China's Geography Problem

Summary

The video script explores the geographical advantages and challenges that have shaped China's growth and strategic position in the world. It highlights how the fertile Yellow River floodplain has been crucial to China's agricultural success and ability to support its large population. However, the script also points out China's geographical vulnerabilities, such as its borders with Vietnam, Laos, and Myanmar, which lack natural protection and could pose significant challenges in the event of conflict. The importance of Tibet to China's military strategy and water supply is discussed, as well as the strategic significance of Mongolia and the potential threats from the United States' Pacific military presence. The script also touches on China's economic reliance on exports and imports, its growing influence in Africa, and the potential risks of its increasing global engagement. The video concludes by emphasizing the importance of geography in understanding China's current and future geopolitical situation.

Takeaways

• 🌾 **Agricultural Land:** Eastern China's fertile land, particularly the Yellow River floodplain, has been crucial to the country's growth and ability to support its large population through agriculture.
• 🌱 **Double-Cropping:** The climate allows for double-cropping, significantly increasing rice output and contributing to China's food security.
• 🌍 **Geographical Challenges:** Despite its large population, China faces geographical vulnerabilities with arbitrary borders to the south and potential military conflicts with neighboring countries.
• 🏞️ **Tibet's Strategic Importance:** Tibet serves as a military buffer between China and India, extending China's border to the Himalayas and protecting the water sources for major rivers.
• 🚂 **Infrastructure Development:** China is investing in transportation infrastructure in Tibet to integrate the region further and counteract potential resistance from the native population.
• 💧 **Water Supply:** Tibet is vital for China's water supply, as it is the source for the Yellow and Yangtze Rivers, which are essential for the country's agricultural productivity.
• 🇲🇳 **Mongolia's Buffer Role:** Mongolia's vast, sparsely populated terrain acts as a natural barrier to the north, offering China a degree of geographical protection.
• 🌊 **Maritime Vulnerability:** China's eastern border, despite being an ocean, is not entirely safe due to the presence of powerful states like the US and potential for naval blockades.
• 🏝️ **South China Sea Disputes:** China's efforts to establish sovereignty in the South China Sea are driven by the need for access to the Pacific and protection of its maritime trade routes.
• 🌐 **Global Dependencies:** China's economic growth has led to increased reliance on foreign imports, particularly food and oil, which exposes the country to vulnerabilities related to international relations.
• 📈 **Economic and Political Shifts:** Historically focused on regional dominance, China's rise to a global power has changed its economic and political strategies, including significant investments in Africa.

Q & A

What is the significance of the Yellow River in Chinese history?

The Yellow River is significant in Chinese history because it provided some of the best agricultural land in the world, which allowed the civilization to grow and become the most populous country.

What is double-cropping and how does it benefit China's agricultural output?

Double-cropping is the practice of planting a second, slightly less productive crop after the main rice crop is cultivated. This increases rice output by about 25%, allowing China to produce more food using the same amount of land.

Why is rice cultivation advantageous for China compared to wheat?

Rice cultivation is advantageous because it yields 11 million calories per acre, compared to wheat which yields only 4 million calories per acre, making it a more efficient crop for feeding a large population.

How do the borders between China and its southern neighbors impact its geographical challenges?

The borders between China and its southern neighbors were set arbitrarily due to historical conflicts, lacking natural geographical protection. This makes it easier for these countries to invade China, despite China's technological advantage.

Why is Tibet strategically important to China?

Tibet is strategically important to China because it provides a buffer zone between China and India, extends China's border to the Himalayas, and controls the water supply for China's two longest rivers, the Yellow and Yangtze.

How does the lack of transportation infrastructure in Tibet affect military strategy?

The lack of transportation infrastructure in Tibet makes it difficult for both an invading force and China to advance a large number of troops towards the region, thus affecting military strategy.

What is China's approach to integrating Tibet into its territory?

China is integrating Tibet by building infrastructure like the world's highest railroad, highways, and airports. It is also encouraging Han Chinese migration to Tibet to change the demographic composition and ensure loyalty to the Chinese government.

Why is water control from Tibet crucial for China's agricultural productivity?

Water control from Tibet is crucial because the water from Tibet feeds China's two longest rivers, which in turn support the agricultural productivity of the eastern zone of China, a key factor for the country's food security.

How does Mongolia serve as an asset to China's northern border?

Mongolia serves as an asset due to its friendly relations with China, its vast and sparsely populated terrain, and the Gobi Desert, which acts as a natural barrier against efficient land-based invasions.

What is the significance of the South China Sea for China's maritime strategy?

The South China Sea is significant for China's maritime strategy because it allows China to establish sovereignty and military presence, ensuring access to the Pacific in case of war and protecting its maritime trade routes.

How does China's economic reliance on exports and imports affect its geopolitical strategy?

China's reliance on exports and imports, particularly food and oil, makes it vulnerable to maritime blockades and restrictions. This vulnerability influences its geopolitical strategy to secure access to oceans and maintain friendly relations with trading partners.

What is the impact of China's growing size and influence on its historical approach to regional dominance?

China's growing size and influence have led it to move beyond its historical focus on regional dominance in Asia. It now seeks to secure resources and influence globally, particularly in Africa, which has become a key supplier of resources for China.

Outlines

00:00

🌏 Geographical Blessings and Challenges of China

The first paragraph discusses the contrasting geographical features of China that have influenced its development. It highlights the agricultural benefits provided by the Yellow River floodplain and the overall suitability of Eastern China for farming, which has been crucial for supporting its large population through practices like double-cropping. The paragraph also notes the high caloric output of rice compared to wheat, explaining the population density in China. However, it acknowledges China's geographical vulnerabilities, such as arbitrary borders with neighboring countries like Vietnam, Laos, and Myanmar, which, despite being smaller, could pose significant military challenges due to their large active military personnel and the difficult jungle terrain. The importance of Tibet, both from a military strategic perspective and as a water source for major Chinese rivers, is also emphasized. The paragraph concludes by mentioning China's efforts to improve transportation infrastructure in Tibet to consolidate its control and integrate the region more closely with the rest of the country.

05:02

🌄 China's Strategic Geographical Assets and Vulnerabilities

The second paragraph delves into China's other geographical assets and vulnerabilities. It points out the importance of Tibet as a water source for China's agricultural productivity and the potential risks of foreign control over this resource. The paragraph also discusses Mongolia as a natural buffer to the north, due to its vastness and harsh terrain, and the friendly relations between Mongolia and China. The potential threat from the east, particularly the United States' military presence in the Pacific region and its allies, is highlighted. It outlines China's efforts to establish sovereignty in the South China Sea to secure access to the Pacific Ocean, despite the negative impact of these actions on diplomatic relations with neighboring countries. The paragraph emphasizes China's reliance on exports and imports, particularly food and oil, and the risks associated with maritime blockades. It concludes by reflecting on China's historical focus on regional dominance and its recent global expansion, particularly in Africa, where it has invested heavily in resources and agriculture.

10:03

📈 Squarespace Promotion and Web Presence Importance

The third and final paragraph shifts focus to a promotional message about Squarespace, the platform used to create the presenter's other channel's website. It emphasizes the ease of use, professional templates, powerful website builder, and customer service offered by Squarespace. The presenter shares their positive experience in building a website quickly and at a reasonable cost. The paragraph serves as a reminder of the importance of having a professional web presence for various ventures, including YouTube channels and businesses, and encourages viewers to use Squarespace with a provided discount link. It concludes with a thank you note and a promise of another video in two weeks.

Keywords

💡Geographical Protection

Geographical protection refers to the natural barriers provided by the physical features of a country, such as mountains, rivers, or oceans, which can serve as a defense against potential invasions. In the video, it is mentioned that China lacks strong geographical protection, which is a vulnerability despite its large population and military strength.

💡Yellow River Civilization

The Yellow River Civilization is the historical settlement that marks the beginning of Chinese history for many. It is significant because the fertile floodplains of the Yellow River provided excellent agricultural land, which supported the growth of the population and the development of the civilization. The script highlights the importance of this region for China's agricultural success and its role in making China the most populous country in the world.

💡Double-Cropping

Double-cropping is an agricultural practice where two crops are grown on the same piece of land within one year. The video explains that in China, after the main rice crop is harvested, another, slightly less productive, crop can be planted, which increases the rice output by about 25%. This practice is crucial for China's ability to produce more food on the same amount of land.

💡Border Disputes

Border disputes refer to disagreements between countries over the demarcation of their shared boundaries. The script discusses China's border disputes with Vietnam, Laos, and Myanmar, which were not naturally set by the environment but were determined by historical conflicts. These disputes are significant as they represent potential flashpoints for conflict and affect China's geopolitical strategy.

💡Tibet

Tibet is a region that has been under Chinese control for the past 300 years, despite its distinct ethnic identity from the Han Chinese majority. The video emphasizes Tibet's strategic military importance to China, as it provides a buffer zone between China and India. Additionally, Tibet is crucial for China's water supply, as it is the source of major rivers like the Yellow and Yangtze.

💡Han Chinese

Han Chinese are the largest ethnic group in China, predominantly inhabiting the eastern part of the country. The script mentions the Han Chinese in the context of their migration to Tibet, which is part of China's strategy to integrate the region more closely with the rest of the country and to counter the potential for a foreign military presence in the area.

💡Water Security

Water security refers to the availability of sufficient water resources to meet the needs of a population without compromising the ability of future generations to meet their own needs. The video discusses how Tibet's water resources are vital for China's agricultural productivity, as they supply water to the country's two longest rivers. Control over these water resources is seen as critical for China's food security.

💡Mongolia

Mongolia is a large, sparsely populated country to the north of China. The video describes it as an asset to China due to its friendly relations, the natural barriers like the Gobi Desert, and the long supply lines that would make an invasion difficult. Mongolia's position also serves as a buffer between China and its northern neighbor, Russia.

💡South China Sea

The South China Sea is a region of strategic importance due to its maritime routes and resource-rich waters. The video explains China's efforts to establish sovereignty in the area by building military bases and artificial islands. This is part of China's strategy to ensure access to the Pacific Ocean in case of conflict, as its economy heavily relies on maritime trade.

💡NATO Powers

NATO, or the North Atlantic Treaty Organization, is a military alliance consisting of the United States and several European and North American countries. The script suggests that in the event of a war, countries to the south and east of China, which might side with NATO powers, could pose a significant challenge to China due to their proximity and potential military support from the alliance.

💡Neocolonialism

Neocolonialism refers to the practice of using economic, political, or cultural influence to control or exploit a country, typically former colonies, instead of direct military control. The video discusses China's investment in Africa, which some describe as a form of neocolonialism. Chinese corporations have been buying land and resources in Africa, which has implications for China's self-sufficiency and its reliance on foreign powers.

Highlights

China's large population is supported by its fertile agricultural land, particularly the floodplains of the Yellow River.

Eastern China's agriculture benefits from double-cropping, boosting rice output by 25%.

Geographical challenges include arbitrary borders with Vietnam, Laos, and Myanmar, set by historical conflicts.

China's geographical protection is limited, making invasions from Vietnam, Laos, or Myanmar easier.

The strategic importance of Tibet as a barrier between China and India, preventing easy military advances.

Tibet serves as a crucial water source for China, with major rivers like the Yellow and Yangtze originating there.

Development projects in Tibet aim to integrate it more closely with China, including railways and airports.

China's relationship with neighboring countries is strained by territorial disputes and military tensions.

Mongolia acts as a geographical buffer to the north, providing security against land-based military threats.

The South China Sea is central to China's strategy to ensure maritime access and prevent potential blockades.

China's military buildup and artificial islands in the South China Sea have affected its relationships with neighboring nations.

Economic reliance on exports makes maritime access crucial for China's economy.

China's increasing dependence on food and oil imports marks a shift from historical self-sufficiency.

Investments in Africa are seen as a form of neocolonialism, securing resources needed back home in China.

China's strategic shift from regional power to global influence reflects its need to support its large population.

Transcripts

This video was made possible by Squarespace.

Build your custom website for 10% off by going to squarespace.com/wendover.

China is a country both blessed and cursed by geography.

On one hand its land has allowed the country to grow to almost 1.4 billion people but on

the other hand it really doesn’t have great geographical protection.

The beginning of what most people call Chinese history often starts with the Yellow River

Civilization and there’s a good reason why this settlement grew into the most populous

country in the world—the floodplain of the Yellow River is some of the best agricultural

land in the world.

In fact, the entirety of eastern China is perfectly suited for Agriculture.

This was and still is crucial to the country’s success.

What’s more, this area is just warm and wet enough that farmers can do what is know

as double-cropping.

Once the main crop of rice is cultivated in June and July, another slightly less productive

crop can be planted for October cultivation.

This increases rice output by about 25% which means China can make more food using the same

amount of land.

Europe mostly relies on wheat to feed its population which only outputs 4 million calories

of food per acre of farmland.

Rice, on the other hand, grows 11 million calories worth per acre.

It’s easy to see why there are so many people in China.

But China does have its geographical challenges.

To the south it borders three countries—Vietnam, Laos, and Myanmar.

The borders between these three countries and China seem almost arbitrarily set because

they sort of were.

Vietnam’s was set after the Sino-French War, Laos’ was set following its involvement

in the Vietnam war, and Myanmar’s was set following a small war with China in the 60s.

None was naturally set by the environment; all were chosen arbitrarily by humans at war.

These countries are not insignificant—combined they have nearly one million active military

personnel while China, the much larger country, has just over two million.

Significant conflict with any of these countries would not be a one-sided war.

While China would have the technological advantage, any of these three countries would have a

significant home-field advantage.

Vietnam, Laos, and Myanmar are all jungle countries—one of the most difficult environments

for warfare.

This was part of the reason why the Vietnam war lasted so long.

It’s just so hard to move troops in the jungle so everything slows down.

Without any geographical protection of its borders it would be significantly easier for

Vietnam, Laos, or Myanmar to invade China than the reverse.

But China does have an advantage elsewhere.

China and India just aren’t good friends.

They have border disputes, military conflicts, political differences, so its just hard for

them to get along and that is why Tibet is so important.

Tibet was historically its own empire; it was only in the last 300 years that China

took it over.

Tibetan people are ethnically different from the Han Chinese inhabiting China’s east.

It just doesn’t make sense for Tibet to be part of China…

except militarily.

Only 0.2% of China’s population lives in Tibet which accounts nearly 13% of the country’s

area.

More people live in the inner four districts of Beijing than the entirety of Tibet.

It’s just incredibly desolate, but it serves a purpose.

If China didn’t rule Tibet, then India would.

Maybe not formally, but there’s little chance that an independent Tibet would not be economically

and culturally dominated by either India or China.

It just doesn’t have enough power economically or militarily to resist, but in China’s

view, it could not and cannot allow for an Indian Tibet.

Indian rule of Tibet would mean that there would be no geographical protection between

the populated area of China and India because Tibet is that geographical protection.

Not only does Tibet extend China’s border to the Himalayas, it’s also an unpopulated

area without the transportation infrastructure needed for an invading India to advance a

large number of troops towards eastern China.

But that also means that there’s not the transportation infrastructure necessary for

China to advance towards India, but China is trying to change that.

They recently opened the worlds highest railroad to Tibet, they’re building highways constantly,

and they also opened a large airport in Nyingchi just miles away from the border.

In the near term the goal of these projects is to further integrate Tibet into China.

The government has all but failed at winning over the native Tibetan population, but they

can change who lives in Tibet.

Hundreds of thousands of Han Chinese have moved into Tibet and many more visit each

year.

The government knows that Tibet’s usefulness is diminished if when a foreign military shows

up the population thinks that means liberation rather than invasion.

But there’s another reason why China needs Tibet—water.

That whole eastern zone of agricultural productivity exists because of all the water from Tibet.

The Yellow and Yangtze Rivers—China’s two longest rivers—both get their water

from Tibet and foreign control of the water supply of the country would, in the governments

mind, strike a catastrophic blow to the country’s food security.

If there were, hypothetically, a significant mountain range separating Tibet from eastern

China, there’s a good chance it would still be independent.

The water would still come from China and the mountains would act as the geographical

protection that China desires.

But to the North is another one of China’s assets—Mongolia.

It’s an enormous, sparsely populated, friendly country.

With the gobi desert and other desolate terrain, there’s just little chance that any modern

land-based army could make it across with any efficiency.

The supply lines would be enormously long and by the time they got to the Chinese border

there would have been ample warning.

But then again, who would want to invade?

Mongolia’s only other neighbor is Russia which is a friendly ally of China both militarily

and economically.

China need not worry about its northern border until relations with Russia sour.

But that leaves the eastern border.

Now, you would think that this would be China’s safest border—the ocean—but you have to

consider that powerful states lay just off China’s shores, the most powerful one being

the US.

The United States has a significant Pacific military presence with bases in South Korea,

Japan, and Guam.

It’s also a close ally with Taiwan, Indonesia, Singapore, and Malaysia meaning that, if a

serious dispute with China occurred, the US would have no problem blockading China and

cutting off its maritime access, and of course, China knows this.

That’s why China has spent so much time, energy, and political capital to establish

sovereignty in the South China Sea by building military bases and artificial islands.

It knows that it needs these islands so it has sovereignty over the area so that it can

reach the Pacific in case of war, but ironically, its actions in the area are souring its relations

with the very nations that China needs on its side.

The Philippines, for example, doesn’t have a bulletproof relationship with the US.

While the two countries are allies, Philippine leadership has attempted to distance themselves

from the US.

If China hadn’t ruined its relationship with the Philippines over the South China

Sea dispute it could’ve won them to their side which would allow China crucial access

to the Pacific if the US attempted a naval blockade.

China’s entire economy relies on exports so restrictions to access to the oceans would

lead to economic ruin.

With its enormous population, China also relies on the importation of food, most of which

comes on ships.

Without jobs or food, there’s a good chance that the population would rise up against

the government and end the current regime.

China didn’t want to be a global power spreading its influence to every continent until recently.

It wanted to be the the dominant power in its region, Asia, but historically it kept

its affairs within the region.

It never colonized outside of Asia and for much of history it didn’t have a significant

navy to project its power around the world.

But that has changed just because China got so big.

China is now of a size where it cannot support its population with its size alone.

Self-sufficiency in food production has been a major aspect of China’s domestic policy

for decades, but the country has found a way to move past that as its economy has grown.

Africa has emerged almost as China’s China.

It supplies the country that supplies the world.

China has pumped enormous amounts of money into the continent in what some describe as

a form of neocolonialism.

Chinese state-backed corporations have bought huge amounts of land in Africa to mine minerals,

drill for oil, and grow food.

China now imports more food and oil than it exports.

While that is a sign of the development of its economy, it also means that it is now

reliant on foreign powers which is a vulnerable position for a country that is often at odds

with some of those foreign powers.

China doesn’t have bad geography, it has some of the best in the world which has allowed

for it to grow into the largest country in the world, but as it grows into a more and

more powerful and developed country, it needs to be cognizant of its vulnerabilities if

the current regime wishes to continue.

It’s clear that because of its geography, the country is in a more precarious position

than some may think.

If there were every a reason to go to war with China, the country is surrounded to the

south and east by countries that would likely side with NATO powers.

To the west and north, China is surrounded by countries and regions without the infrastructure

to support China is a war.

China is a nuclear power which means formal war with other superpowers is unlikely, but,

if it ever were to happen, its hard to deny that its major disadvantage is geography.

I just went through the process of building the new website for my other channel, Half

as Interesting, which reminded me why I love Squarespace so much.

All in, it took me about an hour to make this simple website and the hosting fees are very

reasonable.

For whatever you do, whether its a YouTube channel, a business, or anything else, having

a professional web presence is incredibly important because that’s how people find

you.

Squarespace makes this so easy with their beautiful templates created by world-class

designers, powerful website builder, and 24/7 award-winning customer service.

No matter what you do, build your web presence for 10% off with Squarespace by going to squarespace.com/wendover.

Squarespace makes this show possible so please at least go check them out over at squarespace.com/wendover.

Thanks for watching and I’ll see you in two weeks for another Wendover Productions

video.