinions, often by exaggerating or twisting statements out of context. They suggest that people should focus on supporting the national team rather than engaging in negative discourse, which only adds to unnecessary tension.

Why is Erick Thohir’s decision to hire Patrick Kluivert defended?

Erick Thohir is defended because of his vast experience in football management, particularly with high-profile clubs like DC United and Inter Milan. The speaker trusts that Thohir’s decision was made with careful consideration and isn’t a rash one, despite Kluivert’s less-than-impressive coaching CV.

What does the speaker mean when they mention that experience as a coach isn't always the key to success?

The speaker highlights examples of successful coaches like Pep Guardiola, José Mourinho, and Xabi Alonso, who had limited coaching experience when they started but still achieved great success. This illustrates that a coach’s experience isn’t always the determining factor for success, as talent, adaptability, and team dynamics play crucial roles.

What is the speaker's perspective on the Netherlands’ football philosophy and its relevance to the Indonesian team?

The speaker emphasizes that the Dutch football philosophy, which involves attacking play and tactical discussions, aligns well with Indonesia’s football culture. They believe that Dutch coaches, like Kluivert, who understand this style of play, could help lead the team to success, especially with the growing number of Dutch-based players in the squad.

Why does the speaker believe Patrick Kluivert’s appointment might still work despite concerns about his past coaching record?

The speaker believes Kluivert’s appointment might still work because of his established name as a player, which can earn respect from both local and diaspora players, as well as international opponents. Furthermore, his limited coaching experience doesn’t necessarily disqualify him, as many successful coaches have started with minimal experience.

What is the speaker's view on the possibility of Indonesia qualifying for the World Cup?

The speaker is cautiously optimistic, stating that Indonesia’s chances of qualifying for the World Cup have increased due to a stronger squad. With the return of key players and the potential inclusion of new talents, the speaker believes that the national team has a reasonable shot, as they are only a few points behind Australia.

What advice does the speaker give to fans regarding how to react to the changes in the national team coaching staff?

The speaker advises fans to avoid negativity and focus on supporting the team, regardless of personal feelings about the coaching change. They emphasize that unity is essential for the team’s success, and criticizing PSSI or the new coach will only harm the morale of the players and coaching staff.