Kenapa Masih Ada Perang, Kalo Udah Ada PBB?

Summary

The video explores the complexities of global conflicts and the role of the United Nations in peacekeeping. It highlights the impact of the UN Security Council's veto power, which often hinders conflict resolution due to national interests. Using examples like Russia-Ukraine and Israel-Palestine, the video critiques the UN's effectiveness in achieving global peace. The analysis questions whether true peace is possible under the current international framework, suggesting that power dynamics within the UN limit its ability to resolve major conflicts.

Takeaways

• 😀 The United Nations (UN) was created to maintain world peace and prevent war by managing international conflicts.
• 😀 The UN has a system of Security Council members who are supposed to ensure peace, but their vested political and economic interests often create obstacles.
• 😀 The five permanent members of the UN Security Council (U.S., Russia, China, U.K., and France) have veto power, which can block decisions, leading to gridlock and ineffective resolutions.
• 😀 Russia, in particular, has used its veto power to block peace resolutions, such as those addressing the Russia-Ukraine war, frustrating international peace efforts.
• 😀 Despite these challenges, the UN has successfully helped resolve conflicts in some regions, such as overseeing ceasefires and protecting civilians in Côte d'Ivoire.
• 😀 The UN's role in international peacekeeping is often undermined by the lack of enforceable authority over its member states, especially in conflicts involving powerful countries.
• 😀 The Israel-Palestine conflict is a major example where the UN has been unable to effectively intervene, with the U.S. using its veto power to block resolutions calling for ceasefires.
• 😀 The UN’s failure to stop the ongoing violence in Gaza is highlighted as a critical issue, as it has not been able to compel Israel to end military actions against Palestinians.
• 😀 The concept of world peace is questioned—can global peace truly be achieved with or without the UN? The speaker seems to suggest that international cooperation is essential, but difficult to realize under the current system.
• 😀 The challenges of UN peacekeeping and conflict resolution point to the complexities of modern geopolitics, where the interests of powerful nations often dominate global discussions.

Q & A

What is the primary role of the United Nations (UN)?

The primary role of the United Nations is to maintain international peace and security by preventing wars and resolving conflicts between nations.

Why is the UN often criticized for not effectively resolving international conflicts?

The UN is criticized because its Security Council members, especially the five permanent members with veto power, can block resolutions, which prevents effective conflict resolution, as seen in the Russia-Ukraine and Israel-Palestine conflicts.

What is the Security Council, and why is its veto power significant?

The Security Council is a key body within the UN responsible for maintaining peace. It consists of 15 members, including five permanent members (the U.S., Russia, China, the U.K., and France), who have veto power, allowing them to block resolutions even if the majority of members agree.

How has Russia used its veto power in the UN Security Council?

Russia has used its veto power to block peace resolutions, particularly in the context of the Russia-Ukraine conflict, preventing the adoption of resolutions aimed at achieving a ceasefire or peace settlement.

What was the outcome of the UN’s involvement in the Israel-Palestine conflict?

The UN has faced challenges in resolving the Israel-Palestine conflict. The U.S. has used its veto power to block resolutions aimed at achieving a ceasefire, and the situation remains unresolved despite efforts through the UN's various bodies.

What is the role of the International Court of Justice (ICJ) within the UN system?

The International Court of Justice (ICJ) handles legal disputes between states, including cases like the one brought by South Africa against Israel over alleged genocide. The ICJ can issue rulings, but its decisions often lack enforcement power.

What was the result of the International Court of Justice case between South Africa and Israel?

While the ICJ ruled on the case between South Africa and Israel, it did not mandate Israel to stop its actions in Gaza, highlighting the limited enforcement power of the court in international conflicts.

What are the challenges the UN faces in peacekeeping missions?

UN peacekeeping missions often face challenges such as limited resources, political interference, and the inability to enforce decisions effectively, which can lead to unresolved conflicts and continuing violence.

Can the UN always prevent wars or resolve conflicts?

No, the UN cannot always prevent wars or resolve conflicts, especially when powerful member states use their veto power to block resolutions, or when parties involved in a conflict do not comply with UN mandates.

What does the speaker imply about the future of world peace in the context of the UN?

The speaker questions whether world peace can truly be achieved, suggesting that even with the UN’s efforts, the challenges posed by international politics and the interests of powerful nations make global peace difficult to attain.