Lantang! Anggota DPR PDIP Gebrak Meja Semprot Mendag soal Serangan Kementerian: Bapak Jangan Diam!

Summary

The speaker critiques the frequent changes in the Ministry of Trade's regulations, which have been altered almost monthly, undermining the Ministry's credibility. While acknowledging global challenges, the speaker stresses the need for careful, well-thought-out policy adjustments. The focus also shifts to the issue of illegal imports, particularly in the textile industry, where large quantities of unrecorded goods enter the country. The speaker urges the Ministry to improve its communication and task force effectiveness to address these issues, emphasizing transparency and accountability in dealing with the challenges facing the sector.

Takeaways

• 😀 The speaker congratulates the Minister for their extensive experience, being the first minister from a non-political party background, which is rare in Indonesia.
• 😀 The speaker also acknowledges the Deputy Minister's transition from a member of Parliament to the Deputy Minister role, highlighting her potential to leverage her legislative experience.
• 😀 A major concern raised is the frequent changes in the Ministry of Trade's regulations (Permendak), which are being revised almost monthly, creating instability and uncertainty in the business environment.
• 😀 The speaker stresses that rapid changes in trade regulations undermine the credibility of the Ministry of Trade, questioning the effectiveness of such frequent revisions.
• 😀 A key issue discussed is the alleged blame on the Ministry of Trade's regulations (Permendak) for the bankruptcy of some textile businesses, with the speaker urging the Minister to clarify these misconceptions to the public.
• 😀 The speaker highlights the ongoing issue of illegal imports, particularly in the textile industry, where the gap between exports from China and imports to Indonesia shows significant unreported imports.
• 😀 The speaker advocates for clear communication from the Ministry regarding the causes of financial troubles in businesses, especially in relation to textile imports, and the need for a spokesperson to address such concerns.
• 😀 There’s a call for better coordination between the Ministry of Trade and other relevant authorities, such as the Task Force on Illegal Imports, to tackle the ongoing issues of illegal trade more effectively.
• 😀 Despite efforts, the Task Force on illegal imports is criticized for being ineffective in curbing the entry of illegal textile imports, with millions of dollars still entering illegally in 2024.
• 😀 The speaker calls for more thorough and accurate data analysis to help reduce the confusion surrounding regulations and illegal imports, and stresses that regulations should be stable and well-thought-out before implementation.

Q & A

What is the main issue discussed in the script?

The main issue discussed in the script revolves around the challenges faced by Indonesia's Ministry of Trade, particularly regarding the frequent changes in import regulations (peraturan Menteri Perdagangan or 'Permendak') and the impact of illegal imports on industries like textiles.

Why is the frequent change in 'Permendak' problematic?

Frequent changes in Permendak are problematic because they create uncertainty and disrupt businesses. The regulations are being changed almost every month, which harms the credibility of the Ministry of Trade and confuses industries trying to adapt to the rules.

How does the speaker view the role of the Ministry of Trade in managing import regulations?

The speaker acknowledges the complexities of the global environment and the challenges faced by the Ministry of Trade, but stresses the importance of thoroughly reviewing and carefully implementing changes to Permendak to avoid undermining the ministry's credibility.

What does the speaker suggest should be done when facing pressure to change regulations?

The speaker suggests that the Ministry of Trade should resist making hasty changes in response to external pressures and instead conduct thorough studies and assessments before implementing new regulations.

What issue is raised concerning the impact of 'Permendak' on the textile industry?

The speaker explains that 'Permendak' is wrongly blamed for the bankruptcy of textile companies, when in fact, the real issue is the massive illegal imports of textiles, which are not adequately addressed.

What is the scale of illegal textile imports mentioned in the script?

The script mentions that in 2024 alone, illegal textile imports could reach up to 800 million USD, with a total discrepancy of around 1.4 billion USD in illegal imports that are not properly recorded.

How does the speaker critique the handling of illegal imports by the Ministry of Trade?

The speaker criticizes the Ministry of Trade for its ineffective handling of illegal imports, particularly in the textile sector, and questions the effectiveness of the task force set up to address the issue.

What is the speaker's stance on the Ministry's approach to communication and handling criticism?

The speaker advises the Ministry of Trade to improve its communication, especially when responding to criticisms or attacks from other ministries. It is important for the Ministry to clarify misunderstandings and defend its policies when necessary.

What role does the speaker believe the 'Task Force' (Satgas) should play in managing illegal imports?

The speaker believes the Task Force (Satgas) should be more effective in combating illegal imports. However, the speaker implies that the Task Force's efforts have not been sufficient, as illegal imports continue to enter the country without proper control.

What recommendation does the speaker make for the future management of import regulations?

The speaker recommends that future management of import regulations should be more stable, with longer-lasting and carefully considered regulations to ensure that businesses can plan effectively and the Ministry maintains its credibility.