Best Dutch Oven? I Tested Le Creuset, Staub, Lodge & More

Summary

In this video, the host tests nine popular Dutch ovens to determine which one offers the best performance for the price. Key factors like heat retention, moisture locking, durability, and design are put to the test. The review compares budget options like Tramontina and Lodge with premium brands like Le Creuset, Staub, and Made In. Ultimately, the video provides insights on which brands are worth the investment and which ones might not meet expectations, offering valuable recommendations based on both performance and cost.

Takeaways

• 😀 The cost of Dutch ovens varies greatly, with premium brands like Le Creuset and Staub offering high-end features, while budget-friendly options like Tramontina still perform well for everyday use.
• 😀 Durability is an important factor, and some Dutch ovens like Tramontina and Lodge Essential Enamel show signs of wear, such as chipping, after testing, while others like Staub and Made In hold up better.
• 😀 Heat retention is crucial, with Staub performing the best overall, followed by Made In. Some Dutch ovens, like Caraway, show poor heat retention in tests.
• 😀 Moisture retention is another critical performance factor, and Dutch ovens like Staub, Le Creuset, and Made In excel in keeping moisture locked in, while Caraway has the worst moisture retention.
• 😀 Lid design is important for cooking and handling. Most Dutch ovens feature traditional round knobs, but some, like Great Jones and Misen, have less functional or uncomfortable designs.
• 😀 Many Dutch ovens, such as Lodge and Made In, offer larger handles and bigger knobs for easier lifting and control, which is a standout feature for usability.
• 😀 Lodge stands out with its excellent warranty that covers chipping or cracking of enamel, offering peace of mind for customers.
• 😀 Some brands, like Caraway and Great Jones, have a more modern or unique aesthetic but may sacrifice functionality, such as with non-standard lid handles or smaller side handles.
• 😀 Le Creuset and Staub are premium brands that are well-known for their consistent enamel quality, although Le Creuset is notably lighter and more versatile with color options.
• 😀 Despite all Dutch ovens being made from similar materials (enameled cast iron), small differences in design and functionality can affect performance, with Staub and Le Creuset standing out in terms of quality and finish.

Q & A

What key factors were tested to evaluate the Dutch ovens?

The key factors tested were durability (how well the enamel held up after dropping a metal spatula), heat retention (temperature measurement after heating to 400°F), moisture retention (measuring water loss after boiling), lid moisture redistribution, and knob temperature (how hot the knobs got after boiling water).

Which Dutch oven performed the best in heat retention tests?

Staub performed the best in heat retention, followed closely by Made In. Le Creuset had the third-worst heat retention due to its thinner walls.

What were the downsides of the Tramontina 5 1/2 qt Dutch oven?

The Tramontina Dutch oven had poor heat retention, small handles that were difficult to grip, and arrived with a chip on the lid. It also had less effective moisture retention and its enamel was prone to chipping.

What unique features did the Lodge Essential Enamel 6qt Dutch oven offer?

The Lodge Essential Enamel Dutch oven offered large handles, a big lid knob, and solid heat retention. It also has a strong warranty that covers chips and cracks under normal use, which makes it a great budget option.

How does the Lodge USA Enamel 6qt Dutch oven differ from the Essential Enamel collection?

The Lodge USA Enamel 6qt Dutch oven is made in the USA and has larger handles, a wider cooking surface, and a more refined design. It's also heavier and more expensive than the Essential Enamel version.

What issue was noted with the Great Jones Dutch oven?

The Great Jones Dutch oven had a less functional lid handle (a brass-colored metal handle shaped like an upside-down U), which made it difficult to lift and control. Its side handles were also shorter and less ergonomic.

What makes the Made In 5 1/2 qt Dutch oven stand out?

The Made In Dutch oven stands out for its excellent heat retention, wide cooking surface, and large knob. However, it is heavy and its lid has a smooth design that makes it difficult to rest a spoon on it.

What are the drawbacks of the Misen 7qt Dutch oven with the grill pan lid?

The Misen Dutch oven with the grill pan lid is very heavy, weighing close to 17 lbs, which can be cumbersome. The grill pan lid lacks a knob, making it hard to lift, and it can stain if not cleaned thoroughly.

How did the Caraway 6.5qt Dutch oven perform in the tests?

The Caraway Dutch oven had poor heat retention and moisture retention, with evaporation running to the edges of the pot instead of evenly redistributing. The rough texture on its bottom also made it prone to scuffing delicate surfaces.

What makes Staub's 5 1/2 qt Dutch oven a premium choice?

Staub's Dutch oven is known for its excellent heat retention, moisture distribution, and flawless enamel finish. It also has a flat lid design that allows for better moisture control. However, its small knob and handle openings can make it less practical for some users.

What makes Le Creuset 5 1/2 qt Signature Dutch oven unique compared to other brands?

Le Creuset is known for its lightweight design, large handles, and a variety of color options. It has a smooth, two-tone gradient enamel finish. However, its thinner walls result in poorer heat retention compared to other brands like Staub and Made In.

Which Dutch ovens would be best for someone on a budget?

The Lodge Essential Enamel Dutch oven is the best option for those on a budget. It offers great performance at a lower price point and comes with a solid warranty that covers damage from normal use.

Which Dutch ovens are recommended if budget is not a concern?

If budget is not a concern, the best options are Le Creuset, Staub, and Made In. These brands offer superior performance and design, with Staub and Made In standing out in heat and moisture retention tests.